Wednesday, May 24, 2006

Memorial for Katie McCarron

She was three years old and murdered by her mom because she was autistic. Please go here.

Tuesday, May 23, 2006

Voting while disabled

Cross-posted at Echidne of the Snakes:

Today was election day in my small town. There were only three school bond proposals to decide and unfortunately they don't have a chance in hell of passing, but I went to vote just the same. Because I can. I turned down the absentee ballot option because I wanted to go vote at the poll and I was sure access here, at this time, wouldn't be a problem.

With September primaries quickly coming up, the fiasco of Florida's hanging chads still haunting election judges everywhere, and the requirements to provide fully accessible voting for all varieties of disabled people, there's a considerable amount of voting angst among public officials and private citizens who keep up on voting issues.

HAVA, the federal Help America Vote Act of 2002, requires that every polling place in the country provide a voting system that persons with disabilities can use independently and privately. Much voting for disabled people has been known to occur at a table in public, with one or two poll workers assisting with the voting procedure. This system lacks privacy and provides no way for blind citizens to know if the poll workers truly marked the ballot as instructed.

Enter the machines. Since HAVA means every voting district in the country needs some way to meet federal requirements, many business opportunities sprouted for manufacturers of electronic voting machines. But acquiring voting machines that satisfy disability access, voter trust, and accuracy has been a nightmare for voting officials around the country. Citizens are suing the states for better set-ups, states are suing the companies manufacturing the machines for failures of all kinds, and September looks closer than ever.

It seems certain that disabled voters will be the ones to bear the brunt of this problem. In New York City, there will be just five polling places where disabled people can hope to find total access this fall. That's one polling site in each borough for a population of people largely dependent on public transportation that doesn't do well accommodating them either.

One solution to this whole mess that seems to be gaining currency is voting by mail. Absentee voting is being expanded to "permanent" absentee voting and then to "no excuse" absentee balloting and voting by mail for all. Many claim it's a much better system and supposedly many disabled people would prefer to always vote by mail.

I think it's a bad idea. Oh, it might be smart in the short-term while the numerous problems with voting are minimized, but in the long-term it's maybe bad for democracy and certainly bad for the disabled. If the solution to problems of accessibility is to not require anyone to show up, then all the churches and rec centers and other polling sites that are not currently accessible will have less pressure to become so. And all the poll workers who will be trained on how to interact with disabled people to help them vote will never be trained. And all the disabled people who rarely get out of the house because of Medicare homebound laws* and lack of transportation, will have one less reason to interact with the world. All this equals less accessibility and freedom for the disabled in the long-run.

Additionally, I believe the assurance of maximizing privacy and actual casting of the votes disabled people choose themselves can only happen at polling sites. This may be true for many women as well, if they are in coercive relationships. A private vote taken at a public place ensures society's most vulnerable citizens the freedom to make their own political decisions. Should disabled persons require human assistance to vote after all, at least it is legally required that someone impartial -- or two people, one from each party -- assist. If privacy must be sacrificed in any way, as it most certainly will be for many severely disabled people if everyone votes by mail, there should be neutrality built into the assistance.

Of course, voting that discriminates against the disabled hasn't been resolved even with the ADA being 16 years old. There's no reason to expect any future public outcry about voting by mail -- if there is one -- will center on the rights of disabled persons now. But there are other reasons it remains a bad idea.

___________________________________________________

*From an article at New Mobility (italics mine): In 2002, at the 10-year anniversary of the ADA implementation... President Bush (announced), "Today Medicare recipients who are considered homebound may lose coverage if they go to a baseball game--which, of course, I encourage them to do--or meet with a friend or go to a family reunion. So today I announce we're clarifying Medicare policy. So people who are considered homebound can occasionally take part in their communities without fear of losing their benefits."

Sunday, May 21, 2006

Cooking up a fallacious (and offensive) comparison

Piny over at Feministe recently discussed my post on the New Zealand murder where the convicted man received a lighter-than-typical sentence for killing a disabled man. He was generous about what I had to say, but he also follows the logic of the problem and shows how smart he is:

In “The Disability Gulag” and assorted other writings, Harriet MacBryde Johnson makes the point that terms like heroic measures and special accomodations can be extremely ableist: they start at a zero/norm of “needs no assistance,” and trend upward through “needs a lot of assistance.” This can be a problem, because it implies that lives like hers exist at an extreme of social obligation; her needs are not given parity, and her life becomes an indulgence. It also means that people most in need of recognition are least likely to receive it.
and
So when a court decides that an assistant has less of a responsibility to hurt disabled people, or decides that sustained contact with disabled people mitigates culpability for murder, the only vulnerability it creates is an “extraordinary” one. This decision poses an enormous threat to people who need caregivers. It defines reliance on caregivers as an imposition on those who provide care–so much so that disabled people may expect violent reprisal for all that “stress.” All of that is invisible, because lives in which caregivers are mundane are invisible.

