Monday, January 15, 2007

Blind Rage and the legacy of Helen Keller

It wasn't until I began reading Georgina Kleege's Blind Rage: Letters to Helen Heller that I realized my own ambivalence to the deaf-blind female icon of disability. Written as a series of letters interrogating Helen Keller and the written record she left behind of her life, Kleege explores what has been left unsaid, altered for public consumption, and molded to fit the appropriate image of what a woman without hearing and sight was expected to be in the late-19th and early-20th centuries.

A blind woman herself, Kleege fuels what could be called either creative nonfiction or a feminist critique of Helen Keller's life and autobiographic writings with the frustration and anger of a lifetime of comparisons to Keller -- the saintly example of a proper, over-achieving disabled girl famous all over the world. I learned last year that critiques of famous public figures with disabilities from a feminist/disability rights perspective are just about impossible to find, so this book is especially welcome and needed as a contribution to both feminist history and disability studies.

Kleege's approach in questioning Keller's life is a distinctly feminist one. An awareness of "the gaze" exists throughout the book, and though it is primarily a nondisabled gaze upon the body and actions of a blind-deaf woman, as a disabled woman myself I find this inextricably intertwined with the familiar male gaze of feminist theory and critique. (And Michel Foucault's medical gaze, as well.) After all, the nondisabled gaze upon Keller would have been quite different were she a deaf-blind boy and man instead of a girl and woman. Ability and gender are inseparable in the complex personal interactions of disabled women within a society that privileges both male and able-bodiedness.

The book is divided into four sections: Consciousness on Trial, Full Body Contact, Working the Pump, and The Hand's Memory. Roughly, these cover Helen's childhood attainment of language, adult relationships, making a living through her famous story, and old age.

I'd read part of Consciousness on Trial a couple years ago as part of the anthology Points of Contact: Disability, Art and Culture which had at least one other essay that examined the power of the sighted gaze upon blind folks and intrigued me as a sort of colonization of disabled bodies. That colonization leads to assumptions about the minds of disabled people and what they are and are not capable of as the Other -- we've seen this public process recently in the case of Ashley X.

At age eleven, Keller wrote a story for the man who headed the Perkins School for the Blind, and he proudly published it as an example of the excellence of the school and his young deaf-blind prodigy. But the story turned out to be strikingly similar to a story Keller had no doubt been read at age eight, during the summer shortly after she began to understand the handsigning teacher Annie Sullivan used to communicate with her. She was learning new words, language, at an astonishing rate. Communicating exhuberantly. Absorbing new ideas like a sponge.

The school put Helen on trial for plagiarism, attempting to discern if Sullivan was honestly relaying the true achievements of her famous student or exaggerating her capabilities. Without "Teacher" at her side, young Helen faced a panel of unidentified men and women she could neither see nor hear who interrogated her about the complex concepts of knowledge and memory. Kleege imagines the details of the scene and the aftereffects it had on Keller's confidence.

Kleege also unflinchingly explores Keller's life through these nondisabled preconceptions and doubts of what a deaf-blind woman can be:

So here it is. Here's what I've come to ask. Were you a hoax, Helen? A fake? There, I've typed the words. Forgive me, Helen. It's a betrayal, I know. My stomach feels tight and slimy. My flesh is pulling back from my skin. But I really need to know. Because as I'm sure you've thought from time to time, maybe every hour of every day, it's what they think. Them -- the ablebodied, the hearing and seeing majority, the Normals, as some of us call them today. They may play lip service to your achievements, may laud all you accomplished, hold you up as an example to children: "Why can't you be more like Helen Keller?" But behind all those words there's a doubt. Maybe you were a hoax, a fake, a fraud. Yes, Teacher tamed you. She cleaned you up and made you docile. She taught you how to shake hands and smile for cameras. She taught you to make your little hand gestures, and to mumble on cue. But who's to say you were really saying what she said you were? (p.31)
What it would mean to be a "hoax" in this context is tenuously dependent on what the nondisabled public believes is the distance between their able-bodied expectations of who Helen was and all that she and Teacher offered about who she was. As Kleege makes clear, what they offered the public had a great deal to do with what the public was ready or willing to accept. Still, as interest in her as a Vaudeville "act" proves, Helen's very livelihood was dependent on the public's awe and borderline disbelief of everything she was. A charismatic storyteller, Helen (mostly with Sullivan) toured Vaudeville stages for years as a means of financial support. The novelty of her being considered a being of intelligence and consciousness is what made her a ticket-selling act. Or, more pessimistically stated, the continuing doubt of her consciousness and humanity are what drew the crowds.

