Wednesday, November 07, 2007

The wild life

It feels like winter coming here at the Gimp Compound. This past weekend, my father put up his little hand-turned wooden dish bird feeder and set out the winter birdbath on the back deck, which has been cleared of patio furniture for the season. The hand-turned feeder is about an eight-inch dish attached to a two-foot dowel and hung from the edge of the eave just outside the picture window I face when I enjoy my morning tea. The winter birdbath is heated, and wasn't plugged in at first, but the water froze solid yesterday, so it's a little birdy hot tub now.

The winter bird accommodations bring the wildlife right up to the picture window instead of 15 feet out at the oak tree bordering the back deck, though the suet feeder gets attached to the tree trunk for the winter and will become a popular lunchtime destination too. The past couple days there've been chickadees, nuthatches, juncos, downy woodpeckers, sparrows and finches at that little feeder a few inches from the glass. They eat a bit, then notice the shape of me through the window at a table about five feet away and they stretch and tip their heads to focus an eyeball in my direction with curiosity and concern. And they chatter to each other. Drive the cat wild inside. The squirrels look for dropped seeds under the feeder and sit eyeball to eyeball with the cat while she twitches uncontrollably.

Last week, the pileated woodpecker came to see if the suet was up yet. It wasn't. I sat with my tea, frozen motionless, while the massive 15-inch male crept up the tree trunk, peered with paranoia all around, then resignedly flew away. And today there was squirrel sex. Lots of it. In the oak tree, in the neighbors' oak tree up high -- a hundred feet off the ground. Much exuberant molesting of each other throughout the afternoon.

Life inside the picture window is much duller. Me, I'm exhausted from a night spent training a brand new nurse. All went great, but I never sleep well the first few nights with someone new around, so I'm tired and off to bed early tonight.

But check out my friend Grace's post on Wilma Rudolph. Wilma was my first hero. I read her autobiography when I was in grade school, and long before I identified as disabled or used a wheelchair I thought she was the most amazing person on earth. I'll do tomorrow's post now too, early, about another hero of mine.

Tuesday, November 06, 2007

The DaDa Awards

Liz Crow and her Roaring Girl Productions is my biggest blogging failure. Liz and I first exchanged emails well over a year ago and I volunteered to interview her and discuss her work. I linked to clips of one of her award-winning short films, Frida Kahlo's Corset back in July on the 100th anniversary of Kahlo's birth, but have never managed to cough up interview questions for Liz to answer.

And I still haven't done that. Nor have I actually seen her full productions beyond the generous info at her website (that info includes film clips, stills, and scripts, by the way). But let me list a few of the many things that fascinate and thrill me about her work:

1.) Her documentary film The Real Helen Keller explores the famous woman behind the iconic deaf-blind celebrity. Here's the film script (.pdf), which is an excellent read by itself:

Narration: Helen was one of the first people to understand that charity was not the answer. She recognised that disabled people lived in poverty because they were excluded from jobs and that poverty in turn created illness and impairment. She argued that what was needed was radical change.

In an era when venereal disease was a leading and unmentionable cause of blindness, she was willing to campaign on this in the press.

Georgina Kleege (author of Blind Rage): People were scandalised when she wrote about it, because she had to write about venereal disease and sexual promiscuity and issues she wasn’t supposed to think about. But at the same time she talks about the issue obviously as a woman’s issue, a woman’s health issue. She also perceived it as an economic issue because she understood that more affluent women would have access to better healthcare, so for her it was information that needed to be given to less affluent women, so that they could make demands of whoever was providing healthcare to them. So she had a mind, it seems to me, that made these sorts of connections that other people weren’t making.
2.) Her short experimental film Frida Kahlo's Corset.

3.) Her project to design the Access Tripod, a tool that would allow wheelchair-using filmmakers to run a handheld camera themselves instead of directing someone else to capture their creative vision.

4.) And her experimentation with ways of making films more accessible to all viewers. Anyone who has ever tried to use the captioning feature tacked onto a commercial film DVD has experienced how separate the accessibility features are from the film itself. Sometimes the captions are ridiculously inaccurate*. Sometimes text is unreadable or descriptions incomplete. Often, it's not an available feature at all. In my family, that means one person who is hearing impaired misses out on much of the dialogue and the shared experience is lessened for us all.

Liz's company is exploring new ways of using captioning, sign language and audio description (ACS) as an integral part of the creative process of her films. Does it make me a film geek that I find this incredibly exciting? Maybe.

Anyway, Liz Crow has been short-listed for a DaDa Award under the category of "New Media" and it's time for the public to vote. The DaDa Awards are sponsored by NWDAF, the North West Disability Arts Forum, based in Liverpool, England. NWDAF is dedicated to promoting equal access to art for all disabled and deaf people, from celebration of disability culture within art to employment to full audience access.

Anyone can vote. Vote before November 27. And check out the other nominees in all eight categories too.

Other links about Liz's work:

Netribution Film Network interview with Liz Crow about Frida Kahlo's Corset

21 Things to Remember, a short film by Liz Crow (link is to "clip 1" with "clip 2" available below it providing audio description)



----------------------------------------------------------

*One of my all-time favorite films, Jesus of Montreal, has captioning where something like this frequently occurs: The character on screen clearly says, "I'm 18 years old" while the text just below reads "I'm 23 years of age."

Monday, November 05, 2007

Preschoolers: What happens when people get old?

Image description: A large piece of butcher paper hangs in an outdoor display of drawings by preschoolers prompted by the question "What happens when people get old?" This paper shows a simple line drawing of a character in a wheelchair. The character looks a little like a mouse's head sticking out of a large square cart on wheels. Below an adult has printed a child's thoughts, "You go in a wheelchair. Your body is a little twisty."

Flickr: Frauenfelder

Sunday, November 04, 2007

Disability journals

The Fall 2007 issue of the Society for Disability Studies' journal, Disability Studies Quarterly, is available free online. The topic is "The State of Disability in Israel/Palestine." It sounds like this particular issue will remain available for free, and there is some talk of expanding that access to all future issues, which would be great. I hope that would include past issues as well.

The latest issue of the Review of Disability Studies: An International Journal is available in .pdf and .doc formats here.

The second issue of the Journal of Literary Disability, on the topic of "Disability and the Dialectic of Dependency" is available here.

The third issue of Wordgathering: A Journal of Disability Poetry is available here.

And, because it might interest writers, M/C Journal: A Journal of Media and Culture, which focuses each issue around a one word theme (the current issue is about "error"), has an upcoming issue that will explore the meaning of "able". Submission info here.

And finally, the CFP for the Society for Disability Studies' annual conference, in New York City, June 18-22, 2008, is available here.

Feel free to use the comments to link other relevant journals or CFPs.

