Disability and Freethinking, Part 2
Ruth Geller at Humanist Network News writes about Harriet McBryde Johnson and her atheism. Check it out, and the discussion in comments of my last post on freethinking here.
Justice is what love looks like in public. -- Cornel West
Ruth Geller at Humanist Network News writes about Harriet McBryde Johnson and her atheism. Check it out, and the discussion in comments of my last post on freethinking here.
Posted by
Kay Olson
at
2:03 AM
0
comments
I received an email query recently from the Editor Ruth Geller of the Humanist Network News about individuals with disabilities who are non-religious, either agnostic or atheist. Geller hopes to do an article on the topic.
The topic intrigues me too. Disabled freethinkers? There's Harriet McBryde Johnson, of course.
I'm agnostic, as I've said before, though not without a yearning for something more satisfying than saying that I find faith an unpersuasive belief or emotion. Truthfully, I'm not in the same league of freethinkers as people who declare themselves atheists -- I just haven't put the time and effort into examining the issue that I have into, say, disability issues. (Or Things That Crack Me Up.) I feel comfortable calling myself a disability activist and a feminist because I've actively explored both topics and feel reasonably well-read there. Not so with faith, rationalism and belief, yet.
What about you? If you're disabled and consider yourself a freethinker, Geller is interested in talking to you. Contact info here:
Ruth N. Geller, EditorOr, can you name other atheist or agnostic disabled folks besides McBryde Johnson? Historic figures or contemporaries? (Penny?)
Humanist Network News
Email: RGeller@humaniststudies.org
------------------------------(tel): 518.432.7820 x210
(fax): 518.432.7821
-------------------------------------
The Institute for Humanist Studies
48 Howard Street
Albany, New York 12207
-------------------------------------
Web site: www.HumanistStudies.org
E-zine: www.HumanistStudies.org/enews/
Podcast: www.HumanistStudies.org/podcast/
Myspace: www.myspace.com/humaniststudies
Posted by
Kay Olson
at
10:52 PM
12
comments
Labels: belief and religion, carnival, Harriet McBryde Johnson
Overwhelmingly sad news today: Harriet McBryde Johnson has died at age 50.
Image description: The photo shows Johnson in a flowered-print navy dress looking toward the camera. She sits in her wheelchair, though the image is a close-up focusing on her and not the chair. Johnson leans forward, right elbow on knee, chin in right hand. She's a middle-aged white woman with dark hair in a very long braid trailing over her shoulder and into her lap. She's not quite smiling, but looking interestedly back at you.
The Post and Courier of Charleston, SC, provides a preliminary notice, with a more formal obituary expected soon (the NYT will have something too, I hear):
Harriet McBryde Johnson, a well-known Charleston disability and civil rights attorney, died Wednesday.
"She worked yesterday. It's a shock to everybody," said friend and attorney Susan Dunn.
She was born July 8, 1957, and had been a Charleston resident since age 10.
She told The Post and Courier that she became an attorney because her disability-rights work had taught her something about the impact of law on how people live. . . .
Johnson, who was born with a neuromuscular disease, drew national attention for her opposition to "the charity mentality" and "pity-based tactics" of the annual Jerry Lewis muscular dystrophy telethon. Lewis told the Chicago Tribune he had no intention of making peace with opponents such as Johnson. He likened the idea of meeting with them to entertaining Hezbollah or insurgents in Iraq.
The protests started after Lewis wrote a 1990 Parade magazine article in which he imagined being disabled. Among his conclusions, "I realize that my life IS half, so I must learn to do things halfway. I just have to learn to try to be good at being half a person."
Posted by
Kay Olson
at
6:21 PM
6
comments
Labels: Harriet McBryde Johnson, heroes
For the many people googling Harriet McBryde Johnson because of her Christmas Day editorial in The New York Times, she's mentioned on this blog here, here, here, here and here.
Posted by
Kay Olson
at
11:31 PM
0
comments
Labels: charity, Harriet McBryde Johnson, telethons
As Harriet McBryde Johnson says, "The Terri Schiavo case is hard to write about, hard to think about." I've had an emotional deer-in-the-headlights response about it for quite some time now. Months. And while the legal options for saving Terri Schiavo from starvation may have been exhausted, I'll offer here some writings by others that provide the disability perspective so lacking in the mainstream debate.
Harriet McBryde Johnson on Slate, via Disability Law:
In addition to the rights all people enjoy, Ms. Schiavo has a statutory right under the Americans With Disabilities Act not to be treated differently because of her disability. Obviously, Florida law would not allow a husband to kill a nondisabled wife by starvation and dehydration; killing is not ordinarily considered a private family concern or a matter of choice. It is Ms. Schiavo's disability that makes her killing different in the eyes of the Florida courts. Because the state is overtly drawing lines based on disability, it has the burden under the ADA of justifying those lines.
Given the current research regarding brain activity and misdiagnosis, it's a virtual certainty that countless people have been helpless to prevent their own deaths through starvation and dehydration. There's an analogy to DNA evidence and the death penalty. Here in Illinois, the staggering numbers of innocent and wrongly convicted people on Death Row resulted in a moratorium on the death penalty. Whether you agreed with the death penalty or not, everyone was forced to find ways to make sure no innocent person ended up on Death Row again. The same amount of concern should apply to medically induced deaths, in which the numbers far exceed the number of convicted people executed each year.More by Stephen Drake:
People on the right are killing us slowly with cuts to the budget and Medicaid while the people on the left kill us quickly and call it "compassion" -- either way we end up dead -- AND WE OBJECT.
There isn't a single disability rights activist I've heard from who is happy that things ended up at such a sorry pass, and who isn't afraid that this will make liberals hate them even more than they now do. Yet it cannot help being noticed that it generally depends on whose ox is being gored as to what side of the states' rights debate one comes down on. We're all for federal laws when it comes to things like civil rights -- and gay marriage. We're not, though, when it comes to things we've labeled as "right to die" -- which we say are "privacy issues."
We might want to take another look at the cost of such privacy.
Posted by
Kay Olson
at
2:35 PM
4
comments
Labels: ADA, choice, consciousness, disability studies, Harriet McBryde Johnson, NDY, politics, right to die, Terri Schiavo