Thursday, June 14, 2007

Disability Blog Carnival #16 at PilgrimGirl

I'm really, really excited about Jana's presentation of the carnival, up today at PilgrimGirl. The theme is "Borders" and there is so much rich material linked to there, as well as an excerpt from a piece of Jana's writing on Gloria Anzaldua's Borderlands. Check it out.

The next carnival was scheduled for David's, but since he's off on an exciting, unexpected trip to Costa Rica (!), the Kuusisto's are hosting #17 at Planet of the Blind on Thursday, June 28. I hear that the theme will be "Laughter, The Best Medicine." Deadline is Monday, June 25, and further info on submitting is available at the carnival site here.

Visual description of the carnival icon above: Penny made this several carnivals ago and being a thorough historian she describes it herself: "The image is from an 1803 etching by Robert Dighton, depicting Brook Watson (1735-1807), an English merchant and politician who lost his lower right leg to a shark attack in his youth (while swimming off the coast of Havana, Cuba, in 1749)." It's a color drawing of an old man in profile, wearing a brown coat and knicker pants. His right leg is amputated below the knee, and replaced with a wooden peg. The other leg has a bandage on it and he is using a cane. The words "Disability Blog Carnival" are superimposed over his middle section.

Wednesday, June 13, 2007

Movie review: Notes on a Scandal

Along with Testament, Penny mentioned in comments of an earlier review of mine that Notes on a Scandal, the 2006 psychological drama that scored four Oscar nominations, has a child actor with Down syndrome in the cast. Penny said:

Child actors with Down syndrome occasionally have small roles in films where their visible difference is not much commented upon, nor does it become a major plot point. I'm thinking of Testament (1983), for example, and last year's Notes on a Scandal. Both smaller, serious dramas, with women in the leading roles--maybe that's no coincidence?
I got a chance to see and write about Testament last weekend, and now I've seen Notes on a Scandal too. Unlike in Testament, where the child with Down does not seem to be used as a signifier of anything else within the plot, I do think Ben, the 12-year-old son of Cate Blanchett's character, Sheba Hart, carries more symbolic meaning than the average nondisabled child in an adult drama. But the story is emotionally and psychologically dense, so he doesn't simply stand for unspoiled innocence, or parental sacrifice, or unruliness, as developmentally disabled folks frequently do in fictional stories. I think Ben, played by Max Lewis, does symbolize all those things, but there are also some great family scenes where I think his presence is fully integrated and normalized in ways rarely seen in film.

Based on the novel by Zoe Heller, which was on the short list for the Man Booker Prize back in 2003, Notes is about two women: the aging, bitterly lonely lesbian history teacher, Barbara Covett, played by the fabulous Judi Dench, and Sheba Hart, the straight, married art teacher who has an affair with a 15-year-old student. The events of the story are narrated as Barbara keeps a journal of her obsessive relationship with Sheba, and she's a captivating and disturbing "unreliable narrator" in the tradition of Holden Caufield or Humbert Humbert. (For full coverage of the movie's complex psychodrama -- complete with spoilers -- check out this review at Blogcritics.)

Upon meeting Sheba's family -- her much older husband, teenage daughter and Ben -- Barbara caustically refers to the children as "a pocket princess" and "a somewhat tiresome court jester." Barbara's desire for Sheba and jealousy of her family life leads her to manipulate events to break Sheba from her family. Her last name isn't "Covett" for nothing.

Two of the film's most dramatic scenes hinge on the role Ben plays in his mother's life. After a tryst with her underage lover, Steven, in her art studio behind the family's London flat, Sheba first waxes nostalgic about a Siouxie and the Banshees' album Steven sees. When he then picks up a wizard's hat Sheba is making for Ben's upcoming school play and jokes about such a childish thing being for a 12-year-old, Sheba tells him her son has Down syndrome. It's a sobering moment for the characters, filled with complex subtext: she hadn't told Steven about her son's disability, Steven is the picture of boyish youthful perfection, she's long past her carefree punk rocker days, Ben represents her life's realities.

In another scene, a grief-stricken Barbara has just left her beloved cat at the local vet to be euthanized when she flags down a car loaded with the Hart family on their way to Ben's school play. On the sidewalk, Barbara demands Sheba stay with her and abandon her family plans, suggesting she will reveal Sheba's illegal and adulterous behavior if she doesn't get her way. The choice would be wrenching without it involving a developmentally disabled child, but Ben is used specifically to ratchet up that effect (very similar to the blackmailing of the father of a very ill daughter in Derailed, by the way).

I mentioned that developmental disability in fiction often symbolizes an unruliness in life. A classic example is Lennie in Steinbeck's novella Of Mice and Men, where the developmentally disabled man accidentally kills animals and a woman with uncontrolled physical strength. In Notes, I think the unruliness Ben represents is equal parts adult disenchantment with life's realities and joyous familial free-spiritedness. Sheba, describing to Barbara how she fell into the affair with Steven, says:
This is going to sound silly, but something in me felt... entitled. You know, I've been up to my head all my life, a decent wife, a dutiful mother coping with Ben. This voice inside me kept saying "why shouldn't you be bad, why shouldn't you transgress? I mean, you've earned the right."
And on disenchantment more generally:
My father always used to say... you know, on the tube...? "Mind the gap." ....It's just the distance between life as you... dream it and... life as it is.
Again, any family with all it's adult obligations would serve to illustrate this, but Ben is used to intensify the effect. This may not be an inaccurate portrayal, but it does seem to be the main or sole dynamic signified by children with developmental disabilities (physical ones, too) in fiction.