Saturday, November 03, 2007

Nobel laureate James Watson and the big liberal tent

Last month, scientist James Watson, who won the Nobel back in 1962 for his work in understanding the Double Helix structure of DNA, was busy apologizing for his remarks that Africans are less intelligent than other folks. Undercover Black Man reports this isn't even the first time this year the 79-year-old has been compelled to backpedal and apologize for offensive comments. Actually, he's got the sexism, homophobia and ableism going just as good as the racism, as noted in a Washington Post column by Michael Gerson:

In 2003, Watson spoke in favor of genetic selection to eliminate ugly women: "People say it would be terrible if we made all girls pretty. I think it would be great." In 2000, he suggested that people with darker skin have stronger libidos. In 1997, Watson contended that parents should be allowed to abort fetuses they found to be gay: "If you could find the gene which determines sexuality and a woman decides she doesn't want a homosexual child, well, let her." In the same interview, he said, "We already accept that most couples don't want a Down child. You would have to be crazy to say you wanted one, because that child has no future."
So let's just look at Watson for a moment. He's Mr. DNA. He was the head of the Human Genome Project, the mapping of our genes to determine which genes cause which traits, variations and health conditions. He's the guy who was in charge of discovering the most basic information about how human beings differ from one another. And his opinions about those differences? Africans lack intelligence, girls should be designed to be pretty, dark-skinned folk can't keep their pants zipped, and there's no problem or social loss to identifying and eliminating gay people and those with Down Syndrome before they're ever born.

These ideas Watson has about whose genes are good and whose are inherently bad are not random and unconnected. And I suspect it's also no coincidence that everything he's not (African, female, gay, developmentally disabled) falls short of being equal or worthy.

Gerson notes:
Watson is not typical of the scientific community when it comes to his extreme social application of genetics. But this controversy illustrates a temptation within science -- and a tension between some scientific views and liberalism.

The temptation is eugenics. Watson is correct that "we already accept" genetic screening and selective breeding when it comes to disabled children. About 90 percent of fetuses found to have Down syndrome are aborted in America. According to a recent study, about 40 percent of unborn children in Europe with one of 11 congenital defects don't make it to birth.
I don't know exactly how atypical Watson's beliefs are, but they're not as rare as Gerson indicates -- especially with regard to Down Syndrome and abortion. Gerson continues:
No one should underestimate the wrenching challenge of having a disabled child. But we also should not ignore the social consequences of widespread screening of children for "desirable" traits. This kind of "choice" is actually a form of absolute power of one generation over the next -- the power to forever define what is "normal," "straight" and "beautiful." And it leads inevitably to discrimination. British scientist Robert Edwards has argued, "Soon it will be a sin of parents to have a child that carries the heavy burden of genetic disease." A sin. Which leaves disabled children who escape the net of screening -- the result of parental sin -- to be born into a new form of bastardy and prejudice.

This creates an inevitable tension within liberalism. The left in America positions itself as both the defender of egalitarianism and of unrestricted science. In the last presidential election, Sen. John Kerry pledged to "tear down every wall" that inhibited medical research. But what happens when certain scientific views lead to an erosion of the ideal of equality? Yuval Levin of the Ethics and Public Policy Center, a rising academic analyst of these trends, argues: "Watson is anti-egalitarian in the extreme. Science looks at human beings in their animal aspects. As animals, we are not always equal. It is precisely in the ways we are not simply animals that we are equal. So science, left to itself, poses a serious challenge to egalitarianism."

"The left," Levin continues, "finds itself increasingly disarmed against this challenge, as it grows increasingly uncomfortable with the necessarily transcendent basis of human equality. Part of the case for egalitarianism relies on the assertion of something beyond our animal nature crudely understood, and of a standard science alone will not provide. Defending equality requires tools the left used to possess but seems to have less and less of."
Gerson apparently equates science with liberalism, and that correlation would be an interesting side debate, I suppose, though Watson certainly isn't sitting at the same progressive campfire as I am. Given his record, lets not pretend that Watson holds the liberal view of egalitarianism in any special esteem. Why does Gerson focus his criticism on liberalism? Possibly because the prejudices of the right are usually obfuscated by the anti-choice stance that does appear to accept developmental disability (and gayness and race) as part of the glorious diversity of human life, until it comes to funding things like special education or Head Start. Prejudices on the left can be seen as simple hypocrisy, something much easier to point a finger at.

Gerson says the "temptation of eugenics" involves a reductionism of individual human value into the tangible or quantifiable. While his point is an important one, and one I find especially important as a disabled feminist, he's reductionist himself in the way he shrinks the messy real-world issues of reproductive justice and choice for women into wobbly liberalism. And using Watson and his history of both scientific excellence and ideological bigotry to batter science and liberalism together is a cheap partisan strategy that fails to support the very people he criticizes Watson for devaluing.

h/t to Justice for All

Friday, November 02, 2007

Friday music: Crash Test Dummies



Another great song about difference, bodily or otherwise:

Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm
by Crash Test Dummies

Once there was this kid who
Got into an accident and couldn't come to school
But when he finally came back
His hair had turned from black into bright white
He said that it was from when
The car had smashed so hard

Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm
Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm

Once there was this girl who
Wouldn't go and change with the girls in the change room
But when they finally made her
They saw birthmarks all over her body
She couldn't quite explain it
They'd always just been there

Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm
Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm

But both girl and boy were glad
'Cause one kid had it worse than that

'Cause then there was this boy whose
Parents made him come directly home right after school
And when they went to their church
They shook and lurched all over the church floor
He couldn't quite explain it
They'd always just gone there

Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm
Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm

Belated video description: The music video involves a grade school play in an old ornate theater with the Crash Test Dummies acting as the musical orchestra. Each of the stanzas is basically performed by the school children with varying reactions from parents and other adults in the audience. The girl with birthmarks is portrayed by a girl with large polka dots on her skin. The parents of the last child are disapproving and unhappy by the portrayal of their religious beliefs.

Thursday, November 01, 2007

Lately, at the Compound

National Blog Posting Month -- A man's back tattooed with tribal art and I love unpredictability in my friends. People who say or do things it wouldn't immediately occur to me to say or do either intrigue or frighten me. Those who do not frighten me I often want as friends, and I've had some success in getting what I want in that regard.

In the past two years, I've learned that unpredictability is just about the last thing I want in the people who help me daily with personal care, trach health, vent upkeep, etc. I have 24-hour nursing assistance (the "nurse" part being required for state financing of assistance because I use a vent), and other than reliability and competence, predictability is what I crave most in my assistance. When someone is fluttering around me helping with suction or hygiene or other stuff that directly affects my person, the last thing I want is to be watching them and thinking "Now, what the hell are they doing with that?" Predictability requires less mental energy than astonishment or confusion and the less energy I expend with my assistants, the more I have for the rest of my life. And while predictability has been a little elusive at the Gimp Compound lately, it's not my biggest challenge.

It's been my biggest challenge these past two years to adjust to always always having someone present to assist me and keep me breathing. I don't go for strolls around the neighborhood alone, I don't stay home on my own for even ten minutes and I don't wander around the mall by myself. That's new these past two years. I'm a person who has always enjoyed being alone. I like my own company.

The idea behind this constant assistance is that my vent circuit could pop apart (as it does now and then) and no one wants to be responsible for my accidental death from lack of air and suffocation. I can breathe a little bit on my own, and in certain circumstances I can put my circuit back together again, but not so easily that it's a sure thing. So, the trade-off is that I get more supervision than your average toddler.

Having someone always waiting in the wings to assist is not nearly the luxury you might imagine it to be. Intimate discussions are weird with someone close at hand. Lively political debate at dinner always seems peculiar when a silent (and generally professional and discrete) presence sits in the next room. And, in fact, on days when the household has indulged in a big pot of chili it can be downright stifling to family entertainment.

Constant personal assistance is a serious challenge to privacy and personal autonomy, and I've learned a lot about myself and other people while trying to negotiate the space I need. My mp3 player is a key part of my "leave me alone" strategy. So is closing my eyes and pretending to sleep. If you can't escape people -- or even leave the room -- you sometimes must simply shut them out.