Then Bob over at Creative Destruction riffs off of Piny's post and things go downhill from there. Cooking up a comparison between disabled people and fetuses, he calls his post "Sauce for the Handicapped [sic], Sauce for the Unborn," and before we know it we're not only comparing the killing of a grown man and former paralympian athlete to abortion, but the resulting comments devolve into a tired debate among nondisabled people about how a person is no longer a "person" (but still "human") when their cerebral cortex shuts down. "Intrinsic value," life support and even animal rights are mentioned. It's very depressing, even more so because this is the first post categorized as "Disability Issues" at that group blog.

(Note to self: Request Feministe add a Disability category to their index so the fine recent discussions over there can be accessed more easily.)

Back to the lumpy gravy. Along with some inaccurate assumptions about what pro-choice feminists (Are there any other kind?) all believe, Bob says this:
The logic that the judge used in ameliorating the consequences of Smail's killing is orthogonal to the logic used by pro-choice advocates. The jump from "it's OK to kill a fetus" to "it's OK to kill a cripple" does not appear to be overwhelmingly large in magnitude. It seems like a fairly tricky endeavour to try to justify one as being obviously acceptable while the other remains a monstrous crime - particularly if you choose to defend abortion but condemn the killing of the disabled. After all, Keith McCormick was never going to get better - was never going to become a full human being in the Singerian ethical sense. But a fetus fairly quickly becomes an independent being with a full life ahead of him or her.
To amuse those who know me very well, I will enumerate my issues with the above paragraph.

Number one: Language, language. "Cripple." Oh, how I wish there existed truly offensive epithets uniquely designed for nondisabled white men that made them feel the burn too. They seem to be the ones who mind the least using other group's slurs to make a point. Why do you suppose that is?

Second. Umm, yeah, it is a huge jump to compare murdering a living breathing full-grown man with family and friends who have interacted with him for decades to abortion of a fetus. The former is here with the rest of us doing all the daily things anybody does and the latter might be here sometime in the future sharing the experience.

The fact that both a quadriplegic and a fetus need some help to survive does not make them equal anymore than it makes a nondisabled person and a fetus equal. A quad needs assistance with most daily activities (and maybe the technology or service animal to help do care for himself) and a fetus needs to feed off the body of another human being for many months until it can hopefully survive in the planetary environment the rest of us exist in, even then with a high level of care. I do think it's fair to compare the level of assistance a person with quadriplegia needs to that an infant needs, but that's not the same as the unborn.

And McCormick didn't have to be looking forward to a cure to value his life as it was, whatever pain it involved -- remember there was no evidence whatsoever that he thought his life should end. Perhaps it's surprising to know that many of us severely disabled people believe our lives have incredible value even if we will never "get better." Health and ability are great things, if you've got them, but they do not create the essence of what is valuable in life.

Third, a fetus does not "fairly quickly (become) an independent being with a full life ahead of him or her." I imagine many, if not most, mothers who bear the brunt of the childraising work would not say that years of assistance is "quick," except in the sentimental sense. Surely no teenager I've known believes their "independence" arrives quickly. I'd argue nondisabled "independence" is myth anyway, but that's for another day. Also, Bob presumes a fetus will be born nondisabled and remain that way when that's really not what the warranty guarantees, so the presumption of independence is pointless.

Finally, philosopher Peter Singer's ethics with regard to disabled people are creepy enough without applying them incorrectly. He doesn't claim to support involuntary euthanasia for persons who are physically impaired but remain mentally unimpaired, and I don't believe he'd support the murder of McCormick as Bob seems to imply. Singer's preference utilitarianism does suggest McCormick's life would have less "utility" than a nondisabled person's life, but a fetus wouldn't even qualify as a "person" in his ethical world so again the comparison fails.

None of what I've argued above -- or, in fact, any disagreement about what Bob says -- about the worth of McCormick's life is debated in the 28 comments that follow over at Creative Destruction. Instead, there's a brief exchange concluding, apparently, that the disability of McCormick has no bearing on the shortened sentence. And then animal rights is brought up, and, oh, go read the rest. The entire debate really is a good answer to the question "What would nondisabled privilege look like?"

Saturday, May 20, 2006

Da Vinci Code Redux

Cross-posted at Echidne of the Snakes:

Just over a year ago, I wrote about Dan Brown's piece of literary genius that is The Da Vinci Code, and since the movie is opening this weekend to packed audiences now seems a worthwhile time to refer back to how both literature and Hollywood use disabled people for dramatic purposes. I haven't seen the film, but already know from the trailer that the book's damaging stereotypes remain intact.

Once again I warn: to understand disability stereotypes and simply apply the most likely one here is to make your own spoiler for the story.

