Saturday, September 23, 2006

Saturday Slumgullion #12

  • "Pimp my gimp." Recent Doonesbury strips showing B.D.'s efforts to decorate his prosthetic leg are the latest in good crip giggles.
  • Sage of Persephone's Box has an announcement about blog color choices and the her ability to read what is offered. While we're on the topic, I can't remember who posted on it recently, but the CAPTCHA function for spam-proofing comments at many sites is troublesome for many of the sight-impaired. I've turned mine off and so far the spam on my little site is only about 2 per day.
All down the West Africa coast, ships registered in America and Europe unload containers filled with old computers, slops, and used medical equipment. Scrap merchants, corrupt politicians and underpaid civil servants take charge of this rubbish and, for a few dollars, will dump them off coastlines and on landfill sites.
  • Another article in the same edition tells of the daily struggles of African women and how sexism and ableism work together to make life hard:
An HIV-positive woman is nearly 10 times as likely to experience violence at the hands of her partner as a woman who does not have the disease. Domestic violence causes more deaths and disability among women aged 15 to 44 worldwide than cancer, malaria, traffic accidents and war. In at least 20 African countries, more than half the women have also suffered female genital mutilation.
  • The founder of a Swiss clinic offering assisted suicide for the terminally ill wants to widen the scope of elligible people to those who are depressed.
He claimed that such a move would help to cut the suicide rate to about 20 per cent to 25 per cent of its current level. “You could avoid the huge majority and reduce costs to the health services,” he said.
    Apparently, if someone commits your suicide for you, it isn't legally suicide. (True, btw. This also means family can cash in on insurance policytaken out on the dead person.)
  • A visually-impaired Atlantic City man sues the city and the "senior-transportation service" (I'm not sure why they call it that and not just paratransit like everyone else) because the driver arriving to pick him up in July, 2004, refused to let his guide dog on the bus. She was afraid of dogs.
  • A respiratory disease called "popcorn lung" plagues workers in American factories where a chemical in artificial butter flavor is used on microwave popcorn.
  • Time magazine's feature story, "Who pays for special ed?" begs for some disability blogging by those with more expertise than me on the squeeze between parents of disabled children and school districts feeling a desperate budget crunch.
  • Larry Scott writes about the Republican plan for "Buying-out Disabled Veterans" with a lump-sum disability compensation and all the questions that brings up about eligibility for medical care through the VA.
  • "The Meaning of Deafness" discusses education for deaf students and the conflicting philosophies parents of young children must chose between.


Crossposted at Alas, A Blog
Check there for more comments

Wednesday, September 20, 2006

Andrea Dworkin on disability

I don't know what the feminist reaction to this post will be, but it won't get out of my head, so I had to write it out. I'm interested to hear.

I'm not a big personal fan of Andrea Dworkin's writing, but I appreciate her contributions to feminism and her work as a radical thinker. When she died in April, 2005, I read a couple dozen obituaries and blog posts that celebrated her life and learned more about who she was as a woman and activist. The Guardian released "Through the Pain Barrier," reportedly her last piece of writing, completed just a month before her death. I was excited to hear that the topic was her experience with disability, and I couldn't wait to see what the woman whose writing and speaking style had been described as "apocalyptic" might say about disability and civil rights.

I was disappointed.

Her account of her osteoarthritis, double-knee replacement and the years of troubled rehabilitation and pain afterward is deeply personal, as is typical of many Dworkin essays. She begins by blaming her osteoarthritis on a 1999 rape in a Paris hotel.

Doctors tell me that there is no medical truth to my notion that the rape caused this sickness or what happened after it. I believe I am right: it was the rape. They don't know because they have never looked.
I do believe horrific experiences and emotional pain can contribute significantly to a person's health, but I wince at the general notion that a common condition needs to be attributed to personal crises. Impairments happen. God doesn't cause them and they exist without need for any form of moral explanation, whether it blames the person or makes them a victim of someone else's moral flaws. Needless to say, I'm uncomfortable with the way Dworkin begins.

Dworkin's treatment for her worsening knees follows what I understand to be a typical pattern of drugs, cortisone shots and finally knee replacement surgery. I don't envy her or the senior citizens I know who've had this treatment or are in the midst of it. Despite various setbacks, the people I know personally who have been through this recovered their mobility after the surgeries, though they did experience the basics of what Dworkin describes rather dramatically here:

I still don't know what he did to me but I came to the conclusion that the operation was barbaric, involving as it did the sawing out of the arthritis, which meant sawing through bones. It was like being kneecapped, twice, or having one's knees and bones hammered and broken into bits. After the operation I was in a nightmare of narcotics and untouchable pain. There were morphine shots. I asked for them and got them often. Even morphine shots in the upper arm hurt.

I had a hallucination but it is still real as rain to me. I was in Virginia Woolf's house and I was happy. But "they" wanted me to go down the stairs. I can't, I begged, I can't. My hospital bed was at the top of the stairs and I was afraid that they were going to push me down. I saw the steep decline of the steps. I couldn't get over my visceral fear of falling or being pushed or being turned over from the bed down the flight of steps. I kept experiencing my bed as being on the edge of a precipice.

I agree that the operation seems "barbaric" and thinking about it gives me the willies, but I dislike how Dworkin makes these personal experiences of a common procedure out to be extraordinary. All serious surgeries cause pain, and heavy-duty painkillers do cause hallucinations. I violently beat up a sock puppet in one fentanyl-induced hallucination last November for reasons I can't explain. After back surgery at age 16, I imagined my hospital bed was in a basement hallway and I'd been abandoned there. It took repeated reassurances from nurses and my hospital roommate to convince me I was safe and stop me from hollering for help. My grandmother saw spiders all over the walls once. These hallucinations are normal, though as individual as dreams, and are not proof of anyone's suffering or victimization.

I relate well to Dworkin's descriptions of physical and occupational rehabilitation, including the weird and often purposeless tasks required in OT:
Rehabilitation also includes so-called occupational therapy: throw a ball around in a circle; put round pegs in round holes; stand up, arms on a table, and read a page of a magazine; water a plant; play checkers or cards; and the piece de resistance, cook and serve a simple meal.
And the sexism she notes of caregiver expectations upon returning home I saw, as well:
On discharge, social services are provided. My male partner is not expected to be a care-giver.
I have no experience of the "pain management centres" she describes, but they do sound tedious. I'm simply stunned by the potent mix of painkillers she says they kept her on.
Curly eventually puts me on Percocet, fentanyl patches and methadone. I am on these drugs for nearly two years. I become slightly indifferent to the awful pain. My speech slurs and my memory is impaired.
Fentanyl is dangerous for any length of time, I was told. The patches Dworkin used prompted an FDA advisory in 2005. I was weaned from fentanyl injections after a few weeks in ICU and I missed it terribly at first. You may recall fentanyl was the painkiller mixed with heroin or cocaine that was responsible for dozens of deaths this past spring.

Dworkin's three-story New York residence disturbs me greatly. Not that she didn't move somewhere more accessible -- I know how difficult that can be. But did she really spend years crawling up and down three floors of steps between kitchen, bathroom and shower? I find that intolerable, and either unbelievable or lacking in creativity or... something. Adapt, Andrea. Adapt! Bathe in the kitchen or pee in the shower or something. Spare yourself some pain. If there are any triumphs of adaptation Dworkin does discover for herself, she never mentions them.