I first learned that two years ago while in hospital. If you can't walk away and someone is invading your space: be unapologetically rude. Ignore them. Wave them imperiously away. All young women should be taught this early. I can't believe it took a dire health crisis at age 38 to experience the freedom of blowing someone off when they're in your face and won't go away. Nice Minnesota girls just don't get that memo in their ordinary lives.

Predictability and privacy are linked. To be able to have assistance always around but not intrusive requires that assistance knows what to do without constant negotiation or discussion complicating the day. Home health care provides at least the hope of achieving that in ways inmates of nursing homes can almost never expect. No doubt those who do this care appreciate consistency too, since mistakes happen more easily in unfamiliar situations.

This is where my mental energy has been these past several months when I've been blogging much less. I've switched home health care agencies, said goodbye to four nurses, met and trained three nurses, and some other stuff I'll write about soon. I'm hoping to get back to writing more here this month, and I've joined up for NationalBlogPostingMonth to encourage myself.

Image description: The black-and-white photograph above is the upper back of a man with a tribal art tattoo across the shoulders and the following "tattooed" just below: "NaBloPoMo '07 Blog Free or Die" with a little skull image after the "'07".

Sunday, October 28, 2007

Don't join Yaari

If you got an email from me to join something called Yaari, please ignore it. I got that same email, explored it and gave out a bit too much info before bailing out myself. Yet it seems the site has spammed everyone in my email files (like, a week after the fact) despite me expressly saying not to do so and having changed my passwords. Sorry for the trouble. And thanks to those who emailed me to ask what was up, otherwise I would not have known this was happening.

Tuesday, October 23, 2007

Another typical story of health care in the U.S.

At Feministe, La Lubu tells the story of her daughter's premature birth, relating the loss of her job, fight for health care benefits, and the tedious and often unbelievable details of "welfare" coverage of medical bills. Here's a couple excerpts, but go read the whole thing:

.... I received my first bill from her original hospital. It came after six weeks of treatment—before my daughter was officially listed as being under the insurance plan (see, you have to produce a birth certificate first, and there’s a time lag between when you can obtain the official birth certificate from the state, and the processing of the paperwork with the insurance plan. First, I had to prove that the baby that came out of my body via the fully-paid for emergency c-section, was actually mine. Don’tcha just love bureaucracy? It didn’t include neonatology services, radiology services, pediatric cardiology, respiratory therapists, or even surgery. But it was about $750,000 just the same. Now remember, that was before the hefty insurance discount was applied.

And I laughed. Yes, I laughed. What the hell else could I do? Who the hell did they think was going to be pulling $750,000 out of her ass? Because it sure wasn’t me. At the Ronald McDonald House, I traded war stories with the other parents. Most of the parents there were long-termers—waiting for the call for new organs for their sick children. Everyone had lost their jobs because of their children’s medical crises. At least once. I met folks whose employers couldn’t be bothered to give them a week of time off. I met a family where both parents had hepatitis C (and that ain’t cheap, people); they were waiting for their toddler son to get a lung transplant. People from all over the nation. A nation of isolated medical crises.

and
There are many myths in These United States (why do I keep wanting to type “Untied” States?). The myth of Individuality reigns above all. The idea that one stands, or falls, all on his or her own. It is at the root of the notorious historical amnesia this country suffers from. It informs racist and sexist beliefs. It distorts the ability of various progressive groups to organize around issues central to the fabric of our lives, let alone form coalitions with other progressive groups to aim towards and achieve justice for All. It is the poison in our well. This ridiculuous notion that we can manage without the assistance of others. (and can I just mention that in the middle of the word “ridiculuous” there is a “culu,” or ass? So that while I can’t prove it, the true etymology of “ridiculuous” probably refers to laughing one’s ass off?)

We stand on the shoulders of those who went before us. We stand with the help of those who stand with us, whether we are aware of it, or whether we choose to admit it. In the United States, we are taught that we stand “on our own two feet,” as if we weren’t taught how to stand, how to walk. We are supposed to “pull our own bootstraps” regardless of whether we have shoes, or broken laces. Even those of us who are not taught those lessons in our family of origin are affected by them, as the Cult of Individuality permeates the atmosphere outside the front door: in the schools, in the workplace, and especially in the political arena, where the values of Calvinism are given a fuel injection of Ayn Rand. We are told that those who stumble are careless. That they should have planned better. Should have had more savings. Should have foreseen the deluge. Didn’t they know that it was inevitable? That they aren’t among the saved?

That is what is behind the opposition to S-CHIP. That those currently without a safety net, save that of their own wages and savings, should necessarily suffer. Should declare bankruptcy. It is their destiny. After all, if they were Worthy People, they would be able to come up with the money on their own. They would be able to find a sponsor. Hence, the number of benefit parties, barbecues, chili cook-offs, mostaccioli dinners, and poker runs held at taverns, union halls, churches (temples, masjids), and social clubs throughout the midwest and elsewhere; a desparate attempt to come up with some kind of money, and prove some kind of personal worth in the face of cancer, accidents, heart attacks, strokes, premature birth, job loss and any number of cascading personal crises that don’t tend to arrive alone. Half of all bankruptcies in the United States are due to medical bills.
***

My own posts on the costs of health care include this and this and this.



Monday, October 22, 2007

Mail with Mom

Recently, MissCripChick wrote a blog letter to her Mom and Amanda of Ballastexistenz received an email from hers.

MissCripChick writes, in part:

please do not take this as sarcasm, but i just wanted to take a moment and let you know how much i appreciate the fact that you haven’t tried to murder me, drug me, take me off my ventilator, withhold food, lock me in the garage, abuse me, harvest my organs, or rip my utereus [girl parts] out over the years.
And, lest her thanks be seen as unnecessary, Amanda describes the email her Mom really did send to her:
My mother wrote to me a few weeks ago to make sure I knew that she had never, ever, once, thought of killing me.

It was one of those surreal moments where I sat there and thought, “If I were non-autistic, non-disabled, I doubt she’d have felt the need to reassure me of something that should have been a given. And I think a non-disabled person would have been puzzled to get such a message out of the blue. I wish I was more puzzled as to why.”
The above letters are one response to the belief that the murders and resulting media coverage of disabled children are isolated, tragic events rather than an epidemic of prejudice and devaluation. They illustrate the effect the murders of Katie McCarron and Lexus Fuller and Tracy Latimer and Ulysses Stable and Christopher DeGroot and so many other children have on all families with disabled children.

As Amanda says:
What on earth kind of message makes parents believe they actually have to reassure their own children that really, seriously, they never even once considered killing us, and that really, seriously, we were wanted?

I can only guess it’s some toxic mix of the constant stream of murders and the messages that the press and various autism charities send out about the supposed frequency and normalcy of such thoughts. This isn’t support. Anything that makes my parents, and doubtless others, question such fundamental things about their relationship to their own children, and seriously believe I might think they’d had these thoughts, is not in any way support.

Wednesday, October 10, 2007

The next Ashley X

Her name is Katie Thorpe. Other bloggers have been covering this latest story. Penny has the link collection here. Let her know if you got a link to add to the list.