With a lifetime of confounding expectations of the nondisabled public, fielding questions implicit and explicit about capability, Kleege understands how the pressure effects Keller:
It's the doubt, Helen. You know about the doubt. It's that nagging unease at the back of your mind whenever anything good happens. You're in school and you wonder, "Is the A on this paper a gift? Would a Normal student get an A for this?" You get a job, but you wonder, "Do they really think I'm qualified or is this just some sort of affirmative action quota?"

....Of course you know about the doubt. The plagiarism case seems to have been the precise moment in your life when the doubt first took hold. Because you must have understood that they would never have done it to a Normal child. If you'd been a Normal child, they would have said, "So someone read you the story, and you remember the story but don't remember the person reading it to you. OK. I can see how that could happen. Sounds reasonable to me." But because it was you, and because seeing and hearing had nothing to do with your experience of the world, they couldn't let it go at that. (pp. 33-4)
As a specific interrogation of the icon Helen Keller, Blind Rage is deeply compelling. Kleege speculates about Helen's adult relationships and possible romantic connections. She explores the complex power struggles undoubtedly present in her lifelong association with Sullivan, who was a recovered blind person deeply aware of the threatening abysses of poverty and dejection awaiting helpless disabled women. She questions to what degree the medium of Sullivan for so much of Helen's communication, and the enterprise of being such a famous person, affected who Helen was and who she appeared to be.

On a broader level, Kleege's book works as a discussion of how history remembers those who can't always speak for themselves, those living under the shadow of monolithic stereotypes of what they can be, and those whose consciousness and humanity are relentlessly doubted.

_____________________________________________

Visual description of photos: The three photos above came from a simple Google search for images of Helen Keller.The first is her in profile as a child, the second is of her as an adult with Annie Sullivan next to her signing into her hand. The last is a portrait of Keller as an elderly woman, looking directly into the camera. It seems by far the most honest and unstaged and, to me, interesting of the three.

Patston on Ashley

This is short, but worth reading.

Sunday, January 14, 2007

Teaching "The Elephant Man"

Conspicuously missing from yesterday's slumgullion: Stephen at Planet of the Blind briefly reviews the movie by David Lynch and how it addresses questions in the news lately about disabled folk and the medical community.

Saturday, January 13, 2007

Saturday Slumgullion #23

Flea at One Good Thing answers an email with questions about raising a child with obsessive compulsive behavior. Scroll down to the "December" heading for just this part if you must.

An old post by Chris Clarke at Creek Running North on "Wheelchair Invisibility":

I got Herb situated at the section where his chair could slide underneath, and we chatted for a while until the bright college kid waiter came to take our order.

Twenty bucks says that any disabled folks reading this know exactly what happened next.
What part of "Nothing About Us Without Us" don't they understand? Kicking the gimp off the panel in Camden, UK.

A Scottish charity launches ad campaign comparing folks with Down Syndrome to pets. Their rationale seems to be that since more Britons give to animal charities than charities for the disabled, this will prick people's consciences. Or something.

In Sydney, Australia, "Have Wheels, Will Travel. It's a Joke."

A story of disability and marriage in Nigeria. Cringe-worthy English and attitude here, but hey, a detailed story of living with a disability in Nigeria:
Mr. Pam narrated that after the accident, there were various forms of challenges especially from his parents and few friends who saw no reason in marrying a lady that could not make use of her legs, adding that his insistence to forge ahead with the relationship was followed by denial and rejection from his family and some friends.

Pam stated that after the accident, he always realised that she could not use her legs anytime because she could no more escort him as she used to do, stressing that in spite of the unfortunate situation, nothing changed concerning her character and attitude towards him.
Performer Claire Cunningham on her dancing and artist's philosophy:
"The idea I put forward was about finding a performance style that used the abilities created by my disability - the upper body strength I have as a result of using crutches. To me that meant exploring aerial techniques, because, like with my crutches, I'd be bearing my weight on my arms. I thought I would concentrate on using equipment like ropes, slings or maybe trapeze. See if there were ways to make my crutches part of that equipment. Maybe devise a performance piece. And in the process, through Waterbaby - the company I've formed with my colleague Linda Payne - perhaps create movement training programmes for physically disabled individuals."
"For every fatality in Iraq, there are 16 injuries." An op-ed on the war from the Hartford Courant.