I remain ambivalent about the descriptions of her leg braces and the humor and pathos there. It doesn't seem as though she accepts her body for what it is, and I had hoped for more from the woman who made no accommodations to expectations of feminine beauty or style. Depression rules her state of mind:
I can't bear it or accept it. I reject the extent of my disability. I find myself in a silent rage that stretches over weeks. I am utterly exhausted by my incapacity. I am worn out from walking. I am sick of physical therapy.
She lacks perspective on what a "little humiliation" is too:
I keynote a conference on the Holocaust. The organiser picks me up. She is driving a truck. I try to climb up into it. She physically pushes me under my ass without permission, all the while talking to me in baby talk, put your tooshie there, keep your cute little fanny there. I turn to her and say, I am disabled, not stupid. A friend throws a party for me in Washington. I ask how many steps there are to the apartment. He doesn't know. I assume he will get back to me. John and I go to the party. There are three flights of steps. I can't get to the party being given for me. We could have given it in another venue, the friend says the next day. It cuts. I go to a bar and need to use the rest room. The men's is filthy, the bartender says; the women's is two flights up. I use the dirty one. I go to a new movie theatre that has elevators and disability bathrooms but the polished stone of the floor is so slick that my crutches cannot safely navigate it. I am walking with a friend who suddenly looks at my crutches and says, you don't want to be this way the rest of your life, do you? Her repulsion is barely masked. I feel unutterably alone.
While some of these encounters are minor, the party in her honor that she could not even attend seems a big frustration and failure of her friends to me. Three flights of steps overlooked when the guest of honor used leg braces and crutches -- it seems unconscionable.

The last several paragraphs hold promise as she turns to public access and the ADA, though most of my disappointment lies here. She acknowledges that:
Only a determined policy of public access can help to mitigate the loneliness. One needs to be able to enter buildings; have a cup of coffee; go to a restaurant, the theatre, cinema or a concert; attend school; go to lectures or readings; use public transport, bathrooms, hotel showers; go to museums and sporting events and political rallies. One needs equal opportunity in employment. One needs to be integrated into the world, not separated from it; yet one has special needs, ones that able-bodied people rarely consider. The low consciousness of the able-bodied increases alienation.
She praises the accessibility the law has provided for her in public places, and gives credit for this to juries awarding high punitive damages to plaintiffs, which is not untrue but significantly misrepresents the successes and history of the ADA in the courts. There is no indication at all that more needs to be done or that the law is perpetually under fire in the media and from Republicans in Congress.

So that wraps up my ungenerous critique. Admittedly, I'm generally uncomfortable with Dworkin's emotive writing style. And I'm uncomfortable with any telling of the crip experience that has even a whiff of the "why me?" stereotype of disability as drama. I've seen too many disease-of-the-week, inspired-by-a-true-story, whine-until-some-nondisabled-person-snaps-you-out-of-it sagas on TV and film to be comfortable with any reinforcement of that tale.

And the last time anyone really famous was given big media attention for their disability, it was Chris Reeve on Barbara Walters talking about how he had wished himself dead and how his purpose in life was now to find a cure for paralysis. When he died a decade after his paralyzing injury it was widely reported that the cause was sepsis from bedsores and that such problems were an understandable killer of any quad. In truth, Reeve died from a violent reaction to a medication, and while he had been dogged by infections he was sitting in his wheelchair at a hockey game earlier on the day of his death, something no person with a dangerous sore on his butt would ever do.

It took Reeve the better part of a decade as a disabled person to start speaking about the basic civil rights we all deserve, though he spokpubliclyly about other issues all the time. My expectation that Dworkin would stir the pot for disability rights was unrealistic and bound to disappoint. Disability isn't an identity anyone embraces overnight, and some obviously impaired people never accept it.

And beyond that, becoming politicized about the social treatment of disabled people also doesn't come easily. For most, there's no discussion around the dinner table about the day's humiliations with others who've experienced the same. The disability rights movement was largely started in the U.S. by a generation of people who caught the polio virus and were institutionalized together and perceived the injustice of their collective treatment because of this. Most crips don't experience this kind of community unless they seek it out. Not Reeve, not Dworkin, not me.

Dworkin had nothing remotely "apocalyptic" to say about disability. If she'd lived another 20 years that may or may not have changed. Her last piece of writing is not at all political despite it's mention of the ADA -- because her mention of the ADA was completely uncritical. It's just a personal piece, quintessentially Dworkin, really. And the sad truth is that any newly disabled person (or newly accepting of the identity) is not ever speaking politically about disability rights unless they say they are, celebrity or not.

Crossposted at Alas, A Blog
Check for more comments there

Tuesday, September 19, 2006

My ventilated life

I'm in a grumpy mood. It's clearly autumn today, and I love the smell of the air, but it's dreary outside and my allergies are bad. Inside, I have a meeting this afternoon with the administrator of the home health care agency that manages the nurses who help me. And all the nurses too. The meeting is here in my home with all the people who have to follow me around 24/7, and frankly, I don't want to see any of them, even the ones I'm especially fond of.

In an old New Mobility article on vents and vent users Barry Corbet writes:

The biggest single problem vent users face is the outrageous cost of their equipment and care. Many who use invasive ventilation need skilled nursing, and paying for 24 hours a day of that can be a nightmare. A few have trained friends, family and unskilled help so well they feel comfortable with a minimum of nursing care.

The care level may not be a matter of choice. Many states mandate skilled nursing for vent users. That annoys those who feel they can get by with cheaper help, and alarms those who fear their essential nursing will be cut by the current enthusiasm for cost containment.
My 24-hour nursing care isn't a matter of choice. If I get help with the cost, the help is required to be medically trained nurses. I don't know what level of assistance I'd be comfortable with -- what I get now appears to be my only choice other than a nursing home. I do need someone around to help me use the bathroom, to suction my lungs of gunk (because the trach disallows the normal process of clearing one's throat), and to help reconnect tubes should they suddenly fall apart. Or switch vents or get the external battery if there's a vent or power failure, respectively.

My big beef with my nursing assistance is that it totally medicalizes my life -- my normal life at home where I'm not ill. In the hospital I had my "vitals" (blood pressure, temperature, pulse, etc.) taken twice a day, at the beginning of each 12-hour shift. Here at home, since the vitals are supposed to be written on the time sheets each nurse hands in for pay, I sometimes have them taken three times each day. Any remarks by me that "I feel fine, terrific," would only be anecdotal to the medical evidence of the vitals they are required to collect.*

There are also nursing notes made about my activities for each day. It's written down if I took a nap, went to Target, visited with a friend, didn't want lunch, or cleaned the closet with my Mom. I'm sure there are much more intimate details, but I avoid pissing myself off about it all by not reading the log. I do know that if I whack my shin on something accidently, the bruise will probably be noted in the charts. My mother might also be asked about it as a check against my being abused.

These required procedures that do not contribute to the smooth use of my vent are an invasion of my privacy, and there's nothing I can do about it. And from what I understand I am not even permitted to contribute to the payment of this care since I'm on both federal and state disability aid. There's no incremental plan. Either I'm wealthy enough to cover it all, or I'm forced to be poor to keep the government paying for it. And there's no chance of my covering it all.

Vent user Greg Franzen tells a similar story:
"The way the insurance looks at it," he says, "you need skilled nursing. I agree with that. But if that's the case, then they won't pay for attendants. Now if I get attendants to fill in the non-nursing hours and they do a satisfactory job, will the insurance say that I don't need skilled nursing anymore? That would be devastating. I don't know if it's true -- I'm too afraid to ask."

If he lost his skilled nursing care, would a nursing home become a threat? "Very much so," he says. "People with vents are very, very vulnerable because of the cost issue. And when we have these Dr. Kevorkians running around, and with a budget crisis, I'm a more attractive target than other people just because of the expense."

It all adds urgency to the cost issue. "Somehow," he says with finality, "I need to be able to make enough money to take care of myself."

Greg might seem well-equipped to do that. He graduated in 1990 from the University of Missouri with a degree in environmental design. The trouble is, Greg says, salaries start at about $15,000 a year. "If I'm going to make $15,000 a year, and my costs are over $80,000 a year, what good is that going to do me?"

So he stays at home. In the meantime, how's his quality of life? "I think it's excellent." What makes it good? "My zeal for life. My love of life."

Quality of life is a topic of the same series of articles linked above (italics are mine):
A 1992 life satisfaction study by John Bach compared responses by 80 Duchenne muscular dystrophy ventilator users to responses by 273 MDA clinic directors. The clinic directors significantly underestimated the users' reported life satisfaction. The study concluded that patients who were perceived by physicians to have a poor quality of life were less likely to be offered assisted ventilation.