Yet I think Ben offers more complexity than that, even on the theme of unruliness. Barbara is attracted to Sheba's bohemian artsy-ness and describes her as "different" from her other colleagues at school. They first meet when Barbara steps in to help Sheba with an altercation between two students -- an unruliness Sheba cannot manage on her own. In thanks, Sheba invites Barbara to lunch with her family, where Barbara finds herself observing casual family intimacy that includes a ritual after-lunch family dance. Young Ben is a key part of this free-spirited unruliness, the happy abandon of family togetherness that best reveals the loving connections Sheba endangers with her affair and Barbara threatens with her jealousy.

Penny wondered, in her comment quoted above, if "both smaller, serious dramas, with women in the leading roles--maybe that's no coincidence?" I don't think it is a coincidence that films centered on women's stories seem to portray parenting of children with Down syndrome more realistically than we've historically seen. (Take that observation for what it's worth -- I'm a student of disability in fiction but I'm not a parent and don't currently spend any time with children with developmental disabilities.) But I also think that the portrayal of these children, in Testament and Notes, by children who actually have disabilities is a function of the roles being small and not competitive roles for established actors. Adult developmentally disabled characters are typically played by nondisabled actors because some well-known star gains prestige from the role.

Monday, June 11, 2007

Admin notes

I've added some new blogs to the sidebar:

Andrea's Buzzing About
Big Noise
Bums & Bellybuttons
Rolling Around Life
The Seated View
Witticisms

Also, I've changed my name under my Blogger profile. It has read "Blue/Kay Olson" and now reads simply "Kay Olson." I'll answer to either still, or Blue Lily, which is the longer version of my feminist bulletin board name over the years. I was also Blue Girl at the Ms. Boards before they were deleted.

Finally, summer is here and the weather is mostly quite fine. I smell increasingly intermittent posting coming on, but that's a good thing. It means I'm out enjoying life.

Because

Penny tells me it's Peter Dinklage's birthday today:






















































Photo descriptions: There are five photos of Dinklage (My Imaginary Boyfriend). The first is a publicity shot for the sci-fi series Threshold where Dinklage wears a leather jacket over a dark red shirt. The second and third photos are from The Station Agent. In the second, he's standing on some railroad tracks with a suitcase next to his feet and the train tracks disappearing into the distance behind him. In the third, he's sitting in a doorway at the top of a few stairs with a woman and they're leaning toward each other to kiss. In the fourth photo, he wears a tan three-piece suit and stands at a podium in a courtroom. I think the photo is from Find Me Guilty. In the fifth photo, Dinklage sits at the edge of a table wearing blue jeans, a white undershirt and an unbuttoned dress shirt. His hands are in his pockets and his hair is tousled. Mmmm. The last pic is in black and white, as is the photo on the railroad tracks.

Happy Birthday Peter!

Movie review: Testament

In the comments to my review of the movie Tiptoes, Penny mentions a 1983 movie called Testament for it's portrayal of a child with Down Syndrome:

Child actors with Down syndrome occasionally have small roles in films where their visible difference is not much commented upon, nor does it become a major plot point. I'm thinking of Testament (1983), for example, and last year's Notes on a Scandal. Both smaller, serious dramas, with women in the leading roles--maybe that's no coincidence?
I ask:
Do you think the kids in them are just kids or does their Down Syndrome symbolize something about the mothers' lives?
And Penny answers:
Well, in Testament the boy's mother isn't in the story--he and his father are among the secondary characters, neighbors to Jane Alexander's lead character. I haven't seen it in years, but my memory is that his Down syndrome isn't "symbolic" of anything--they're presented as another ordinary, decent family, father and son, in the aftermath of a nuclear disaster. The film's tagline was "Imagine a day like any other. The children are fighting, the refrigerator is humming. Highways are jammed, playgrounds are filled. Everything is perfectly normal... For the very last time."

But as I'm reading now, the boy's name is Hiroshi--probably a reference to Hiroshima. Oh, hmm, now I feel like I have to track it down and watch it again. No hardship, it's a good film.
I saw Testament on dvd this weekend and I'd agree with Penny's characterization of the boy in the film. Hiroshi's father runs a gas station and Hiroshi is one of a couple orphaned children the main character, Carol Wetherly, takes in to care for -- along with her own three kids -- after nuclear bombs dropped across the U.S. leave her small northern California city intact but vulnerable to radioactive fallout from nearby San Fransisco. It's a grim story despite the fact that the tragedy is sparely shown. There are no bombed-out buildings and very few grisly details of radiation poisoning rendered. The politics of the attack is beyond the intimate scope of the story. This is about the slow quiet death of a community and it's people.

Hiroshi is well-loved by his father and treated with kindness and friendship by the other characters in the film. His Down Syndrome is noted at the beginning, briefly, when one father assures Hiroshi's father that it is basically unimportant and the child is always welcome in the Wetherly home. Hiroshi's part is small in the film, but he's not ever treated as unimportant, expendable or unloved as famine and illness strike the community. And from what I can tell through Googling the name "Hiroshi" it seems that it is a perfectly ordinary and perhaps common Asian (Japanese?) name not meant as any reference to the bombing of Hiroshima in WWII.

Jane Alexander was nominated for an Academy Award for her portrayal of Carol Wetherly. Lukas Haas, who plays her youngest, appeared in his first film here, and Kevin Costner and Rebecca De Mornay also have small but poignant roles.

