Monday, October 23, 2006

Odd-looking and uppity

Harriet McBryde Johnson apparently spoke at some big event in Michigan earlier this fall. As usual, she reportedly had some great things to say about disability rightish stuff. But first, Sharon Emory, the writer of this article has to make clear how twisty and gimpy and short Johnson is:

Watch Harriet McBryde Johnson for a while, and she starts turning your concept of human height on its head.

The "fearless voice for equality and freedom'' -- as she was introduced last month at the 25th anniversary gala for Michigan Protection & Advocacy Service Inc. -- uses a body so molded by neuromuscular disease that it nearly folds over on itself in her motorized wheelchair. "A jumble of bones in a floppy bag of skin,'' is the way she describes it.

The 49-year-old South Carolina lawyer and author wears her brown hair parted down the middle in a braid that hangs over her left shoulder and immediately reaches her lap. Just below are her black-slipper-shod feet, which point downward from the wheelchair footrests, seemingly ready for a pirouette at any moment.

Rising barely higher than the back of her wheelchair, her body exists on a horizontal rather than vertical plane. And that kind of mind-expanding experience is just for starters.

Once she opens her mouth, which she notably has no problem doing, you're likely to get blown back in your chair if you're the sensitive type.

The rest of the article gets down to the business of crip rights -- or rather, human rights, since Johnson challenges her audience (and evidently the reporter) to think in terms of providing for everyone instead of creating special programs for the disabled:

"Why not aspire to a world where all students have a right to a free and accessible education, where everyone can have useful work at a living wage?"

Society has no idea what to do with disability beyond opting to take care of it, hide it, lock it up, let it die "or put it on a pedestal and call it inspiration,'' she says ruefully, all of which involve "setting us apart from the human community.''

Johnson always, always rocks.

But look back at that part about her opening her mouth:
Once she opens her mouth, which she notably has no problem doing, you're likely to get blown back in your chair if you're the sensitive type.
What exactly does this mean? Why is it notable that she has no problem opening her mouth? Is it a reference to ability or agency? Does it express approval or is it critical? What about Johnson's message will shock the sensitive?

The vivid description of Johnson's body and its abnormalities is the visual set-up for the news that she has something original and forceful to say. The piece is written so that her body and her message cannot be easily separated, and are, in fact, the message together.

The headline of this column reads "When special isn't good enough." And the beginning paragraphs emphasize how different, interesting, challenging -- special -- Johnson appears physically. "Opens her mouth" is a particularly physical way to say that she "speaks" and it suggests something crude about the activity because it doesn't refer to the content of her speech but instead to her body and what it is (and isn't?) capable of.

Why mention Johnson has no problem opening her mouth? The only possible reads I can imagine are references either to her physical capability of uttering words, or her outspokeness. If it's the latter, again it's a particularly crude and physical way to say she speaks her mind. Her actions are described as if her disabled body is expressing itself rather than her intellect, and that this is somehow unattractive, inappropriate -- uppity.

Toward the end of the article, it's noted that Johnson publicly debated philosopher Peter Singer:

Johnson, who specializes in disability rights law, attained what she calls "weird, semi-celebrity status" when she took on noted philosopher and Princeton University professor Peter Singer in 2001.

Basing his argument on preference-utilitarian principles, Singer made his case for allowing parents to kill severely disabled babies so that, theoretically, as many people as possible could fulfill as many of their preferred choices as possible. Having lived nearly five decades with a congenital disease, Johnson took umbrage at his line of thinking.

It's not mentioned that Johnson's semi-celebrity occured because her richly descriptive and fascinating account of this debate was a cover story for The New York Times Sunday magazine and later a chapter in her book, To Old To Die Young. Nor is Johnson's side of that debate explained, though Singer's specific philosophical approach is described. It's only noted that Johnson "took umbrage" that people like her should be allowed to be killed at birth.

Johnson's message for her speech in Michigan is abbreviated into the article's title "When special isn't good enough." This reads together with the focus on Johnson's body and the failure to show her intellect or lawyerly knowledge as products of an accomplished and perhaps radical mind. It reads as a rebuke for asking for favors -- special demands from those with special bodies.

Obviously, I don't know the intent of the reporter for this piece, but while seeming to cover the interests of disabled people she instead presents Johnson as an abnormal body that behaves in an unseemly way by opening her mouth.

Sunday, October 22, 2006

I can't get Junius Wilson out of my mind

I read this at Disability Studies, Temple U. a few days ago and can't stop thinking about old Junius Wilson.

A 1994 NYT article says this:

Black and deaf, Junius Wilson was 28 years old when he was jailed, charged with assault with intent to rape. He was declared insane and sent to North Carolina's mental hospital for blacks. Then he was castrated.

That was in 1925. Decades later, the charges were dropped, but Mr. Wilson remained in a locked ward.

Now 96, Mr. Wilson was finally moved on Friday into his first real home in 68 years.

"Decades later." The charges were dropped five decades later. Yet the institution kept him locked up for almost two decades more. What caused a reassessment of his case when he was in his 70s?

Is Junius Wilson still alive? (Unlikely, I suppose, since he'd be about 108 now.) How long did he live in freedom? Was it freedom to him? Were his last years happy and did he get to experience some of the things he was so long denied? Did he know friendship or love or even just a good conversation during all those years locked up? What happened to his family?

I'll have to wait for the book, by Susan Birch and Hannah Joyner. But as Dis Hum announces, Susan Burch will be speaking about Wilson in Columbus, OH, in mid-November. Check Penny's post for the details.

Sadly, Wilson's problems as a deaf person with the criminal justice system are neither rare nor something that just happened decades ago. I don't have access to the entire article, but an abstract for a paper on "Obstacles Faced by Deaf People in the Criminal Justice System" by Vernon and Miller reports:

Deaf people, especially those who are not well educated, are at risk for serious injustices when they enter the criminal justice system. The present study describes these risks at all stages of the legal process, including arrest, trial, probation, prison, and parole. These dangers are greatest for those who are poorly educated, read at a fourth-grade level or lower, have poor communication skills (American Sign Language and English), and lack awareness of their legal rights. Primitive personality disorder (PPD) is the term mental health professionals use to describe this set of characteristics. The risks that the segment of the deaf population with PPD faces when its members run afoul of the law are described, a case history provided, and some relevant legal and interpreting issues are discussed. A case is made for applying the concept of linguistic incompetence to deaf individuals with PPD.
Not that Wilson was necessarily poorly educated -- he may or may not have been -- but he was also a young black man in North Carolina during Jim Crow.

I can't stop thinking about him.

Thursday, October 19, 2006

Comparing niqab-wearing women to disability

Since the story of Aishah Azmi, the niqab-wearing teaching assistant suspended from her job, broke, former British foreign secretary Jack Straw has been busy making an ass of himself. Or a bigger ass, I suppose, if you're a Muslim member of his constituency. Straw is currently the Leader of the House of Commons and Lord Privy Seal (that last sounds like a bullshit title, doesn't it), and has been handing out opinions about niqab-wearing women.

In this week's The Sunday Times, UK, India Knight writes an opinion about Straw and the niqab called "Muslims are the new Jews." While Knight believes the request that Azmi remove her niqab while actively engaged in teaching English to children is reasonable, the fallout of religious bigotry surrounding the case deeply offends her:

...What we are witnessing is religious bigotry of the most shameful kind. The words used in the context of the veil debate —-- "strange", "“spooky", "“weird", "“offensive", "“creepy", "“wrong", "“evil-looking"”, "“sinister" -- are not words a civilised society should use about other human beings.

People are made uncomfortable by all sorts of things: I find shaven-headed, tattooed men unpleasant, especially if they'’re drunk. I'm not mad keen on hooded gangs of youths at three in the morning. Facial piercings hurt my eyes....

But we all need to coexist peaceably. The fact that I find the man in Camden market with bolts through his face, or the Orthodox woman dressed in a drab sack and wearing a bad wig, as "“weird" --— weirder, actually --— than a woman dressed in black with only her eyes showing is neither here nor there.

I don'’t expect they think much of me, either. But I would have to be deranged, or consumed with hatred, to attribute random demerits to them on the basis of their physical appearance. A lot of people are made uncomfortable by disability, for instance -- because they live in a civilised society they don'’t say it.