In a 1992 study by Bach and Campagnolo of 395 ventilator-assisted people who'd had polio, 86 percent reported their lives were characterized by hope, value, freedom and happiness. Forty-two percent of the ventilator users were employed and 39 percent were married. Yet again, the health professionals used for controls underestimated the life satisfaction of people using ventilators and overestimated the difficulties. It was concluded that physicians should be aware of their inability to accurately gauge the life satisfaction of individuals and should not use their perception of poor quality of life as a reason to deny ventilator assistance.

In a 1994 life satisfaction study by Bach and Tilton, 42 ventilator-assisted quads and 45 autonomously breathing quads were compared to a control group of health care professionals. Both groups with spinal cord injury reported higher life satisfaction ratings than were predicted by the controls. Notably, the ratings for those who used ventilators were higher in some areas than for those who didn't -- the former were dissatisfied with sexual function only, whereas the latter were dissatisfied with their jobs, health and sexual functioning. Vent users said life was friendlier, more interesting, more enjoyable, fuller and more hopeful than non-vent users.

A 1992 study by Whiteneck, Charlifue and Frankel of people with spinal cord injury at least 20 years post-injury showed that those using ventilators rated their quality of life higher than those who didn't, and had a lower rate of suicide ideation.
I can't explain why vent users are reportedly happier than similarly-disabled nonvent users, but I have no problem believing it's true. This vent-using life seems to be underestimated in so many ways by people. And over-regulated.

___________________________________________

*Update: The home health care meeting went extremely well. Apparently, residents in nursing homes only have their vitals checked weekly. (!) Because I have some very smart nurses I am now on the institutional plan. Once each week for vitals, except temperature, which is an indicator of infection. W00t!


Crossposted at Alas, A Blog
Check there for more comments.

Avast ye mateys!

Arrr! That's right, it be International Talk Like a Pirate Day, possibly the silliest idea ever. But admit it: You're dyin' t' drink some grog and tell someone t' go walk the plank. This silliness be about pop culture pirates, ye see, not the bloody an' brutal pirates that still sail the seas t'day.

Pop culture pirates, it be true, are surely the gimpiest people ever. Eye patches, hook hands, peg legs, and those terribly awkward hats. Why that be, I've no idea. Anyone?

Crossposted at Alas, A Blog

Saturday, September 16, 2006

Saturday Slumgullion #11

Years and years have gone by and I still can't get used to all this staring. And then the talk. Talk like fruit dropped in crystal. The talk they have kept secret even from themselves.
  • Dr. Lisa I. Iezzoni writes in the New England Journal of Medicine (as a doctor who uses a wheelchair) about the failings of nondisabled doctors in dealing with disabled patients.
  • Gordon Rattray travels Ethiopia with lots of assistance from generous and friendly people.
  • Penny at Disability Studies U, Temple Univ. offers an impressive round-up of recent disability blogging that puts my slumgullions to shame.
  • Wheelchair Dancer spent a little time last weekend critquing the NYT and its lack of crip savvy in two particular articles, here and here. Excellent analyses of the nondisabled slant in mainstream media. She also writes with candor and delicacy about how the joys of imperfection do sometimes clash with a decided ambivalence about her disability. I hope to write a response to this soon, but it's not to be missed on its own.
  • Kari Brooks catalogues some of the responses she gets when it becomes known she's a special education teacher in her post, "God loves alligators."
  • Nappy as I Want to Be writes about youth of color and mental illness. She provides lots of excellent links about specific racial groups and how vulnerability to both mental illness and lack of care can effect each when care is built focusing on the point of view and problems of mostly white males.
Now, it's a good thing I don't engage in making mass judgements about nonautistic people based on the actions of a few. If I did, I'd probably be pointing to this incident as proof that we have a moral imperative to search for a cure for "non-autism".

Like the exhibit, the book traces the families' efforts to find education, friends and support for their mentally disabled children - at a time when institutionalization was the social norm.

Through informal dinners and other get-togethers, the families became a political force, Schwartzenberg said.

"You learn about these remarkable moms," Schwartzenberg said. "It's a story about the women's movement. It's a story about civil rights. It's a story about family collections. And it's a story about disability as well."

The families' efforts culminated in the passage of the state's 1971 Education for All law, which guaranteed every Washington child an education. The law was the predecessor to the federal Education for All Handicapped Children Act of 1975.

  • In a FindLaw column from 2001, Sherry F. Colb discusses disability discrimination and her experience with the New York bar exam:
The exam was scheduled to begin at 9 AM, but the proctors in the "special" room did not hand out the test papers until closer to 10. I worried briefly that we might not get the full time allotted to complete the test, but no one seemed to be keeping an eye on the clock. The next morning, on Day Two of the exam, it appeared we would again be starting late. I asked one of the proctors whether perhaps we could begin our exam at 9 AM on that day. With a puzzled expression on her face, she asked why. I replied that everyone else was taking the exam at 9 AM, and that I did not know of any reason for us to be delayed. She smiled and responded slowly: "If you think you can take the exam with the normal people, why don't you go ahead and try?"

Crossposted on Alas, A Blog

Check there for more comments

Friday, September 15, 2006

Society for Disability Studies 2007 CFP -- Not just for scholars

Call for Proposals
Society for Disability Studies
20th Annual Conference
Seattle, May 31-June 2, 2007
“Disability & Disability Studies: Works in Progress”
Submission Deadline: 15 November 2006

2007 marks the 25th year of the Society for Disability Studies, and the field has changed dramatically over the last quarter century. As Disability Studies continues to grow, increasing its presence in university departments, cultural criticism, and art and knowledge production, SDS wants to take this anniversary opportunity to reevaluate the discipline and reflect on the state of the field. Current Disability Studies scholarship differs from much of that which precedes it, most notably in its efforts to be more inclusive, offering a more complex conception of what constitutes “disability.” Rather than remaining rooted in a particular cultural moment or ideological understanding, Disability Studies is a work in progress.

In order to encourage this kind of self-reflection, both as a field and an organization, this year’s conference addresses the idea of “works in progress,” paying particular attention to the following themes:

Disability is a work in progress. What does “progress” mean in terms of disability? How has the notion of “progress” itself been used to justify the oppression of people with disabilities, and how can these histories serve as points of coalition with other peoples marginalized in the name of “progress?” How have ideologies of “progress” been used to create and maintain categories of “disability,” and how do these histories inform and inflect histories of race, ethnicity, class, gender, sexual orientation, nation, and religion? How are definitions and representations of disability in progress, shifting according to the needs of capital, policy, and resistance? How are current immigration practices and debates building on existing notions of disability? Are the increases in disabled veterans in the US and its allies, and the massive numbers of peoples injured by occupations, invasions, insurgencies, and other conflicts worldwide, transforming our understandings of “disability” in terms of theoretical analysis or public policy?

Disability Studies is a work in progress. In its efforts to inform disability policy and understanding, the discipline has too often neglected salient categories of analysis. What issues have been swept under the rug and at what costs? What are the reasons for this lack of critical examination? As Disability Studies has grown, how has it marginalized particular methodologies, theoretical frameworks, or knowledge bases? Will the discipline benefit from a broader, more comprehensive focus, and if so, how? How does current Disability Studies scholarship vary from previous Disability Studies scholarship? At this stage in the field’s development, what possibilities for collaboration with other fields and knowledges exist? Where is the discipline headed?

SDS is a work in progress. Consider, for instance, the organization’s recent efforts to integrate race and ethnicity. Where are the points of future growth? How might SDS develop an international or transnational focus, more actively engage individuals with intellectual disabilities, facilitate the inclusion of grassroots activists, and encourage academic and/or political involvement with questions of war and immigration? What barriers currently prevent the participation and inclusion of these individuals and concerns? What role, if any, has SDS played in the construction of these barriers? How are artists, scholars, and activists deconstructing them, and what might the organization learn from their efforts?

