Monday, July 09, 2007

What would that look like?

In the recent discussion of Aimee Mullins in Sports Illustrated, Sara, Trin and I have been debating Mullins' portrayal in that mag, and the portrayal of amputees and disabled people, generally, by the media. In the sidebar at right I've got a category for analysis of media coverage of disability, Wheelchair Dancer frequently looks at NYT coverage (examples of that here, here, and here), and there's a thoughtful discussion at Medical Humanities Blog, also about a woman amputee excelling in her career.

So, what would positive media coverage of Aimee Mullins, specifically, look like? How would someone laud her successes without putting her on the supercrip pedestal or fetishizing her amputated limbs either textually or with photos? Here are a couple alternatives to the SI story's sexualized supercrip slant:

And here is Petra Kuppers on "Addenda? Contemporary Cyborgs and the Mediation of Embodiment" where she specifically analyzes a fashion photo of Mullins wearing those old-fashioned wooden prosthetics she briefly mentions in the SI article. It's a complex look at disability, feminism, Mullins' agency or complicity with the image, "false consciousness" and media portrayal both of disability and femininity. I'm too short on time and energy just now to write about it, but it's right on topic here.

Visual description: There are three photos here. The first is one of Lynn Johnson's collection on Mullins and is in black and white. Mullins stands in her athletic uniform and high tech racing prosthetics on a race track facing a woman holding a microphone and two men with tv cameras on their shoulders. This is a media interview at the 1996 Paralympics in Atlanta.

The second photo is the fashion art pic Kuppers analyzes and this is her thorough description: "The large colour photo presents Mullins sittting on the floor, her head in her hand in a defeated or melancholic position. She appears squeezed into the frame, contained by the photo’s borders. The colours of the image are brown and beige, earthy, taking up the blond of Mullins’ wild hair and echoed in the make-up. Mullins is wearing various stiff items of clothing, all of which extend out of the photo frame. The clothes are referenced in the accompanying text, in accordance with the generic conventions of fashion photography. The comprise of: a calico-coloured skirt skeleton reminiscent of whalebone crinoline underskirts (crinolin [sic] frame, for hire from Angels and Bermans) and a textured close-fitting top (suede T-Shirt by Alexander McQueen) to which shoulder ornaments are attached that look like wooden filigree Japanese or Spanish fans (wooden fan jacket, by Givenchy Haute Couture). She is also wearing artificial ‘mannequin’ lower legs (not referenced as ‘model’s own’ in the picture blurb, but extensively discussed in the Press). The legs look old and stained, and while one foot with coloured toenails is visible in the frame, the other reaches out to frame-left."

The final photo is Mullins running full-out on a beach with the ocean and blue sky behind her. She's heading down the beach away from the camera and appears to be wearing the exact black bra top and string bikini bottom she wears in the posed studio photo topping the SI article -- that much-discussed other photo.

16 comments:

frog said...

As you know, I'm a big fan of Petra's work.

Anonymous said...

Thank you, Kay!

Anonymous said...

Great post, thanks for the links. I'm also a big fan of Petra's work, as it was a seminar I took with her that really got me going on disability studies.

Trinity said...

Please please please tell me Ms. Cyborg is one of us. I HATE the cyborg thing when it comes from fascinated academics.

Kay Olson said...

Yep, Petra calls herself a "disabled movement artist" and she also writes extensively about performance and disability. Some of that "performance" is about social interactions, not solely artistic activity like dance and theater. She's got a couple books out on the topic.

Her artist's statement might help you see her thought process and perspective, Trin. It's here for one project of hers. And here's her CV.

Have you read Donna Haraway's Cyborg Manifesto? (It's available in full text in several places online.) If not, this much I know: it's a feminist piece of writing that claims women are cyborgs under a definition of cyborgs as cultural outsiders. I don't know how much Kuppers relies on that in her overall writing, but Haraway's manifesto was helpful to me as a way of understanding what the heck "cyborg theory" is about. And I felt it spoke about disabled people's lives at least as well as it does about women, generally.

Anyway, I think Kuppers is both "one of us" and a "fascinated academic."

By the way, I first heard academic types discussing cyborg stuff at a disability studies conference and was taken aback by it too. I haven't read much about it, just the minimal bit I mention above. I think it does matter who is the fascinated one comparing us to machines. Transhumanists get on my nerves in this regard, though I admit they say some interesting things.

Trinity said...

I read Haraway's piece. I want to like it because I know a lot of people who do, but "cyborg" is rather fraught for me so... writing that abstract I have a hard time with.

If it were something less academic about reclaiming the term ("We are not broken bodies, we are your Cyborg Apocalypse!"), I'd like it better, I think.