Imagine if Straw had said, "There are an awful lot of autistic people in my constituency. I tell them to look me right in the eye, otherwise I can'’t help them."” Would there not be an outcry? I'’m sorry to equate Islam with disability, but I am doing so because an observant person'’s religion is as integral a part of them as their genetic make-up.
I'm fascinated both by the way disability keeps coming up as an analogy with this topic, and by the apologies or outrage that seem to follow automatically from that. In the blogging I wrote about in my last post, the outrage was from one commenter (at PunkAssBlog) to another in comparing the choice of wearing the niqab to the lack of choice involved in a severely disabled woman using a wheelchair. In her opinion piece, Knight regrets the need to "equate Islam with disability." The discomfort runs in both directions, and the implication is that there is something unseemly in the comparison.

What's unseemly is pity, though it's presence is not recognized. It's viewed as unseemly to equate a regular "normal" difference like religious clothing with something as pitiful as a disability. Religious diversity is expected and comprehensible despite the bigotry it brings out. Disability is shameful and pitiable, and equating something good and acceptable about human nature with it is something to apologize for.

For example, Sunrunner has responded to my last post with quite a bit of interesting information about her muslim background and Islamic culture generally. But she also notes that comparison to disability would generally be found insulting to muslim women because of the stigma attached to disability.

I find the comparison between niqab-wearing women and disabled people to be incredibly apt, despite other people's clear discomfort with it. In direct public interaction, both a niqab and certain impairments may require other people to broaden their mind and accommodate the difference. And for the niqab-wearer or the person with the impairment, that difference about their physical being may make interacting with the rest of the world more difficult -- disabling.

Feminists have long noted that various styles of dress for women tend to inhibit movement. Along with the niqab, high heels and short skirts restrict complete physical freedom of movement. Sure, a person can adjust and very skillfully adapt to restrictive clothing, but that doesn't negate the effect. Choice, company dress code or coercion also do not negate the impairing effect of wearing something more physically restrictive than other (less, looser, different) clothing.

And regardless of political opinions about the niqab, it can't be denied that its purpose is to create a barrier between the wearer and other people. Muslim Brits interviewed for the BBC generally acknowledge the niqab requires some social adjustment, and many women who have tried it likewise acknowledge it can put limitations on the wearer.

So, despite what seems to be a general distaste and discomfort with the comparison between niqab-wearing women and disability, I find it interesting and possibly instructive about social interactions with people of any kind who come across as "different" or "challenging."

Wednesday, October 18, 2006

A very long post on niqab-wearing teachers, feminism and disability

There's some fascinating discussion going on at some feminist blogs about the case of Aishah Azmi, a muslim woman in Britain who teaches at a London school while wearing the niqab. School officials have reportedly asked her to remove the face mask while teaching the children because some children have complained of not understanding her clearly. Azmi is a bilingual assistant teacher and many of these children are learning English as a second language.

Feminists seem to be divided on the issue of dress for muslim women generally, with some believing that coverings linked to the muslim faith are always misogynist and others believing that any mandate of women's dress that controls how much of bodies are covered or revealed is the problem, including a country or employer that requires female muslims to not wear a veil. The former claim cultural relativism of the latter and the latter claim insensitivity to the choices of nonwestern or nonwhite women of the former. Well, in a nutshell. There's been much volatile and bitter blogging around the same old issue of white feminists not including the concerns, cultures and realities of women of color in their politics lately as well.

I want to look at this specific case of Aishah Azmi and the discussion on some feminist blogs where disability has come up in more than one context.

At Feministe, where author Jill supports Azmi, commenter Sunrunner says:

I am sorry, but I am going to have to disagree with this. I would not want my child in a class that is taught by a teacher whose face cannot be seen. Think about it–how is a child supposed to feel? Have you ever had an extended conversation with someone wearing a niqab? It is much harder to pick up on social cues . . . is she happy or unhappy with what I am saying? This sort of visual feedback is extremely important to children.
Jill responds:
Just out of curiosity, would you oppose your child being taught by someone with a facial deformity?
Meanwhile, Gordon K notes:
...Access to facial expression and all of the facial cues that we call “lip reading” is extremely important in learning a language, particularly for students who are deaf, hard of hearing, or apraxic (and many of these students are mainstreamed). So is it appropriate to take a job teaching such a class if you are going to wear a veil?
In a reference to the ADA, Sally says:
I’m wondering if it would be useful to apply the “reasonable accomodation” standard that’s used in the U.S. with regards to disabled people. If your religious practice seriously affects your fundamental ability to do your job, that’s a problem. If it merely makes people uncomfortable or requires some extra effort from your employer, then religious freedom trumps.
Most commenters in this thread at Feministe believe discrimination of some kind (religion, gender) is at play regardless of their opinion on whether a teacher in Azmi's position should be fully veiled. This includes Leederick, who says:
Wearing a veil hampers her ability to do her job. It makes it particularly difficult for children who are hard of hearing. Her job’s teaching children, and I do think interaction and being able to see someone’s face is very important there.
Meanwhile, Sunrunner responds to Jill:
Of course I would not object to my child being taught by a woman with a facial deformity! Anyway, I would assume that if a person is able to speak (necessary for teaching and caring for children) she has the capacity for some kind of facial expression. It is not at all the same thing as a blank, black mask.
In fact, this assumption is not correct. While I have some "capacity" for facial expression, many of my facial muscles were the first affected by my neuromuscular disease and the dimple I had in my left cheek hasn't been seen for about 30 years. If you run into it, let me know. But anyone who knows me personally (except those who have known me exclusively in the past year) can tell you that some people with very limited capacity for facial expressions rarely let other people get a word in edgewise. Even just communicating on paper lately, I rarely shut up. Anyway, while facial muscles do effect pronunication and clarity, inability to use most of them has no impact on the amount of speech a person can produce.

Interestingly though, I have been accused of having a blank mask of a face by someone angry with me in a conversation we were holding. "Icy demeanor" was part of the accusation and it was used to undermine my point-of-view (which was unrelated to disability). My language was understood perfectly. The emotional content of my argument was, perhaps, not understood. So, no facial deformity here, just a "blank... mask."

Discussion at Creative Destruction includes a debate about whether or not seeing a teacher's mouth is necessary for learning a language. It's noted that blind people manage to acquire speech without sight. And there's the comment that blind people have special powers in their use of their other senses, but children should be afforded every sense possible to learn. Much like the ironic invisibility of deaf muslim children or devout muslim women who use sign language -- which I presume exist and manage to communicate somewhere in this wide world -- blind children don't come up in this discussion.

Robert, whom I believe to be the "Bob Hayes" author of the CR post, says:
So as long as a teacher is only handicapping some of her students’ ability to have a successful life, it’s OK?
Language is fascinating throughout this multi-blog discussion. When I find time, I'll post about a muslim woman's ironic use of language and imagery in defense of wearing the niqab in Britain's The Sunday Times.

But Robert's comment brings us to PunkAssBlog. Post author R. Mildred writes:
If a class of 6 - 12 year olds needs to see the teachers lips to understand her ... then I assume she has the training to deal with a special ed class and when she say “the kids can understand me fine” (as she has done) we can pretty much take her word on it - and if she’s teaching deaf kids she should need to be able to sign anyway and that she wears a niqab is an incidental side note that isn’t really relevent.
I don't plan to step into the deaf politics minefield that is oralism versus sign language here, but I do want to note that not all deaf children are taught with sign language. On the other hand, R. Mildred does take it for granted that being muslim and deaf aren't mutually exclusive -- or more specifically, being a niqab-wearing woman and being familiar with deafness and sign language -- and I appreciate that.

If you aren't fascinated already, here's where I think the discussion gets riveting. Sunrunner, commenting here as well, links to a Guardian article by a non-veil-wearing muslim woman journalist who dons the niqab for 24 hours and, as expected, finds it completely oppressive.

Then, R. Mildred basically claims that a teacher wearing a niqab could provide children with a superior education to those who learn language while relying on the ability to see their teacher's full face:
The niqab doesn’t even hide as much facial information as people assume, it just takes a bit of familiarity to get used to reading the eyes without the landmarks.

hell, if a child learns to communicate from a woman wearing a niqab, she’s had a masterclass in reading people’s faces, give them a full face and they’ll be able to read people’s minds.

Lack is described as an asset. Sounds just a little like some disability rights arguments that impairments or inabilities have their own inherent values.

