Showing posts with label Ashley Treatment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ashley Treatment. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 10, 2007

The next Ashley X

Her name is Katie Thorpe. Other bloggers have been covering this latest story. Penny has the link collection here. Let her know if you got a link to add to the list.

I've said all I plan to say for the time being in comments at Feministe, mainly in response to the notice that disabled people weren't contributing to that thread. Here's a repeat of my comment over there:

There are a number of us disabled bloggers and blog readers around who weigh in here at Feministe occasionally. Many of us (not me this time) have been writing about this case during this past week. I’m sitting out this round (of debating the specifics of the UK case) for the reasons I specified last January when the Ashley X case came to attention, summed up beautifully by Brownfemipower back then:

Maybe, just maybe, bloggers who are disabled don’t really want to discuss shit like this over and over and over again–especially when people are not just discussing their right to access or something like that (where the presumption of humanity deserving of life is at least present), but are actually challenging disabled peoples very right to live as autonomous respected human beings. Maybe bloggers who are disabled really don’t feel like debating whether or not they are “burdens” worthy of extreme forms of violence just to suit able-bodied people. Maybe they aren’t interested in debating whether or not they have a right to be alive.

The typical response to what BFP says there is “But disabled people don’t know the burden of caring for disabled people.” Or “But the girl in question is much more disabled than these disabled people arguing against the treatment.” When exactly do our voices and experiences become relevant? I always forget when that’s supposed to kick in?

One final thing: It’s good to remember that in the case of Ashley X, the hospital broke the law by not obtaining a court order for the surgery — one step in the process meant to insure her interests are considered separate from her caregivers, specifically with regard to a disabled person’s reproductive rights. Also, though it wasn’t revealed until a full month after the media storm, the hospital ethics committee was torn on this case and in the absence of a consensus, they granted the parents’ wishes. That decision (or lack of one) occurred without any sort of disability rights perspective on the ethics committee.

Tuesday, May 08, 2007

Hospital violated state law performing "Ashley Treatment"

I will do more than simply post the links on this soon, but the news for now from the Washington Protection and Advocacy System (soon to be Disability Rights Washington - DRW):

Many people with disabilities have expressed great concern over the use of invasive medical procedures used to keep a young child with disabilities small. As reported at great length, parents of a six-year old girl named Ashley asked doctors at Seattle Children’s Hospital to give Ashley high doses of hormones, and remove her breast buds and uterus.

Pursuant to its PADD federal mandate, the Washington Protection and Advocacy System (WPAS) used its federally granted access authority to initiate an investigation into the use of the “Ashley Treatment.”

The investigation revealed that legal the rights of the child were violated when the hospital involved proceeded with the hysterctomy portion of the treatment without a court order first being obtained.

The hospital acknowledges its mistake and has agreed to implement many procedures to prevent similar legal violations from happening in the future.

Please read the WPAS Investigative Report Regarding the “Ashley Treatment” for more information about what happened to Ashley and how to prevent it from happening to other children with disabilities.

Update: Ashley X's parents respond to today's report:
Parents of Ashley X's Position on the Legal Findings on Hysterectomy

As the loving parents of Ashley X we support the vigilance of WPAS in their effort to protect the vulnerable members of our society.

In 2004 Ashley X was indeed given a hysterectomy without a court order. Prior to the surgery, we had consulted with a disability lawyer and learned that the state law, which is intended to protect the rights of the disabled to procreate, did not apply to Ashley's case since:

1- Given Ashley's developmental state and prognosis, which is well-documented by her doctors and was reported to the Ethics committee, voluntary procreation is not meaningful or applicable to her case and will never be.

2- Sterilization is not the intent of the Ashley Treatment but a byproduct of it

While we support laws protecting vulnerable people against involuntary sterilization, the law appears to be too broadly based to distinguish between people who are or can become capable of decision making and those who have a grave and unchanging medical condition such as Ashley, who will never become remotely capable of decision making. . Requiring a court order for all hysterectomies performed on all disabled persons regardless of medical condition, complexity, severity, or prognosis puts an onerous burden on already over-burdened families of children with medical conditions as serious as Ashley's.

As responsible and loving parents, deeply concerned for the wellbeing of our child, we provided a better quality of life to our Ashley, who is doing very well under our love and care. We hope that other families of the many children like Ashley will likewise be able to care for and benefit their children without undue obstacles.

We appreciate your continued support, prayers, well wishes, and respect of our privacy.

Sunday, May 06, 2007

Coming Tuesday -- Info pulled upon request

The full info on Tuesday.

Update: Info here.

Thursday, March 29, 2007

More writing on Ashley X

As people incorporate the Ashley Treatment into their thinking about disability or just spend a little time with the ethics of it all, more continues to be written about the case and the precedent it creates:

Patricia Williams for The Nation, posted at AlterNet:

This was also very wrong as a matter of ethics and public policy. There seems to be, in the national debate about this case, a popular consensus that the parents were well motivated, so who are the rest of us to judge? That sentiment is expressed loftily, as in Peter Singer's New York Times op-ed ("she is precious not so much for what she is, but because her parents and siblings love her and care about her"), and crudely, as in an anonymous online posting to the disability rights organization FRIDA ("I think your group is a pain in the neck ... if and when something happens to the caregiver, who will take care of the disabled person ... your group or the state who really does not give a hoot.")
Dave Reynolds at Inclusion Daily Express asks the question "Should 'Ashley X' be at the Center of Community Living Debate?":
Frankly, however, I haven't been able to make that link between community supports and Ashley's parents. I don't think one has much to do with the other.

For one thing, I found nothing in statements by Ashley's parents to suggest that an increase in community supports would have kept them from surgically changing their daughter to fit what they wanted her to be, an eternal "Pillow Angel". To the contrary, they said that they had tried in-home services but were not happy with them. Not that their satisfaction with the services would have mattered; even if they had the best in-home supports for Ashley, they still would have chosen their radical procedure.

"We would never turn the care of Ashley over to strangers even if she had grown tall and heavy," they wrote.

And because we knew this would never be just about Ashley X, Today's Zaman, a Turkish news site reports:
Two families with children suffering from cerebral palsy voiced support on Friday for another family’s plea to stunt the growth of their son, 13-year-old Umut Mert, who suffers from the same disorder. Füsun Evren, Umut Mert’s mother, earlier this week announced she was looking for a doctor who would stunt her son’s growth, in an operation now referred to as “Ashley’s treatment,” so named after a 9-year-old Seattle girl whose parents opted to stunt her growth with high-dose estrogen.