"I think it does matter who is the fascinated one comparing us to machines."

Yep.

Anyone else ever gotten "you're a Borg" from drooling idiot boys?

Elizabeth McClung said...

My reaction has been slow in coming as I have thought about this a few days. I find it frustrating that the photo's by Lynn Johnson use an exerpt from SI that talk about her ready to "fully become a woman" which seems somehow linked to her getting her specially made "barbie" legs. I had assumed that 17 year old females in Afganistan with Red Cross hand me downs were also "fully" a woman - odd that.

I guess the other problem I have is that the coverage of her feels to me like every year when I see the cover picture of Pride Parade and it is a outragous drag queen or someone in a leather thong and I think "Who is this person; I was there, I didn't see them?" - the coverage is unrepresentation. I see many other athlete's competing against her and I have to wonder, is it because she goes to Georgetown, because she models, becuase she has a symetrical and idolized beauty bodyshape, because she has "Barbie" legs that she has an article in SI and another does not.

She is a great role model and has done a lot with her life except that of the dozen or so disabled people I know who are athletic, few are physically able, no matter how dedicated, to be competitive in any way, though I would say some are as dedicated to thier sport/s. Nor, since many have have several operations are they people you might want to put in a national magazine in a thong. While they often have to break althetic barriers in order to participate in the communities where they live, this is not considered activism but rather able bodied people "allowing" integration. These are the people I know - many of whom I would very much like to see an in depth article about.

(as for the Sport Foundation article - the same approach is used as when interviewing transsexual athletes like Mianne Bagger - what does her ability to wear high heels and a slinky gown have to do with her as an athlete? Why then is it the lead paragraph?)

Kay Olson said...

Frog: I know! I was hoping you'd see this.

Trin: I love that. Cyborg apocalypse!

I haven't gotten "Borg." Just "freak."

Elizabeth: To my mind, the unrepresentativeness of Mullins is linked to the pornification topic. I don't have a categorical problem with sexy photos -- I have a problem with a complete lack of balance.

Trinity said...

"Trin: I love that. Cyborg apocalypse!"

*grin* *cackle*

Anne Corwin said...

I'm someone who considers myself to be a transhumanist -- I think that life is good, that death sucks, and that "natural" is pretty much meaningless as a criterion as to whether something is desirable or not.

In my own writing I try to emphasize the intersection between "transhumanism" and disability rights through asserting that people ought to have the right to configure their own bodies (and maintain certain configurations that suit them) without being coerced or discriminated against.

My use of the term "cyborg" extends all the way down to things like eyeglasses and clothing; it's a word that, in my mind, implies merely that a person has done something to make it possible (or easier) to operate in a certain kind of environment.

But yeah, I know what people mean when they refer to the "academic fascination" thing; I've gotten a bit of this for being autistic -- there's only so many times a person can take hearing, "Wow! Some people like you can go on to become great scientists!" But the best way to deal with stuff like that, I've found, is to not go away -- to keep interacting with people who talk about you like you're a curiosity until they can't do it anymore. :P Pointing out when stereotypes and biased language are used tends to help too.

Kay Olson said...

Hi Anne: I've read several disability-related posts on your blog over the past year or so and enjoyed them, and I actually have a file on transhumanism that I've been intending to use to explore further what it's all about and how it relates to disability rights and disability culture.

Partly it's the language of transhumanism that I can't relate to. "Configurations," "augmentation," post-human" and all that. I get "cyborg" to some extent, partly because of the explicit feminist way that Haraway broadens the meaning of the term.

Also, I don't relate well to what seems to be an obsession in transhumanism with extending life. That seems diversionary or incompatible to me with fighting for basic quality health care that so many people -- especially poor disabled folk -- lack. I mean, if extending lives so people live 30, 40, 50 years beyond what is current life expectancy is a priority, well, for who? And who gets lost in that fight for resources? Not that it has to be a zero-sum game, but it often seems to work that way. More generally, the focus seems off to me.

Those are a few of my admittedly limited and ignorant reactions to the bit I have read on transhumanism, but I do hope we can continue the conversation as I learn more.

Anne Corwin said...

Kay: Thanks for your response...I've been very tentatively attempting to engage in a bit of "gap-bridging" between the disability and transhumanist communities for a while now.

With regard to the life extension thing: I'm actually confused as to why the broader disability community isn't more gung-ho about life extension! I am coming at both transhumanism and disability rights from a similar angle: that in which all lives are valuable, and nobody is expendable. Age, like disability, is often used as a basis for discrimination, and I don't see "life extension" as anything more strange than the application of lifesaving medicine to older folks.