Quin says:
When I studied status in theatre class (by which I mean, the unconcious perceived status that two people feel when relating to each other– not talking about social class here– a king can play low status to a chimney sweep), I learned through experience that anything which makes it harder to read your expression enhances your perceived status in other people’s eyes. So, for instance, sunglasses naturally increase your status because people cannot see your eyes moving; they even may get the sensation that you are calmly staring straight into their eyes at all times, even if you’re really just looking everywhere at once nervously.... Anyway, I imagine a veil would probably act in a similar fashion.
"Anything?" I disagree with this statement for more than one reason, but from a perspective of my experience as it relates to not just disability but perceived difference (before I was visibly impaired in any other way) I find it to be untrue. Status comes from elsewhere than this.

Responding to Sunrunner's link of the "veil-for-a day" Guardian article, Sly Civilian says:
Gah! I’ve got really serious objections to using that narrative as an anti-veiling argument. Ask anyone in disabilities activism if it’s a good idea to put somebody in a wheelchair “for a day” to show them what it’s really like.

Temporary “adoption” of a social, physical, cultural, whatever barrier is NOT the same thing as durable inhabitance of an idenity constructed in response to that fact. The tourist has none of the knowlege, experience, support, training, or coping stratagies, and experiences “disability” in a completely artificial and unrealistic fashion. By selective appropriation or by revulsion, the tourist response almost always lacks grounding or respect.

While the author wrote of her concern of exploring her Muslim idenity in this way, I’m worried that consumption of this article as anti-veil is to miss what this experience is and isn’t. For one thing, it is NOT an accurate representation of what daily life is like for a woman wearing the niqab. Definitionally, a tourist (even one from a nearby country) is not the same as a native.

To that very last, I'll note that it's also not the same as wearing a niqab because you wish to. This slides away from the topic of Azmi and her students, but it is true that the current wisdom among disability activists is that crip-for-a-day programs might do more harm than good. Yet I believe Sunrunner misunderstands Sly Civilian's point because in response there is this:

Oh, so you are comparing veiling to being disabled?

A disability is NOT a choice, a veil is (sometimes). One chooses to wear it for a day or a month or a year or a lifetime, but one does not choose to be disabled. One simply is or is not.

Along with eventually saying she(?) agrees about disability simulations, Sunrunner adds:

Anyway, my point was that it is ludicrous to compare a woman who choose to wear a veil in a country in which it is not mandated with another woman who is confined to a motorized wheelchair due to a life threatening disabling illness. So if my anger is stupid, it is no more stupid than your stupid analogy.
Despite what Sunrunner declares, I find the comparison is being made all over the place. Azmi is declared disabled by the veil, her niqab is compared to facial deformity, her ability to communicate is debated with regard to sight, hearing and other physical ability. The ADA and "reasonable accommodation" are invoked. Words like "handicapping" are used. Some commenters address Azmi's abilities, some address the childrens' possible disabilities. Commenters relate their own various disabling learning experiences.

These Western feminist debates struggle to balance the religious and cultural freedom of muslim women with freedom from misogynist limits religion and culture make on muslim women's lives. Race is also a factor. And it's clear disability is too, though the thoughts of disabled muslim women (feminists?) are not present here. The niqab-wearing disabled women know these issues intimately and undoubtedly struggles to find balance as well. I know they're out there. But silent in -- or silenced from -- this particular online debate.

There was an anonymous non-signing deaf commenter on PunkAssBlog:
As long as disability has been introduced here, any deaf children in the classroom would be required to ask her to remove her veil if they wanted to understand her, or be removed to another classroom if she refused. And before any of you pile on me, *I* was that non signing deaf child in the class who constantly had to teach her teachers not to face the blackboard, to look at us, etc. To this day I still have to educate my teachers (I continue taking classes in all kinds of things.) Access to the visual expression on someone’s face is critically important for me and other non signing deaf. It is not a choice. It is not “some whitey” making glib objections. It’s a fight against ableism or disablism (pick your country).
I don't know if "anonymous" was truly heard. Neither R. Mildred or Jill, the original posters at PunkAss and Feministe, respectively, have appeared to consider the intersection of disability, though it's part of the discussion everywhere.

Sunday, October 15, 2006

Five things that feminism has done for me

My friend Amanda at Life in a Suitcase tagged me for this feminist meme that is traveling around. It started because of concerns (and outrage) about funding changes by the Canadian government for Status of Women Canada (SWC), including the removal of the word "equality" from the government agency's mandate. I don't know the intricate details of all this, but the meme is certainly a good topic to think and write about.

My five things:

It provided me with a home to grow up in where my parents respected each other and nurtured everyone's dreams and goals regardless of gender.

It made my study and career choices at college free from the gender restrictions and pressures my mother experienced.

It's given me a context in which to understand my experiences with religion and my spirituality.

It's added to my interest and understanding of my experiences as a disabled woman.

It's provided me with many many warm, loving women friends, both out in the world and online. Stunningly, during my four-month hospital stay, I received snail mail and packages (as well as online prayers and support) from dozens of individual feminists all over the world -- all online friends or acquaintances that at the time I'd never met. I've since met eight of them in person. Our common concerns and experiences brought us together online and provided me with support when I needed it most. (Amanda is one of them, btw.)

Saturday, October 14, 2006

Saturday Slumgullion #15

  • Joseph Rainmound writes "This Democrat's Deaf" on DailyKos about changing definitions for disabled and deaf. It's more than that though, go read.

  • Arrests of dozens of Gallaudet students, professors and alumni on Friday are only the latest event in the long-simmering battle at Washington, D.C.'s university for the deaf. Joseph Rainmound at DKos again, this time with a linkfest of inside opinions on the situation.

  • The 7th Ouch! podcast was slated to be the last, but apparently listener protest has saved it -- so have a listen to the silly Brits. And if you haven't heard the less goofy but still informative American DisabilityNation podcast #10, the latest one features an interview with Not Dead Yet's Diane Coleman.

  • Damon at Do Your Worst! thinks efforts to get mainstream TV to run a crip-savvy disability show are pointless when "mainstream" is being fragmented and undermined by technology that gives us YouTube and whatever minority groups make the effort to put out there themselves.

  • Candy Harrington at Barrier Free Travels shares the thoughts of Mr. Upright-Uptight on access accommodations, though she calls him Mr. Pea Brain.

  • NormEmma at YouTube offer a music video about the Euthanasia Blues -- a disability rights perspective on legalized euthanasia and physician assisted suicide. Via No Pity

  • LoudGirl at The Phat Girl Speaks thinks about Rosa Parks on the bus and her own recent experience on London public transit, which while unlikely to go down in history, nevertheless has much in common with what led Parks to take her stand.

  • Crutch! This is the one link in this list to visit if you have limited time -- Bint Alshamsa of My Private Casbah has Bill Shannon's amazing four-minute YouTube video and her commentary of what the man is all about.

  • The Guardian reports on a new disabled and documentary version of The Full Monty called The Crippendales.

  • "Disable children can be our scientists" notes a reverend in Sierra Leone.

  • After 30 years of institutionalization, Chip Hill is moving to a group home near his family in Chattanooga.

  • As a nod to Disability Awareness Month (yes, October), Kathi Wolfe writes for the Washington Blade about cripness and queerness all in one.

  • "Running with honor" in the Washington Post presents a nondisabled woman's thoughts on participating in the Army Ten-Miler run with many young veterans wearing prosthetic legs and recent war widows.

Friday, October 13, 2006

The Carnival is coming here

The second Disability Blog Carnival will be here Thursday, October 26. Submissions are due Monday, October 23. The theme for this stop on the carnival tour is "The Cure," though any submissions about disability rights, disability culture, or personal disability experiences are welcome.

By "The Cure" I don't mean (as Penny noted) that I'm looking for posts about the fine but gloomy alternative band of the '80s. I'm refering to the issue -- or question -- that pretty much defines how people think of disability. Dan Wilkins wrote this about "the cure" while a board member of the National Spinal Cord Injury Association:

Society needs to understand that, of the nearly sixty-million belonging to this U.S. Disability Culture alone and millions more around the globe, those who dream of cures are far and away in the minority compared to those who dream of acceptance and access to all that their society and community has to offer. The majority of us with disabilities are comfortable in our skin. We see ourselves as unbroken and not in need of "fixing". We are proud of our disabilities and of the wisdom and perspective gained from the experience. The majority of us, along with our friends and family, dream of the equity and respect that comes from a community that has expanded to include and accommodate all of its people.