Hiroshi is played by a young actor named Gerry Murillo who has not acted in any film since. Murillo does have the facial characteristics of a child who could have Down Syndrome, so it appears that this is a film where a child with developmental disabilities was hired to play a child with developmental disabilities, and that he is not symbolic of anything else within the story.

Thursday, June 07, 2007

How fast does that chair go?

Or: "Don't break the speed limit."

Ah, the clever things people say to you when you use a wheelchair.

In Ben Carpenter's case, the answer would be "50-mph":

Paw Paw police said the semi hit Carpenter's wheelchair as he was trying to cross from the north to south side of Red Arrow at Hazen Street at about 3:30 p.m. The driver of the truck, a 52-year-old Kalamazoo man whom police have not named, told authorities he'd been waiting at a red light and didn't see Carpenter. When the light turned green, he proceeded west on Red Arrow.

"I made a mistake," Carpenter said of his decision to cross the road. "A big mistake."

Carpenter said after the truck hit him, his wheelchair somehow turned frontward and its handles became stuck in the truck's grille. From there, police estimate, the truck reached speeds of 50 mph before pulling into a Ralph Moyle Inc. trucking facility in the 39200 block of Red Arrow.

"It's a good thing the place was only a couple of miles away," Carpenter said.
Check out the news video of Carpenter's story at MSNBC here.

This story is wild and funny, but being a wheelchair "pedestrian" is dangerous business. Unaccessible or nonexistent sidewalks (or construction without available alternative routes) often require wheelchair users to travel in the street. Even when there are ramps at street corners, they are often not placed so that they can be used without brushing the grill of a car, often a car where the driver is looking the other direction in anticipation of turning into the street. If there's one ramp per corner -- as opposed to one ramp per each side of a crosswalk -- it sometimes means that crossing the street involves flirting with the traffic zipping by on the green light. If ramps aren't maintained when streets are re-tarred, there can be such jarring bumps at the base of the ramp that staying in your seat is even tricky.

I've had my scooter clunked a few times by the bumpers of cars that move while I'm forced to use the ramp practically under their tires. I've even kissed the corner of a bus once. I had the right of way and was busy doing my damnedest not to kiss the underside of it too.

I'm glad Carpenter wasn't hurt. I wish it was safer for all of us out there.

Tuesday, June 05, 2007

Boys on Wheels

Funny or not so much?


Direct YouTube link here.

The lead singer of Boys on Wheels is Jesper Odelberg and he is a guy with cerebral palsy, as well as part of a Norwegian comedy show. The four-minute video linked above is a montage of rock songs with lyrics slightly altered. For example, the first song is in Norwegian, the second is a spoof on the '80s hit by Norwegian band A-Ha: "Take On Me," instead called "I'm Not Gay." Bryan Adams' '80s power ballad "Heaven" has been altered so the lyrics begin:

Baby, you're all that I want, but you're living on the fifth floor.
I'm finding it hard to get there, in my wheelchair.
Bon Jovi's "Living On A Prayer" is spoofed as "Living In A Wheelchair." The lyrics are provided in subtitles within the video.

Also at YouTube, Boys on Wheels singing "My Balls are OK" and "Making Love in a Handicap Toilet"


Monday, June 04, 2007

Setting the record straight about Jack

The following via email from Steven Drake of Not Dead Yet:

In 1993, Jack Kevorkian told Time Magazine, “If they will allow themselves to be strapped to a wheelchair for 72 hours so they can't move, and they are catheterized and they are placed on the toilet and fed and bathed. Then they can sit in a chair and debate with me."

Kevorkian is talking about us – we're some of the people who were here throughout his trial and conviction for the murder of Thomas Youk. Many of us have similar conditions to people – especially women – who make up the bulk of Kevorkian's body count. We have significant disabilities and chronic conditions.

Given the recent press coverage, this might surprise you, since Mike Wallace and Kevorkian only referenced “terminally ill” people on Sunday night. The Associated Press and the New York Times have been describing his body count this way as well.

They're wrong. In 1997, the Detroit Free Press documented the numbers of non-terminally ill people who died in his hands in the series “The Suicide Machine.” This was reaffirmed later when the results of a study were published in 2000 in the New England Journal of Medicine.

The press hasn't played into such blatant misinformation in such a big way since they gave the Bush Administration a “pass” on its suggestions that Saddam Hussein was responsible in some way for 9/11.

Jack evaded us at his trial – living up to his word has never been a strong point with him. We're here now – to challenge him, his allies, and the press who keep passing off their lies and misinformation.

Unlike those who found, or were taken to, Kevorkian, unlike those who got death instead of the real supports they could have used to rebuild their lives as disabled people – we’re Not Dead Yet, and we’re here to set the record straight.

Some links:
1993 Time issue with Kevorkian on cover. Table of contents here.
Detroit Free Press coverage of Kevorkian. Scroll down for "The Suicide Machine" series that documents the many people Kevorkian killed who were disabled, not terminally ill.