Access is a work in progress. Often, the tendency at conferences is for participants to present completed work. This can have the effect of the presenter talking at the audience instead of to them. This conference encourages participants to try out innovative forms of access while bearing in mind ways of actively engaging the audience. For example, how can participants share their work in creative, less traditional ways in order to increase access? What can participants do not only to honor but further SDS’s access policies? How might conference access itself, and particularly presentation access, be a matter of research and discussion?

“Work” is a work in progress. Arguably, barriers often exist between Disability Studies scholarship and disability activism. One aspect of this conference will be to address these barriers through the lens of “work,” engaging divides between scholarship and activism in new ways. How might scholars and activists conceptualize their work differently? Are some kinds of work valued more than others? In what ways does each group’s work inform the other’s? How might insights from disability research translate into community activism, and how might activist projects be translated into research projects? How might the two groups—Disability Studies scholars and disability activists—work collaboratively? What are the benefits in drawing firm lines between these two approaches to disability, and what might be the attendant risks in doing so?

SDS invites activists, artists, and scholars to submit proposals for all work in progress in Disability Studies. Work can be submitted in a variety of formats, including paper presentations, poster sessions, performances, video/DVD recordings, etc. The Program Committee will make every effort to honor participants’ requests insofar as presentation format. We ask participants to bear in mind that the committee may reassign participants to other presentation formats, styles, and panels in order to develop the richest program possible.

Contact information and additional submission details provided at the link above.

Thursday, September 14, 2006

Congressional Oversight Committee on the ADA

Today the U.S. House of Representatives Judiciary Committee, Constitution Subcommittee, held an oversight hearing on "The ADA: Sixteen Years Later." Witnesses included Tony Coelho, Robert L. Burgdorf, and Naomi Earp, former House member, professor of law, and EEOC chair, respectively. Video of the hearing available here.

ADAPT on NPR's Morning Edition

Listen for Joseph Shapiro, author of No Pity, on Friday's Morning Edition of NPR. He'll be discussing ADAPT (American Disabled for Attendant Programs Today) and their efforts to free disabled people from institutions and insure accessible, affordable housing is available. ADAPT has been making noise in Washington, D.C. this month.

Grab your scalpel

Even this virtual hip surgery made me squeamish, but it is very cool.

Wednesday, September 13, 2006

Chairless classroom creates spatial inequality

Mayo Clinic researchers have designed a chairless classroom that they say may cut down on childhood obesity even as it helps children focus on learning and being happier in school.

"We know that a major culprit behind obesity is a lack of physical activity," says Dr. James Levine, a Mayo Clinic obesity researcher who has studied the connection between everyday movement and weight.

Levine wondered if a different type of classroom could encourage movement, and ultimately, reduce the risk of obesity. Earlier this year, Levine and Mayo Clinic colleagues put the notion to the test. They designed what they believe is the first classroom without chairs using a range of creative and mobile tools. Each student had a "standing desk" on wheels that could easily move around the classroom. Apple loaned wireless notebook computers and iPods, which students used in regular learning activities.
My high school chemistry class had high tables and stools for students to sit at. The experiments were done at these tables or at the high counters along the walls. Each student had a table and lab partner -- except for me. I sat alone at the front of the class at a low table about a yard from the chalk board.

When we had experiments, I joined some duo, peering at what they worked on with the project at my eye level. There was no way I could participate hands-on, particularly when volatile chemicals were used. A few experiments I could do at my low table. Alone. Where I didn't have the camaraderie of teamwork that the other students all enjoyed.

Similar to my chemistry classroom furniture, many restaurants now feature tall tables and stools for guests. Some busy lunchtime cafes even have wall-hugging counters with no chairs at all so workers can stand and eat -- part of the hurried lunch break of American work culture. By law, these establishments have to provide accessible wheelchair seating. I don't know what the exact occupancy ratio is, but frequently this means one or two normal-height tables in a corner somewhere for the likes of me -- if the place is ADA-compliant. A similar problem exists in bars, and restaurants that have lots of booths.

When an environment is apportioned out so that, by furniture design, wheelchair users are excluded from most of the space and all that space creates a social environment as high or higher than the wheelchair user's eye-level, the exclusion can be keenly felt. It's spatial discrimination, really. There's a place for you, but you can only stay in your place since the rest of the environment is designed in a way that is not usable.

It's fundamentally different from seating at, say, a stadium or theater where wheelchair access seating must be integrated into the whole floor plan. It may not be optimum seating -- in fact, it rarely is, since building owners can make more money keeping the premium seats wheelchair inaccessible -- but there's the potential for everyone present to be seated, more or less equally. (Nondisabled people standing at concerts and giving wheelchair users only butts to look at from their equally-expensive seats is another topic for another day.)

I like the idea of classrooms where the furniture is all mobile and teaching allows for movement and more dynamic and varied gatherings of students, but if classroom furniture begins to be designed for the standing student, the sitting ones will be even more excluded spatially. The mobile part would be excellent -- more room for wheelchairs to get around. But furniture for standing students raises the plane of classroom conversation over the wheelchair user's head.

The ADA doesn't account for perceptual/conceptual discrimination of this kind so there would be no legal recourse, as far as I know. I'm all for making classroom learning a more comfortably physical experience. Perhaps there's some way to copy what I'm told is a West Point custom: students who feel in danger of falling asleep during lectures are encouraged to get up and stand in the back of the classroom, promoting activity to focus attention. At least that's voluntary.

Article via Amy Tenderich at Diabetes Mine


Crossposted at Alas, A Blog
Check there for more comments

48

Here at the Gimp Compound, my amazing parents are celebrating their 48th wedding anniversary. I just want to say a simple

Congratulations!
I love you!

Monday, September 11, 2006

Five years later

There's some fine writing elsewhere today about 9/11 and looking back through the last five years at what it's meant to Americans. I'll refer you to more eloquent bloggers for that.

There are also some touching stories of heroes from five years ago and the devastating health effects of working in the debris.

Sunday, September 10, 2006

Providing an education

When I was twelve, doctors told me I was rarer than one-in-a-million with a condition called sarcotubular myopathy. It's not a flamboyant disease. Nothing that would make good TV emergency room drama. But apparently I am medically "interesting."*

I've seen hundreds of doctors in my life, many at teaching hospitals where student doctors are a common feature of consultations with specialists. In theory, I enjoy being an active part of the learning process in the field of medicine. In practice, the presence of students fundamentally changes the doctor-patient relationship so that I'm much less the priority at my costly (and sometimes crucial) appointments. A couple times, a doctor with something to prove to his students has left me feeling like the object of abuse.

I've had good experiences with student doctors, student nurses and student respiratory therapists (also student nurse's aides, student x-ray techs, student phlebotomists, etc.) but I'm going to describe one bad experience. Someday soon, I'll relate my worst medical student experience -- this isn't it. But both happen to have occurred within the last few years at a world-renowned hospital I have generally excellent opinions about.

The neurology department patient waiting rooms all have inaccessible examining tables with fancy dark wood sides that match the decor. In fact, the only accessible examining tables I've seen at this world-famous clinic are in the physical medicine department. But I'd seen neurologists before, and the last one had no problem with me remaining in my electric scooter while he tested my reflexes and the strength of a few muscles. The steering column pops out so it's easy to get close enough to me. I'm just lower than usual and sitting somewhere stable instead of perched on a bench I can't get to myself and need someone else to hold me upright on.

I hadn't met this Dr. Neuro before, and he came in with three residents. The students stood quietly in the corner while Dr. Neuro reviewed my medical history with me. All went well until he inquired if I could get up on the examining table and I replied that it was very inconvenient and suggested I stay in my scooter chair. He may well have had excellent reasons for preferring to use the table, but it was clear from his sharp response and demeanor that his sudden shift to insisting I get up on the table was related to the presence of the observing residents.

So we did it his way, with my parents and the residents assisting, and two residents helping me as I struggled to remain sitting atop the table without any useful support. Needless to say, testing the reflexes of a woman tensed to keep her head upright and her body from falling to the floor was impossible. I didn't stay up there long. It was readily apparent that the only thing to be learned was that I do indeed have severe muscle weakness, as both my patient records and I had declared.