There are two disabled characters in Brown's story and -- surprise! -- they are both the villains. One has polio:

The villain isn't disabled so much as "crippled." Crippled. Crippled. Did I mention he is crippled? Well, Brown does. Over and over and over as Mr. Crippled Secret Villain limps around and other characters comment on the fact that he is crippled. This is to make sure that the densest reader understands that twisted on the outside means twisted on the inside. Why is he a villain? Because he's crippled and that can drive a person to be not nice.
This need to establish a certain hinkiness to the character of Teabing not only makes it into the film, it's in the trailer. "What can an old cripple do for you?" Pretty much Ian McClellen's first lines. Also in the trailer, there's a moment where Teabing drops his crutches to lunge and grab an artifact/clue out of the air. While this can be seen as a show of how important the mystery is to Teabing, it's also iconic of the idea that disabled people might be faking their impairments and making fools of everyone. This able-bodied anxiety is part of the stereotypes too, and cleverly, Teabing gets to be like those of us who are actually disabled and living with impairments yet also subject to frequent suspicion about our true identities.

The second villain is an albino man played in the film by Paul Bettany. I mentioned the albinism in my review a year ago, but didn't give poor Silas fair attention. Luckily, Andrew Leibs at Ragged Edge provides the historical context of albinism's stereotypical treatment.
Readers will no doubt recall the stalking Silas, who executes four people in one night doing God's work. Most of the stereotypes common to books and films that exploit albinism are present: red eyes, loyalty that leads to self mutilation and an abusive past that spawns a born-again brutality and proficiency in killing.

It is impossible for one with albinism (most of us detest the dehumanizing word "albino") to read Brown's book and not feel diminished. Knowing that Silas is the only experience most people will ever have with albinism is deeply troubling. Such characters take root in the imagination where there are no positive human images to balance them and thereby they assume great power.
I disagree with Leibs that Silas is the "only" albino experience that most of the nondisabled public will have, but he's dead-on about the depressingly consistent characterization. For an astounding list of how characters with albinism are portrayed, look here. Evil, they are, the pale Satans of Hollywood!

In writing this I learned that albinism creates vision problems and people with this condition are considered legally blind. Isn't it interesting though, how portrayals of evil albinos (all those I can rcall) don't include any pesky vision problems that would hinder their ability to terrorize normal people? Too bad evil albino characters aren't played by actors with albinism. Even if they had to act sighted (and presumably get the same acclaim sighted actors get for acting blind), at least they could sort of represent.

But then, disabled characters aren't meant to be acted by disabled people. That would ruin the Oscar race for all the able-bodied actors. It's no accident that Ian McClellan doesn't have any actual need for crutches and Paul Bettany has real no pigmentation issues. Not that this film is Oscar material if most reviews are accurate descriptions. But really, why take a chance?

Friday, May 12, 2006

New Zealand murderer gets lighter sentence because victim was disabled

In New Zealand last week, a man who stabbed his roommate six times in the neck before slitting his throat has escaped the typical life sentence for murder, receiving instead a maximum of 12 years with possible parole in seven. The judge awarded the defendant the shorter sentence because he suffered from "accumulated stress" and because the victim was disabled.

Keith McCormick, who had won several medals in the Paralympics, was watching TV when his roommate Eric Neil Smail came home drunk and decided to kill him. The fact that Smeal was a part-time caregiver for McCormick helped guide the judge toward leniency despite there being absolutely no evidence McCormick wished to die.

Christchurch Justice John Fogarty told Eric Neil Smail:

"The evidence is that you thought you were doing an act of mercy in a way that minimised any awareness that he was about to die and was being killed."
What a relief to know that if a friend murders you and you remain oblivious to his intentions until it's too late, his life won't be completed ruined.

Judge Fogarty also acknowledged, "It wasn't a suicide pact. The right to life is the most fundamental of our rights and you took that away." Yet because Smail reportedly could not distinguish between his own needs and those of his victim's, Fogarty determined a life sentence was cruel and unusual punishment.

Interestingly, Judge Fogarty, who was appointed to the high court in 2003, has been "an advisor to the Deaf Sports Federation of New Zealand (formerly NZ Deaf Sports Association) for many years and was part of the organising committee for the XVth World Games for the Deaf held in Christchurch in 1989." One wonders if he knew how to sign and communicate with the people he served. Evidently, advising and organizing sporting events for deaf people doesn't involve believing disabled people deserve the same level of fundamental rights as everyone else.

Philip Patston, disabled comedian and managing director of Diversityworks in New Zealand, says:
It won't matter if your victim is successful and enjoying life - if you believe they're in pain and feel bad about it, just "take it on board" and kill them mercifully. You'll feel better.
Representing some popular beliefs, a longtime friend of Smeal has stated that "Being a caregiver, and probably not having the formal training that a person should really have ... it's a lot of stress to put on a person." Which, of course, justifies murder. And in New Zealand apparently provides an interesting method of stress relief.

Oh, to be cool

Nothing too deep today. Here's an article at PhysOrg.com about a federal grant to help Florida State University create greater student diversity in their computer science and information technology program. Notice the subhead, bolded italics mine:

You don't have to be a nerdy white guy to be a computer geek. In fact, you can be a woman, a minority, a person with a disability or someone who is downright cool.