It is a matter of two different dreams. One dream sees the person; or more precisely, the disability as the problem. The other, more widely held dream sees society itself and the environment as the problem; with its lack of attitudinal, architectural, political and programmatic access. The former sounds logical, based upon archaic misconceptions of what life “must be like” for those living with a disability: "Of course one would want to be healed." The latter demands we, as a community, step back and take a look at the bigger picture, at how we perceive and treat people who get around or see or hear differently. It demands we take responsibility for our thoughts and actions, the baggage we carry, and for the history of exclusion and segregation. It is discrimination and it must end.

Back in 1996, David Mitchell said this at Electric Edge:

The key tension that exists in nearly all stories about disability is seen most clearly in the "cure narrative." It's a story of uneasy obliteration, for it always ends in the "loss" of the object upon which it depends: Either the disability is eradicated and surrenders its seductive interest, or it resists conforming to the narrative of its rehabilitation and the evidence of that refusal must itself be obliterated. This is what Paul Longmore means by the "cure or kill" paradigm: both get rid of disability.
Mitchell refers to "stories about disabilities," which certainly applies to literature and film but also to the stories of our individual lives and the narratives people imagine about every disabled person they see. "The cure" is the persistent human project to fix people of impairments rather than accept their lives as good enough, valuable as they are.

I don't see having a philosophical problem with the cure mindset as remotely the same thing as being against scientific discovery and medical breakthroughs, but that's frequently misunderstood. Also, I have my own questions when confronted by the crip-savvy question "If there was a cure available, would you take it?"

I want to know if this fantasy cure is for everyone or just me? Is it expensive? Is it free? Does it hurt? Will it last? Are we talking just cure, or turning back time to a post-impairment body free from general inability? Will people see me as nondisabled to the point I'll be more employable? Will taking the cure mean I lose any disability aid? Will the prejudice go away too?

And many, many more.

So, the theme "the cure" refers to the above, and I'm hoping for whatever it inspires you to write about disability. Send submissions to the carnival site or to my email at kay.fine@gmail.com with the subject line "carnival," please. Deadline Monday, October, 23.

Thursday, October 12, 2006

Carnival Day

My computer is off to the shop for a hopefully brief period of time, so I may be offline for just a day or through the weekend.

In the meantime, go to Disability Studies, Temple U. where Penny Richards has the first ever Disability Blog Carnival with an amazing collection of offerings to read from an incredible variety of sources.

See you soon.

Things that crack me up, #11

A recent sitemeter check reveals a Google search for "What Paul Reeve said at the end of his famous ride?"

Possible answer: Spell my name right.

Wednesday, October 11, 2006

Things that crack me up, #10

Visual description: In the foreground a sign reads "wheelchair access" with an arrow pointing to the background, which looks like lumpy prairie or grassy beach. Absolutely not wheelchair accessible. Nothing manmade appears beyond the sign.

Originally uploaded at Flickr by inframel

Sunday, October 08, 2006

Pickle for three, please

I met Marian the day I came to college in my week-old electric scooter, still learning how to drive it well. She was my assigned roommate in the residence hall and we were the first two female disabled students to ever room together at our university. With only a few accessible rooms, my freshman year was the first that there were enough women in wheelchairs to require two to a room to fit everyone in.

Campus housing had called me over the summer and asked if I was okay rooming with another disabled woman, apparently concerned if we'd have enough room to maneuver. I'd thought it was a stupid question -- if I wasn't okay with it, would they quick remodel another room before I arrived in two weeks? Also, the slim detail that my new roommate would also be using a wheelchair excited and startled me. I hadn't considered it before.

Marian and I were happy roommates and became close friends immediately. Our resident assistant turned out to be Anne, a disabled woman Marian had been tight with as a child at Easter Seals summer camp. Marian, pessimistic and wryly funny, and Anne, loudly hilarious and over-the-top, were a completely new experience for me. I hadn't had friends with disabilities -- let alone scooters or wheelchairs -- ever before. I revelled in the startling visual power we had when we went somewhere, lining up serially on a narrow sidewalk like a brief parade of fast go-cart Shriners or driving three (sometimes more) abreast across campus and talking and laughing like anyone else, but at our seated height.

Sophomore year, by arrangement, Marian and I shared a bathroom with Anne, and we often treated our two dorm rooms like a suite by keeping the bathroom doors open so the bathroom itself became a narrow hallway from one room to the other. While the bathroom -- just a toilet and an open area with grab bars for a shower and room for a shower chair -- was all tiled and slightly sloped to a central floor drain, there was an eight-inch ramp sloping an inch or two down outside either doorway (Anne's or ours) into the small sink/foyer area of each dorm room. The closets faced each bathroom door, so if you stood in our closet, you could look through the bathroom into Anne's closet, directly opposite.

Early one evening just after dinner, Marian and I were in our room. Marian was sitting in our small closet finding something and I was talking with her, my scooter parked in front of the closet doorway.


Anne came roaring through the bathroom into our room, laughing as she came down the little ramp. To our surprise, her Amigo scooter hit the side of my scooter and her front bumper lifted to rest on the platform of my scooter by my feet. The front wheel of her front-wheel drive was lifted off the floor.

So. Marian was trapped in the closet. I was parked in front of the closed door to the hallway, and Anne's scooter was hung up on mine. We all used our chairs full-time, so none of us was able to get out and push. We sat there surprised that three mobile adults could immobilize themselves without any of our chairs breaking down.

This was before cell phones, so we giggled when the phone rang and our answering machine clicked on. We contemplated what exactly we would shout if we decided to holler for help. Then we jokingly began conversations none of us wanted to hear and required a captive audience.

"Have you been saved by the Lord?"

"Let me tell you about my essay on Moby Dick."

"You know, my husband had a stroke recently and now he needs a wheelchair too...."

We nearly laughed ourselves sick before I managed to move my scooter back and forth enough to dislodge Anne's. It was a bit of a disappointment to be free. Suddenly the room was accessible to all of us again and we were a little less bound in common camaraderie.

It was one of the silliest, funniest moments of my life, though it doesn't translate well for the larger world. It's a crip thing, and probably rare at that. It's an example of what makes living with a particular disability a unique cultural experience. One I would never have found at home with my family.

Saturday, October 07, 2006

Saturday Slumgullion #14

  • A story about a disabled woman and her nurse who stuck together through Katrina and the many evacuations and relocations and complications that ensued.
  • A Wal-Mart in Albany, NY, kicks service do out of store.
  • A two-part newspaper feature on a transgender woman repeatedly refers to her suffering from gender dysphoria and the complex emotional and mental difficulties involved in transitioning.
  • Over a year after Katrina, FEMA is reaching out to disabled evacuees to let them know they now have accessible trailers available to live in.
  • The U.S. Supreme Court to consider again the Texax death penalty case of LaRoyce Lathair Smith, whose learning disability was not given to the jury as information to consider when he was sentenced.
  • The remains of at least 51 people suspected to be victims of the Nazi T4 program to murder disabled persons have been found in Menden, Germany. About half were infants and children.
Embarrassment is the least of 18-year-old Rozina Rehman's problems after her back was broken a year ago in the earthquake that killed 75,000 people and scarred the minds and bodies of many, many more.

The first anniversary of the quake is on Sunday, but the young woman remains too self-conscious to go back to school in a wheelchair, so she stays home with her parents.

"I am scared what people will say. I can't get out of this wheelchair now for life," says Rozina, who was dug out from the rubble of her home in Balakot, in Pakistan's North West Frontier Province, one of the towns hit hardest by the disaster.

Tuesday, October 03, 2006

Just so we're clear

These were hate crimes.

links via Echidne

Things that crack me up, #9

They're like square seaside wheelchair condoms.

Visual description: Two wheelchairs on a terrace overlooking the sea on a clear sunny day, but the wheelchairs are surrounded by box frames with clear plastic windows -- one frame is red, the other blue. The people inside are apparently enjoying the view.

Originally uploaded at Flickr by Mooganic

Monday, October 02, 2006

The saddest entourage ever

I've never seen the HBO series Entourage, but I know entourages are supposed to be cool. Hip. Impressive. They're supposed to help acquire stuff, and beautify the star, and enlarge the star's importance with their very presence.

Here at The Gimp Compound it's Parts Replacement Week. Today I went to the local clinic to have my trach swapped for a newer, less ooky one and Wednesday there will be drilling of teeth. Too bad the attendants can't be sent ahead to have their teeth drilled instead of mine. I would so go for that.