Poetry: Robert Pinsky

Below is a poem by Robert Pinsky, who served as U.S. Poet Laureate in the late '90s. The new Journal of Literary Disability also has an essay, "Disability Haunting in American Poetics" by Sharon L. Snyder and David T. Mitchell that explores Pinsky's writings on disability in American poetry:

Pinsky’s essay about the thematics of haunting could be found culpable for its own repressions in the midst of formulating a theory of national identity that is based upon eradicating the conflicts of the past. In many of his examples, the haunting of the American poet is identified with the sudden eruption of ‘nightmarish figures’ that disturb the language of poetic revelation. Upon close reading, many of Pinsky’s haunting figures appear marked by cognitive and physical disabilities that upset the more abstract and utopian longings of American ideals. Because haunting operates as a barely discernible phenomenon (a ghostly presence often concretizes an otherwise repressed content), disability, as a metaphor for what Toni Morrison calls “unspeakable thoughts unspoken” (1989, 1), haunts Pinsky’s poetry of haunting. Better yet, the poets of which Pinsky writes may be fully aware that disability is their topic of contemplation, meaning that only Pinsky’s essay can be said to be haunted by the specter of disability.
So, in the above essay combined with Pinsky's poetry on psychiatrists some interesting ideas emerge. Here also, a psychiatrist comments on the poem below.

An excerpt from "Essay on Psychiatrists" by Robert Pinsky:

III. Proposition

These are the first citizens of contingency.
Far from the doctrinaire past of the old ones,
They think in their prudent meditations

Not about ecstasy (the soul leaving the body)
Nor enthusiasm (the god entering one’s person)
Nor even about sanity (which means

Health, an impossible perfection)
But ponder instead relative truth and the warm
Dusk of amelioration. The cautious

Young augurs with their family-life, good books
And records and foreign cars believe
In amelioration—in that, and in suffering.


IV. A Lakeside Identification

Yes, crazy to suppose one could describe them—
And yet, there was this incident: at the local beach
Clouds of professors and the husbands of professors

Swam, dabbled, or stood to talk with arms folded
Gazing at the lake ... and one of the few townsfolk there,
With no faculty status—a matter-of-fact, competent,

Catholic woman of twenty-seven with five children
And a first-rate body—pointed her finger
At the back of one certain man and asked me,

“Is that guy a psychiatrist?” and by god he was! “Yes,”
She said, “He looks like a psychiatrist.”
Grown quiet, I looked at his pink back, and thought.


Read the whole poem here.

Friday, June 01, 2007

The Huffington Post: Disability advocates should get over it

I've got some other stuff to do tonight, but wanted to share the link.

Excerpt:

From where I sit, I don't see how compassion in dying has anything to do with disability rights. For those of us who want to offer dignity to those whose pain can no longer be nursed, the fact that our society too often treats the disabled as second-class citizens also is a powerful assault on our humane sensitivities.

Could the real issue for some disability advocates be that ongoing life experiences have convinced you that able-bodied citizens feel you are "in the way," and that right-to-die types have as the ultimate goal more tools to get you, our disabled brothers and sisters, "out of the way?"

While I don't have the life experience to see things from your perspective, I have to tell the disability advocate community that such a mind-set strikes me as a bit paranoid. I liken it to the fear in some minority communities that some forms of contraception are really efforts at medically sanctioned genocide.

Disability advocates, please understand we right-to-die types are not your enemies. We are your friends.

Thursday, May 31, 2007

Amputee soldiers return to active duty

The Quaker Agitator notes the changing military policy on injured soldiers. From the Yahoo story:

Previously, a soldier who lost a limb almost automatically received a quick discharge, a disability check and an appointment with the Veterans Administration.

But since the start of the Iraq war, the military has begun holding on to amputees, treating them in rehab programs like the one here at Fort Sam Houston and promising to help them return to active duty if that is what they want.

"The mindset of our Army has changed, to the extent that we realize the importance of all our soldiers and what they can contribute to our Army. Someone who loses a limb is still a very valuable asset," said Lt. Col. Kevin Arata, a spokesman for the Army's Human Resources Command at the Pentagon.

Also, just as advances in battlefield medicine have boosted survival rates among the wounded, better prosthetics and treatment regimens have improved amputees' ability to regain mobility.

So far, the Army has treated nearly 600 service members who have come back from Iraq or Afghanistan without an arm, leg, hand or foot. Thirty-one have gone back to active duty, and no one who asked to remain in the service has been discharged, Arata said.

Most of those who return to active duty are assigned to instructor or desk jobs away from combat. Only a few — the Army doesn't keep track of exactly how many — have returned to the war zone, and only at their insistence, Arata said.
Yeah, I hate the Iraq war and Bush is a liar I want impeached. But I don't automatically see this as bad. It's problematic for oh so many reasons, but continuing to employ people who might otherwise join the ranks of the unemployed disabled seems better to me than simply discharging them and leaving them to fend for themselves.

What do you think?

Link courtesy of reader Jo.

Movie review: Tiptoes

Imagine the movie North Country cast with Brad Pitt playing Charlize Theron's role of the woman suffering sexual harassment at work. Not as a man suffering that harassment. Imagine Pitt cast in the part as a woman, without irony or satire.

Or imagine Spike Lee's Do The Right Thing, about an urban cauldron of racial tension, but unironically cast entirely with white actors in the main roles. You know, because the actors are talented and it would be an exciting challenge to portray someone of another race convincingly when the audience is aware of exactly who they, as actors, are. Some of the white cast would need to wear blackface, but it's part of the craft of acting. Right?

Those movies had impressive scripts. But now imagine a film about an engaged couple where the woman gets pregnant but the man hasn't yet told her that dwarfism runs in his family. His twin brother is a dwarf, played in all seriousness by a well-known 5'10" actor.