Thursday, May 04, 2006

Crip wrestling in Japan

Via Lady Bracknell, here's something I've never quite seen before. Warning: site has lots of crude and offensive language.

The comments at that link are as fascinating as the event itself. Everyone seems captivated and offers a strong opinion. So. Is it just another freak show designed to exploit disabled people or is it something more positive than that, and if so what?

Monday, May 01, 2006

There's no place like home

Today is BADD (Blogging Against Disablism Day), engineered by Diary of a Goldfish. Check out her site for links to the more than 100 bloggers who signed up to contribute to the discussion today.

Blogging Against Disablism Day

Everyone knows about the on-going "health care crisis." But what everyone may not know is that for many disabled people this increases the threat of institutionalization because of the structure of private medical insurance and Medicare/Medicaid assistance today. In fact, despite the 1999 Olmstead ruling that unnecessary institutionalization violates their rights under Title II of the ADA, it's estimated that over 250,000 disabled people wish to move out of nursing homes but remain trapped.

In February of this year, the Money Follows the Person initiative was part of an Omnibus Budget bill signed into federal law. Though it's designed to allow people to take their Medicaid funding with them when they move out of nursing homes and other institutions, it's a five-year plan to begin implementation next year and will only cover 40 states. It's a victory against the powerful nursing home lobby, but the big win would be passage of MiCASSA.

Next year is too late for many disabled people confronted by a loss of their freedom now. In West Virginia, long-term vent users are shipped to Ohio as part of a sneaky state policy to save money.

In Florida, the state program for funding home-based health care (a way to comply with the Olmstead decision) has a waiting list years -- perhaps decades -- long. With rising healthcare costs far outpacing funding for the Florida program, over 3,000 people are literally waiting for the 828 people enrolled in the program to die before they have hope of receiving care in their homes. Or they're dying while they wait.

In North Dakota, Nodakwheeler Mark Boatman is about to move 850 miles from family and friends because Montana will free him from the nursing home by covering home-based care if he resides there.

Harriet McBryde Johnson calls the institutions where disabled people are housed the "disability gulag" (better yet, read her book):

The nursing home is the gulag's face for people like Dave, me and Grandmother. That is where the imperatives of Medicaid financing drive us, sometimes facilitated by hospital discharge planners, ''continuum of care'' contracts or social-service workers whose job is to ''protect vulnerable adults.'' Pushed by other financing mechanisms, people with cognitive disabilities land in ''state schools,'' and the psychiatrically uncured and chronic are Ping-Ponged in and out of hospitals or mired in board-and-care homes. For all these groups, the disability rights critique identified a common structure that needlessly steals away liberty as the price of care.
My own story of narrowly avoiding involuntary shipment from the rehab hospital to a nursing home of my private insurance company's choice can't be considered a total victory under the circumstances presented above. I'm not locked away yet. That's the most honest way to explain how it's all resolved.

Thursday, April 27, 2006

My very own Nurse Ratched

It's funny what sticks in your mind about a person and becomes either a lovable quirk or a trait you will never be able to stand wherever you find it again. I've recently developed a strong aversion to the phrase "just a titch," which was always a bit dubious but now makes me want very badly to slap the person who says it.

There was this nurse -- I suppose there was bound to be one, since 12-hour shifts for four months equals 240 nursing opportunities to meet someone not even a mother could love. Here's what she liked to do: Knowing I couldn't speak because of the ventilator* and couldn't escape her for the duration of her shift, she liked to put her face down close in front of mine and loudly ask personal questions that were none of her business.

"ARE YOU SAD?!"

It takes a special talent to violate someone's personal and emotional space with such a simple quetion. Yet she had the knack.

When I didn't answer (I was busy contemplating what the correct "fuck-off" response is to someone whom I might have to ask to wipe my ass within the hour,) she began to lecture me about "bucking up" and "this too shall pass" and all that. "Sad" really wasn't an issue so much by this point as, perhaps, "livid."

She stirred up my mild-mannered Minnesotan parents too. They came to visit that Sunday hoping we'd immerse ourselves in the benign weekend hospital limbo you get if nothing too urgently worrisome develops. It's a sort of boredom you feel lucky about.

Instead, this woman began asking questions about my future, and then stating that what we (the doctors, my parents and I) had decided was all wrong. She challenged my parents to come up with a new plan immediately. Right now. What's it going to be? Huh? Tell me.

And then there was the ventilator weaning. That's where the settings are changed so you have to begin doing the work of breathing instead of the machine. Over days (or weeks or months) you wean for longer times with less and less assistance. On that Sunday, when I became exhausted sooner than Nurse Ratched felt was appropriate, she exclaimed, "I cannot in good conscience allow you to quit yet!"