New Jersey may remove ableist language from state constitution. The language in question was added by amendment in 1844: "No idiot or insane person shall enjoy the right of suffrage."

A special ed student is told by his school principal that he can't compete in a spelling bee because he doesn't "have the brains":
The controversy at the East Flatbush school began in December when Lamarre, who won his class spelling bee, was declared the school's winner after no other class held a competition.

Lamarre got a laminated "school champion" certificate, but he says that later that day, Brown told him he couldn't move to the next level because he was in special education classes.

Friday, January 12, 2007

I am tired

Because fear and hatred of disabled people hides in people's hearts in the same way as sexism, transphobia and racism:

Ashley is not a "disabled" person that can enjoy a stroll down the mall for social stimulation. A 3 month old mind cannot do such a thing.

Personally, I'm tired of liberal whiners thinking they are better than everyone else.

The word disabled gets used way too much. If you can make your own decisions and think for youself, then guess what, you're not disabled.

Ashley on the other hand can do not of these things, her I would considered disabled.
Because so many people deny the slippery slope, but during the Schiavo case a common argument to silence the voices of disabled people was that Terri wasn't disabled but brain-dead, and now a common argument to deny the voices of disabled people is to claim Ashley's level of consciousness (higher than Terri's) is comparable to a turnip and also irrelevant to our experiences:
The problem is modern medicine can keep a turnip alive for many years i.e. 100 years ago this child would have died at a very young age as mother nature intended. But since we have to play God and keep the turnip alive then we also get to play God and choose when/how to trim the turnip when it grows in a way we deem unfit. Basically this treatment is ENTIRELY for the parents benefit and as such it does help the parents but please drop the delusion that it helps the vegetable because the vegetable would be best off with as little pain inflicted as possible i.e. let the vegetable die.
Because I know some supposed "turnips" online who slay me with their sharp intelligence:

Please remember that disabled women are women, too. So much of these discussions go back to a description of disabled people as being passive recipients of care from “mostly women”, leaving disabled women totally invisible in the whole thing. I’ve seen really good feminist disability writing (try Jenny Morris), but feminist writing that approaches disability primarily as a caregiving issue isn’t generally it — it casts women as the victims of the existence of disabled people (including disabled women) and usually proposes horrifically oppressive solutions to the problem of our existence.

Because this isn't about just one child:
The action is in response to the AMA’s sanction of the “Ashley Treatment” through its publication of the original case article in the Archives of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine case. This AMA owned-journal went so far as to call for further “study” of the issue by subjecting more children to the same drastic surgeries and follow them over time.
Because there are other signs that society is becoming more impatient with the existence of disabled folks:
For example, Dr. Goldberg said, a 29-year-old woman and her partner might now choose amniocentesis instead of a blood test. In the past, the more invasive procedure was seldom recommended for younger women because it could sometimes result in miscarriage. Now the risk is considered to be quite low, and in any event, Dr. Goldberg said, for some couples “losing a normal pregnancy secondary to the procedure is not as problematic as the birth of a Down syndrome child, so they’re willing to take that risk.”
Because so many of our supposed allies seem unable to listen or offer real support beyond their own fears and agendas:
If I were this girl’s caregiver, my worst fear would be that there would be a chance one day that I may not be around to care for her. And that she might end up in hospice care, where she could be sexually abused and end up pregnant. And that because she’s white, there would be a lot of antagonism towards aborting said pregnancy to spare her the misery and that a bunch of “pro-lifers” would stake on the hospital, Terri Schiavo-style, enamored of the idea of a pregnant white woman without a real will of her own. In other words, the perfect baby incubator. There’d be moaning and wailing and sentimental rhapsodizing about getting a “miracle” baby out of this poor girl. Doctors, under all this pressure, would cave because it’s not like she can really do anything about it. And then the baby would be born and everyone would be all in raptures and Reader’s Digest would have an article about it and Ashley would be reduced from a human being to a baby incubator. So you better believe I’d want to just circumvent that. This situation has nothing to do with eugenics unless you’re paranoid enough to think that the genetically normal offspring of college-educated white people are a target.
Because of the disrespect:
While I certainly don't envy your situation and feel blessed that I am lucky to not be disabled, I am sickened by your rantings. Who exactly do you think you are? Your disability is NOT an entitlement to place judgement upon others.