Yep, the couple (Carol and Steven), an artist and firefighter, are played by Kate Beckinsale and Matthew McConaughey. That's them in the center of the photo for one DVD cover, at left. Gary Oldman, a great actor but 5'10", plays McConaughey's dwarf twin brother Rolfe (Oldman is also 12 years older than McConaughey), always filmed in lumpy clothing to hide the fact he's walking on his knees. He's in the picture at far right. Pictured at far left is Patricia Arquette, who plays Lucy the average-sized lover of Rolfe's weird, bitter French Marxist dwarf friend, Maurice. Maurice is played by Peter Dinklage, an actual little person and fantastic actor.* He doesn't appear anywhere in the photo, or the billing in that DVD cover photo.

Got that? Tiptoes, a movie about dwarfism with all average-size actors playing any character with billing. The secondary characters and extras include dozens of little folks, so it was a very conscious casting choice to not let dwarfs represent themselves in any major substantive character-developed way. And while it's good to see a film about dwarfism, exploring the unique difficulties and cultural events that bring little people together, they remain -- if you'll forgive me -- the sideshow to the average-sized people who spend the film talking about them or, in Oldman's case, acting as one of them.

False representation, however earnest or talented the actor, is still a form of silencing and control. Why shouldn't this be any less outrageous and offensive than blackface? Why is this accepted but we never see a male actor given a woman character for a role?

"Nothing about us without us." It's a disability rights political slogan for important reasons: too often someone else insists on controlling the story to ridiculous degrees.

Oh: I did enjoy little bits of the film. Dinklage was fun to see, and I do like all the actors in the cast. The script was uneven and boring toward the end. Tiptoes premiered at the 2004 Sundance Film Festival, but damned if I know why.


* Peter Dinklage played the lead in the film The Station Agent, which I reviewed here. He's also My Imaginary Boyfriend, so I may be slightly biased when I say he's the best thing in Tiptoes.

Regarding Kevorkian

Not Dead Yet is demanding that the Associated Press retract and correct a faulty poll that asked the public misleading questions about the parole of convicted murderer Jack Kevorkian. From the press release:

According to the AP, the survey asked the following question:

"Do you think that Michigan doctor Jack Kevorkian should have been jailed for assisting terminally ill people end their own life, or not?"

"This question misinforms the respondent about the nature of the crime Kevorkian was convicted of and also mischaracterizes the health status of the majority of people who died at his hands. As anyone who watched the 60-Minutes telecast knows, Kevorkian directly injected lethal chemicals into Thomas Youk. This is not 'assistance'," says Stephen Drake, Not Dead Yet's research analyst. "Further, the word 'people' is paired with 'terminally ill', indicating that the majority of his body count consisted of people who were close to death." Beginning with the Detroit Free Press series 'The Suicide Machine' in 1997, there is overwhelming documentation that the majority of people who went to Kevorkian had non-lethal chronic conditions and disabilities.

Diane Coleman, president of Not Dead Yet, personally contacted Trevor Thompson, the AP's Manager of News Surveys, to demand a retraction and correction.

"Mr. Thompson eventually agreed the question didn't jive with the facts of Kevorkian's career or conviction but rejected any corrective action after consulting with the D.C. Bureau Chief, Sandy Johnson. Johnson claimed that the story about the poll was accurate, disregarding responsibility for contaminating the poll with a misleading question."

Carol Gill, Ph.D., agrees with the concerns of Not Dead Yet. "All good survey designers know that misleading questions produce invalid results. When participants are asked to respond to inaccurate and confusing items, the result is spoiled data. Unfortunately, this poll contained flawed questions. It's impossible to base sound conclusions on these results." Professor Gill is a research psychologist and associate professor at the University of Illinois at Chicago.

Drake adds that the refusal of Thompson and Johnson to address the misinformation in the poll is a violation of the AP's public "Statement on Values and Principles," which calls for swift and comprehensive corrective action when it publishes erroneous information.

"This is worse than the usual error," says Drake. "In this case, it created news in the form of a survey and then reported on that fabrication. Instead of simply reporting misinformation, AP has created the information in a way that superficially resembles scientific sampling. It has knowingly polluted the public discussion about an important public policy topic - and the organization is refusing to take responsibility for it."
Chicago columnist Mike Miner on the issue.

And a recent article from the Detroit Free Press stating that pro-assisted suicide activists are desperately trying to distance themselves from Kevorkian and his legacy:
As Jack Kevorkian, 79, prepares to re-enter the national spotlight this week after eight years in prison, assisted-suicide advocates are doing all they can to distance themselves from the man called Dr. Death.

His release from a Michigan prison Friday -- one week before a planned California vote on whether to join Oregon as the only states to allow assisted death for the terminally ill -- could not come at a more critical or inopportune time for the movement, which has worked for years to legalize the practice and shed the ghoulish persona many associate with Kevorkian and his suicide machine.
The article notes that in Oregon, where assisted suicide is legal, "Suicides under the law peaked in 2006, with 45 patients choosing to end their lives early."

That's inaccurate. There are no 2007 stats yet, so there's no "peaking." If 2006 has the highest stats, then possibly it's an upwards trend.

Here's a link to the Free Press coverage of Kevorkian over the years. Steven Drake says in comments at the Miner link above:

I've lost count of the number of Michigan journalists who admit there have been problems with accuracy in covering Kevorkian but don't seem particularly troubled by it.
Also, to my knowledge, the disavowal of Kevorkian by other assisted-suicide proponents is only vocal now, after he's been convicted, paroled, and will again have a public microphone. If someone can show me where these people have been speaking stridently against Kevorkian and his methods prior to now, when it's politically expedient to do so, I'd be interested in seeing that.