It was one of these comments -- I forget which -- that made my mom the angriest I've ever seen her. Since Mom is an only child, I don't think she's smacked anyone in her entire life, but I really expected her to lay down the smake that day. Well, I was hoping she would.

That didn't happen. The end held little drama at all. My dad tried to have a calm discussion that might relieve the tension. Mom left the room. Nurse Ratched went to write something about me in her charts. And I tried to be satisfied with just giving her the bird or sticking out my tongue every time she turned her back. Childish, I know. Did that make me feel any better? Oh, just a titch.

__________________________________________________

* A person can speak while using a ventilator, but it requires pratice. Speaking usually involves either a special type of trach or valve, or lowering the cuff that routes air from the vent downward into the lungs and allowing air to escape out past the vocal cords as you exhale (so the lungs can use the air first). The latter usually compromises the set amount of air the person gets, so it can be tiring.

Monday, April 24, 2006

New links added

I've put several new links in the sidebar list of disability blogs:

Sunday, April 23, 2006

Blogging Against Disablism Day - 1st May 2006

Blogging Against Disablism Day

Diary of a Goldfish started this. Anyone can join.

Saturday, April 22, 2006

Been down so long it looks like up to me

When I began my recent three-month stay at a rehab hospital I came from a month in an ICU. I arrived by ambulance on a gurney, attached to a ventilator, with both a feeding tube and PIC line. I'd spent very little time out of bed and hadn't so much as had a drink of water by mouth in four weeks. It was all pretty grim, but the point of my transfer to rehab was that there was plenty of room for improvement, even for a gimp like me.

My assigned primary doctor at rehab was bubbly and optimistic. At our first meeting she suggested I consult the in-house psychiatrist and be prescribed an anti-depressant.

"Show me someone who can't walk," she said, "and I'll show you someone who's depressed."

That's what I get for consulting an expert -- I had no idea that I've been clinically depressed since 1983. I thought my current anxiety was because, you know, I'd been in a month-long medical crisis and still wasn't breathing or eating on my own and all this was new and alarming to me. Or, perhaps, the experience of near-constant discomfort and pain had unnerved me just a little bit. Nope -- the inability to walk has apparently been the emotional ruin of me since I was fifteen. (Gimpy Mumpy writes here about the aggressive tendency of the medical establishment to prescribe psychiatric pharmaceuticals to disabled people on the grounds that we can't possible be stable or content.)

I wanted to ask the doc if she'd read my medical records and knew I'd begun this current medical crisis from a permanently seated position or if she was actually that bubbly and optimistic that she planned to cure me of uncurable pre-existing conditions too. I've little interest in any form of that myth and certainly not from any doctor caring for me.

Maybe her image of a rehab patient didn't allow for already-disabled people getting sick. Maybe her physician God-complex was running amuck. Maybe she was just a loon. But maybe the cultural default image of a person being bodily "normal" didn't allow her to register the facts plainly in my medical files. Files she finally told me she had read. And certainly she didn't understand at all how her statement denied a lifetime of who I am.

John Hockenberry, in his autobiogaphy Moving Violations, tells of a mishap with a city bus that cut too close to a street corner and caught his manual wheelchair where he sat on the sidewalk. He dove clear of disaster, but his chair was mangled under the bus. As people ran to help and he calmly told them he was fine but wasn't getting up because he couldn't walk, they were unable to piece together what he said. Being already disabled wasn't a logical possibility to them, even with the wheelchair in evidence.

That's just how invisible disabled people are: we can't possibly, really exist. (Unless, of course, you poke us in public with rude questions to assure yourself we're real.)

Back to Dr. Perky. What pep talk does she give to her patients seeking rehab because of permanent paralysis? Does she tell them they will never be happy again because of their new injuries? And is their dosage higher than mine?

Tuesday, March 28, 2006

Self portrait for some 3rd grade friends

Cartoonish self portrait of my electric scooter hitting a big rock: a surprised look on my face and my hair flying in all directions.

Tuesday, March 07, 2006

On this long hiatus

I haven't written a word here since August, but my recent distractions have been compelling. I've been in hospital since early November -- ICU for one month and a rehab hospital for the other three months. I got home yesterday.

Although I've used a wheelchair or electric scooter since 1983, my life has utterly changed from this recent illness. What began as a horrific stomach ailment and turned into pneumonia has also left me with a feeding tube in my stomach and full-time ventilator use through a trach. I've arrived home to round-the-clock nursing care and much hope that this will get easier either through further recovery or habit and acceptance.

I've also got a lot I could -- and do hope -- to say here about my experiences in hospital and with insurance companies. And there's that Part 3 of Losing my religion to write, the point of which has significantly changed due to my recent adventures. I do hope to get back to it now. Thanks again to everyone who has given their support, even those who just wondered what was up with my blog being silent.

Wednesday, August 24, 2005

Losing my religion, part 2

The doorbell rang early in the evening and my mom went to answer it. It was shortly before Christmas. I was 17. We were making cookies and within minutes I planned to drive to a friend's house and pick her up for an evening of knocking about in search of random fun. Like teenagers do.