I've said all I plan to say for the time being in comments at Feministe, mainly in response to the notice that disabled people weren't contributing to that thread. Here's a repeat of my comment over there:

There are a number of us disabled bloggers and blog readers around who weigh in here at Feministe occasionally. Many of us (not me this time) have been writing about this case during this past week. I’m sitting out this round (of debating the specifics of the UK case) for the reasons I specified last January when the Ashley X case came to attention, summed up beautifully by Brownfemipower back then:

Maybe, just maybe, bloggers who are disabled don’t really want to discuss shit like this over and over and over again–especially when people are not just discussing their right to access or something like that (where the presumption of humanity deserving of life is at least present), but are actually challenging disabled peoples very right to live as autonomous respected human beings. Maybe bloggers who are disabled really don’t feel like debating whether or not they are “burdens” worthy of extreme forms of violence just to suit able-bodied people. Maybe they aren’t interested in debating whether or not they have a right to be alive.

The typical response to what BFP says there is “But disabled people don’t know the burden of caring for disabled people.” Or “But the girl in question is much more disabled than these disabled people arguing against the treatment.” When exactly do our voices and experiences become relevant? I always forget when that’s supposed to kick in?

One final thing: It’s good to remember that in the case of Ashley X, the hospital broke the law by not obtaining a court order for the surgery — one step in the process meant to insure her interests are considered separate from her caregivers, specifically with regard to a disabled person’s reproductive rights. Also, though it wasn’t revealed until a full month after the media storm, the hospital ethics committee was torn on this case and in the absence of a consensus, they granted the parents’ wishes. That decision (or lack of one) occurred without any sort of disability rights perspective on the ethics committee.

Monday, October 08, 2007

Remake of the Ramones' song



Direct link to YouTube video here. Visual description: This is a video remake of the classic Ramones song "I Wanna be Sedated" sung and performed by dozens of elderly residents of a nursing home, it appears. In day rooms and hallways, using wheelchairs and walkers, elderly men and women sing or holler the lyrics raucously together directly to the camera. Someone plays a guitar and another man bangs on a piano in the background. One guy with white tufts of hair above each ear and eyeglasses with one lens patched over with tape plays a harmonica. The lyrics:

Twenty-twenty-twenty four hours to go I wanna be sedated
Nothin' to do and no where to go-o-oh I wanna be sedated
Just get me to the airport put me on a plane
Hurry hurry hurry before I go insane
I can't control my fingers I can't control my brain
Oh no no no no no
Twenty-twenty-twenty four hours to go....
Just put me in a wheelchair, get me on a plane
Hurry hurry hurry before I go insane
I can't control my fingers I can't control my brain
Oh no no no no no
Twenty-twenty-twenty four hours to go I wanna be sedated
Nothin' to do and no where to go-o-o I wanna be sedated
Just put me in a wheelchair get me to the show
Hurry hurry hurry before I go loco
I can't control my fingers I can't control my toes
Oh no no no no no
Twenty-twenty-twenty four hours to go...
Just put me in a wheelchair...
Ba-ba-bamp-ba ba-ba-ba-bamp-ba I wanna be sedated
Ba-ba-bamp-ba ba-ba-ba-bamp-ba I wanna be sedated
Ba-ba-bamp-ba ba-ba-ba-bamp-ba I wanna be sedated
Ba-ba-bamp-ba ba-ba-ba-bamp-ba I wanna be sedated
Punk music sung with irony by seniors. This just makes me so indescribably happy!

The Ramones themselves in a much duller video performance here.

h/t to Changing Aging Blog

Update: The performance is by the Young at Heart Chorus. Here are links to YouTube videos of performances and staged music videos of "Staying Alive", "Road to Nowhere" and Coldplay's "Fix You".

Sunday, October 07, 2007

Deaf Karaoke with David Armand



Direct link to YouTube video here. This is a live performance of the song "Torn" by comedian David Armand of The Hollow Men with singer Natalie Imbruglia at the 2006 Secret Policemen's Ball for Amnesty International.

Visual description: Armand is on-stage at a live event acting out the lyrics to the pop song "Torn" (lyrics here). The performance looks like sign language but has been described as "mime style interpretive dance". I don't know sign, so I don't know if any of the performance uses actual sign language, but much of it is puns and it's cleverly easy to follow for a hearing person: Armand holds up four fingers for the word "for", mimes reeling in a fish for the word "real", and mimes a magic act for the word "illusion". Halfway through this performance, Imbruglia appears on-stage singing and eventually joins him in the gestures. There's a wordless slide guitar part toward the end of the song where Armand and Imbruglia mime playing the guitar.

Is this cultural appropriation? A comedy act that has nothing to do with deafness and Deaf culture? Or is it cultural cross-over that might be useful to the Deaf, Deaf theater, and communication with Deaf folks?

Here's a different mime performance by Armand, to Paul Young's 1980s hit "Wherever I Lay My Hat, That's My Home"

h/t to Group News Blog

Friday, October 05, 2007

More Profit, Less Nursing

A recent NYT article on nursing homes illustrates how for-profit institutions can be dangerous for inmates of those homes:

The typical nursing home acquired by a large investment company before 2006 scored worse than national rates in 12 of 14 indicators that regulators use to track ailments of long-term residents. Those ailments include bedsores and easily preventable infections, as well as the need to be restrained. Before they were acquired by private investors, many of those homes scored at or above national averages in similar measurements.

In the past, residents' families often responded to such declines in care by suing, and regulators levied heavy fines against nursing home chains where understaffing led to lapses in care.

But private investment companies have made it very difficult for plaintiffs to succeed in court and for regulators to levy chainwide fines by creating complex corporate structures that obscure who controls their nursing homes.

By contrast, publicly owned nursing home chains are essentially required to disclose who controls their facilities in securities filings and other regulatory documents.

The Byzantine structures established at homes owned by private investment firms also make it harder for regulators to know if one company is responsible for multiple centers. And the structures help managers bypass rules that require them to report when they, in effect, pay themselves from programs like Medicare and Medicaid.
One of the demands of ADAPT at the recent sit-in at the Chicago headquarters of the American Medical Association (AMA) was that doctors divest themselves of financial interest in the nursing homes they recommend to their clients.

While there is a movement by aging Boomers gaining steam to make nursing and assisted living institutions into communities where people can go to live happily instead of going there to wither of neglect and die, a key factor in the injustices visited upon the people who end up in these homes is that continued institutionalization with minimal service and minimal care financially benefits someone else.

Back to the NYT article (italics mine):
Nurses are often residents' primary medical providers. In 2002, the Department of Health and Human Services said most nursing home residents needed at least 1.3 hours of care a day from a registered or licensed practical nurse. The average home was close to meeting that standard last year, according to data.

But homes owned by large investment companies typically provided only one hour of care a day, according to The Times's analysis of records collected by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.

For the most highly trained nurses, staffing was particularly low: Homes owned by large private investment firms provided one clinical registered nurse for every 20 residents, 35 percent below the national average, the analysis showed.

Regulators with state and federal health care agencies have cited those staffing deficiencies alongside some cases where residents died from accidental suffocations, injuries or other medical emergencies.

Federal and state regulators also said in interviews that such cuts help explain why serious quality-of-care deficiencies -- like moldy food and the restraining of residents for long periods or the administration of wrong medications -- rose at every large nursing home chain after it was acquired by a private investment group from 2000 to 2006, even as citations declined at many other homes and chains.

The typical number of serious health deficiencies cited by regulators last year was almost 19 percent higher at homes owned by large investment companies than the national average, according to analysis of Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services records.
Behind those statistics is the isolation and suffering of many inmates, some of whom are disabled people with decades of life left to live. Living, if the care isn't too deadly, that is.