I accept that I may be asked to do physically difficult or uncomfortable things to get medical treatment. I don't have a problem with that or with attempting things trial-by-error. I also know doctors take each "fact" a patient tells them about themselves with professional scepticism and I'm glad that they do. But I don't need an ego contest to come between me and my medical care.

I don't recall the rest of the appointment or if anything useful was determined or planned. Dr. Neuro was gruff and when the appointment ended, one of the residents trailing out behind him quietly apologized to me. It was a memorable appointment only because the residents were clearly embarrassed by their boss, and the boss had weirdly seen me as a threat to his authority. I do wonder what, if anything, was learned by the students that day.

__________________________________________

*One thing that makes me interesting with regard to the diagnosis is that I am not a Hutterite male. Not even close.


Crossposted at Alas, A Blog
Check there for more comments

Saturday, September 09, 2006

Saturday Slumgullion #10

  • Michael BĂ©rubĂ© shares a Chicago Tribune article where Jerry Lewis compares MDA Telethon protestors to those delightful poster children of Islam -- Hezbollah.
  • Nat Hentoff of The Washington Times looks back at the Schiavo case as Michael Schiavo becomes a Democratic shill for the right to die.
  • The photojournalists' blog WarShooter features captivating pictures of "Disability in Cambodia," though the repeated use of "suffers from-" should be ignored, if possible, unless the condition following that phrase is replaced by "abject poverty."
  • The current issue of Clamor magazine features a report on "The New Wartime Body" where Dennis Clarke, a doctor specializing in lower-extremity amputees and getting them prosthetics, says:
“The prosthetic industry is moving forward because of war.... War is the single driver of technology in our profession. The net effect of these young and vibrant amputees is that they are pressing forward and doing well; that makes us look good. Technology does not lead change. Need leads change, and war is good for business because it necessitates need. One could argue that as earnest an anti-war statement could be made regarding the same issues.”
  • ComicFoundry features a two-part analysis by Franny Howe entitled "Dissing Abilities: The Contradiction of Disabled Superheroes." It's on the strange hero-worship of animated freakery.
Crossposted at Alas, A Blog
Check there for more comments

Friday, September 08, 2006

Part D drug formulary quirks

I'm signed up for Medicare Part D, though it wasn't by my choice. The company they chose for me sent me a huge packet filled with information, rules, disclaimers, and a partial drug formulary -- that is, a partial list of the prescription drugs they've decided to cover at this time. Since local Republican politicians are swaggering in their campaign ads about how they helped create this giant headache, I thought I'd look at some details of which drugs my assigned company covers.

I freely admit I don't have any professional training that informs me about prescription drugs. My observations are purely as a layperson looking at the formulary that people must refer to in order to see if what company and plan they will choose.

My particular company is in the Medicare Part D business in all 50 states and Washington, D.C., though co-pays and monthly premiums of plans vary from state to state. Here in Minnesota, the three different plans offered vary by co-pay, premium, and when the doughnut hole begins (though it's federally-mandated that the doughnut hole end at $3,600). These three plans are named "Signature," "Complete" and "Premier," which, of course, tells you nothing whatsoever about how they actually compare. You can't even determine basic versus fancy coverage from the plan names.

Drugs are categorized according to whether the plan covers them: "generic," "preferred," "non-preferred," "specialty," and not covered. Looking at the online Signature plan formulary, which has the lowest monthly premium, here's what I can observe:

Under antidepressants, the only two brand-name drugs that are preferred are the MAO inhibitors Nardil and Parnate, both of which I've never heard of and were omitted from the formulary I received by mail. Every listed brand-name reuptake inhibitor (Cymbalta, Effexor, Lexapro, Paxil, and Zoloft) is non-preferred, meaning the consumer cost will be higher. They are all also listed as "SE," which inexplicably stands for "step therapy." This means that these drugs will not be covered by the plan unless you first try some other drug of the company's choosing, probably a generic drug. There are many generic antidepressants covered, but if you don't have a prescription for them or the brand-name equivalent, you need to visit the doctor for a new one or pay the non-preferred brand-name price.

Almost all vaccines listed are generic or preferred. A few are "specialty" and require prior authorization (PA) from the company in order to be covered.

All anti-HIV agents seem to be brand-name and preferred.

Under "bipolar agents" only Depakote and the generic lithium carbonate are in the formulary at all. Depakote is non-preferred here and wherever it's listed elsewhere.

All but one "blood glucose regulator" is either generic or preferred. So diabetics get better coverage than those who are bipolar, it seems.

Under "dyslipidemics" -- apparently cholesterol-lowering drugs -- it's a very mixed bag: There are generics. Crestor, Lescol, Vytorin and Zycor are all preferred, while Advicor, Lipitor and Zetia are not.

Cialis, Levitra and Viagra are all preferred, though quantity limits (QL) exist.

"Sex hormone modifiers" -- birth control -- are mostly generic or preferred. Plan B is non-preferred. Don't tell me that's not political.

The only "sedative/hypnotics" listed are Ambien and the generic chloral hydrate. Ambien is both non-preferred and has a QL.

All of this can be changed at any time, though consumers can only switch plans at certain times during the year. I haven't been able to find any information on when those times you can switch plans occur.

A new Kaiser Family Foundation study resulted in the following information about Medicare Part D:

Eight in 10 pharmacists (81%) say that they have had customers who had problems getting their prescriptions. One in five (19%) say such problems affected “most” of their customers in Medicare drug plans.

Two in three pharmacists (67%) say they had customers leave the pharmacy without a medication because the prescribed drug was not on their Medicare drug plan’s formulary.

Almost six in 10 pharmacists (58%) say they had customers pay out-of-pocket for their drugs because they could not verify their enrollment in a Medicare drug plan.

Nearly half of pharmacists (49%) say they had customers leave without a prescription because they could not afford the co-pay charged under the Medicare drug plan.

Nearly half of pharmacists (45%) who serve “dually eligible” beneficiaries, who were previously getting coverage through state Medicaid programs, say that these customers experienced more problems filling their prescriptions than other Medicare customers.

Among doctors with patients in Medicare drug plans, 59% say that they have had patients who experienced problems getting their prescriptions, with 15% saying “most” of their patients in Medicare drug plans had such problems. One in 10 (10%) say that they had a patient who suffered a “serious medical consequence” as a result of such problems.
And on the business side:
More than one in four (27%) say that they had to take out a loan or a line of credit because of cash-flow problems related to the Medicare drug benefit. About three in four independent pharmacists say both that they have dispensed prescriptions to their customers without knowing whether they would be paid and that the reimbursements they receive from Medicare drug plans are less than what they get from commercial payers.
It's hard to make conclusions from the formulary, though the Kaiser survey supports the idea that the program has a knack for denying some consumers the drugs they need. At the very least, it's become much more troublesome to maintain your health if you have to use Part D. Choice really isn't part of the plan. It's been replaced by uncertainty.

Crossposted at Alas, A Blog
Check there for more comments

Wednesday, September 06, 2006

Nothing about us without us

I haven't been able to stop thinking about this (.pdf file) since I read it a week ago. It's the text of a speech by Jim Elder-Woodward given to the Scottish Disability Equality Forum in 2000 that begins with a description of events at the 14th World Congress of Rehabilitation International in Winnipeg, Canada, in 1980.

At this Congress, Rehabilitation International published its own Charter, the central aim of which was to call on participating governments to take all necessary steps to ensure disabled people had full integration and equal participation in all aspects of the life of their communities.

However, at the same congress, the Executive of Rehabilitation International turned down an amendment to its constitution, proposed by the Swedish delegation, that disabled people should comprise 51% of its ruling body.

All hell went loose when this decision was announced. There were approximately 200 disabled people at the conference from America, Australia, Africa, Asia - everywhere, even the backwaters of Europe. No-one could understand the duplicity of these doctors, social workers, and officials from governmental and non-governmental bodies who comprised Rehabilitation Internationals Executive at that time.
Despite the shock over the executive decision, this sort of paternalism over the lives of disabled people is such a central issue to disability rights that the international rallying cry of the movement is now "Nothing about us without us!"