But my mom returned to the kitchen and said to me with dismay, "It's for you."

Outside the front door stood Christmas carolers from our church youth group waiting to sing for me. Not for my family (all members of the church), nor for my sister and me, but specifically for me.

I'd chosen not to carol with them that year (likewise my sister), but I'd gone the year before and recalled how we'd begun with a list of elderly church members, most who didn't leave home anymore during icy winter days. I remembered we'd been asked if there were others we wished to carol, with invalids getting special preference. The theory, I suppose, is that "shut-ins" need extra holiday cheer.

Unaccountably, I'd now made the list.

They sang three songs -- the last was my favorite Christmas hymn. My youth group peers had known it was my favorite from the thoughtful personal discussions we'd shared in confirmation class, and I guess they thought that would be a special treat for me. But we'd talked as equals in class and here I was cast as the subject of their benevolent generosity.

As I watched them sing I wished their visit was somehow a silly joke, a tease to a good friend who failed to join them in their caroling fun. But none of these people were my close friends and their visit was utterly sincere. When they'd made the list of who to go sing songs for, my name had obviously been raised as a person in serious need of holiday cheer -- as an invalid, I guess -- despite my presence with them every weekday in school and long hours most days at after-school activities.

At the end of the third song, the carolers presented me with a little plate of Christmas cookies which were really quite similar to the cookies we'd been baking when the doorbell rang. My mother and sister -- in an act of family solidarity -- returned the gesture by giving them a plate of ours. I smiled grimly wishing I was already driving across town in my mother's sportscar. Would they have sung to the rest of my family if they'd arrived fifteen minutes later? Would cookies have exchanged hands? I honestly don't know.

I'm thinking this out as I go. Part 3 to come.

Sunday, August 21, 2005

Losing my religion, part 1

When I was in tenth grade I was confirmed at a United Methodist church in suburban Chicago. My family had lived in Illinois for about three years at that point, I'd had two years of confirmation preparatory classes, and I'd been using a wheelchair for less than two years. A few weeks before confirmation, there was a weekend canoe trip to northern Wisconsin that, in retrospect, it is pretty impressive that I participated fully in.

I don't really recall details of the camping in tents or the complications of peeing in the woods, though I'm sure that felt adventurous at the time. It was completely inaccessible terrain and I needed help to function out there. I expect my very helpful twin sister remembers those details all too well.

What I do remember vividly is my canoe getting lodged atop a big rock in the midst of a daunting set of rapids. Neither I and my paddle-mate nor the more experienced canoeists who tried with successive float-bys could knock us off our perch, so the decision was made to help me abandon the canoe and use two good swimmers flanking me to insure I got safely to shore. We all had life-vests, of course.

"Don't let my face get in the water," I told my pastor and the other man just before I was dragged into the river and we headed for shore. The water was fast and icy cold, and there was undoubtedly considerable pressure to, you know, not let me drown while under their care. But all of this went very well, the men swam me to shore, and after lunch we continued down the river. The trip ended happily.

So I was surprised that Sunday while the confirmation rituals were afoot that my pastor retold this tale. He repeated for the congregation what I'd said and it became a little parable of faith how in a life-and-death moment I had only asked that my face not get wet. It was an example of how ready I was to commit myself to the church. It was a touching moment for everyone but me. I had been completely misunderstood.

My directions had been utterly practical. I couldn't swim and couldn't be certain I would be able to hold my head out of the water unless they carried me in a particular way. If I sucked in too much water they would have a crisis on their hands, so in the simplest terms possible I told them what I needed from them. Faith never entered into it. I considered it my responsibility to help them assist me. If I had chosen to say nothing and it had caused them to not help insure I could breathe, that would not have been called a lack of faith. It would have been called a tragic lack of information. ("I had no idea she couldn't hold her own head up. And who knew you could get pneumonia so easily?")

Yet my pastor interpreted my words as proof of a childlike faith worthy of praise and appreciation. And I believe my status as the "girl in the wheelchair" fed this perspective, and it certainly was the reason I was singled out as the teen to relate a story about to the congregation. That sort of attention goes with being disabled and it's the sort I learned early had little to do with seeing who I really am as a person. Frustratingly, an event that should have been about spiritual and community affirmation left me feeling invisible and misunderstood.

There was another similar event later on that same year. But I'll get to that another day.