Wednesday, October 03, 2007

The History of My Shoes and the Evolution of Darwin's Theory

Cover of Fries' bookDisability is all about adaptation. That's not news to me. As performance artist Neil Marcus has said, "Disability is an art—an ingenious way to live." It's improv, sometimes all day long, when out in the public environment built primarily for nondisabled folks. I suspect that's not news to most disabled people either.

But Kenny Fries' newest book, The History of My Shoes and the Evolution of Darwin's Theory, combines musings on adaptation and the life and science of Charles Darwin with personal memoir and travel diary in unique and thoughtful ways. One thing Fries notes, particularly in regard to Darwin and his success as a scientist, is that interdependence (and sometimes dependence) is a natural part of human interaction and achievement:

Darwin's journey toward the theory of evolution itself was an act of reciprocity. His social situation, his finances, his family and friends, led to his collecting success, as well as to the publication of his theory. He used his family members in his experiments, and was assisted by neighbors. To arrive at the ideas at the core of On the Origin of Species, Darwin depended on the theories of others, such as Malthus, Lyell, and Wallace. Was Wallace's lack of social standing the reason he is not remembered today for cofounding evolutionary theory?

As man advanced in civilization, Darwin noted, small tribes became united into larger communities. Each individual began extending his social instincts toward all members of the tribe and eventually to members of the same nation, even though these people were personally unknown to him. Darwin concluded that once this point was reached, only artificial barriers prevented an individual's sympathies from extending to the members of all nations and races. (pp 163-4)
In terms of disability, interdependence (and dependence) has been relentlessly framed by society as weakness stemming from tragic imperfection. Yet in many other situations, interdependence is called "backup" or "teamwork." Collaboration. Ingenuity.

Fries explores the difference in perception that has traditionally determined that disability and the adaptions people invent in the face of impairments are uncool despite many disabled people's use and reliance on cool cutting edge technology:
"When you think disability, think zeitgeist," writes disabled journalist and news broadcaster John Hockenberry. Humanity's specifications "are back on the drawing board, and the disabled have a serious advantage in this conversation." We live in a time when the disabled are on the cutting edge of the social trend of the broader use of technology. Wireless technology and electronic gadgets are ubiquitous. The meaning of what it is to be human is wide open.

Who decides riding a motorcycle is cool whereas riding a wheelchair is not? Who decides drinking through a straw is sexy but breathing through a respirator is not? Who decides using a personal computer is natural but using a Braille 'n Speak, a variation of a PC, is not?

What we learn by adaptability may tell us more about the natural ways in which all of us can best flourish in an increasingly interdependent, complex, and confusing world. (p 180)
My favorite parts of The History of My Shoes are Fries' hikes up mountains, through Thailand, and around the Galapagos Islands, where he observes and relates what he sees to his life experiences with his own physical impairments. I think there's often the idea that creatures in nature evolve into or toward perfection and that the struggles they have to survive are due to life's cruel nature, environmental hardship and human interference. And that's all part of it on a grand scale. But the individual creatures Fries observes (or Darwin wrote about) persisted despite "imperfection." And adapted individually when they could. Just like us.

Both Simi Linton and Stephen Kuusisto have blogged about Fries' book, Linton adding her own thoughts on adaptation and Kuusisto (also quoted in a blurb on the book's back cover) looking at the poetry within Fries' prose.

Friday, September 28, 2007

Friday music: Don't Let Me Be Misunderstood by Nina Simone



Link to a YouTube video here. The images in the video present a montage of photos about the American Civil Rights movement, set to Nina Simone's 1964 recording of "Don't Let Me Be Misunderstood."

Lyrics to the song:

Baby, you understand me now
Yet sometimes you see that I'm mad
But don't you know that no one alive
Can always be an angel
When everything goes wrong you see some bad

But I'm just a soul whose intentions are good
Oh Lord, please don't let me be misunderstood

You know sometimes, Baby, I'm so carefree
With a joy that's hard to hide
And then sometimes again it seems that all I have is worry
And then you're bound to see my other side

But I'm just a soul whose intentions are good
Oh Lord, please don't let me be misunderstood

If I seem edgy I want you to know
That I never mean to take it out on you
Life has it's problems and I get more than my share
But that's one thing I never mean to do
Because I love you
Oh, Oh baby, I'm just human
Don't you know I have thoughts like anyone
Sometimes I find myself long regretting
Some little foolish thing some simple thing that I've done

Because I'm just a soul whose intentions are good
Oh Lord, please don't let me be misunderstood

Don't let me be misunderstood
I try so hard to, please
Don't let me be
While the seeds of the lyrics came from a songwriter's spat with a girlfriend, the song and Simone's recording are associated with the Civil Rights Movement. But a more personal view of her performance of the song might be seen with the knowledge that she was apparently bipolar:
Simone had a reputation in the music industry for being volatile and sometimes difficult to deal with, a characterization with which she strenuously took issue. In 1995, she shot and wounded her neighbour’s son with a pneumatic pistol after his laughing disturbed her concentration. She also fired a gun at a record company executive whom she accused of stealing royalties. It is now recognised that this ‘difficulty’ was not just the result of an overly-perfectionist rigor, but her raging outbursts and diva-like extremes were actually the result of a psycho-medical condition, most probably a bipolar disorder or borderline personality disorder. Simone reluctantly took medication for her condition from the mid sixties on. All this was only known to a small group of intimates, and kept out of public view for many years, until the biography Break Down And Let It All Out written by Sylvia Hampton and David Nathan revealed this secret in 2004.

Wednesday, September 26, 2007

Designer Babies and the Pro-Choice Movement

I'm suffering from Acute Blogging Malaise. So, I'll just post the link to this article and hope to say something relevant in comments if discussion on it erupts.

"Designer Babies and the Pro-Choice Movement" by Rebecca Tuhus-Dubrow in the current Dissent. A few excerpts:

In vitro fertilization (IVF) does not merely help the infertile to procreate; increasingly, it allows parents to determine the genetic makeup of their offspring. Initially, preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) targeted severe childhood diseases, such as Tay-Sachs and sickle cell anemia. Now, more parents use it to screen out genes for late-onset, treatable diseases, such as colon cancer; sex selection is also popular. According to a 2006 survey conducted by the Genetics and Public Policy Center at Johns Hopkins University, 42 percent of 137 IVF-PGD clinics allowed parents to select for gender. Scientists predict that parents will be able to choose such characteristics as blue eyes or curly hair. Less certain, but plausible, is that scientists will be able to identify genes for more complex traits, such as intelligence and homosexuality. Genetic engineering, which will enable not merely the selection but the insertion of desired genes, is on the horizon. In the United States, this rapidly advancing technology is unchecked by any regulatory mechanism.
and
Even without the borrowed buzzwords, the pro-choice movement would be uneasily close to the issue. Historically, pro-choice arguments have focused on the right to privacy and freedom from government interference. Legally, those are the terms that define reproductive rights. The landmark Supreme Court cases Connecticut v. Griswold (1965) and Roe v. Wade (1973) recognized the right of individuals to control their reproductive destinies. Legal scholars predict that when the question of selecting the traits of offspring inevitably arrives in court, it will be considered in this framework.