By 1980, disabled people worldwide had begun to organize specifically for civil rights. The first CIL (Center for Independent Living) was founded in Berkeley in 1970. UPIAS (Union of the Physically Impaired Against Segregation) was founded in Britain in 1972 with what began as a round-robin letter exchange among disabled people -- some stuck in institutions. The 25-day sit-in at the San Francisco offices of the U.S. Department of Health, Education and Welfare had happened in 1977. That was to demand enforcement of Section 504 of the 1973 Rehabilitation Act, which said that any organization or service accepting federal money had to be accessible to disabled people -- public transit and other public places too.
Back in 1980, as part of their rationale for excluding disabled people from their membership, the Executive of Rehabilitation International issued a statement saying that disabled people were not ready to participate in the highly complicated decision-making which they had to undertake.
RI had, at that time, been dedicated to improving the lives of disabled folks for 58 years, yet they refused to allow those same people more than token membership in the democratically-run leadership. Their rationale wasn't uncommon, but the resulting anger at that meeting can surely be given some credit for the successes of the recent UN treaty for the rights of disabled people.

Elder-Woodward on the 1980 RI meeting again:
That night was electric. Disabled people congregated in a side room at 11 pm. There was no organisation, no format for the meeting, no leadership - just an angry mob of disabled people talking in groups and milling around the room. Then Ed Roberts got on the stage. Ed had poliomyelitis and at that time Reagan had not yet kicked him out of his job as Director of Rehabilitation for California. Puffing on his oxygen cylinder, as if he were Harold Wilson, smoking a pipe, he greeted the noisy rabble, by crying out - 'Cabbages of world, unite!'

There was such an uproar of acknowledgement and then all went quite whilst Ed spoke about the need to develop a separate international disability movement.

Those few disabled people organised themselves there and then to draw up their own constitution and began to agree strategies and structures before going to bed at 4 am in the morning utterly exhausted.

I had never felt, nor have since, the galvanising energy which came from such a hungry angry mob of disabled people. They had come from the four corners of the world and they were in no mood to be cast aside by a load of quacks and pen-pushers.
Some of those disabled people went home to countries where the normal treatment of the disabled is beyond appalling, where constant warfare increases the number of disabled folks daily, and where to be disabled means to be sub-human.

The new UN treaty may do very little of actual practicality for most disabled people in the world. I don't know how that all shakes out. The effectiveness of the UN is certainly a continuing debate. But symbolically the treaty is incredibly important. And in the process of hammering it out, hundreds of governments and NGOS like Rehabilitation International had to work with disabled people who were there insisting they determine their own lives. That's a process I'm happy about.

Crossposted at Alas, A Blog
Check there for more comments

Monday, September 04, 2006

The joys of impairment

In discussions about quality of life or eugenics or disability pride, some nondisabled person often asserts that it's obvious -- despite all moral arguments on the value of disabled persons lives -- that a body with impairments is just physically less desirable and not something any sane person would choose. Lacking something can't possibly be better than having it, right? It's an argument that always fascinates me.

It fascinates me because it seems like a very specific aspect of physicality to decide unequivocably that there is one obvious answer for when we recognize such biologically-based statements about sex or even body weight are problematic. Being one sex or the other means that each of us physically has some abilities and some lack of abilities that those of the other sex don't. The ability to bear children versus absolute freedom from the "burden" of bearing children -- we recognize the political and subjective aspects of those perspectives.

Of course a body that can do more tricks is physically superior, better, handier to have. And for past generations and people in different locations then and now, a tricksier body has been advantageous to survival. I don't disagree with that, so far as it goes.

But often the added implication is that there can't possibly be anything good about a body with impairments, and that isn't necessarily true. I understand that this is hard for many people to accept. Maybe it helps if I accede that much of what I appreciate about my specific body and it's abilities/inabilities is related to the technology that I use.

Individual physical experience is important, so my assertions of enjoyment are limited to my own experiences, which I'll describe in a minute. But I'm not the only one. Wheelchair Dancer notes that her joy of dancing is inextricably linked to how she can make her manual wheelchair move and express what she's feeling. And she's certain this cannot be simply and completely mimicked by a nondisabled dancer using a wheelchair:

You can get a sense of how long it takes to turn in a chair, what it feels like to PUSH a chair, how to stroke, wheelie, etc. But you don't know what it means to actually live in a chair and feel it melded to you as an extension of your body or, especially, what it means to actively use the chair instead of feeling it as a prop. And this means you won't be able to move in it as we do. You won't feel comfortable in it in the same way that we do; you don't even see the texture and surfacing of the floor the same way. Our relationships to the space are different.
I'd argue that while a nondisabled body can eventually learn the dance moves so that they look the same as when a disabled wheelchair user does them, there is a psychological aspect to exercising the limits of your body's abilities -- regardless of what those limits are -- that adds emotionally to the experience. I also believe a quadriplegic can be an athlete if she is pushing the physical limits of her body and experiencing all that goes with that. If individual experience is given value, it doesn't matter with what body it's achieved.

Here's a Spanish ad with some dancing to consider. And Aaron Fotheringham's athleticism seem obvious to me here, where his moves are similar to those of skateboarders and bikers. New Disability's interview with Aaron reveals that he's used a wheelchair virtually his whole life, explaining why he makes it look effortless -- it's a natural way of moving for him (not the flipping, but using a manual chair, generally).

As I said, technology contributes to all this. Even power wheelchairs provide unique joys. When I was in college as an undergraduate, my friends and I used to play around in our wheelchairs when the campus was quiet at night. I liked to drive my scooter in tighter and tighter circles until it tilted onto only two wheels. The challenge and thrill was to pull out of the circle just in time before tipping over. Also, many of the same joys people get from driving their cars can be found driving an electric chair. There's skill to it, enjoyment of speed and mastery of a machine.

On a less athletic level, I used to have a large power chair with a tilt-in-space feature on the chair. It was a special pleasure to park anywhere on the campus quad and recline back, eyes closed to enjoy the morning sun. My portable Barkalounger and the social dispensation to do something strange like park and nap wherever I wanted were a perverse pleasure to me.

Surprisingly, I find moments of enjoyment in my ventilator and feeding tube now that I have both of them. If I exert myself doing something and get short of breath, I can simply lean back in my chair and wait until the ventilator helps me catch my breath. It's not resting in the same way a nondisabled person does after he's been working out. You might say it's lazier than that, an anti-athletic recovery that doesn't require me to do anything.

Likewise, at night, when my PEG tube is hooked up to a slow drip of liquid nutrition, there's a physical comfort to knowing my body is getting protein while I sleep. I could get the tube pulled if I wished, now. It's not absolutely required for my sustenance at this time. But it's a comforting back-up, that, along with a low cholestoral count and no concern about my gaining too much weight means that I'm curiously free of all concerns about my diet that most other women struggle with daily.

It'd be easy for a nondisabled person to say these little joys I mention are really sour grapes about what my life is missing. Or that I've stirred up a bit too much lemonade from my supply of lemons. Fruit metaphors aside, I inherited my optimism and always find that here and there life is sweet. But the point is, there are aspects of this specific, highly-flawed body that are uniquely enjoyable, and I'm not the only disabled person to make that claim.

Crossposted at Alas, A Blog
Check there for more comments

Sunday, September 03, 2006

Protesting pity

So the MDA Telethon is tonight and tomorrow. I've written here and here about the reasons a charity telethon -- particularly one that insists on using Jerry Lewis to evoke pity for disabled people -- does not help the status of disabled folks. Or, more precisely, the Telethon and the money it raises are not worth the pity.

Harriet McBryde Johnson is spending Labor Day at the 16th annual Charleston, SC, MDA Telethon protest making this point. In a press release:

Calling for an end to pity based fundraising tactics, an ad hoc group will be picketing and distributing handbills to protest the "Jerry Lewis" telethon for the Muscular Dystrophy Association on Labor Day morning. The group will be in the area of King, Meeting, and Market Streets downtown. They will gather at approximately 10 AM and be available for interviews at 11:00 AM on September 4.