Tuesday, May 29, 2007

Race as disability

Back in March the story of the Andrews family of Long Island came to public attention. The NY Daily News announced "What a mess, baby: Parents say fertility clinic botched in-vitro & girl's got the wrong dad":

A Long Island woman and her husband are suing a Park Ave. fertility clinic for allegedly inseminating her with the wrong man's sperm.

After struggling to conceive their second child, Nancy Andrews and her husband, Thomas, turned to New York Medical Services for Reproductive Medicine for in-vitro fertilization treatments, according to a lawsuit.

Andrews soon became pregnant and the couple was overjoyed. They only discovered the clinic's "colossal blunder" after Andrews gave birth to her daughter Jessica, court papers charge.

"While we love Baby Jessica as our own, we are reminded of this terrible mistake each and every time we look at her," the Commack couple said in documents filed in Manhattan Supreme Court. "It is simply impossible to ignore."

Thomas Andrews is white and his wife is Dominican. But Jessica, who was born Oct. 19, 2004, has darker skin than either of them as well as "characteristics more typical of African or African-American descent," the lawsuit states.

The couple tested their daughter's DNA using a home kit and later with two more sophisticated methods. All three of the tests confirmed their suspicions - the tot has a different father.
The story came to public notice in March because a judge ruled the couple can precede with their medical malpractice lawsuit but disallowed the claims of mental suffering -- the parents' suffering and baby Jessica's suffering for being a different race than her parents. There's a lot to unpack here and The Nation's Patricia Williams took a stab at it:
What's distinctive about the Andrews case is that the parents... tried to cite... Jessica's pain and suffering for having to endure life as a black person. The Andrewses expressed concern that Jessica "may be subjected to physical and emotional illness as a result of not being the same race as her parents and siblings." They are "distressed" that she is "not even the same race, nationality, color...as they are." They describe Jessica's conception as a "mishap" so "unimaginable" that they have not told many of their relatives. (Telling the tabloids all about it must have come easier.) "We fear that our daughter will be the object of scorn and ridicule by other children," the couple said, because Jessica has "characteristics more typical of African or African-American descent." So "while we love Baby Jessica as our own, we are reminded of this terrible mistake each and every time we look at her...each and every time we appear in public."
Since the claim of mental distress of their child hinges on appearance and public perceptions of skin color, Williams comments on the family's photo:
The picture underscores the embedded cultural oddities of this case, the invisibly shifting boundaries of how we see race, extend intimacy, name "difference." According to the Post, Mrs. Andrews is "Hispanic" and apparently, by the paper's calculations, one Hispanic woman plus one white man equals "a white pair." The mother is "a light-skinned native of the Dominican Republic," seeming to indicate that while she may not be "white," she's also not "black." Each narrative implies that if the correct sperm had been used, the Andrewses would have been guaranteed a lighter-skinned child. But as most Dominicans trace their heritage to some mixture of African slaves, indigenous islanders and European settlers, and as dark skin color is a dominant trait, it could be that the true sperm donor is as "white" as Mr. Andrews. But that possibility is exiled from the word boxes that contain this child. Not only is Jessica viewed as being of a race apart from either of her parents; she is even designated a different nationality--this latter most startling for its blood-line configuration of citizenship itself.
Paul Butler at BlackProf discusses the race issue as well.

If I understand the legal situation correctly, the parents' claim of mental suffering is essentially a "wrongful conception" or "wrongful birth" claim and their suit on behalf of Baby Jessica's mental suffering is a "wrongful life" claim. New York state, where the case resides, has precedence in these situations, which Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Sheila Abdus-Salaam cited in her ruling. Regarding the "wrongful birth" claim:
By logical extension of the principles enunciated by the courts in New York that the birth of an unwanted but otherwise healthy and normal child does not constitute an injury to the child's parents, and that even parents of a child with a serious disease cannot recover for emotional injury for the birth of that child, plaintiffs in this case cannot recover for mental distress arising from having a child who is not Mr. Andrews' biological offspring.... Plaintiffs cannot recover damages based upon their claim that they were deprived of the opportunity to have a child of their own genetic makeup. The Court of Appeals has rejected as too speculative a claim that is " . . . based essentially on "wrongful nonbirth", the deprivation of an opportunity by a woman to have a child by her husband.
While these types of lawsuits were originally an additional claim for malpractice issues like failed vasectomies or lack of medical information provided by doctors, much of the case law centers around the distinction of whether or not a child with disabilities is involved. And, of course, that determination hinges on the ability to diagnose that there's "something wrong" with a child at the time a suit is filed. In the Andrewses case, if Jessica had not been perceived as looking physically different from her parents, her genetic differences (in this case, the fact that her father was not a biological parent) may have gone forever unnoticed.

And because the wrongful life suit (rejected by the judge) on Jessica's behalf claims she will suffer physical and emotional stress from having darker skin than her family, race is made here to be a kind of disability. Disability, after all, is not only about actual impairments, but also perceived impairments -- the ADA recognizes this fact of the social stigma of disability.

While the specific circumstances (of botched reproductive technology leading to wrongful birth and life claims due to skin color) may be new, positing race or gender or ethnicity as a disability is not historically new. Disability is and has frequently been used as a method of demonizing or oppressing other minority populations. That goes back at least as far as Aristotle claiming that women are mutilated (read impaired) males. The medical definition of "hysteria" linked femaleness with mental instability. Irrespective of diagnosed intellectual impairments, black male schoolchildren in U.S. public schools are much more likely than other kids to be placed in special ed classes or considered behavioral problems. There are innumerable examples of oppressed minority identities having their identifying biological difference labelled as a disabling condition.