I don't think that someone's life automatically becomes "not worth saving" once they turn 80 or 90, any more than someone's life becomes "not worth saving" if they lose their ability to walk to talk. And considering that many disabled people alive today would not have survived in previous generations (due to lack of sufficient medical technology), it no longer makes any sense to say that "nature" should be allowed to just take its course. Once we crossed the threshold of keeping people alive and well through the use of ventilators and heart medication and other such things, we removed "nature" as an arbiter of who lives and who dies. So there doesn't actually, in my mind, seem to be any valid ethical argument as to why some people should HAVE to die if the means could be developed to prevent this.

As far as resources go, I think that people always tend to find the resources to obtain and support the things they value -- I mean, people choose to spend their money to pay for sports tickets, designer clothes, Hello Kitty accessories, sitcom DVDs, and numerous other things that do not in any way relate to helping the poor. I agree that people need to wake up and get their priorities in order, but I think that all categories of saving people and improving their lives fall under the same umbrella of "stuff that is really important". I don't see why different advocacy groups can't band together to pursue a cause in a focused manner while other groups pursue other causes; certainly, we need more attention to helping supply clean water to third-world countries, but I don't think that life extension advocates are any hindrance to this. The hindrance comes from widespread complacency and people who don't care a lick whether anyone else lives or dies, not from people who are actually working in some way to save lives and advocate on behalf of vulnerable populations.

And speaking of populations, some people often cite "overpopulation" as an argument against the idea of extending lives, but personally I think that it's more ethical to encourage people to have fewer kids than it is to tell old people that they are obligated to visit Carousel at a certain point when they are perceived to have "outstayed their welcome". Saying that people ought to "get out of the way" because they're old seems to me no better than saying the same using disability as the justification.

Just my 2 cents...

Anne Corwin said...

Oh, and I am also extremely concerned about making sure that proper health care is available to *all* that need it. The fact of resource-distribution inequality (especially in terms of health care and environmental variables, like food and clean water) literally keeps me awake at night sometimes. To me, life extension simply means, "health care for older people that actually works" (because health care that actually works generally refers to health care that can actually save your life), and I think that effective health care should be a basic right for everyone regardless of age.

Also, would you mind if I brought this comment exchange and some of your concerns into a post on my own blog? One of my biggest concerns about transhumanism is the (sometimes neglected) need to include diverse perspectives, including the perspectives of the broader disability community and people therein. I don't think it's right to talk about "emerging technologies" and make judgments about them without rigorously consulting the people most likely to be affected by those technologies.

Kay Olson said...

I'm actually confused as to why the broader disability community isn't more gung-ho about life extension! I am coming at both transhumanism and disability rights from a similar angle: that in which all lives are valuable, and nobody is expendable.

I can't speak for the broader community, just myself, but "life extension" just isn't in my list of things to worry about or aim for. Getting someone to listen to me rather than the person accompanying me when I'm in a medical crisis is a concern. Managing my medical bills and the repeated threats to turn the account over to a collection agency, only to call the company threatening and find I don't owe them anything yet because everything is circling between Medicare and MN assistance and insurance and all is a concern for me. The general public not seeing or believing that Jack Kevorkian does not have the best interests of severely depressed or physically disabled but non-terminal people in mind concerns me. Ending up in a nursing home because I can't rely on some of my home care staff to show up concerns me. Simone D., the Hispanic woman whom the NY courts recently decided a state institution can continue giving electro-shock treatments against her will concerns me. Elder care that doesn't involve abuse or coercion concerns me.

Life extension? Just talking about disabled folks keeping the lives they have without them being cut short by abuse, prejudice or even benign neglect seems a full enough job to me. Not just disabled folks, either. Poor, immigrant, people of color, elderly, people in other parts of the world whom our national policies impair or otherwise damage their health.

It's not that I'm not fascinated by the idea of life extension, or can't imagine it as a positive thing. I just can't imagine it as a cause that deserves priority. I can't get excited about it, politically.

Eh, more to say but no time now....

Anne Corwin said...

Hmm, I think I see what you mean. While longevity medicine/"life extension" might not be a bad thing, it is perhaps more important to get people out of the kinds of dangerous situations that might very well make it so that they never have the chance to get old in the first place.

Kay Olson said...

Also, would you mind if I brought this comment exchange and some of your concerns into a post on my own blog?

Go ahead. I consider anything on this blog fair game for discussion anywhere.

Hmm, I think I see what you mean. While longevity medicine/"life extension" might not be a bad thing, it is perhaps more important to get people out of the kinds of dangerous situations that might very well make it so that they never have the chance to get old in the first place.

Er, exactly. Now I feel silly being so long-winded. ;)