"We don't want pity," says Harriet McBryde Johnson, protest organizer who has one of the neuromuscular disabilities covered by MDA. "Pity sets people apart, divides the world between those labeled as helpless and their purported superiors. We see disability as a natural part of the human continuum and believe that people with and without disabilities can and should work together to solve problems that affect us all. We want solidarity, not pity."

Among those who will attend in solidarity is Dorothy Scott, president of the Charleston Branch, NAACP. "I believe, as Martin Luther King told us, an injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere. When a nationally televised telethon promotes false stereotypes, that affects everyone, because it makes our world less fair."

Street protests were galvanized by a 1990 article by telethon host Jerry Lewis that said, among other things, that if Lewis had muscular dystrophy he would have to learn how to be "half a person." Lewis stood by his remarks and dished out more of the same in the years that followed. MDA stood by him until 2001, when Lewis told a CBS reporter, "You're a cripple in the wheelchair and you don't want pity? Stay in your house!" MDA finally apologized for that one, but activists said it was too little, too late. They say MDA should replace Lewis as telethon host, stop using children on the air, and provide a full and independent accounting of the telethon as a first step toward weaning itself from the fundraising vehicle.

For more information about the controversy, go to: Crip Commentary

"On a personal level," Johnson says, "I am concerned that another generation of children should not hear the telethon message unchallenged. MDA still describes conditions like mine as 'killers of children.' I am now 49 years old, enjoying an active life I never imagined possible." Johnson practices law in Charleston. She has organized a local telethon protest for 16 consecutive years. "They are still doing what they do," she says, "so I'll keep doing this."
Mike Ervin, another protestor of the Telethon, speaks in a video clip from his half-hour documentary The Kids Are All Right about his growth from 1960s MDA poster child to disability activist. The clip requires Quicktime, which can be downloaded for free here.

Crossposted at Alas, A Blog
Check there for more comments

Saturday, September 02, 2006

Saturday Slumgullion #9

  • Poetry! DisPoet's latest entry on Sheila Black is another of the infreqent but thoughtful offerings on disability in poetry. And Penny Richards at Disability Studies, Temple U offers a very Scottish poem by Violet Kennedy-Erskine Jacob about a disabled WWI veteran.
  • Ballastexistenz writes a long but brilliant critique of therapy and how it stigmatizes the individual's behavior while ignoring the politics involved. Her post relates to class, race and gender as easily as to autism, I believe. An excerpt to entice:

This is one reason I don’t fit in in support group atmospheres. I have zero interest in sitting around serenely saying “I have a great deal of anger issues over what I perceive to sort of be a return to previous ideas about something that looks a bit like eugenics” or something. And I can’t even begin to count the amount of times that someone has completely disregarded what I or someone else has to say, only to focus on the fact that we sound too “angry” — an accusation which can be brought on not only by being angry, but by talking about things that make them angry.

In the autistic community, this often takes the form of autistic people lecturing each other about social skills and the proper ways to do things. Because we’re already presumed deficient in “social skills” (which tend to mean, in these contexts, adhering to white middle-class therapy-culture social norms) it becomes easy to lecture us on the fact that nobody will ever listen to us until we communicate in a way that’s not only thoroughly unnatural to us (more so than language is already to many of us, while those who cannot use language at any particular moment are seen as even more vile in their/our means of communication), but based on an arbitrary set of social norms.

  • Less serious a topic, I'm going to all my rock concerts with Leonardo DiCaprio from now on.
  • Operation Eden catalogs the extreme mental health problems in Katrina, one year later.

  • A question I'm hoping someone can answer: A report on escaped Ohio inmate John Parsons recites his history of legal problems (italics mine):
Parsons was later indicted on four counts of aggravated murder; one count each of aggravated robbery, tampering with evidence and having a weapon while under disability; and two counts of grand theft.
Eh? What does this mean? Exactly what is the poor man "under"? Any ideas?

  • The NYT writes on "Breaking the Biology Barrier," otherwise known as getting paid leave when adopting a child. If paid leave for childbirth is about the woman being temporarily disabled, then adopting mothers don't qualify, but if it's about adjusting to new parenthood, then they would -- and all male parents, as well.
  • And last but never least, Ouch! Podcast #6, always silly, and including their trademark quiz "Vegetable, vegetable, or vegetable?"

Friday, September 01, 2006

Fake disabled children

A couple weeks ago the Wall Street Journal ran an article about how textbook publishers meet diversity quotas for the photos in their books. The article covers the lengths publishers go to in order to portray diversity in race, ethnicity, religion, age, gender and disability in textbook images so that their books will sell to diversity-sensitive school districts. But when it comes to portrayals of disabled people, nondisabled children are frequently placed in wheelchairs or given crutches to stand in for actual disabled models.

[Photographer] Ms. Coppola estimates that at least three-fourths of the children portrayed as disabled in Houghton Mifflin textbooks actually aren't. "It's extremely difficult to find a disabled kid who's willing and able to model," she says. Houghton Mifflin, which acknowledges the practice, says it doesn't keep such statistics.

Houghton Mifflin's little-known stratagem illustrates how a well-intentioned effort to make classroom textbooks more reflective of the country's diversity has led publishers to overcompensate and at times replace one artificial vision of reality with another.
Well, I don't know why disabled children would be less willing or able to model and make money. It's unlikely that the problem is caused by a particular minority group being unwilling to model and be represented. Much more likely, talent agencies are not interested in disabled children (and adults) and do not accept them as clients. That's no doubt a result of discrimination at talent agencies (which mirror the Hollywood/high fashion aesthetic) where the concept of diversity is not yet thought to include disabled persons, and disabled children that look like they have impairments would be unlikely to be hired unless the agencies completely change their aesthetic of who makes a good model. And, of course, the book publishers have decided that the appearance of diversity is a good enough representation of actual diversity.

This prejudice that manipulates the reality of what disabled children look like is just the tip of the iceberg. It goes without saying that children with hidden disabilities (that may nevertheless alter their appearance in subtle ways) are not represented in photos -- are they mentioned in the captions or text? Do the rented wheelchairs and other equipment look like what modern disabled children actually use? Do they rent, say, non-stereotypical equipment that disabled people regularly need, or just the easy symbols of disability -- crutches, wheelchairs, white canes? Are developmentally disabled children represented at all? Are the fake disabled children ever played by non-white boys and girls? What must black or hispanic or asian children look like to satisfy their diversity requirements? Does a blond hispanic girl qualify as hispanic or would she never be hired to represent her people either? How girlish does a girl have to be?

The WSJ article, headlined "Aiming for Diversity, Textbooks Overshoot: Publishers use quotas in images to win contracts in big states, but they may be creating new stereotypes," is mainly cast as a subtle critique of diversity and the standards educational systems have used to try and support diversity:

In 2004, according to federal estimates, non-Hispanic whites made up 67.4% of the U.S. population and 59.9% of the school-age population.

Under McGraw-Hill Co. guidelines for elementary and high school texts, 40% of people depicted should be white, 30% Hispanic, 20% African-American, 7% Asian and 3% Native American, says Thomas Stanton, a spokesman for the publisher. Of the total, 5% should be disabled, and 5% over the age of 55. Elementary texts from the Harcourt Education unit of Reed Elsevier PLC should show about 50% whites, 22% African-Americans, 20% Hispanics, 5% Asians and 5% Native Americans. Of the total, 3% should be disabled, says Harcourt spokesman Richard Blake.

The publishers' guidelines are closer to the race statistics of California than the federal estimates, reflecting the markets for their sales, which are urban areas of big states like California, Texas and Florida. But the publishers' guidelines do not come close to accurately portraying the disabled as the estimated "one in 12 children" or 10% of all Americans that the 2000 Census indicated.

It's true that not all disabled children's traits identifying them as disabled can be captured in a picture. This is especially true for the various learning disabilities that have caused the number of children identified as disabled to climb in the past decade. Yet, the educational point of incorporating diversity into elementary school textbooks is to teach about the world as it exists for the children reading these books and to offer them images that look like them.