Like it or not, pro-choice groups, then, will be compelled to take a stand. They will have to distinguish their concept of reproductive rights from that advanced by neo-eugenicists and to decide whether and how to endorse regulation of reproductive technologies without jeopardizing already tenuous rights. But along with these challenges come opportunities. By incorporating concerns about the abuse of reproductive technologies into a pro-choice platform, the movement can shift away from an individual-liberties paradigm toward a social justice orientation; move away from a single-issue focus on abortion toward a more comprehensive agenda; and form coalitions with other segments of the left.
and, although race, class and GLBT issues related to choice are prominently covered, the only explicit mention of disability and disability rights activists is bolded below:
This issue creates strange bedmates. The common political assumption is that conservatives would oppose the potentially radical change promised by reprogenetic technologies, while liberals would embrace the scientific progress they represent. And indeed, the religious right, concerned about the embryo and the blasphemy of playing God, condemns them, while some liberals are more inclined to welcome them on the grounds of “progress”—and, perhaps, in opposition to “culture of life” priorities. At the same time, economic libertarians oppose regulation of this three-billion-dollar-a-year industry, and a fringe of neo-eugenicists wants to create a super race. Qualms on the left include the potential exacerbation of inequalities, the eugenic overtones, and the environmental implications of meddling with nature.

Other progressive contingents have their worries. Disability activists are wary of technologies that essentially aim to eliminate their community. Gay and lesbian people have an especially complex relationship to assisted reproductive technology. I spoke to staff at the GLBT (Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Trans-gendered) Community Center in New York, who said that to the extent that it helps them have genetically related families, they welcome the technology. But if a “gay gene” is ever identified, their communities, too, could be threatened. Many feminists are troubled by sex selection, but fear that regulating any aspect of reproduction could jeopardize abortion rights.
Go over and read the whole article here.

Thursday, September 13, 2007

One more photo

These group action pics give me happy chills.

Dozens of ADAPT protestors rolling single-file toward the headquarters of the AMA.

Image description: From observer rachelleb, this color photo is taken from several stories above the street of dozens of ADAPT protestors , mostly in wheelchairs, in the far right lane of Chicago's State Street rolling single-file toward the headquarters of the AMA this past Monday.

I think it's safe to say. . .

Dozens of people in wheelchairs filling a city sidewalk and the entrances to a union office building.that folks in wheelchairs have the edge in creating successful sit-in protests. Not that it's all about sitting around, but we do bring extra immovable objects with us everywhere we go. Immovable if we choose to make them immovable, that is.

This post is to notify feed readers of updates to the post just below on the ADAPT actions this week in Chicago. Specifically, the local Chicago TV news coverage links at the bottom of that post should be easier to access now.

Here's another video, this one from Chicago's Fox TV on Tuesday's protest and blockade of the Thompson Center.

The image above is another photo from Tim Wheat, showing dozens of people in wheelchairs filling a city sidewalk and the entrances to the offices of the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME), a union that persists in putting their members' incomes above the freedom of the disabled people housed in the institutions they serve. You can read Tim Wheat's diary of Wednesday's events at the ADAPT site.

Also check out the blog coverage of Galen Smith, an activist at his first ADAPT actions. He writes of Wednesday's action against the union:

We got periodic updates from our negotiators and learned that it was not going well. First AFSCME tried to counter the letter we gave them with a letter of their own. They expected us to sign a letter saying that nursing homes should stay open!! Then they said they would call their national office. Eventually they left the table and said they weren't coming back. When negotiations broke down the police moved in to start arrests.

AFSCME had 120 ADAPTers arrested today - for picketing. The irony was not lost on us as we chanted...

The People United Will Never Be Defeated!

...a chant that has long been used by striking unions.

The arrest process extremely relaxed. An officer approached me where I was standing blocking the alley and warned me that if I didn't move I would be arrested. I didn't move. Then he told me to follow the line of people heading for arrest. There was no police escort as we walked about a block and a half to line up on a sidewalk and wait for our citations. ADAPTers chatted with the officers as they wrote up our citations who laughed and joked with us. When the officer handed me my ticket he smiled and said, "You've been very bad. Here's your ticket" as he patted me on the shoulder and sent me on my way with a chuckle.

Wednesday, September 12, 2007

Updated: ADAPT action in Chicago

"Individually, no one's more invisible
than a person in a wheelchair.
Collectively they're pretty spectacular."

Source

How totally exciting and energizing is this?

Two disabled women at the protest outside the headquarters of the AMA.

Protestors, mostly using wheelchairs, block a revolving door.

A woman writes

A man surrounded by other wheelchair-using protestors chants.

Image descriptions: The four photos taken by Tim Wheat are part of ADAPT's coverage of the week's events here. The first is of Marca Bristo, CEO of Chicago's Access Living (the ILC) and former chairperson of the National Council on Disability, in a power wheelchair holding a Chicago Sun-Times newspaper layout of coverage from a 1992 protest where the large headline reads "Disabled take home-care protest to AMA's doorstep." She sits next to Laura Hershey, Denver writer of Crip Commentary, also in a power wheelchair outside the American Medical Association's headquarters in this 2007 protest.

The second photo is inside a building, taken from above, showing a half dozen activists blockading the entrance. Some people are sitting in power wheelchairs and scooters, many wear ADAPT t-shirts.

The third photo is outside the AMA headquarters. A woman is writing "Community Choice" on a large glass window with a red paint marker and activists are visible lining the outside of the building along the glass in the background. The Community Choice Act, Senate Bill S. 799 and House Bill H.R. 1621, seeks to break the institutional bias by using existing funding that now pays for nursing home coverage to provide the choice of community-based services instead.

The fourth photo shows a man, surrounded by other wheelchair users, chanting or hollering. In comments below, it's suggested he's also signing as he chants. Perhaps the sign for "Now."

From ABC Chicago channel 7: "Disability activists wrap up week of Chicago protests" (video at link too):

- Hundreds of activists for the disabled protested again Wednesday in downtown Chicago, demanding better housing conditions. They are angry with Illinois government officials for spending too much money sending the disabled to nursing homes.

Wednesday was the last day of what Adapt calls its fall action. The disability rights group has targeted medical and governmental agencies since Monday in its push for access to more community-based services.

Hundreds of members led a vocal call for change to the system that they say gives them only one option - care in an institution.

Members of Adapt parked their wheelchairs in front of the Chicago headquarters of the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees Union, at 29 N. Wacker.

They blocked the entrances and crowded into the lobby in a demonstration over housing options for people with disabilities.

"Everyone deserves a choice and right now, choices don't exist," said Gary Arnold of Adapt. "It's institutions or nursing homes or nothing for thousands of people."

Adapt is fighting for the Community Choice Act, a bill introduced to Congress earlier this year. It would allow patients with disabilities to access care in and around their homes, rather than rely on care from a nursing home.

Chicago's WGN covered the week's activities in video. The three individual clips cover the protest at the headquarters of the AMA and the shutdown of the Thompson Center. Here, here and here. Those links should work (for me, each opens three windows: the main WGN page, a WGN video troubleshooting page and the actual news video in Windows Media Player, preceded by a 20-second ad). Let me know if that doesn't work for you, please.

Update: I've added some info about the people in the above photos to the in-text image descriptions since commenters have helpfully identified the activists. Also, the links to WGN videos just above should now be a little easier to access, thanks to Stephen Drake of NDY (Check the Not Dead Yet blog for day-by-day coverage of the events and additional photos. Steve has been my source for all the links in this post, along with ADAPT itself.)