Yes, I have attendants. They're my folks and the state-paid nurses I've referred to before, and though a nurse is supposed to be here 24/7 as long as the state is paying for any care of a person with a vent, they're covering about 60% of the hours this month and my weary parents are handling the rest. Anyway, there's always someone lurking about me.

In the past I've brought my parents to many doctor's appointments -- particularly the specialists because 1) we all know the drill, 2) I feel more powerful with them there, and 3) we can remember things better if we all try together. In the hospital, especially when very helpless, it was really important they were around. I focused on not letting anyone accidentally injure or kill me, and my parents worried about other details. I don't know how anyone manages all that alone.

So. I have this nurse who goes where I go, and parents who have a knack for teamwork in the doctor-patient arena with me. All four of us went to the clinic together today for the trach change. And while there is good people-watching of all kinds there, I'm sure we are something to see. If you wandered into the nearest church lutefisk dinner and picked out two reasonably limber senior citizens and a women aged 35 or older, you'd have an idea of the utter coolness of my entourage. They carry gauze and saline. They wear comfortable shoes.

My entourage. My posse. My gang. My, uh, parents and my nurse.

No Bigger Than a Minute

Tuesday, October 3 -- that's tomorrow! -- on PBS' POV series, Steven Delano's documentary called "No Bigger Than a Minute" will air. (It's on at 10 p.m. here, check locally for the time where you are.)

From the film's synopsis:

"My name is Steven. I am 48 years old and I'm a dwarf." So begins Steven Delano's unusual new documentary, "No Bigger Than a Minute." What follows is neither an academic discourse on the life and times of America's "little people," nor a project in self-affirmation in the face of social discrimination — though the film includes healthy doses of both of these. "No Bigger Than a Minute" has tongue-in-cheek re-enactments, a music score structured after Delano's own mutated DNA sequence, short-statured Hollywood stars such as Peter Dinklage ("The Station Agent") and Meredith Eaton ("Family Law") and musicians, rappers, comedians, novelists, doctors and ordinary folk. Not to mention filmmaker Werner Herzog and an uneasy, and very funny, cameo by Randy Newman, singer-songwriter of the top ten hit, "Short People."

What really stirs this eclectic mix into potent form is Delano's own reluctant "star turn" at the film's center — a film he didn't originally envision appearing in at all. Delano's opening statement is both the culmination of one story, about what he'd learned of dwarfism after 40 years of ignoring it, and the beginning of a new story. It's this new story that thrusts him into his own film to delve into questions of humanity's treatment of difference, tensions between personal and group identities and the future evolution of these contradictions. It's here that Delano faces the most untidy dilemma of all: In the brave new world of genetic engineering, when it is conceivable that dwarfism can be bred out of human populations, is this what we want?

You may have noticed my imaginary boyfriend will be part of the film. He was on Nip/Tuck recently too, and his nanny-character made a little speech saying very disability rightish things. I do believe he could improve any seedy sexist drama he acted on. Any documentary too.

Sunday, October 01, 2006

Something less creepy about former Rep. Foley

It's international news that the FBI is examining e-mails between former Republican Rep. Mark Foley and teenage Congressional pages. Democrats are calling for hearings, we're learning other Republicans knew of these e-mails for some time, and Bush denies having known anything until now (which, as usual, is either hard to believe or completely believable).

What you may not know about Foley is that he was the guy who repeatedly introduced the ADA Notification Act to the House, hoping to weaken the ADA by requiring disabled people to notify any business of noncompliance and then wait 90 days before seeking legal redress. Well, 90 days plus all this time since 1990 when the ADA was passed and businesses everywhere went on notice that they should figure out if they were meeting the standards of the law.

Kara Sheridan wrote in 2005 for Audacity magazine:

Under Foley’s sponsored act, our role as the sole enforcers of the ADA would expand even further to include properly notifying those that deny us basic access to their facility and then waiting to see what happens. It’s difficult to understand that more waiting after fifteen years is a solution to anyone’s problem. Mark Foley’s ADA Notification Act is blurred behind the mask of protecting the vulnerable people with disabilities from "shiesty lawyers" who seek to take advantage of small business owners.

This paternalistic attitude that we are somehow less capable of protecting ourselves compared to the average citizen is more evidence to Foley’s underlying principle that the burden upon small businesses to comply is more valuable to consider than our rights as equal citizens.

While he has definitely been briefed and is well practiced in using politically correct terms and carefully shying away from outright stating that he believes many ADA standards are not truly necessary and expensive trivialities, he still makes it clear with his statements in interviews with the media.

Instead of sharing the perspective of a person with a disability who has been denied access to any public place he/she wishes to go, Foley instead shares stories of those that file lawsuits against strip clubs or those that file complaints based on the difference of a few inches from the standard disabled parking place.

The Ragged Edge covered Foley's ADA Notification Act back in 2000 when Clint Eastwood helped spread disinformation at a Congressional hearing.

It's good reading, though not as juicy as the current Foley news.

A credo for support

Here's an excellent four-minute video made in memory of Tracy Latimer. It's not about Tracy Latimer, it's about disabled people in general and how to treat them. For those who need it, there's both audio and written text of the spoken words.

A video like this seems important after reading how many people commenting to my post "Is your life hard or super-hard?" by admitting they are hesitant or fearful around disabled people and aren't sure how to teach their children differently. These comments were mainly at Alas, I believe, and I don't think the people saying these things are unusual or any more ableist or self-conscious than the average person. Sad, but true.


Via The Belonging Initiative

Friday, September 29, 2006

Saturday Slumgullion #13

I love doing these slumgullions, but with the first Disability Blog Carnival coming up at Disability Studies, Temple U. I may focus here more on non-blog slumgullionish stuff. Or maybe there will be so much disability blogging I can gather the leftovers here. We'll see how it goes.

  • Mark Boatman at Nodakwheeler had planned to escape the South Dakota nursing home he was stuck in (because of the state's lack of funding for in-home care) last May, but it didn't go as planned. Happily, he has recently made a successful break and is enjoying his freedom in Montana.
People just wouldn't talk to me. It is one of those things that is hard to put your finger on. Like there are a thousand little ways that people disregard you. And if you looked at each one, you may not think it is a big deal, and some individuals may have even had a very legitimate excuse that has nothing to do with you, but when you put them all together over time...you can only conclude that a large number of people really don't have any interest in getting to know you. I asked people out for coffee and I got turned down every time. I would go up to people and talk and they would make a hasty exit. Once this woman came up and talked to me and I was fiddling around with my hearing aid from having been using the FM system. I said, "I'm sorry, my hearing aid wasn't working and I didn't get all that you said." She said, "So you just let me go on talking when you couldn't hear me?" I said I got the gist of what she said but I might have missed some things. She made a hasty exit and has never talked to me again. I have even said hi to her by name and she doesn't even say hi back. I used to go home from church after this stuff would happen again and again and just feel like crap. Part of it was just asking myself what I was doing wrong or that was so awful? If the Unitarian Universalist can't deal with me, who can?

Crossposted at Alas, A Blog
Check there for more comments

Jury duty

I've been called up for jury duty at the county court level. This is the second time in three years that this supposedly random process has chosen me, though my parents have never in their lives been called to serve. I was summoned twice in my 13 years in Arizona too.

Here's how it generally works: A summons in the mail notifies the recipient that she must serve unless she qualifies for specific exemptions. There's a questionnaire where she verifies she's a U.S. citizen, has never been charged with or convicted of a felony, and doesn't have a disability that would interfere with serving. To each she answers "yes" or "no." "Yes" to the question about disability requires verification by a doctor, of course.

Every time (four times now), I've answered the disability question with a write-in of "maybe." Is there reliable public transit to get a person with a wheelchair to the courthouse? Is the courthouse wheelchair accessible? Are the courtroom, the jury box, and the restrooms that the jurors use accessible too? Will my personal attendant or nurse remain available to me? Will I be treated respectfully if I need accommodations not immediately available? I figure I'm not the wildcard in this equation.

Marta Russell, author of Beyond Ramps: Disability at the End of the Social Contract, wrote about her summons to jury duty in 2002. After some adventures with parking, elevator access, and building security, it was time for a little ableist attitude from a jury administrator:

Those of us who have been using wheelchairs for some time know the routine. No matter where you choose to place yourself you will be told that you are in the way and asked to move. It took about ten minutes but an administrator was soon by my side telling me I was blocking traffic and suggested that I "move over there" pointing to a table against the opposite wall.