For disabled children, there is almost nowhere in mainstream public for them to see disabled folks portrayed as they actually exist. In Hollywood, the plum Oscar-contending roles for the highest-paid actors are for nondisabled actors, with portrayal of disability being part of what gets the applause. The "realism" of Hilary Swank in Million Dollar Baby, for example, is what gets attention as being truthful about disability.

When was the last time you saw a disabled person on TV who drooled, or needed a personal attendant, or used a power wheelchair and had a schlumpy body because that's why people need power chairs? Perhaps in the inspirational story on the local news, but not with the diversity of regular characters slowly becoming otherwise more representative of our world on TV dramas like Grey's Anatomy or 24 or Lost.

With fake disabled children the accepted practice in textbook photos, another opportunity to show what we really look like is not only lost, but distorted. Real disabled people, when they do appear in public, become less attractive, abnormal versions of the disabled people we have learned to look at, in the same way that fat women have become the less attractive, abnormal versions of women because we've all seen the ideal skinny women everywhere so often she's become the accepted fake. It's little wonder the result of this switcheroo is the nondisabled stare all visibly disabled folks are familiar with as part of their public experiences. That stare is blatant curiosity and even astonishment, and efforts at diversity in textbooks will only reinforce it.

Crossposted at Alas, A Blog
Check there for more comments

Tuesday, August 29, 2006

Another child with autism murdered

This is a photo of 3-year-old Marcus Fiesel, who was in foster care when he was locked in a closet without food or water for a weekend. His foster parents, who received a grand each month for his care, left home for the weekend to attend some sort of reunion. Arriving home to find Marcus dead, the foster father burned his body and hid it. Then they lied to officials and the public, claiming Marcus had wandered off on a trip to a park when his foster mother had fainted.

He's the third child with autism to be killed this summer in the United States.

Full story here. And commentary about how the news article was written by Whose Planet is it Anyway? here.

Remembering a hero

"Society is nothing more than what you do and say every day. When you speak, society speaks. When you change, society changes."

Bush, Sr., said, "He was a courageous, good man." Clinton said, "The contributions he made to our lives and the life of this nation will thunder on long after he is gone." Bob Dole called him "a pioneer in the disability field who never tired working to improve the lives of those with severe disabilities." Tom Harkin said he was "the Abraham Lincoln of the disability community." And Ed Kennedy said, "He was one of our country’s greatest warriors in the fight for civil rights for people with disabilities."

If he were alive today, Justin Dart, Jr. would turn 76 and he'd probably be remembering the anniversary of Katrina by speaking publically somewhere on how disabled people were disproportionately the victims of the government's lack of planning and slow response. Or he'd be speaking about the thousands of innocent civilian casualties in Iraq and Lebanon. Or he'd be campaigning from state to state for some political candidate who supports universal health care as a national priority.

Dart died in June of 2002, but he's was a disability rights leader, a father of the ADA, and a rolemodel for anyone wanting to change the world. I won't repeat his life history when others have written so well about it here and here. But I will include some inspiring excerpts.

New Mobility reported Dart's recollections of the lifechanging 1966 visit to a Saigon, Vietnam "institution" for children with polio, the virus that also left him using a wheelchair from age 18:

"The floor of the whole place was covered with children ages 4 to 10, with bloated stomachs and matchstick limbs," he recalls. "They were starving to death and lying in their own urine and feces, covered with flies. A little girl reached up to me and looked into my eyes. I automatically took her hand and my photographer took pictures. She had the most serene look I have ever seen--and it penetrated to the deepest part of my consciousness. I thought, here is a person almost dead, and she knows it. She's reaching out for God and has found a counterfeit saint doing a photo op. I was engulfed by the devastating perception that I have met real evil, and I am a part of it. The way I'm living and dealing with disability is killing this little girl. I'm going to go to my hotel, drink Johnnie Walker, eat a steak, and this picture is going to be in some magazine. I told [my fiancée] Yoshiko, 'We cannot go on as we have been. Our lives have got to mean something. We have got to get into this fight and stop this evil.' "
A lifelong Republican serving in various government positions under Reagan and Bush, Sr., Dart abandoned the party in 1994 when it pushed to amend or repeal the ADA and IDEA (Individuals with Disabilities Education Act). In 1996, he publicly campaigned for Clinton, against fellow Texan Bush, Jr., the son of the man he sat next to as the ADA was signed into law. He spoke at the DNC and visited all 50 states before the election, speaking for disability issues and supporting Clinton.

His health failed in 1997 and he worked from home after that, but even in his last days he worked to empower disabled people, sending out this last statement:
"The days of dying carry a special responsibility. There is a great potential to communicate values in a uniquely powerful way—the person who dies demonstrating for civil rights. Let my final actions thunder of love, solidarity, protest—of empowerment.

"I adamantly protest the richest culture in the history of the world, a culture which has the obvious potential to create a golden age of science and democracy dedicated to maximizing the quality of life of every person, but which still squanders the majority of its human and physical capital on modern versions of primitive symbols of power and prestige. I adamantly protest the richest culture in the history of the world which still incarcerates millions of humans with and without disabilities in barbaric institutions, backrooms and worse, windowless cells of oppressive perceptions, for the lack of the most elementary empowerment supports.

"I call for solidarity among all who love justice , all who love life, to create a revolution that will empower every single human being to govern his or her life, to govern the society and to be fully productive of life quality for self and for all. I do so love all the patriots of this and every nation who have fought and sacrificed to bring us to the threshold of this beautiful human dream. I do so love America the beautiful and our wild, creative, beautiful people. I do so love you, my beautiful colleagues in the disability and civil rights movement."
Unsurprisingly, his trademark boots and cowboy hat still provide inspiration and empowerment at disability rights events.

Monday, August 28, 2006

Movie review: The Station Agent

In The Station Agent, Finbar McBride, a dwarf, inherits a rural New Jersey train depot when his only friend dies. He goes to live there and despite wanting to be left alone he has repeated encounters with a few interesting local people. I don't know why I missed hearing about this film when it was released in 2003 (there was even some Oscar buzz), but my newest imaginary boyfriend has been waiting for me all this time. Actually, the whole cast is wonderful. Everyone is funny and fascinating in a quietly hilarious way.

"Dwarf" was the term used in the film, with "midget" once quietly denied. "Little person" never came up, so I'll take my language cues from that unless I hear otherwise. Not that dwarfness (dwarfism?) was exactly the point of the story.

Fin's appearance as a dwarf is quietly present all through the film -- especially whenever he goes out in public -- but it is never presented as an impairment or the source of any crude jokes (visual or otherwise) where he's too short to do something. He's a capable, independent man others seem to be drawn to. His dwarfism is a disability only in how other people see him, and possibly in how a lifetime of this has shaped his character.

In the UK, "disability" is the term those familiar with disability politics use to distinguish societal actions of prejudice and discrimination from the physical or mental conditions -- "impairments" -- that may or may not be actually present. While the ADA attempted to incorporate this idea into American civil rights by, for example, including discrimination against people believed to have AIDS as well as people who actually do, this distinction is not well-recognized anywhere. But Fin is a great presentation of how society disables an individual even when impairments are not apparent by setting them apart with stares and the behavior of strangers.

Peter Dinklage, who plays Fin, has talked about the effect this treatment can have:

Unfortunately, a lot of kids' curiosity is squelched by their parents. Adults don't want to embarrass somebody else, but that perpetuates itself, and it can lead to shutting out anyone who's different than you. Obviously we all do have these societal behaviors that we have to abide by. But, I talk to some people who just don't want to meet my eyes. They think looking at me is rude, because they were brought up not to point or stare or whatever.
Fin's stoic loneliness matches that of the other characters and presents an interesting collage of the many ways people become socially alienated from the world. Disability as a kind of social alienation is only one example. The way Fin and the other misfits he meets form a bond is despite their separateness is the quiet beauty of the film.

Seriously, this movie makes my top ten favorites, and not just because it's probably the first ever well-developed dwarf character on film.