Sunday, September 09, 2007

Wagadu journal on disability

The summer volume of the Journal of Transnational Women's & Gender Studies is a special issue on “Intersecting Gender and Disability Perspectives in Rethinking Postcolonial Identities.”

And it's all available online here.

Friday, September 07, 2007

Ad Council "Crutches" PSA

The Ad Council has a campaign called "Don't Almost Give" and a series of public service announcements that includes one called "Crutches." Here it is with the other five ads at their website -- it's the second one. And here it is at YouTube:



Description: The 30-second ad shows a outdoor cement staircase and a man on wooden crutches slowly climbing the stairs one step at a time. He climbs about 6 steps during the brief ad. The male voiceover: "This is a man who almost learned to walk ... At a rehab center that
almost got built ... By people who almost gave money ... Almost gave ... How good is almost giving? About as good as almost walking."

I heard about this ad on a disability listserv, but eeka at One Smoot Short of a Bridge has already written on the condescending attitude. She sums it up very well:

Sure, the guy deserved to have better care, and presumably could have recovered more fully. But the inaccurate and pitying language needs to go. What's he doing right there in the film clip? He's walking. He's getting places. He's living his life. Even if the reason for his disability was something preventable that we should be fighting to change, the way to accomplish this isn't by describing the way he gets around as "almost walking." I suppose it might be different if he were a real individual who personally describes his disability in this way, but since he's an archetype, it comes across as describing people with disabilities as "almost" doing things. This kind of view can be dangerous, because when we're all sitting around a table, if we're stuck on the idea that one of the people "almost" walked to the meeting, we're going to unconciously feel that he has less to offer than people who fully got to the meeting, even though we're all there in the end.

Friday music: Evelyn Glennie

Evelyn Glennie is a talented percussionist who is also profoundly deaf. As she explains, media attention that focuses on the state of her hearing misses the point:

Deafness is poorly understood in general. For instance, there is a common misconception that deaf people live in a world of silence. To understand the nature of deafness, first one has to understand the nature of hearing.

Hearing is basically a specialized form of touch. Sound is simply vibrating air which the ear picks up and converts to electrical signals, which are then interpreted by the brain. The sense of hearing is not the only sense that can do this, touch can do this too. If you are standing by the road and a large truck goes by, do you hear or feel the vibration? The answer is both. With very low frequency vibration the ear starts becoming inefficient and the rest of the body's sense of touch starts to take over. For some reason we tend to make a distinction between hearing a sound and feeling a vibration, in reality they are the same thing. It is interesting to note that in the Italian language this distinction does not exist. The verb 'sentire' means to hear and the same verb in the reflexive form 'sentirsi' means to feel. Deafness does not mean that you can't hear, only that there is something wrong with the ears. Even someone who is totally deaf can still hear/feel sounds.
Here is a YouTube video of Glennie's collaboration with Icelandic singer Björk for the song "Oxygen." The visuals are simply a collage of photos of Björk, but that's Glennie playing behind Björk's vocals. The song is part of Glennie's 1998 greatest hits compilation.



Here's a 34-minute video of a presentation she gave on "How to listen to music with your whole body." There doesn't seem to be a transcript of her words (how sadly ironic is that?), but she talks about and demonstrates the difference between technically performing a piece of music and playing it as an artist who listens to and creates nuance.



And here's an excerpt from the documentary Touch The Sound:



Bionic Ear blog mentioned Glennie recently here.

Alison at Noesis writes about the lack of transcript for that TED speech here.

Wednesday, September 05, 2007

"Stay in your house!" part 2

Woman in wheelchair holds sign demanding access to local business.Image description: A young white woman with curly hair sits in a power wheelchair on a city sidewalk. She smiles over the orange placard she holds that reads "Gimps are Hot, Crips are Sexy, We Want Access Too!" The sign is vertical and reaches from her shoulders to her mid-calves as she sits. Further description from the Flickr photo source sissyboystud: "Sarah holding a sign at our ADAPT Youth Summit Action. This sign is targeted at a nail salon with an inaccessible entrance. We have a right to be beautiful and pampered too!!"

Man in wheelchair at a large event smiles broadly as he's towed backwards through thick mud.







Image description: Glastonbury in 2007. A man in a manual wheelchair smiles towards the camera as two men drag him backwards through thick viscous mud at a large gathering where the ground is mud everywhere. The man's feet are covered in mud, as are his gloved hands and the wheels of his chair. I think there's a concert stage and big screen in the far background. Flickr photo credit to Tonymc.

Senior citizens marry. The man sits in a wheelchair.







Image description: Three senior citizens are sitting in fancy dress in a banquet room with a table with flower arrangements behind them. The woman at left is in a lacy taupe dress and matching jacket with a white hat with a gauzy veil attached. She is reaching out and holding the hand of the man at left, seated in a wheelchair. He's wearing a traditional tuxedo with a boutonniere on the lapel. Between them is a woman sitting with hands folded in her lap across some papers. She's smiling at the couple. It looks like a wedding. Flickr photo credit to dosbears.

Tuesday, September 04, 2007

Another insult and apology

From the Washington Post. Jerry again, during yesterday's telethon:

The 81-year-old showman -- prowling about the stage during the live telecast Monday in Las Vegas -- was goofing around and dodging his cameraman, then went into a ramble about imaginary family members.

"Oh, your family has come to see you," he said, speaking to the camera and gesturing toward thin air.

"You remember Bart, your older son," he said, and motioning toward another unseen character, "Jesse, the illiterate f-----.

"No," Lewis said, quickly stopping himself before continuing.

Jesse is, apparently, the gay relative. I'm guessing he rarely comes to Lewis' imaginary family functions when the bigot himself is there. After all, Bart gets to be "the older son" and he is, well, illiterate. . . .

Here's CNN with the video clip. I can't imagine what he'd have said when he got to the sad, crippled little imaginary grandchild with MD.

Wait. Yes, I can.

But it all seemed to work out well for everyone in the end.

Gay & Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation (GLAAD) President Neil G. Giuliano criticized Lewis this morning:
“Jerry Lewis’ on-air use of this kind of anti-gay slur is simply unacceptable,” said Giuliano. "It also feeds a climate of hatred and intolerance that contributes to putting our community in harm's way. Our nation’s media have done an admirable job this year holding public figures accountable for their use of anti-gay slurs, and I hope they continue to do so with Mr. Lewis."

Giuliano said that GLAAD is contacting Lewis’ representatives today to request a meeting with him. "We want to sit down with him, help him understand why these words are so hurtful, and give him an opportunity to raise public awareness about the destructive impact of these kinds of anti-gay slurs, even more so in attempted humor.”
And by this afternoon, all was forgiven after Lewis issued an apology for a "bad choice of words."

GLAAD responded:
“GLAAD thanks Jerry Lewis for his swift and direct apology for this incident,” stated Giuliano. “We join millions of Americans in applauding the important work of the Muscular Dystrophy Association and wish MDA and Mr. Lewis much continued success in their efforts.”
Whew! I'm happy that's over!

He didn't mean it. He's a nice guy. He would never purposely say anything rude about cripp-- I mean, gay people. Everyone carry on! Nothing to see here but a little annual nationally-televised pity party for some dying kids.

Monday, September 03, 2007

"Stay in your house!"

Or, you know, get out there and do your thing. . . .