.... Professor Saim Yeprem from the Religious Affairs Directorate said that Ashley’s treatment was unacceptable. Yeprem said: “Umut Mert would be castrated if he received Ashley’s treatment. Castration is opposed by all religions, not only Islam.”

Dr. Güler Saygun from the Turkish Disabled Persons Administration said that applying such a treatment would require approval from the Ministry of Health’s Ethics Council. The head of the Turkish Association for the Disabled, Zülfikar Akar, said: “We don’t think it’s the right choice, but the mother’s situation is indeed difficult. These situations happen because care centers don’t offer long-term care for people with disabilities.”

Friday, February 23, 2007

Saturday Slumgullion #29

First some new links regarding Ashley X:

"Straight on till mourning" by John Hockenberry at his place, The Blogenberry:

Disability has nothing to do with the morality of the Ashley Treatment. Parents of disabled or non disabled children are the people who bring them into the world and help them live their lives and grow up to be whatever it is they will be. While Ashley’s options as an adult are certainly limited because of her disability they were not predetermined until Ashley’s parents and doctors stepped in.

I am not going to argue that Ashley’s parents are immoral or unjustified in what they did. I will argue that they are no longer Ashley’s parents. Regardless of their love and affection for their daughter their decision to remove her breasts and uterus and maintain her in a state of pre-puberty is not a parental decision. It is more the kind of control one might enforce on a pet to manage the relationship. It is something a farmer managing the productivity of his or her operation would naturally enforce on livestock. This would be done humanely, morally, and no-doubt with considerable tender affection and love for the subjects. There would be no outcry and no controversy, yet no one would confuse these acts of husbandry as parenthood.
From Medill Reports, "Disability activists press 'Ashley Treatment' case with AMA"

"Medical ethics malfunction" by Reuben Apple at his blog Politics and the English Language:
When I first heard about this case, I sympathized more with Ashley's parents than with their daughter, maybe because I thought I had more in common with them. I could even have been persuaded that Ashley should be killed. I thought, mental development arrested at 3 months, she's nothing but a burden, even to herself. Then William Peace reminded me that, in the only way that matters here, I do not have any less in common with Ashley than with any other person: we’re both people. That is the critical point from which I saw that Ashley's dignity - because by extension the dignity of all disabled people and by further extension the dignity of all human beings - should be everyone's primary concern in this matter. Now I think that, if we let her, she might make a contribution to society that few others could.
Kestrell at The Blind Bookworm writes "Whats the story? Ashley X and the journalistic challenge of wirting about disability"

And other linky stuff:

More on hybrid cars and the dangers their quiet engines pose for blind pedestrians.

Newsday's Carl MacGowan on the latest testimony in the case of the deaf boy v. the school district refusing to allow his service dog in school.

From The Michigan Daily, veterans vow to sue if renovations to the Michigan Stadium do not comply with the ADA. More from The Detroit Free Press.

From MSNBC, "Woman in iron lung celebrates 60th birthday"

From the SFGate.com, Tom FitzGerald writes about Kevin Laue, a one-armed high-school basketball player, in "The shotblocker: Amador Valley's Laue intimidates despite disability"

From The Toronto Star, a report on 1,600 developmentally disabled folks institutionalized in nursing homes because Ontario doesn't know what else to do with them. Letters to the editor here. The main article quoted here:

The huge increase of nursing home beds in recent years produced, in some jurisdictions, an over-supply of beds, she says, so that funnelling the developmentally disabled there has helped keep the nursing homes lucrative and filled. She points out that nursing home beds are relatively cheap – cheaper than spaces in either group homes or regional centres – and many of the homes are for-profit enterprises.

Spindel discovered that people with developmental disabilities are, on average, 31 years younger than the general nursing home average age of 83. Some are as young as 18.

From the NYT, an article by Karen Olsson about a young woman and her two autistic brothers (This should be a permanent link):
Tarah Perry wishes her brothers would remember to put on deodorant. Other 16-year-olds, after all, don’t need to be reminded of that by their 14-year-old sister. Other families don’t keep a stick of Degree in the glove compartment to enforce deodorant compliance on the way to school in the morning. Granted, Justin and Jason are different from other brothers — they are autistic twins — and Tarah’s family is therefore different from other families, and generally speaking she is perfectly O.K. with that. It’s all she has ever known. But lately she has been fighting more with her brothers. They irritate her, she says. They stink. She tells them as much, and they squabble about it, as any siblings might — only when you’re 14 and your brothers are disabled and you don’t know whether they’ll ever make it on their own or whether you’ll be responsible for taking care of them, then even the little things take on greater weight. Because what Tarah also wishes is that her brothers will one day manage to hold jobs and find friends and live the kind of life that regular deodorant-wearing people live, or some semblance of it. And in the meantime, it would be nice if they didn’t smell up the car.
AP reporter Nancy Zuckerbrod writes about the No Child Left Behind Act, its effects on learning disabled children (and those learning English as a second language), and expected changes to the law.

Scott Rains at Rolling Rains offers the link to an extensive study on Hurricane Katrina and the disaster's impact on disabled people.

RighteousBabe at DailyKos writes about Ty Siegel, (the Iraq war vet whose wedding pics have made the net rounds recently,) disability politics, pride and identity, and liberals/Democrats. Hundreds of comments in response, too.

The NYT again. Aliyah Baruchin writes on "Battling Epilepsy, and Its Stigma"

Thursday, February 08, 2007

Doctors involved with Ashley Treatment not as unified in support as previously indicated

From today's Salon.com, Rebecca Clarren reports in "Behind the Pillow Angel" that:

Doctors at the Seattle hospital that operated on a disabled girl to keep her from reaching sexual maturity -- the controversial "Ashley Treatment" -- were more troubled by the procedure than has been reported previously.
While it's not paticularly surprising that some of those on the ethics panel did have and do continue to have misgivings both about the specific case and the broader ramifications of the Ashley Treatment, the details of those misgivings are an important addition to the debate, which has frequently included declarations that the situation must be acceptable because a panel of experts signed off on it.