There were people using that table to fill out forms so I mentioned that I would be in the way there too. Why is it that some people do not like to be "upped" by a person using a wheelchair? She certainly did not like it and denied that there was anyone using the table even though three persons were in plain sight at the table at that very moment!

As I went towards the table she went over and grabbed the table, then dragged it off into another area. Plainly agitated she came back over to me and asked in a patronizing tone "Is that enough room?"

My wheelchair is about 26 inches wide, the table was about 5 feet long. Agitated myself, I retorted that if the room had been designed to accommodate a wheelchair and had integrated seating, she would not be having this problem now, would she?

Russell's experience is hardly the most dramatic. George Lane, of the Supreme Court case Tennessee v. Lane, had once crawled out of his wheelchair and up a flight of stairs to reach a second-floor courtroom in Tennessee. When he refused to repeat the process on a different day, he was arrested for failure to appear. (Tennessee v. Lane, itself, is about whether or not a plaintiff can sue a state for damages under the ADA's Title II.)

Lane was a defendant in a criminal case, but access issues remain the same. Well, if fact, it's even more important that a defendant be able to attend his own trial, isn't it?

As for me, my "maybe" means I made it through that initial screening and must wait for my notice of what day I phone the courthouse. At that point, my jury pool group may or may not be required to come to the courthouse that day. I'm on call for this process through the end of 2006.

I could have opted out easily, I believe. There's the chance that writing "I use a ventilator" instead of "maybe," or "state-paid nurse will accompany me" would have been enough to get me passed over, but I'm interested in the process, if a little jaded about how welcome I might be to participate.

Being accepted onto a jury would considerably complicate this life I'm starting to adjust to, but I'm following through. Why exactly? First, there's nothing about my disability that interferes with my ability to make judgments in a courtroom even though there's a presumption in the disability question that I will be a problem citizen. I come with hired staff to help me. I should be good enough if they look at me with an open mind, eh?

And second, since a doctor's note to opt out (assuming I needed to) can cost an office visit and money to acquire, there's an inequality to the initial screening that I object to. Receiving a summons in the mail does not cost most people anything (at the initial stage -- salary loss is a whole other thing), they should be fully prepared to accommodate me when I show up. And fairly assess me like everyone else.

Crossposted at Alas, A Blog
Check there for more comments

Thursday, September 28, 2006

Things that crack me up, #8

It's a little hard to read, but the bronzed plaque on the wall of the building, just beyond the universal disable access sign reads "Walkers Funeral Home."

Originally uploaded at Flickr by Out of Ideas

Tuesday, September 26, 2006

Disability Blog Carnival begins

Penny Richards at Disability Studies, Temple, U., has decided it's time for the Disability Blog Carnival to begin. She's been posting monthly crip blog roundups, and the last one was both amazing and impressively long. And remember Goldfish's Blog Against Disablism Day? That one-time event ended up involving well over one hundred bloggers. So I think this is long overdue.

Generally, the carnival will be about disability, disability studies, and disability rights. Hopefully, people from a variety of backgrounds and disability experiences will jump in to participate.

The first carnival will be held on Thursday, October 12 at Disability Studies, Temple U. Deadline for submissions is Monday, October 9. It's already been noted that submission through the blog carnival site is problematic for those using screen-readers because of the CAPTCHA thingy, so contact Penny at her site to submit or ask further questions. Or to host a future carnival.

I'm hosting the following one, October 26, at The Gimp Parade, and I'll be posting details soon about that.


Crossposted at Alas, A Blog
Check there for more comments

Feminine products denied to disabled women in nursing homes and other institutions; Forced medication to minimize menstruation

From a notice on a disability listserv:

I am forwarding this on behalf of Feminist Response in Disability Activism (FRIDA), a newly established feminist disability rights organization based in Chicago, founded by a collective of highly skilled and committed disability rights community organizers.

On August 3, 2006, F.R.I.D.A (Feminist Response in Disability Activism) held a Town Hall meeting in Chicago for women with disabilities. One of the issues that emerged from the Town Hall was the fact that many women with disabilities living in nursing homes and institutions are:

1. Not provided with pads and tampons (even though this is required by federal regulations mandating that nursing homes provide certain supplies for residents on Medicaid or Medicare, including sanitary napkins and related supplies);

2. Told they have to buy pads and tampons out of the $30 they receive monthly from their SSI allowance (yep, the rest of their money - $603/month – goes to the nursing home and institution);

3. Not allowed to leave the facility to purchase the pads and tampons due to a “level policy” recently instituted in many Chicago nursing homes that prohibits residents from going on “family visits or independent passes” unless several strict requirements are met; and

4. As a result, some nursing home/institution staff are forcibly suppressing the periods of women with disabilities through continual DepoProvera and other methods so staff don’t have to “deal with the mess.”

DOES THIS INFURIATE YOU?

It should! Access to feminine products is a fundamental aspect of reproductive choice!

WANNA DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT?
THEN JOIN THE PAD PATROL/TAMPONS FOR JUSTICE PROJECT!
SEND US YOUR TAMPONS AND PADS!

You can help by donating a box of pads or tampons to the F.R.I.D.A. Pad Patrol. We will make sure the items get into the hands of the women with disabilities who need them.

FRIDA can also take checks or cash to pay for these items; checks should be made out to FRIDA with a note for "pads and tampons".

Send your pads/tampons to:

F.R.I.D.A. Pad Patrol Distribution Center
C/o Sarah Triano, Access Living
614 W. Roosevelt Road
Chicago, IL 60607

Know a woman with a disability who is being denied access to pads/tampons? Then send her our way and we’ll set her up!
At the FRIDA website, they explain why this isn't simply a matter to be put to legal action:
In response to some questions about the Pad Patrol, FRIDA is fully aware that in cases where nursing homes or institutions fail to provide sanitary napkins as dictated by federal law, legal recourse is necessary in case where informal negotiation is not successful. We are in full agreement that systemic change is the only way to ensure long term justice. We do, however, feel that systemic change can be achieved on multiple levels. Some folks have asked whether, in distributing sanitary napkins and tampons to nursing homes, we would enable the nursing homes to continue evading the law.

Our viewpoint is as follows... First, in conducting outreach for a pad drive (which has reached as far as Australia) we are exposing a problem in a system, a problem that many feel a personal connection to. Anyone would be shocked by the idea that someone would have to blow their whole allowance on sanitary napkins or else sit in a crust of their own blood. Add to that the fact that showers are often regulated and you must bathe on a schedule. Sometimes, by relating to something so graphically everyday, we can push awareness of the problem to a critical mass of public opinion.

Second, the larger problem beyond the lack of sanitary napkins and the suppression of periods is the entire system of nursing homes and institutions in which so many people with disabilities become trapped. While the average person will be shocked by the pad issue, they will hopefully also learn a little to care about the wider problems of institutionalization. FRIDA feels, as does ADAPT and many other groups, that we would much prefer to live in our own homes with community supports for our needs, rather than in nursing homes, institutions or group homes. In the end, we see that a feminist issue is really a human issue.

Third, and maybe most pragmatically, the woman who is having her period in 3 days cannot wait for a lawsuit to be settled in five years. There is a final question which FRIDA needs to answer to the public, and that is whether this problem really exists, and whether there are women who are willing to speak out about this issue. There are in fact such women but at this time their identities are protected by confidentiality. FRIDA is working to identify women who are willing to speak out. If you or someone you know is willing to testify and let people know what's really going on with women's rights in nursing homes and institutions, get in touch....
More contact information available at the FRIDA site.

Crossposted at Alas, A Blog
Check there for more comments

Monday, September 25, 2006

"Is your life hard or super-hard?"

My aunt and uncle visited from Wyoming today and I showed them the drawings and pictures their daughter's third-grade students sent me last Spring. There are two series of letters since I replied once and then they all wrote back, practicing their cursive and sharing weird stories, silly jokes, and curiosity about my life. Most of the letters begin "Dear Cousin Kay," which is sweet and cracks me up.

To their first set of questions, I explained how I get help with dressing and using the toilet. I answered questions about my favorite sport, team, color, children's book and all that. Also, that's what my self-portrait was all about. My favorite poem of the many the kids sent was this one by Gunnar:

Roses are red,
violets are blue,
I bet anyone would take a bullet for you.
Scary, yet sweet, right?

I replied to every disability-related question they posed and their second set of letters showed more curiosity.
"How do you get the tube down your throat?"