But culturally, we find it challenging to look at the dynamic from the other direction. Sandel's book (discussed briefly in an earlier, May 26, 2007, post) on the ethics of striving for genetic perfection asks:
Is it wrong to make a child deaf by design? If so, what makes it wrong -- the deafness or the design? Suppose, for the sake of argument, that deafness is not a disability but a distinctive identity. Is there still something wrong with the idea of parents picking and choosing the kind of child they will have? Or do parents do that all the time, in their choice of mate and, these days, in their use of new reproductive technologies?
What if, with an understanding of how elusive and intersecting categories of ability and identity are, that paragraph were rewritten to more closely discuss the Andrewses court case?
Is it wrong to make a child dark-skinned by design? If so, what makes it wrong -- the dark skin or the design? Suppose, for the sake of argument, that dark skin is not a disability but a distinctive identity. Is there still something wrong with the idea of parents picking and choosing the kind of child they will have? Or do parents do that all the time, in their choice of mate and, these days, in their use of new reproductive technologies?
Intersections between identities are never perfect, and matching women's oppression to racial oppression to disability oppression is never a perfect fit of history and experience, but the Andrewses case does beg the above questions about race. The references to "dark skin" could easily be changed to "light skin" to reflect the family's presumption of genetic whiteness, but the "problem" of skin color difference remains.

I confess that I don't know exactly how this court case illuminates the debates over prenatal screening and genetic engineering to avoid children with disabilities. But they are fundamentally related.


Cross-posted at Echidne of the Snakes

Update: Also posted at Racialicious

Mini-slumgullion # 38 -- Announcement-y stuff

Via Penny:

Cindy Sue at Six Almost Seven announces plans to celebrate the eighth anniversary of the Olmstead decision at the Georgia State Capitol. The 1999 Supreme Court decision in Olmstead v. L.C and E.W ruled that Georgia must work toward placing institutionalized disabled citizens in community settings rather than simply warehousing them. It's one of the few certain judicial victories resulting from the ADA and it's had huge, far-reaching implications for disabled people's lives and for public policy. The anniversary is June 22. What are you planning?

Via Connie at Planet of the Blind:

[With]TV -- A new television channel "of, by, and for people with disabilities... and everyone else." Details at POTB, and also at the [with]TV website.

Via Editor David Bolt:

The Journal of Literary Disability's first issue is now available online. (!) Seriously -- ! Stephen Kuusisto co-wrote one of the articles, and they all look interesting and exciting. Once I get a chance to read I'll no doubt be commenting on what's there.

Saturday, May 26, 2007

The Case against Perfection

A new book by Michael J. Sandel, called The Case against Perfection: Ethics in the Age of Genetic Engineering, explores the moral issues created by the increasing knowledge about genetics and the scientific abilities to manipulate our future because of it. I haven't read the book yet, though I do plan to. But an excerpt from the opening pages (available here in .pdf format) offers some intriguing questions which are related to an upcoming post I'm working on.

Sandel begins by looking at a deaf lesbian couple who chose to have a deaf child and juxtaposes that rather radical decision with those couples who seek genetic perfection in their child:

Is it wrong to make a child deaf by design? If so, what makes it wrong -- the deafness or the design? Suppose, for the sake of argument, that deafness is not a disability but a distinctive identity. Is there still something wrong with the idea of parents picking and choosing the kind of child they will have? Or do parents do that all the time, in their choice of mate and, these days, in their use of new reproductive technologies?

Not long before the controversy over the deaf child, an ad appeared in the Harvard Crimson and other Ivy League newspapers. An infertile couple was seeking an egg donor, but not just any egg donor. She had to be five feet, ten inches tall, athletic, without major family medical problems, and to have a combined SAT score of 1400 or above. In exchange for an egg from a donor meeting this description, the ad offered payment of $50,000.

Perhaps the parents who offered the hefty sum for a premium egg simply wanted a child who resembled them. Or perhaps they were hoping to trade up, trying for a child who would be taller or smarter than they. Whatever the case, their extraordinary offer did not prompt the public outcry that met the parents who wanted a deaf child. No one objected that height, intelligence, and ahletic prowess are disabilities that children should be spared. And yet something about the ad leaves a lingering moral qualm. Even if no harm is involved, isn't there something troubling about parents ordering up a child with certain genetic traits?

Some defend the attempt to conceive a deaf child, or one who will have high SAT scores, as similar to natural procreation in one crucial respect: whatever these parents did to increase the odds, they were not guaranteed the outcome they sought. Both attempts were still subject to the vagaries of the genetic lottery. This defense raises an intriguing question. Why does some element of unpredictability seem to make a moral difference? Suppose biotechnology could remove the uncertainty and allow us to design the genetic traits of our children?
The technology of genetic engineering is one cultural location where the politics of reproductive freedom and disability rights come together. These are not the only issues, or the only place these two interests intersect, but it is probably the most culturally compelling in our time.


Cross-posted at Echidne of the Snakes

Friday, May 25, 2007

Things that crack me up, #28

Photo description: A picture of a woman in a wheelchair taken from several feet behind her. A woman with long flowing almost white-blonde hair and a leopard print cushion behind her back sits in a motorized wheelchair. You can't see her face or body, but there's a bumpersticker on the back of the power unit that reads "Does this wheelchair make my butt look big?"