From the Salon article:
The committee members met Ashley and watched her interact with her parents. They saw her in a wheelchair and how she responded to her father's voice. "We got to see this little girl and see a little slice of what her life was like," Diekema told Salon. "It's very clear that Ashley's life is pretty small, that it's about her family. It's not about running around on the playground or dating. Her life is what a 3-month-old's life is like."

After Ashley and her parents left the room, the committee spent two hours in debate. At the end, no one voted with a show of hands. But in the ensuing discussion, the air was fraught with tension. The committee grappled with the following questions. How does keeping Ashley smaller help her? Does the treatment take away anything important to Ashley's own life?
Dr. Douglas Diekema has been the public face of the Seattle hospital, charged with explaining and defending the medical institution's actions, but statements made by Ashley X's parents on their public blog have apparently characterized the situation -- and the treatment's future for other children -- in ways problematic for hospital and those who were on the ethics panel. Again from the Salon article:
The public omission of the debate within the hospital and at the ethics committee results in part from federal medical laws to protect patient privacy. But because the public has been left unaware of the nuance and complexity of the ethical debate within the hospital, doctors worry that other disabled children could be more easily subjected to the Ashley Treatment. (On their blog, Ashley's parents write: "It is our hope that this treatment becomes well accepted and available to such families.") It was in part this fear of the case setting a precedent that initially spurred doctors at the Seattle hospital to question the surgical procedures.

"There were a number of people who were not very comfortable with the idea, and other people who weren't comfortable with it at all," said John McLaughlin, director of the neurodevelopmental program at the hospital. "In the end, the parents' articulate and assertive approach to wanting this done is what carried the day for that one child. However, most of us have major reservations about it for anyone else. My bottom line is that this is one more example of well-intended, but poorly thought-through treatment of kids with disabilities."

Put more succinctly, as her guardians, the hospital gave the final authority to Ashley's parents because they didn't have better medical solutions than the growth attenuation that was proposed and didn't necessarily believe it was a good idea at all.

Most troubling (and though I've seen it discussed on disability listservs, this article is the first I've seen to note this) has been the lack of candor about the whole procedure, from the actual medical treatments included in the endeavor to improve the child's (parents'?) life to the full process of the ethics committee:
What also has Merkens and other doctors and bioethicists worried is that key details of the case have been kept hidden. The article on the Ashley Treatment in the Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine left out several critical details. The authors wrote that Ashley had begun her growth spurt but omitted what percentage of her final height she had already achieved. If she had already reached 85 percent of her final height, the hormones may only have saved her an inch or two, said Dr. Robert Nickel, a developmental pediatrician at the Oregon Health and Science University in Portland. "The real question is: Is there any benefit to this treatment?" said Nickel. "I would have counseled them to wait, to sit back and see what happens over a year because this child might accomplish most of this on her own."

The article also never mentions the breast-bud removal, ostensibly the most contentious element of the Ashley Treatment. (The parents' blog provided that piece of the story.) Taken as a whole, the Ashley Treatment may appear more beneficial than it really is, said Dr. Christopher Feudtner, a pediatrician and bioethicist at the University of Pennsylvania. That's troubling because the treatment, he said, "is prone to abuse."

"We're manipulating her body so that she can fit in better to society, while neglecting the inner manifestations of pain, and that's a radical extension [of current medical philosophy]," Feudtner added. "Some child, somewhere, with much less severe mental disability than Ashley, will get this treatment. It will happen and there needs to be more people standing up and saying this will have side effects we didn't anticipate."

On the ethics panel (italics mine):
Again, the lack of detail about the discussion inside the Seattle hospital has medical observers concerned. "If we don't know exactly the reasoning and the debate that took place formulating that position, there's no way to understand how [the ethics committee and doctors] thought it through," said Feudtner. "It would be analogous to a judge rendering a verdict with no published ruling. This lack of an auditable record leaves any internal dissension or debate squelched from view, leaving the sense this was an easy decision for the committee to make, when that may not have been the case."

The presence of bioethics panels or consultants at other hospitals offers Feudtner little comfort. Medical bioethics is a relatively new field. While nearly all hospitals now have some kind of ethics board or consultant, 72 percent have no process to evaluate themselves, according to a report to be released later this month by the American Journal of Bioethics. There are no national standards or guidelines for ethics committees to follow. There are no standard ethics committee guidelines that aim to address the prejudices and preconceptions, even very subtle biases, of its members. Less than half of all people who conduct ethics consultation have had any formal training.

Also, the article reports that the Seattle hospital alone has had inquiries from three other families asking this "treatment" since the story went public.This puts the hospital and it's ethics panel in rather a quandry, I'd think, since the original news Dr. Diekema gave was that the procedure made perfect sense and was agreed to be beneficial by all involved.

Tuesday, January 30, 2007

Eyes on whose prize, part 2

It was during the transphobia/delink Twisty debates across feminist bloglandia last December that Kactus at Superbabymama happened to note that she'd added this blog and several others to her blogroll. In the comment discussion that followed, an anonymous commenter noted with some resignation that The Gimp Parade links to Heart at Women's Space/Margins, the radical feminist blogging community (if there is one) for several of the women who expressed such hateful transphobia on that ugly I Blame the Patriarchy thread.

My blogroll has since erased itself and I've been slowly adding back what I can remember, but at that time I tried to express whatever strategy it is I've employed for organizing my blogroll. This wouldn't be so important, except that I consider my blogroll the best, most exciting part of this blog because when I began this site in 2004 there weren't so many disability rights bloggers around. Check it out now -- the gimp blog section is joyfully unwieldy.

Here's that commentary on my blogrolling strategy:

I currently have links to both IBTP and Heart's blog, though I've thought many times in the past few months about deleting the link to Twisty. The fact that I just haven't taken the time to tweeze through my blogroll in a long time, despite adding new links I'm excited about, is one reason Twisty is still there.

Another reason she remains linked at my blog sidebar is because my blogrolling policy in so fuzzy and arbitrary in many ways already: it's divided into the crips and the nondisabled, national magazines about disability are mixed in with very small-audience disabled bloggers, Go Fug Yourself is right there in the list with Women's Space.

A few disability bloggers I seriously disagree with are listed simply because disability rights discussions of any kind and disabled bloggers are, frankly, hard to find, not sexy enough to be popular and we need to network and learn from our diverse experiences as disabled folks, if we can.