Photo of wheelchair user and friend viewing Alaskan fjord from a ship's deck.Image description: A beautiful color photo of a blue-skied day off the coast of Alaska. Picture is taken from the upper deck of a cruise ship in a fjord, the white-capped mountains in the background and the water a vivid shade of aqua. The length of the ship can be seen in the middle-ground, and in the foreground by the railing of this upper deck are a couple in the shade of a bulky apparatus on the deck. One sits in a manual wheelchair, and they both look at the incredible view we see. Flickr photo credit to Todd Sheridan, tud5000.

Man on rainbow scooter in Toronto Pride 2007Image description: A colorful photo from the 2007 Toronto Pride parade of a middle-aged white guy wearing just sneakers, shorts, a baseball cap and carnival beads as he rides a red four-wheeled electric scooter that is decked out in rainbow fabric and rainbow flowers. There's a large beach umbrella above him covered in the rainbow fabric, as is the front and back baskets of his scooter. Everything is trimmed with flowers in colors of the rainbow. The crowd watching the parade lines the street in the background. Flickr photo credit to hypersapiens.

Two women in power wheelchairs fish at the edge of a lake.Image description: Two women sit in power wheelchairs at the edge of a lake holding fishing rods. The sun is shining, the water is a vivid blue and there are trees lining the water's edge in the distance. Flickr photo credit to Karva Javi.

Request for technical help: I may have asked this before some time ago, but while I look back for that discussion, can anyone tell me how to use alt tags for photos in Firefox? I've tagged the first two of these three pics, but it only shows up using the Explorer browser. It doesn't show at all in Firefox. Any expertise appreciated.

Yes, the road to hell is paved, but that doesn't mean it's accessible

Banner for Blog Against the Telethon event






Good intentions are tricky. With philanthropy, you can get so invested in your own self-righteous helpfulness that you fail to see you aren't respecting the objects of your charity and their needs. On a personal level that could be called narcissism. On a broader level, it is the annual MDA* Telethon in the United States, hosted by comedian Jerry Lewis.

The telethon has historically relied on pity to sell the need for a cure and Lewis is the unabashed champion of portraying disabled people as pathetic victims and unemployable "half-persons" for the cause. He's also completely unapologetic about demeaning disabled people to raise cash. Never mind that pity never helped any disadvantaged group of people gain their own place in the world. Never mind that he's raised billions for that still-elusive cure while disabled folks languish in institutions and remain largely unemployed because of societal barriers maintained by attitudes like his.

Actor Michael J. Fox, who lives with Parkinson's disease and raises funds for research on it, once said "I feared pity because pity is a step away from abuse." Fox has also stated that his life goes on without a cure, and he's been his own spokesperson, forthrightly showing his impairments while engaging the public thoughtfully and open-mindedly on the related politics of stem-cell research. He's been anything but a pitiable victim, even though he is fighting the clock.

Photo of person in wheelchair with Fox knows pity is harmful, and he's not wrong about it's relationship to abuse. For one thing, a life that is considered hopeless without a cure is held rather cheap. But more to the point on good intentions, when told repeatedly over the years by many former MDA poster children that the telethon experience is demeaning and damaging, Lewis shifts directly from pity to verbal abuse. Over and over again.

Don't believe it? Here's one vague apology the MDA issued to try to shield itself from the damage it's spokesperson causes**, even as they keep him on the job. The offensive remark the apology doesn't really mention is when Lewis said: "Pity? You don't want to be pitied because you're a cripple in a wheelchair? Stay in your house!"

Jerry Lewis has good intentions, you say. The money is for a good cause so it doesn't matter what message brings in the dough. Not every disabled person agrees -- we're a very diverse lot -- but I say the price of pity is far too high. Jerry Lewis has good intentions? I know where he can go with them.

Image descriptions:

The banner at the top of this post is for this Blog Against the Telethon event. It reads, "Until There's a Cure... There's a Telethon: Blog Against the Telethon -- Abolish Charity and Cure Mentality". The text is bold over a black-and-white photographic background of a little blonde girl's face close-up at right and Lewis in a tuxedo pointing a finger toward her downstage at left.

The second image is a color photograph of a person in a manual wheelchair wearing a black t-shirt with bold pink lettering that reads "Piss on Pity" while holding a sign that reads "Dump Jerry". It's taken in 2003 by Tim Wheat of MCIL.

-------------------------------------------------------------

* Muscular Dystrophy Association

** Other damage? In 2000, Jerry Lewis said this at a comedy festival: "A woman doing comedy doesn't offend me, but sets me back a bit. I, as a viewer, have trouble with it. I think of her as a producing machine that brings babies in the world." The Chicago Sun-Times report says that he apologized later to avoid a backlash in fewer telethon donations. Here's the humorous response from several female comedians.

Sunday, September 02, 2007

Anti-telethon blogging

Sigh. It's that time of year again. Miss Crip Chick and Kara Sheridan are leading the online protest against this tiresome Weekend of Celebrating Pity through the Jerry Lewis MDA telethon by asking bloggers to write about charity, pity, the medical model of disability, the tyranny of the belief that we all need a cure, and the asshattery of Jerry Lewis. That's for tomorrow, Monday, the United States' Labor Day.

Banner for Sept. 3 Blog Against Telethon




Image description: A yellow banner with black type reads "SEPTEMBER 3RD, 2007, join the campaign against the MDA telethon, write against ableism, charity & medical model of disability, see: http://crip.power.com for more information"

I'd encourage everyone to discuss this. Even if you're unsure of what it's all about or how you feel about it, it's past time everyone was aware that telethons are problematic and contribute to the oppression of disabled people.

Update: Norwegianity readers, welcome! My post for the blogswarm is here. The main page for the blogswarm entries is at Kara's place.

Back

So, it was actually a lousy vacation. I've spent the bulk of my time with ugly digestive complaints or working through the various management issues of having a home health care agency up in my life 24/7. Or both. But anyway, there was good amidst the bureaucratic busy-ness and grumpy misery. Two highlights of my August were a family gathering in the far reaches of western Minnesota and meeting Brownfemipower while she was in St. Paul for the MALCS conference*.

The Gimp Compound inhabitants met with a dozen other Olsons, including the French branch of my cousinry, in the little city of Montevideo. We shared the courtyard of a great little coffeeshop with a local family where a father and a newborn son spent a few precious hours together while the former was briefly home on leave from Iraq. Poignant, that.

Brownfemipower and I met in the union of the University of Minnesota while my parents wandered around sucking up massive doses of alumi nostalgia. Like everyone I've met in person after getting to know online, BFP is just exactly herself, but more. One of the things we talked about was what candidates would be good for a Radical Hot Off of disabled celebrities. It shouldn't be, of course, but the question is deeply problematic: Mainstream celebrities people would be familiar enough to vote on don't celebrate their disability if they have one, disability is stereotypically seen as the antithesis of sexy, and iconic or noteworthy disabled characters in pop culture are usually performed in film by nondisabled celebrities. Our short list consisted entirely of Peter Dinklage. And while that makes the list perfection, I look forward to adding to it.

Anyway, I'm back.

* Mujeres Activas en Letras y Cambio Social (MALCS, Women Active in Letters and Social Change) is an organization of Chicanas/ Latinas and Native American women working in academia and in community settings with a common goal: to work toward the support, education and dissemination of Chicana/Latina and Native American women's issues.