"How do you get into your scooter?"

"Did you know some electric chairs are run by movements of eyeballs?"
And this one:
"Is your life hard or super-hard?"
For some reason, that last always makes me think of this lovely little encounter I had in a grocery store in Tempe, Arizona, years ago. I was just a couple blocks from my apartment, shopping early so the short ride home in the heat wouldn't spoil anything, when a woman stepped toward me.

She had a little girl with her, about three, and the mother said, "Excuse me, do you mind if I take a moment with you to explain to my daughter about your scooter? She's curious about it."

The girl stood shyly nearby, trading wide-eyed looks with me.

"Um, okay."

The woman squatted so we were all about the same height, tapped a finger very gently on the top edge of the metal basket that hangs at the front of my scooter, and told her daughter how some people don't use their legs or need to sit when they're tired but still have things to do. She noted that the scooter was a very good thing because it helped me get around.

It was a very brief encounter. The mother didn't intrude further by asking me to answer questions or explain about myself. She let her daughter look for a heartbeat or two, we traded smiles all around, then she thanked me and we all moved on. The little girl looked back at me a few times, then they were gone.

This one encounter stands opposed to the dozens and dozens where I've heard a parent shush a child's question or cover their pointing finger as they want to know what the deal is with me. Those parents ducked their heads in embarrassment, or a few gave me a "sorry about that" smile. All left the impression that I should not be talked about or approached.

"Is your life hard or super-hard?"

I have no idea how to answer that simply. I'd never say "super-hard," though to be fair, I know at least one family member who would say "super-hard" because of their relationship to me. But somehow I love the question. Maybe because by itself it says so much.


Crossposted at Alas, A Blog
Check for more comments there

On-going blogroll changes

I'm in the process of changing my blogroll, mostly because my bookmarks are out of control and I lost them all recently so I want to use my blogroll to keep current fascinations handy. But also because I keep finding new disability bloggers who are saying interesting stuff.

My categorization is a pretty fuzzy division of gimp bloggers and other people. The former is only used for people claiming disability as a part of their lives and writing more about it than their med changes. That is, they comment on the social experience of disability. If disability doesn't appear to be a focus of their blog and I still wanted to list them, they are in the latter category, as are some parents of disabled children who may write eloquently about disability experiences but don't claim the identity for themselves.

Some links are only on the blogroll for me. I'm still updating. Please let me know if there are errors to correct.

Sunday, September 24, 2006

Famous crips and disability rights

Looking back at the disability press and its coverage of the FDR Memorial and Chris Reeve's post-injury politics, there's clearly a different perspective of these famous disabled men than the mainstream media presents. The topic of stereotypical representation of disability by the media and newly-disabled celebrities themselves rather than news about disability rights ignites activists to raise their voices. Each of the following links (save, perhaps, the last one) are worth reading in their entirety.

FDR

After the FDR Memorial in Washington, D.C., had been unveiled, there was an outcry from disability organizations that the wheelchair Roosevelt used daily all through his presidency was nowhere visible. A 1997 article in Ragged Edge (then called Electric Edge online, since the 'zine-like print version of Disability Rag was still available) questions "FDR: Rolling in his grave?" :

The controversy among crips is this: Is it great that NOD [National Organization on Disability] is calling Roosevelt a hero for crips, and using him as what one person called a "'culture icon"? Or is it misplaced praise for a man who really went to great efforts to pass as non-disabled?

"It is important to Americans with disabilities -- and important as a symbol of how American society perceives its disabled people --that the Memorial depict the man as he was: tall, strong, heroic and disabled. Don't let them steal our hero!" Hugh Gallagher, author of FDR's Splendid Deception, has said. He has been liberally quoted by supporters of the NOD campaign.

[Blind reporter Kathi] Wolfe worries that the effort to turn Roosevelt into "a crip icon just because he was a crip" contradicts history. "He wasn't a disability hero," she insists. He wasn't "a crip advocate like Helen Keller, who worked to better conditions for blind and deaf-blind people and veterans who had disabilities -- as well as being a feminist and against racism."

Here's the Congressional hoopla that led to adding a statue to the Memorial depicting Roosevelt in his wheelchair. It was a rare triumph that the voices of disabled people were heard and effected change, though likely the biggest reason for their success was Roosevelt's political history of serving oppressed minorities. That aspect of his personal history tipped the scale to support people with disabilities.


Chris Reeve

Along with instantly becoming the most famous, most quoted disabled person on the planet, Chris Reeve was always a lightning rod for political controversy and frustration among disability activists.

In letters to the editor of Electric Edge, readers vent about Reeve:

Due to his high profile, it's no surprise that much ink is devoted to Christopher Reeve. Our world has collided with that of an A-list celebrity in a way that we could never have anticipated, so it is inevitable that we react to him in the Rag, Mouth, Accent, and all of our other usual forums.

Readers themselves may have witnessed or experienced firsthand the myriad thoughts and emotions in the two or three years immediately following such a massively imposed change as is caused by a spinal cord injury. In the clinical model, there are textbook pages written about a pattern of denial, anger, and depression. Christopher Reeve is, so far, the most powerful, influential person to go through this experience. All his talk of The Cure is nothing new; convert gimps have been singing this tune for years. His use of this crap is now drawing the attention it craves because he's the one saying it. We're all horrified because he can undermine the life work of hundreds of advocates in just one speech.

Writing about her 1996 experiences as a South Carolina delegate at the DNC, Harriet McBryde Johnson was on the floor when Reeve addressed the Convention:

They've been building up to tonight's major prime-time speaker, and now they're introducing him: Christopher Reeve. When the introduction ends, the hall lights are dimmed. Onto the stage he rolls and then sits, gleaming under a dramatic spotlight. The crowd is on its feet, wild with welcome, with excitement, with awe. Yes. They're awed by the mere sight of this man sitting, smiling, looking around. He hasn't said a word and they're going crazy. It's real. There's no prompting from the DNC staffers.

I'm in the middle of 60,000 drop-jawed souls, witness to a late 20th-century Pentecost. Physically, Reeve is way above the 60,000, isolated by that spotlight. Symbolically, he's the object of devotion, not a member of the fellowship. As Reeve and the crowd are having their communion, I feel completely out of it.

He's speaking now. I try to listen, but things have become surreal. I look up at Reeve.

I look up and I see ... a ventriloquist's dummy.

How could I think such a thing? I'm horrified. If these worshippers knew my thoughts, they'd tear me up and throw me to the dogs.

I tell myself Reeve's playing out the very peculiar drama of his life the best way he knows how. He's being used, but what can he do? This is a new role for him. He has no script.

But, there he is, Charlie McCarthy.

Where is this image coming from? No quad I've ever known has impressed me this way. I'm pretty quad-like myself. Maybe it's the staging that objectifies him. Or maybe it's the contrast between his persona and the physical vigor we expect on the podium of a national political convention.

No. It's the face. That smile running from ear to ear. The face is commonly considered animated, but I see something ... wooden.

I'm warmed by the sudden sunburst of TV lights; a camera crew is setting up. They want the crip reaction to Reeve's speech.

"Beth, can you block me?"

She stands between me and the camera. The crew establishes a new sightline and she leans right into it. They call someone on their cell phones.

Reeve's measured syllables are perfectly timed with his mechanical puffs of air. The pauses make what he's saying seem important. Even in the dim lights I can see the faces in the crowd, transfixed by the sight of him, fascinated by the sound of him. The gleaming presence. The ventilator whoosh. The body propped up in dress-up clothes.

The camera crew realizes that Beth's not going away. They load up their gear and head elsewhere.

Moments later, there's a woman in a wheelchair on the giant TV screen in the rafters. She's scowling. Quick cut to a nondisabled white woman, tears streaming across a smiling face, backlit to highlight her moment of inspiration. The lights pick out a variety of delegates. White, black, old, young, male, female. Everything but crips.

It's melodrama. The kind of Telethon melodrama I tried to ignore in my childhood and youth, tried to ignore until finally I got angry enough to put up a picket line. How could they bring the Telethon here, to a national political convention? This is my party. How could they do it?

The speech ends and the lights come on. As emotion runs through this vast arena, I'm left cold. I can't possibly feel what they feel. Now they'll want to see me the way they see Reeve, a disability object, presumably tragic but brave, someone to make them grateful they're not like us.