The final reason Twisty is still blogrolled is because of her recurring use of "fucktard" and some periodic objections to it in comments when she does use it. It's not news to me that all feminists are not my friends, with regard to disability politics, and I don't want to be oblivious of discussions that concern my interests. I have a hard time separating the outright offensive from the clueless, when both may be a part of the feminist movement that I, too, consider myself connected too. Ignorance on disability as it relates to feminism (or even generally) is just too heartbreakingly common. I confess I don't know where to draw the blogrolling line.

Heart's blog stays on my blogroll. I don't find her to be particularly knowledgeable about disability rights and politics, but in many other ways I believe her to be a great resource and committed to a level of diversity found on few white, nondisabled feminist blogs.

I don't mean any of the above to excuse the hate spewed on trans folk in the comments at IBTP. I would like to point out though, that despite Twisty's smart-ass comment in her own out-of-control thread, it's entirely possible that her recent health issues kept her offline for a few days and she didn't want to invoke another round of tiresome sympathy by mentioning it. Instead of being the sad cancer patient, she was "controversial" and mean-spirited instead. I believe that's within the realm of behavior she might display. Just sayin'.

Regarding trans hate and radical feminism specifically, I've been trying to connect the dots to ableism and write about it for quite a while now, but haven't been able to put what I know is part of the same issue of feminism, essentialism, bodily truths, and social constructionism together from a disability perspective just yet. I'm so glad Brownfemipower mentioned disabled women in her discussion if this. It is connected.
Aside from the obnoxious use of "tweeze" and the clearly inaccurate characterization of Women's Space being "committed to a level of diversity found on few white, nondisabled feminist blogs" I stand by my rationale. It'd be more accurate to say that Women's Space touches on diverse issues of difference concerning women more regularly than many other feminist spaces, but that's not the same as full commitment, particularly if you include the atmosphere created by regular participants over there.

Anonymous' response to me:
I used to read your blog every post. It hurt me so much though when I finally got around to exploring your site more. For me it's like, I don't know why you've linked to so-and-so. Is it because that's what you truly feel? Are you just trying to provide a wide variety of viewpoints? I don't know.

I do know it scares the hell out of me when I see Margins or Questioning Transgender or Genderville or some other hate site. Even if it's not a direct link.

I'm sure you can somewhat sympathize because ableist sites are just a dime a dozen because so few people even realize it exists. Otherwise good sites, too. Nice folk. Just not aware.

I just want you to know that I know you're doing good work. You've helped me out more than once. But I just can't visit your site anymore because I'm afraid. That's my issue. I'm oversensitive.
Well, Anonymous ain't oversensitive, and blogroll strategy aside, this has really made me think hard since then about my reactions to hate speech, generally, and my disposition against the ableism I encounter.

At the time I responded with this:
The hatred and fear people have about disability and disabled folks is most often expressed through silence or invisibility. In public policy it has historically been through institutionalizing disabled people and making us invisible, but the average person/blogger/commenter simply ignores us instead of raging out loud as is done with hate speech and transphobia.

As a blogroll owner, how do I delink to protest hatred or fear of people like myself if it's expressed by ignoring disabled issues and people? If the common factor of ignorance and cluelessness represents itself as silence too, who do I decide to give up on, in terms of disability issues? And since I do believe transphobia is related to fear and hatred of disabled folks, I don't imagine that where one is expressed the other doesn't also exist. The more I learn, the more I'm sure this is true.
If I made the practice of discounting disabled people's opinions a criteria for who is delinked from my site, I'd have had to remove several of my favorite mainstream feminist spaces in these weeks since Ashley X's story has hit international news. Even if I limited my delisting to blogs where parents of disabled children who disagree with the Ashley Treatment were dismissed out-of-hand, there'd be significant changes.

But back to what's been weighing on me about my own reactions to transphobia, ableism, racism, and other obvious signs of hatred of difference.

What I'd call my formative years as a person with a disability and the need for a wheelchair began in 1983 when I was 15. The Americans with Disabilities Act wasn't passed until 1990, so as I learned about disability in America, I learned that I could not ever count on physical access to public places. The Rehab Act of 1973 was meant to create access in government buildings, but as a high schooler I learned that I could never take it for granted that the pizza joint, movie theater, concert hall, museum, or restaurant my family or friends and I headed to on any given day would actually be a place I could enter. If I could enter, there was still the real likelihood that the outing would end abruptly when I needed to pee and could not access the public restrooms.

Spontaneity increased the likelihood that right there at the front door of the inaccessible building we'd anticipated entering, I and whomever I was with would have to turn away and find someplace else we could go. Calling ahead to ask about accessibility rarely changed the outcome, since nondisabled workers frequently failed to remember some stairs or that the restroom door was just 19 inches wide and in the basement anyway. Sometimes I could be carried inside. Sometimes we could use the kitchen entrance. In some movie theaters lacking dedicated places for wheelchair users to park, I could wedge in next to the smelly garbage can. Once at a Georgetown bar, my friends and I walked the dark and gummy back alley to a delivery ramp that led directly into the cozy back room but the ramp was at a 45-degree slant requiring several of my friends to push my scooter while I accelerated, so I arrived amongst the dinner tables like a bullet shot out of a gun. I'd been in the front of the bar -- an entryway with tables and too-high stools -- and basically been told to leave and try the back door.

When I wasn't alone, there was often some way to make it all work, but only rarely did I ever go anywhere that the building just allowed me in. And there's no immediate recourse to structural inaccessibility. No amount of argument with the manager widens the bathroom stall door or eliminates the need for an elevator. No phonecall or letter made the next day alleviates the problem, either. Pre-ADA, no one was compelled to fix access anyway. They could legally shrug and turn away -- and some did.

There were occasions when the event we'd hoped to attend was prepaid, important, or too exciting for everyone with me to miss, and so I went home or waited somewhere alone while others climbed the stairs without me. I did and do have dedicated friends. My best friend in high school once held me piggy-back through an entire concert so that I could see the band instead of sitting in my chair looking at other people's butts. My brother and father carried me more than once into the melee of the Indianapolis 500, blocks away from our car and up into the bleachers without my wheelchair. Schoolmates carried me on and off the commuter train for the history class fieldtrip into Chicago to see Brian Dennehy perform the play Galileo.

I had a happy and remarkably integrated adolescence because of the love and loyalty of the people around me, but that level of daily exclusion, that impenetrable kind of exclusion that is only fixed with sledgehammers and new elevators IF someone who owned the building decided someday to bother (not on my account, and not when I was waiting at the door) did its part to shape who I am and how I react to discrimination and disregard. I learned emotional ambivalence, the skill of being water off the duck's back, so that I could meet this isolating uncertainty every day.