Courtesy of the Finnish blog Tassutuksia

Check out Disability Blog Carnival #15

Disability Blog Carnival #15 at Ryn TalesThe latest edition of the twice-monthly Disability Blog Carnival is up at Ryn Tales, where "Family" is the theme. Under that theme, host Kathryn gathers posts on the following topics: Loss of Anonymity, Don’t speak for me, What it’s like, Demystifying and Diversifying the Meaning of Perfection, Get a Clue! Tips for Family and Friends, Impact of Prejudice, A Day in the life: Parenting, and Hope for Ellie's Future.

The next carnival is at PilgrimGirl where the theme is "Borders": submission deadline is Monday, June 11, 2007, and further info is here.

Cross-posted at Echidne of the Snakes

Movie review: Emmanuel's Gift

I didn't expect to like this 2005 documentary, the story of Ghanaian Emmanuel Ofosu Yeboah, born without a tibia in his right leg and one of the two million people in his country living as a second class citizen.

Why did I dread watching this flick? Yeboah "overcomes adversity." That tired inspirational trope that dominates stories of disabled people's lives. He rides a bicycle across Ghana. I've never really understood athletic endeavors meant to be attention-getters for some cause. Go pound some nails instead, okay? Do some activity with actual value beyond it's celebrity. And the film is narrated by Oprah Winfrey, who has never before uttered the words "disability rights," though she has no problem exploring the medical aspects and social misfortunes of impairment. Oh, Winfrey's had guests who happen to discuss ableism and crip rights -- Chris and Dana Reeve (to some degree) and William H. Macy* (eloquently) are celebrity examples. Never once did I see her take that bait and follow the thread of social injustice or call for people to demand change.

So I had reservations aplenty.

But here's the thing: In Ghana, where an astounding one in ten citizens have some sort of disability, infanticide of visibly disabled infants is common. If they aren't killed or hidden away shamefully, disabled Ghanaians become beggars on the street. That is the range of options.

So a guy with one working leg riding a bicycle across the nation -- 380 miles -- and calling for disability rights and opportunities had an incredible impact on a society that thought it had everyone in their rightful place.

When Yeboah was born, his father saw him and promptly abandoned the family. His mother was encouraged to kill her son, but instead she sent him to school and taught him he deserved all the privileges and opportunities nondisabled people have. When Yeboah had trouble getting the other schoolkids to let him play with them, he ingeniously saved his money (no easy feat) and bought his own soccer ball -- a rare commodity. The price of playing with it was letting Yeboah join in the game using his one full-grown leg and crutches.

With his mother ill and medical bills to pay, young Yeboah shined shoes for money. He left his village and family behind to go to Accra, the nation's capital, to earn $2 per day shining shoes instead of just $1 per day back home. So, he's a teenage boy on crutches shining shoes far from home to support his family -- mom and two younger siblings, I believe. Yet after his mom dies and he applies to the Californian Challenged Athletes Foundation (CAF), he asks not for cash but for a bicycle because he's thinking big. He wants all Ghanians to see that disabled people can do more than be street beggars.

Yeboah's bike ride makes him a national hero and celebrity. The film follows his visit to America, where he competes in some athletic events and decides on amputation of his limb so he can wear a prosthesis. He returns home without his crutches, but with political momentum. We see him meeting with tribal chiefs, disabled beggars whom he encourages to reach for more, and most poignantly, the father who abandoned him.

The film's slick editing interferes with the story, but the celebrity created by Yeboah's bike ride forces public officials to reconsider national disability policy and respond, as one canny bureaucrat notes, that ''we may have underestimated the urgency of the matter." Returning to the United States, Yeboah meets with fellow Ghanaian and then-U.N. President Kofi Annan, and also receives grant money for his goals of helping other disabled Ghanaians and starting a wheelchair basketball team for the 2008 Paralympics in Beijing.

In a historic meeting at King's Palace in Kibi, Ghana, where because of superstition and stigma no disabled person has ever before been invited, King Osagyefuo praises Yeboah and throws his support as leader of 2.5 million people in Eastern Ghana behind efforts to improve the lives of disabled citizens. Says King Osagyefuo:

“The society and country are not set up to take care of handicapped people. Emmanuel has tenacity, endurance and he has a strong heart to do the things that he is doing and to use what he has done as an example for other disabled people. We will support him and tell the government that they are also part of us—they may be physically challenged, but mentally and intellectually they are the same as us.”
The King's statements are nothing short of revolutionary in a culture where disability is commonly believed to be the karmic result of immorality.

Yeboah hopes to become a member of the Ghana Parliament one day. In the meantime, he's married -- to a nondisabled Ghanaian woman, which is apparently a feat of disability acceptance in itself due to cultural stigmas -- and has a daughter. The film fails to show these last and most ordinary achievements in his life, but Yeboah's story shines through any directorial shortcomings to show what a single person can achieve when he is taught his own self-worth.

------------------------------------

* IIRC, Macy appeared on Oprah after the release of Door to Door, his award-winning made-for-tv true story of Bill Porter, a man with cerebral palsy who confounded all expectations by becoming a top door-to-door salesman. Macy had become a national ambassador for United Cerebral Palsy and when prompted by Oprah about his volunteer position he spoke eloquently and at length specifically about disability prejudice and discrimination.

Cross-posted at Echidne of the Snakes

Guest posting at Echidne's for a week

Tireless feminist blogger Echidne at Echidne of the Snakes has enlisted me and several other folks to keep her place busy while she takes a short break. I'll be cross-posting a few of my entries over there between now and next Wednesday, and since her readership is much, much larger than mine you might pop over and read any comments there. Join in discussion. Enjoy the change of scenery.