I tell myself I'm overreacting, but I'm almost shaking when I join the line at the elevators. A misty-eyed stranger kneels down beside me and clutches the hand I'm trying to drive my chair with.

"Wasn't that just wonderful?"

"No," I blurt out, "it wasn't at all wonderful. I thought it was pretty bad."

"Well, I thought it was wonderful." She springs up and pivots away with an angry shoe-clop on the hard floor. How dare I refuse to be inspired?

On the bus ride back, everyone rhapsodizes about how inspired they are. Gone is the usual friendly chitchat. I stare at the black floor mat and withdraw from the group that has set me apart.

We get to our rooms, way past ready to collapse into our beds, but there's a blinking light on our phone. A message from Mike Ervin: "Hi. Some people from Chicago are having a press conference tomorrow to deal with the Christopher Reeve, er, problem ... "

Beth writes down the details. We'll be there.

Continuing in Part II, Johnson describes the disability rights media response:

Christopher Reeve's speech has left us with a problem. By putting him up on the podium the way they did last night, the DNC has fed--and fed upon--the harmful disability stereotypes I'm here, in part, to fight. When I arrive for the disability caucus and find the gang from Chicago outside the door passing out flyers, I'm overjoyed. The flyer, by Mike Ervin and Anna Stonum, deals pointedly with Reeve.

Local TV news shows up. They shoot video of the group and then zoom in on my red delegate badge, proof of my authenticity as a genuine Democrat from the Deep South. Up here, I guess, I'm exotic. They set up lights. Mike and I agree to talk.

There's a lot of noise and I can barely hear what Mike's saying. Is he really calling Reeve a whiner? No, not exactly, but close. I think Mike might be going a bit too far, but a wave of gratitude washes over me. He's a champion who's fighting not Reeve but the people who put him on that platform.

Another 1997 Electric Edge article asks about Chris Reeve "What's it gonna take?" Here's writer Pat Williams:
Some gimps I know say, "give Chris Reeve a break! He's new to gimpdom. He doesn't realize there's more than Cure out there." These gimps want to believe that after Reeve's been a gimp for a few years, he'll get on to disability rights; he'll speak out on the importance of access, attendant services, all that.

But I don't buy that. I think Reeve knows exactly what he's doing. He knows you can't talk about cure on the one hand and access on the other; he knows people see them as contradictory. He was drawn to the American Paralysis Association, he said, because "they are dedicated solely to finding a cure for paralysis, nothing less. I liked that idea," Reeve went on. "They're not into lower sidewalks and better wheelchairs."

"Suppose Chris Reeve were Barney Frank":

Suppose he wrote an autobiography about seeking a cure for his homosexuality? Suppose he started the Barney Frank foundation to cure homosexuals? Suppose he held a television special to raise money to find a cure for homosexuality?

Suppose Barbara Walters interviewed him on 20/20 on his work to find a cure for homosexuality?

Imagine it.

A 2000 Ragged Edge response to Reeve's Superbowl ad where a digitally manipulated Reeve got out of his wheelchair and walked:

With an unemployment rate of over 70%, the vast majority of people with disabilities could not begin to be considered consumers of this product. But the ad was not created with the disability market in mind; its target was people with money. It unabashedly pulled at heartstrings with an in-your-face, no-holds-barred "disability is bad" message. In the tradition of Jerry Lewis, this ad meant to bring tears to the eyes of football fans during their favorite game, courtesy of the incredibly courageous former Superman.

The ad may have done more damage than Jerry himself: unlike the telethon, this "disability is bad" message aired during one of the year's most watched TV events. Nuveen paid $4 million for that minute of airtime.

At the same link, several disability activists speak out. Paul Longmore:

"The opportunities in this new world for people with disabilities have not been created by technology alone. They are the result of several generations of intensifying disability rights activism that has won passage of laws protecting us from discrimination and guaranteeing us access. . . . We need to ask why society keeps giving Reeve platforms to propagate his views but excludes the disability rights perspective."
Tom Deniston of Accessible Design Associates:
"If I had pulled a Christopher Reeve 30 years ago, none of at least 1,000 buildings would be accessible today."
Charles Krauthammer:
"In Reeve's view, reality is a psychological crutch. His propaganda to that effect undermines those -- particularly the young and newly injured -- who are struggling to face reality, master it and make a life for themselves from their wheelchairs."
New Mobility editor Barry Corbet writes:
Alas, poor Christopher Reeve. He can do no right.

In his quest for cure, he's been roundly criticized by a large and vocal sector of disability activists for obscuring our core message of rights, equal opportunity and dignity.

Alas, poor Christopher Reeve. He can do no wrong.

In his quest for cure, he's raised millions of dollars for research, elevated public awareness for all people with disabilities and brought hope where once there was none. He's become Saint Christopher and there's not much his detractors can do about it.

Ted Gilmer's 2002 New Mobility interview with Reeve presents a detailed picture of the man and his advocacy while also subtly showing how alienated he is from the average quadriplegic's life.

In 2003, Mary Johnson's book Make Them Go Away: Clint Eastwood, Christopher Reeve and the Case Against Disability Rights explains how Reeve's efforts dangerously undermine disability rights.

In a less critical 2004 article about his death Ragged Edge editor Mary Johnson notes:

We are awaking today to a week in which we will read and hear all sorts of encomiums to Christopher Reeve the actor, the brave man who kept on in the face of tragedy, the man who became an icon for stem cell research.

What we will not hear are tributes to the man who changed America's understanding of disability discrimination, who put a face on the problems this country causes wheelchair users by the persistent denials of access and accommodation.

Had he lived, Chris Reeve might one day still have come to symbolize to the American public the fight millions of us must wage in order to get out of institutions, into homes of our own, into jobs, into the public environment. Many of us wanted to believe he would someday embrace the rights issue much as he had embraced, as a nondisabled man, many progressive causes.

I've been getting a lot of heat for daring to criticize Andrea Dworkin's public writing about disability. Thinking critically about who the widely disparate disabled are and how we're portrayed isn't something I decided to play at just to "slam Dworkin." I didn't have a blog during the FDR Memorial issue or until the very end Chris Reeve's life, but I did write a letter to the editor of my college paper about the Memorial:
This letter is in response to the Tuesday State Press editorial stating that FDR should be remembered for his deeds, not his disability. While this newspaper has certainly made more blatant errors recently with regard to group stereotypes, the editorial speaks to the lack of support for diverse groups and their experiences.

It was widely known during Roosevelt's time in office that he used a wheelchair, and buildings all over Washington were equipped with ramps so he could come and go. These ramps were all removed when he died, attesting to the fact that because his disability was hidden, the access needs of other disabled Americans remained unacknowledged for a couple more decades. No, Roosevelt did not want himself portrayed in a wheelchair, but neither did he want any kind of memorial in his honor. We already have the memorial; now the challenge is to depict Roosevelt honestly and in a way meaningful for future generations.

The history and experiences of other stereotyped and marginalized groups have not emerged without struggle. Recognition of both contributions to society and discrimination from society have been hard won for African Americans, Native Americans, women, gays and lesbians, etc. While the editorial board acknowledged that people with disabilities are often pitied and patronized, they fail to truly examine Roosevelt as a president with a disability. He chose to hide his disability because of discriminatory attitudes. As President Clinton has said: "He knew it was necessary at the time because he knew he had the capacity to be president, and he didn't want some artificial perception to keep him from being president."

In addition to Clinton, former Presidents Bush, Carter, and Ford -- as well as 16 of Roosevelt's grandchildren -- support a statue depicting him in a wheelchair. History does not change, but what we see as important about our past continues to evolve. Who our heroes and role models are for the future has thankfully expanded. As the editorial states, "FDR was an inspiration to many," but perhaps not "regardless of his physical state." Perhaps his experiences with polio are part of why he was so great, and why he could say "We have nothing to fear but fear itself."

Incidentally, the new statue would not cost taxpayers a dime. The National Organization on Disability has pledged to raised the necessary funds.

And Reeve is mentioned anecdotally throughout this blog.

There aren't many famous disabled people because disabled people don't get enough media coverage to be recognized as the political activists and political writers they are. It ends up being famous people who become impaired and thrust into a brighter spotlight that society views as our spokespeople -- mostly spokesmen. Without criticism of their unwitting role in our continued oppression, their stereotypical messages go unchallenged. It's not enough to critique the media when the public turns to these celebrities, the roles of the celebrities must be examined too.

Crossposted on Alas, A Blog
Check there for more comments