It's been my defense mechanism, to shrug and say, "oh well." It's sometimes been accompanied by activism and calls demanding access, but mostly only after returning home in defeat. I don't know how other people with disabilities have coped. I don't know how people of color during Jim Crow handled their rage about the back of the bus and the separate drinking fountains, though there is something to be said for being able to get on the bus. I do know something of how women handle the rampant sexism in our culture. These are all relatively quiet violences to the soul.

When the hatred is clearly spoken or made physical, those are different more urgent situations to address. And I'm unfamiliar with them. I spent my youth anesthetizing myself just enough to stand the daily less-violent silent injustices, and I think it means I tend to underact when the hatred is more open. Open hatred is rarely directed at me, because I'm straight, white, upper-middle-class background, educated, and because ableism usually looks different than the racism or transphobia that leads to sudden violence and death. Which isn't to say that the nondisabled person who states, "I'd rather be dead than live like you do," isn't speaking hate -- but almost nobody calls it that and we've all been taught that such a statement is personal preference rather than code for "your life isn't worth as much as mine."

I think my reactions to hatred have sometimes puzzled my friends, the radical feminists ready for a fight, the women of color, lesbian, gay and transgender folk who live with their families under threat of much quicker physical violence than I ever have. I see that and know I need to change and join the greater fight for them and myself a bit differently. How much has the ADA actually changed and how much of my defenses can I afford to dismantle? Does there really need to be a balance between helping myself stay sane and reacting appropriately? It shouldn't be that way.

Monday, January 29, 2007

Eyes on whose prize

I want to speak my own truth, and honor the words of others when they speak theirs. I want to be an ally, but I don't want to get in the way. I want to make the connections between my experiences and other people's in ways that broaden my understanding and avoid the narrowing of concerns into little camps of people struggling for recognition. I want to interject disability issues into conversations where they seem unspoken or invisible, and I don't want to feel selfish for doing it. And I want other people to do the same, so I can see where I've centered my own concerns and marginalized someone else's. I want to see how the whole big mess fits together.

Wanting so much usually keeps me rather quiet, outside of the small community of disability blogs that have become a comfort zone for me. And the comfort has been needed lately when the Ashley Treatment -- a story so fundamentally about attitudes on bodily and mental difference and disability -- continues to be debated everywhere. Only on sites dedicated to bodily and mental difference specifically, have I seen any real re-centering of that debate away from ableist tendencies to make allowances for behavior or words that dehumanize the less than normal body. I've felt myself turning in protectively to my dis or dis-cool friends: Penny, Connie and Steve, WCD, Amanda, I'mFunnyToo, David. . . .

It's no coincidence I feel safest among those who also have an obvious stake in whether or not physical or mental ability is used to determine how we treat people. It's no coincidence that our widely disparate experiences of disability arrive at the same political sympathies. And I suppose it's no coincidence that when we're discounted as irrelevant or fanatical about the topic at hand, we're all discounted together.

And today, Kevin at Slant Truth reminds me that this is how the system of oppressions works, and that it's happening elsewhere and isolation isn't the right response:

I will come out proud and say that I am supportive of the Trans community and will work from here on out for their full personhood. The hate I have seen lately is beyond my comprehension. I reject it all. Fuck you if you aren’t down.
Oh, I've more to say on this, now that I've resolved to begin. But I wanted to get this much out there now.

Thursday, January 18, 2007

Slumgullionish miscellanea (#24)

William Peace's "Protest from a bad cripple: The Ashley Treatment and the making of a pillow angel" in CounterPunch:

Doctors have established a precedent with Ashley—it is ethically and socially acceptable to mutilate the bodies of disabled people. What Ashley and her doctors have failed to grasp is that all disabled people share a common bond. In my opinion there is no difference between myself and Ashley despite the great disparity in our intellectual abilities. If you doubt this let me relay one story from my childhood. In 1972 I was a 7th grade student at a Catholic school in New York. The school was not unusual but I was. I had a rare neurological condition that was beginning to take its toll on my ability to walk. Shortly after school started I vividly recall homework being handed out and the nun came over to me and said, “You no longer need to do homework because you are one of God’s special children”.
A thorough collection of the disability community's responses to The Ashley Treatment.

From NewsDay, Sen. Charles Schumer (D), of New York talks about the special difficulties faced by injured National Guardsmen and Reservists:
Disability claims filed by National Guardsmen and Reservists are denied at twice the rate of active duty troops, he said. Guardsmen and reservists in college sent for full-time training earn just $297 per month, while active duty soldiers earn more than $1,000, he said.

In addition, wounded guardsmen and reservists often must recuperate at medical facilities far from home, he said. They are tied to units scattered throughout the country.

The Guard and Reserves have been used more in the Iraq War than in any prior conflict. At one point, half of the deployed troops in Iraq were with the Guard or Reserves.

"They are risking the same amount of danger," said Schumer (D-N.Y.) at a news conference at Hofstra University Monday, surrounded by cadets with the school's ROTC program. "They should be given the same benefits."
The South Dakota Argus Leader reports on the unusual motions filed in the murder trial of deaf defendant Daphne Wright:
The lawyers requested the victim's friends and family be prohibited by the court from acting out or displaying emotion during the trial. They also requested the court not allow "gruesome or inflammatory photographs" from the crime.

Wright, 43, is accused of kidnapping, killing and dismembering Darlene VanderGiesen, 42, in February 2006. Wright and VanderGiesen were both deaf, which has become an issue in the court proceedings.

Prosecutors have indicated they will seek the death penalty if Wright is convicted on the charges she faces: murder and kidnapping.

But Wright's lawyers say that because she is deaf, it would be cruel to execute her.

And to my Malaysian friend who sent me a link about disability news there, I have lost that email. Please resend the info and other news in the future.

Monday, January 15, 2007

. . . And you're tired too

But really, this article out of the Beach Center for Disability at Kansas University is the best discussion of the issues the Ashley X case represents that I have seen anywhere. Some quotes:

We do not presume to judge the parents or physicians in this particular case. As a case study, however, the case raises complicated issues for us (the Turnbulls are parents of a man with disabilities, and all of us are researchers).