Saturday, August 20, 2005

Saturday slumgullion

  • Marta Russell on the Medicaid kill-off: "The cut is clearly an attack on poor people, and it may wind up killing disabled and chronically ill persons before all is done. It is also a strike from those segments in our society who wish to dismantle the entire Medicaid system. Worse, it will force a rollback of disabled people's civil rights."
  • Kelly Laird at Life is Full: "A few weeks ago I was at a convenient store, looking for my favorite flavored sport drink, when I noticed the reflection of a man standing behind me, getting an eyeful of me. I slowly held up my hand, keeping my back to the man, and shot the bird at the guy, then turned to look in his direction and smiled, so as not to start a fight. He smiled, too, didn't say anything, and I rolled off with the fruit punch."
  • In Tennessee, disabled protestors are fighting state funding cuts that will send many of them to nursing homes in order to receive the care they currently get in their own homes. In Louisiana, The Times-Picayune reminds us with a five-part special report on nursing homes how institutionalization can and does kill. Also, it's big business: "Nursing homes get 94 percent of the money [Louisiana] spends on long-term care for the elderly, compared with 70 percent nationally and less than 50 percent in states such as Oregon and Washington."
  • Minnesota storyteller Kevin Kling on The Ugling Duckling and other myths: "When it turns out he's a swan like all the other swans and not a duck, what's that do for me?"

Tuesday, August 16, 2005

Movie review: Stevie

I rented the 2002 documentary Stevie (by the director of the acclaimed Hoop Dreams) based on the review by Flea over at One Good Thing. It's a heartbreaking, riveting trainwreck of a story that's not at all about disability, though disability is subtly present throughout the film in various ways. Here's one aspect that Flea picked out (but go, read the whole thing here):

I can't remember ever seeing a movie character as full of grace and class as Kim [actually named Trisha]. She was a total Grace Kelly, so full of poise and self-confidence, willing and able to speak her mind and vehemently disagree, but with such graciousness one could not be offended by what she presented as truth.

What really got me the most was Kim's masterful use of subtext during this entire scene. I played this scene endlessly on the dvd player, because it's not often you're in the presence of such a pro. Because here's the thing about Kim: she is very, very disabled. Can't walk, doesn't have good control of her hands and arms, speech slurred to the point of being unintelligible. All her dialogue was subtitled, or we'd have missed it. It's entirely possible Stevie missed most of it. What she didn't say was that whatever fate struck Kim that cost her the use of her body, that was a miniscule impediment to her marriage plans next to the damage done at the hands of her stepfather. Her disability wasn't even worth mentioning next to that. What she only implied was that even if she looked like Giselle, it wouldn't matter, because her ability to be intimate with a man was destroyed.

I've never seen anything put into perspective that clearly.

Stevie's life and relationships -- and the relationships of those close to him -- are intricately explored by the camera that follows them around. His girlfriend and the woman Flea describes both have disabilities, though the girlfriend's is less impairing. Rather than narrate anything about either woman's impairments, the documentary joins them in their lives and lets action and subtext provide the details. It's rare that real disabled people (women, at that!) are present on film without the content of the scene being all about their tragic disabled lives.

There is plenty of tragedy to go around though. Stevie's childhood was filled with abuse, abandonment and neglect. Even whatever special measures were taken to reach him in school left an indelible mark, which is eloquently, if violently, expressed in his vulnerability to ableist playground insults as an adult. Of his sister, the twentysomething Stevie says:

We have our differences. I was gonna knock her in the head out beside the garage because she called me "retarded." I was gonna knock her in the head with a claw hammer. You just -- some things you just don't say. And that's one of them things -- I just don't like that word.


The documentary isn't about Stevie's education or IQ -- he's obviously an intelligent, sensitive and deeply troubled man. But when most media, most films and entertaiment (Jon Stewart's The Daily Show, for example) still use "retarded" as a humorous insult without any apparent recognition of the history of oppression behind the epithet, it's noteworthy that this moment of Stevie's made it into the film. Such quiet representations of disability in the documentary make it unusual and worth a look, but the story as a whole is also haunting and powerful.

Friday, August 05, 2005

Disability studies "mucks up the dichotomy"

Frequently, I forget that disability studies and disability rights are not widely understood ideas. Ever since high school, when I vicariously found fellowship for my emerging identity as a disabled person through the study of civil rights for blacks, I have translated as if from another language the parallel experiences of other oppressed groups into something relevant for me. (That's perhaps a selfish way for a sheltered white girl to learn about race relations, but that's a topic for another day.) I forget that although the parallel is obvious and clear to me, most people have not yet seen or are resistant to accepting disability as a political and social identity.

So news articles that trumpet the new field of disability studies often irritate me even as I'm thrilled to see more recognition. Coming early to the party usually does make the evening seem long. But that's my problem, I suppose.