Why must an unusual medical intervention be even considered for the family who wants to keep their child at home? It shouldn’t, at least not until all efforts to provide support to the family, in its home, have been exhausted. Good policy begins with family support.

And:
Two standards guided the physicians in this case.

One was that this case and subsequent ones should be decided on a case-by-case basis. Due process prefers presumptions, not unguided case-by-case decision-making. At law, a presumption (innocent until proven guilty) pushes decision makers toward a pre-established, socially desirable result. Usually, the presumption can be overcome by sufficient proof (guilty beyond a reasonable doubt).

Case-by-case decision making, without any presumption against surgery, much less such an unusual one as growth attenuation, gives free rein to the physicians and institutional review boards. History teaches that unchecked professional freedom leads to over-use of procedures whose long-term efficacy is unknown or is demonstrably injurious.

The second standard was the usual one of medical risk-benefit. Here, questions arise. What are the long-term benefits of growth attenuation surgery? Will the procedure definitely reduce the child’s weight? Will it produce no undesirable effects? Clearly, the surgery will not prevent the parents from aging or necessarily lead to better and longer-term in-home care.

And this:

One of history’s lessons is that evidence-based decision-making by those who purport to act in another’s best interest has been elusive. Another is that it is exceptionally difficult to stand in the shoes of a person who is a minor with a disability and predict what that person would want, especially where the person’s life has provided no warrant — no evidence — about what the person would want.

Further, disability is a condition that society creates by its failure to accommodate to people with impairments; impairments are the inherent conditions that affect a person’s functioning. Stigma — the negative connotation arising out of difference (such as impairments) — still drives decision-making.

Patston on Ashley

This is short, but worth reading.

Friday, January 12, 2007

I am tired

Because fear and hatred of disabled people hides in people's hearts in the same way as sexism, transphobia and racism:

Ashley is not a "disabled" person that can enjoy a stroll down the mall for social stimulation. A 3 month old mind cannot do such a thing.

Personally, I'm tired of liberal whiners thinking they are better than everyone else.

The word disabled gets used way too much. If you can make your own decisions and think for youself, then guess what, you're not disabled.

Ashley on the other hand can do not of these things, her I would considered disabled.
Because so many people deny the slippery slope, but during the Schiavo case a common argument to silence the voices of disabled people was that Terri wasn't disabled but brain-dead, and now a common argument to deny the voices of disabled people is to claim Ashley's level of consciousness (higher than Terri's) is comparable to a turnip and also irrelevant to our experiences:
The problem is modern medicine can keep a turnip alive for many years i.e. 100 years ago this child would have died at a very young age as mother nature intended. But since we have to play God and keep the turnip alive then we also get to play God and choose when/how to trim the turnip when it grows in a way we deem unfit. Basically this treatment is ENTIRELY for the parents benefit and as such it does help the parents but please drop the delusion that it helps the vegetable because the vegetable would be best off with as little pain inflicted as possible i.e. let the vegetable die.
Because I know some supposed "turnips" online who slay me with their sharp intelligence:

Please remember that disabled women are women, too. So much of these discussions go back to a description of disabled people as being passive recipients of care from “mostly women”, leaving disabled women totally invisible in the whole thing. I’ve seen really good feminist disability writing (try Jenny Morris), but feminist writing that approaches disability primarily as a caregiving issue isn’t generally it — it casts women as the victims of the existence of disabled people (including disabled women) and usually proposes horrifically oppressive solutions to the problem of our existence.

Because this isn't about just one child:
The action is in response to the AMA’s sanction of the “Ashley Treatment” through its publication of the original case article in the Archives of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine case. This AMA owned-journal went so far as to call for further “study” of the issue by subjecting more children to the same drastic surgeries and follow them over time.
Because there are other signs that society is becoming more impatient with the existence of disabled folks:
For example, Dr. Goldberg said, a 29-year-old woman and her partner might now choose amniocentesis instead of a blood test. In the past, the more invasive procedure was seldom recommended for younger women because it could sometimes result in miscarriage. Now the risk is considered to be quite low, and in any event, Dr. Goldberg said, for some couples “losing a normal pregnancy secondary to the procedure is not as problematic as the birth of a Down syndrome child, so they’re willing to take that risk.”
Because so many of our supposed allies seem unable to listen or offer real support beyond their own fears and agendas:
If I were this girl’s caregiver, my worst fear would be that there would be a chance one day that I may not be around to care for her. And that she might end up in hospice care, where she could be sexually abused and end up pregnant. And that because she’s white, there would be a lot of antagonism towards aborting said pregnancy to spare her the misery and that a bunch of “pro-lifers” would stake on the hospital, Terri Schiavo-style, enamored of the idea of a pregnant white woman without a real will of her own. In other words, the perfect baby incubator. There’d be moaning and wailing and sentimental rhapsodizing about getting a “miracle” baby out of this poor girl. Doctors, under all this pressure, would cave because it’s not like she can really do anything about it. And then the baby would be born and everyone would be all in raptures and Reader’s Digest would have an article about it and Ashley would be reduced from a human being to a baby incubator. So you better believe I’d want to just circumvent that. This situation has nothing to do with eugenics unless you’re paranoid enough to think that the genetically normal offspring of college-educated white people are a target.
Because of the disrespect:
While I certainly don't envy your situation and feel blessed that I am lucky to not be disabled, I am sickened by your rantings. Who exactly do you think you are? Your disability is NOT an entitlement to place judgement upon others.

95% of the posters that agree with you are only agreeing out of PITY. They are too short-sighted to see that your particular situation, contrasted with Ashley's, is like night and day. Instead, they ignorantly assume that your ridiculous 'I am Ashley' statement is true simply because you both have severe disabilities.

Why don't you reveal your true motivation? It must be nice to have a link to your blog on CNN, right? Enjoy your fifteen minutes of fame but, seriously, quit with this betrayal nonsense. I mean, come on, to refer to her parents as "parents" (I'm referring to the quotation marks)? Are you actually advocating that they did what they did for any reason other than absolute love, caring and adoration of their daughter?

You may be disabled, but you're still a judgemental, self-righteous prick.
Because the weird convergence of attention and disregard is a kind of quiet violence:
Maybe, just maybe, bloggers who are disabled don’t really want to discuss shit like this over and over and over again–especially when people are not just discussing their right to access or something like that (where the presumption of humanity deserving of life is at least present), but are actually challenging disabled peoples very right to live as autonomous respected human beings. Maybe bloggers who are disabled really don’t feel like debating whether or not they are “burdens” worthy of extreme forms of violence just to suit able-bodied people. Maybe they aren’t interested in debating whether or not they have a right to be alive.

Thursday, January 11, 2007

On the Chicago protest against AMA

From the Associated Press

A report from protestor and FRIDA member Amber Smock on the events of the day:

We targeted the AMA because it sanctioned the "Ashley Treatment" by publishing the original article describing it in one of its publications, the Archive of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine. In addition, the publication's editors recommended that the way to find out if the "Ashley Treatment" was beneficial was to perform it on other children.

Our demands were threefold. First, we asked that the AMA's Committee on Ethical and Judicial Affairs meet with a team of advocates from the disability community to review the case. Second, we asked that the AMA issue a formal statement of support for MiCASSA. Third, we asked that the AMA issue a statement condemning the "Ashley Treatment" for other children.

On Thursday afternoon, our coalition met up at a coffee shop, about twenty strong. (FYI having coffee before an action is a really, really, really good idea!) We would be joined by others at the site. We lined up and proceeded to the building housing the AMA offices. We arrived and attempted to enter through the accessible entrance. Security guards blocked the majority of the group from entering, citing the "fact" that the lobby was private property. Our group began entering through the *other* accessible door. Most of us made it in. Reporters had already arrived and had begun attempting to interview the protesters. Our negotiating team began attempting to meet with AMA CEO Michael Maves.

After several minutes of attempting to gather in the lobby, our team decided to move outside because we were losing the opportunity to get recorded on TV cameras. Our negotiating team remained inside to continue fighting for access (the Michael Maves kind). Once we moved outside, we faced a barrage of TV cameras, as well as print and radio reporters. The media presence was truly incredible and our coalition had worked very hard to achieve that. We whipped out our protest signs, which included slogans such as "Operations Not Accommodations" and "AMA: Stop Medical Oppression of Women." (Thanks to Sharon Lamp, who is DA QUEEN of good slogans!) Gary Arnold then led the group in a skit on how to apply for an ethics job with the AMA.

Then, while we waited for news of negotiations, we chanted and chanted and CHANTED!!! The police wanted us to move away from the building and gave us three warnings. The media were complaining they could not interview us, so we went ahead and moved farther away, so we got interviews and plus, the people looking down from the highrise building had a good look at the disabled people making a stink on the ground! The employees sure had an exciting day. Many came down to the lobby to observe what was going on.

After about 45 minutes, our negotiating team came away with a deal: apparently the CEO was on a plane somewhere and unreachable (so they say...). His secretary committed to securing us a meeting with her boss next week. You know what will happen if that doesn't happen....!!!!! So we will be following up with all of you for your support if they don't meet our promises!

At that point, we had a load of media coverage and as much of a win as we could secure before the paratransit rides arrives. So we called it a victory and chanted some more, yeah you know what it was..."The people united will never be defeated!"
The best thing about this action is the AP covered us with a photographer too, so the story is going out across the nation...and I just got word CNN included our action in a story. The other best thing about the action was the people who turned out and worked to get this organized. The energy was fantastic! Amazing! The best thing to happen to feminist/disability rights in a long, freakin' time!
Local Chicago TV news coverage, complete with video of the protestors.

Disability bloggers quoted on CNN

Earlier this week, David at Growing up with a Disability, Penny of Disability Studies, Temple U., and Nufsaid at Ramblings were noted by CNN for their blogging against the Ashley Treatment from their perspectives of personal experience. I believe I've linked to my friends' writings on this before, but it's so good to see them as part of the national debate. The CNN article here.

Wednesday, January 10, 2007

FRIDA protests Ashley Treatment at AMA tomorrow

From the press release:

At 1 p.m. on Thursday, January 11, Feminist Response in Disability Activism (FRIDA), with the support of other disability groups, will stage an “Ashley Treatment” demonstration at the national headquarters of the American Medical Association (AMA) in Chicago at 515 N. State Street.

FRIDA will demand that the AMA start practicing real ethical accountability and dialogue with the disability community. The action is in response to the AMA’s sanction of the“Ashley Treatment” through its publication of the original case article in the Archives of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine case.This AMA-owned journal went so far as to call for further “study” of the issue by subjecting more children to the same drastic surgeries and follow them over time.

People with disabilities and families nationwide have reacted with outrage to the drastic medical “solution” to what is actually a complex social problem of finding real supports for people with disabilities and their families. FRIDA is also not surprised that the initial recipient of the “Ashley Treatment” was a little girl, given that girls, and girls with disabilities in particular, are perceived as easier subjects for mutilation and desexualization.

Ana Mercado of FRIDA notes, “Our bodies really are the battlegrounds on which ethics debates are fought.” FRIDA seeks to protect our bodies from having to become battlegrounds in the first place. The issue at hand is not our bodies, but the choices that other people make for our bodies.

FRIDA is a group of radicalized women with disabilities representing ourselves and fighting for freedom for our bodies. FRIDA is supported in this action by Chicago ADAPT, the national ADAPT community, Not Dead Yet and Advance Youth Leadership Power (AYLP).

More linkage on Ashley

Time magazine: "Pillow Angel Ethics, Part 2," Part 1 here.

DREDF statement (Disability Rights Education & Defense Fund)

Commentary at The Independent: "The moral line in medicine shifts once again."

Nufsaid at Ramblings: Mom of disabled son weighs in.

DreamMom: Parts 1 and 2 on the Ashley Treatment -- Another Mom of disabled child responds.

Brownfemipower at Women of Color -- Lengthy comments.

Women's Space/The Margins -- Again, long comment thread.

And with huge comment threads, Alas, A Blog: Here and here.

Did I miss someone? Add the link in comments.

Updated:

Sharon at The Voyage writes here and here.

Elmindreda of Random Reminiscing Ramblings writes "Dear Ableist."

Monday, January 08, 2007

Still thinking on Ashley

I'm crossposting this comment of mine from a discussion I'm participating in elsewhere:

One thing I find so frustrating about the widespread discussion of the "Ashley Treatment" is the complete unwillingness by so many people to assess the parental decisions. Understandably, people are sympathetic to their situation and are rightly giving them some benefit of the doubt. But the decision-making process between medical professionals and parents of disabled kids is always really complex, always done on a steep learning curve, and always involves pressure from those medical experts that parents do not always have the experience to rationally assess. It's relevant that the parents' website expressly states that they did not have any doubts about this decision and want very much to offer and push this treatment for other children. That's an incredibly worrisome degree of certainty and salesmanship about a complex and murky ethical decision, if you ask me.