A recent article in the Village Voice frames disability studies' emergence within the framework of 2005 politics:

Lest America divide too neatly into red/blue, NASCAR/latte blocs, one constituency can be counted on to muck up the dichotomy. People with disabilities defy political pigeonholing. The group considers itself an oppressed minority, and its civil rights agenda grew out of 1960s radicalism. But on issues such as euthanasia, disabled people find themselves allied with "culture of life" enthusiasts. As disability activist Simi Linton says, "A lot of disabled people justifiably feel vulnerable to ideas held by their family and the medical establishment that our lives are less valuable. . . . That is why I'm categorically opposed to physician- assisted suicide, because I think some people are more likely to be assisted than others." For secularists, this argument is a bit harder to dismiss than "because God said so."
What follows is an excellent brief on the challenges disability studies presents to academia and vice versa. But my favorite bit in the article is author and activist Simi Linton's description of the annual SDS (Society for Disability Studies) conferences:
Linton... describes these conferences as "quite chaotic. You've got 50 people who use wheelchairs, you've got blind people with dogs, you've got deaf people with interpreters. . . . And we all sort of move to accommodate each other. It's a powerful experience for outsiders coming in for the first time."

It is a powerful experience, indeed. I attended two conferences in the late '90s and found them life-altering events. From the moment the paratransit driver picked me up at the Oakland airport and informed me that he'd been ferrying "my people" around all day, I knew I would participate in something I'd never quite seen before. Oh, I'd met "my people" before. I'd been to gatherings of disabled students at my university. My twentieth birthday included dinner for four at a fancy restaurant, where we requested only one chair at the table. Being with other disabled people was not then new to me, though it would have been in high school when I was new to my wheelchair. But I'd never been to a gathering of educated disabled professionals discussing disability, and I'd never heard a nondisabled person refer to disabled people as "my people" before.

No doubt part of what is so startling and exciting about an SDS conference is the camaraderie. More than one or two visibly disabled people gathering in public often feels subversive; dozens gathering together to discuss disability culture and experience definitely holds some joy. Beyond that, the spirit of interdependence and determined commitment to accommodation in all its necessary forms suggest to me a model of what all of society should be. And not just in terms of disability.

Some might view a typical question/answer segment of a panel presentation at a SDS conference as a logistical nightmare. After all, the panel and the audience both likely require multiple simultaneous accommodations in real time. The audience might need to rearrange itself a bit for someone to reach a microphone and ask a question -- wheelchairs shift, service dogs resettle. The question is translated into sign, close captioned, and possibly translated into French or some other language, as well. All of this occurs for the answer, and the next question-and-answer too. The day, the whole weekend goes on like this. If you haven't been to a disability rights/studies conference this is likely something that you have never seen.

With so many variables to communication and full participation of everyone in the room, the possibilities for what might happen next -- and any point in the meeting -- become endless. It's dynamic, chaotic, and requires a basic a priori acceptance of all difference and subsequent needs. The alternative would be to spend precious time debating who deserves what kind of help and how much they're entitled to have, and really, the U.S. Supreme Court does enough of that for all of us. So, everyone's needs are valid because they say they are, which is unheard of elsewhere, when you think about it.

But the "logistical nightmare" is really an opportunity to view community in a whole new way. Like democracy, patience is required. And a sense of humor, to be sure. But mainly, there's a remarkable sense of acceptance -- not of people's odd bodies and their differences, although that is there too. (That's medical model thinking which is exactly what disability studies attempts to uncover and think beyond.) There's an acceptance that difference fuels the process, feeds it with ideas even as it challenges and complicates. If the multi-cultural global community needs models for how to get along, an SDS conference isn't a bad one. In addition to the topics discussed being about

Wednesday, August 03, 2005

Special ed racial imbalance spurs sanctions

From The Washington Post:

Blacks make up one-fifth of the student population in both Montgomery and Anne Arundel county public schools. But they make up two-fifths of the group labeled mentally retarded.

The two Maryland school systems are among five that face state sanctions because they steer too many struggling black students into special education with problems that, in a number of cases, could be addressed in a regular classroom, according to federal education officials. Starting this
summer, the systems must spend a combined $8 million a year on efforts to reduce the number of black students in special-ed.

Young black students with academic or behavioral problems tend to wind up in special education, educators say, based on a teacher's impulse to place such children where they will get the most help. Special-ed classes are staffed at a far lower student-to-teacher ratio than regular classes.

But some black parents and others have accused school systems across the country of using special education, a federally subsidized program tailored for children with documented disabilities, as a dumping ground for disruptive black children. The Education Department found that, in 2003, although about 15 percent of all students ages 6 to 21 were black, they made up 20 percent of all special-education students and 34 percent of those labeled mentally retarded in
that age range.
More statistics:

The five counties were cited because black students were overrepresented in three areas of special education: first, the counties had a disproportionate share of black students in special-education as a whole; second, blacks were disproportionately likely to be placed in separate special-ed classrooms rather than "mainstreamed" with the general student population; and third, blacks in special education were particularly likely to be suspended.

Eighteen of the 24 school systems in Maryland had "significantly disproportional" shares of blacks in at least one of the three areas, according to state data.

Blacks make up 22 percent of the student population in Montgomery County. But they make up 42 percent of the population considered mentally retarded and 36 percent of special-ed students taught in separate classes, and blacks account for 52 percent of suspensions among students with disabilities, according to enrollment counts taken in October.
Via Disability Law