I could name a few less extreme but questionable ethical medical practices I was subject to as a child with a physical condition that intrigued the medical community my parents consulted beginning at the time of my birth. At the age of nine (same physical age as Ashley) I was examined in a medical boardroom by about 20 medical professionals who saw nothing problematic with me wearing only panties and walking around the boardroom table so that individuals could touch my muscles and discuss what they all saw in my body. There was technical debate and also discussions I completely understood about this or that failure of my muscles when I was asked to perform. A joke or two was made, probably as attempts to lighten the atmosphere, but the laughter is a distinct part of the unhappy memory that has stuck with me these past 30 years. A photographer took pictures that I was sure ended up on the newsmagazine show 20/20 a couple years later as falsely-labeled examples of anorexia. I doubt that was true, but it's always haunted me. I was a bright nine-year-old, but I didn't consent to those pictures of me in only my panties and I don't know who has seen them or where they ended up.

My parents can easily see now -- and even did in the confusion of that day -- that it was an inappropriate and harmful venue in which to give a child medical care, but they were desperate and hopeful and didn't know if the consequences of this ordeal would lead to some cure or treatment that, on balance, would make it worthwhile. They gritted their teeth and stuck it out, hoping for something useful to come of it. Lots of medical decisions are like that. It does not mean the parents should not be judged or culpable for what is decided. The ends do not jusitfy the means, especially when the ends are so completely unknown. And it seems telling and worrisome that Ashley's parents lack any self-reflective doubt about a clearly uncertain situation. It's dishonest about the dynamics, at the very least.

Saturday, January 06, 2007

Ashley Treatment discussion at Pandagon

I regularly enjoy reading the feminist posts and discussions at Pandagon, but the recent coverage there of the story of Ashley X and the medical procedures to alter her body for the convenience of her caregiving parents begs for further discussion away from what seems to be a rather strident point of view that beleaguered parents of disabled children really can do no wrong. You know, because it's their unimaginable burden and, luckily, not ours.

Amanda begins by stating:

To make it very clear, she will never improve. She’s never going to develop the capacity to make decisions or think or move much on her own.
So, okay. This may be completely true. Or it may be partially true and she will show some minor improvement but never be able to make important decisions independently. Or, like quite a few underestimated disabled people chatting about this on the nets, the medical experts may have done what so very frequently happens to disabled people and discounted them far too early. This discounting and underestimating the medical community does before disabled people are then limited in their life options through the decisions of others is a key aspect of the institutional and societal discrimination disabled people face every day.

Is Ashley's situation one where the medical experts' pronouncements of her permanently childlike mental status is absolutely accurate? Wheelchair Dancer and Cory Silverberg argue persuasively that it doesn't matter and I'd warn that the slippery slope argument too often only really applies on the far side of the disability divide rather than within the widely divergent ranks of disabled people, whose abilities vary at least as widely as abilities among those considered nondisabled.

The disabled folks who are talking about this case are not worried about sliding into that crevice the Ashley Treatment opens the way for -- we have been in it, we've been included in discussions as the equivalent of Ashley, public policies and conventional wisdom dealing with the moral fuzziness of this case too often already puts us right there with Ashley. We too are seen as the "objects" of this problem, with the "subjects" duking it out over what constitutes appropriate care. The differences between our mental capacities and those of people like Ashley are used to separate us, invalidate all those times we are treated as if our disabled bodies complemented a disabled mind. We too are infantilized and patted on the head as parents and other experts on our conditions testify to our needs.

Amanda also says:
In terms of disability rights activism, the compelling case for it is the idea that having a disability doesn’t mean that your life isn’t worth living and therefore you should be accomodated and given as many opportunities as anyone else for the joys of life that other people who are considered more able-bodied have. With that in mind, I think it’s quite possible the parents of this girl are living up to that standard, if in a way that’s startlingly out of the norm. They’ve identified their daughter’s needs and pleasures—basically, those of an infant—and are looking for ways to fight social structures and even biology that would erode their daughter’s ability to have those things. It’s weird, but it makes sense. From that perspective, they are taking activism into a new dimension, seeking not a cure, but a radical rethinking of how far we’re willing to go to accomodate the disabled as they are. I might be wrong, but it’s worth considering it from that angle.
What an ugly twisting of disability rights activism to use it to justify behavior "startlingly out of the norm." How is removing the child's breast buds to prevent future sexual abuse "fighting social structures" and public ambivalence to the fate of the thousands of disabled people sexually abused every year. Why is fighting normal biology acceptable for "abnormal" bodies or abnormal minds? How is being treated differently from nondisabled human beings part of the disability rights cause? How does "radically rethinking how far we are willing to go to accommodate the disabled as they are" relate to a case where a child's body undergoes radical surgery? Why does including disabled people among those you treat with basic human respect require radical rethinking at all?

There are lots of viable ways to approach this complex topic of the "Ashley Treatment," but justifying it as a form of disability rights activism is not one of them.

Update: Well, Sally said much of this, much better, in my own blog's comments here.

Friday, January 05, 2007

The Ashley Treatment

Not a good time to write in detail about what I think, here are some other folks who have expressed what's on my mind better than I could have. The first three especially address the Ashley Treatment from both disabled and feminist perspectives:

Wheelchair Dancer

Penny Richards at Disability Studies, Temple U.

Mary Johnson of Ragged Edge

Cory Silverberg

Arthur Caplan, Ph.D., director of the Center for Bioethics at the University of Pennsylvania

Thirza Cuthand at Fit of Pique

I'm Funny Too at Did I Miss Something?

I posted briefly here and here.

The "Ashley Treatment." Do you suppose I could syndicate my medical plan too?

On mental capacity

I felt on top of the discussion yesterday afternoon, but it's shot way ahead of me by midnight last night. I'll get into it more, but for now, this infant:











and this nine-year-old child:














are not mentally equivalent just because the medical determination is that the latter has the mental capacity of a three-month old baby. One has experienced nine years in the world, which may include nine years of memories and clearly does include nine years of consciousness, however different or limited from the consciousness which most of us know.