95% of the posters that agree with you are only agreeing out of PITY. They are too short-sighted to see that your particular situation, contrasted with Ashley's, is like night and day. Instead, they ignorantly assume that your ridiculous 'I am Ashley' statement is true simply because you both have severe disabilities.

Why don't you reveal your true motivation? It must be nice to have a link to your blog on CNN, right? Enjoy your fifteen minutes of fame but, seriously, quit with this betrayal nonsense. I mean, come on, to refer to her parents as "parents" (I'm referring to the quotation marks)? Are you actually advocating that they did what they did for any reason other than absolute love, caring and adoration of their daughter?

You may be disabled, but you're still a judgemental, self-righteous prick.
Because the weird convergence of attention and disregard is a kind of quiet violence:
Maybe, just maybe, bloggers who are disabled don’t really want to discuss shit like this over and over and over again–especially when people are not just discussing their right to access or something like that (where the presumption of humanity deserving of life is at least present), but are actually challenging disabled peoples very right to live as autonomous respected human beings. Maybe bloggers who are disabled really don’t feel like debating whether or not they are “burdens” worthy of extreme forms of violence just to suit able-bodied people. Maybe they aren’t interested in debating whether or not they have a right to be alive.

The 6th Disability Carnival is up!

Head over to The Life and Times of Emma to see the carnival's collection of writings on relationships and disability. It's divided into "Able bodied people writing about their relationships with disabled people," "Parents of Kids with Disabilities Sharing Their Experiences," and "People with Disabilities." Lots to occupy yourself with reading over the weekend.

The next disability carnival is back at creator Penny's Disability Studies, Temple U. and the theme, should you choose to accept it, is "disability history" and "disability and the arts." The show opens on Thursday, January 25, but the submission deadline is Monday, January 21. You can nominate your own or someone else's writing through the carnival submission form, or because the form doesn't seem to be friendly to the sight-impaired, just email the submission to Penny or leave a comment on the blog.

Thursday, January 11, 2007

On the Chicago protest against AMA

From the Associated Press

A report from protestor and FRIDA member Amber Smock on the events of the day:

We targeted the AMA because it sanctioned the "Ashley Treatment" by publishing the original article describing it in one of its publications, the Archive of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine. In addition, the publication's editors recommended that the way to find out if the "Ashley Treatment" was beneficial was to perform it on other children.

Our demands were threefold. First, we asked that the AMA's Committee on Ethical and Judicial Affairs meet with a team of advocates from the disability community to review the case. Second, we asked that the AMA issue a formal statement of support for MiCASSA. Third, we asked that the AMA issue a statement condemning the "Ashley Treatment" for other children.

On Thursday afternoon, our coalition met up at a coffee shop, about twenty strong. (FYI having coffee before an action is a really, really, really good idea!) We would be joined by others at the site. We lined up and proceeded to the building housing the AMA offices. We arrived and attempted to enter through the accessible entrance. Security guards blocked the majority of the group from entering, citing the "fact" that the lobby was private property. Our group began entering through the *other* accessible door. Most of us made it in. Reporters had already arrived and had begun attempting to interview the protesters. Our negotiating team began attempting to meet with AMA CEO Michael Maves.

After several minutes of attempting to gather in the lobby, our team decided to move outside because we were losing the opportunity to get recorded on TV cameras. Our negotiating team remained inside to continue fighting for access (the Michael Maves kind). Once we moved outside, we faced a barrage of TV cameras, as well as print and radio reporters. The media presence was truly incredible and our coalition had worked very hard to achieve that. We whipped out our protest signs, which included slogans such as "Operations Not Accommodations" and "AMA: Stop Medical Oppression of Women." (Thanks to Sharon Lamp, who is DA QUEEN of good slogans!) Gary Arnold then led the group in a skit on how to apply for an ethics job with the AMA.

Then, while we waited for news of negotiations, we chanted and chanted and CHANTED!!! The police wanted us to move away from the building and gave us three warnings. The media were complaining they could not interview us, so we went ahead and moved farther away, so we got interviews and plus, the people looking down from the highrise building had a good look at the disabled people making a stink on the ground! The employees sure had an exciting day. Many came down to the lobby to observe what was going on.

After about 45 minutes, our negotiating team came away with a deal: apparently the CEO was on a plane somewhere and unreachable (so they say...). His secretary committed to securing us a meeting with her boss next week. You know what will happen if that doesn't happen....!!!!! So we will be following up with all of you for your support if they don't meet our promises!

At that point, we had a load of media coverage and as much of a win as we could secure before the paratransit rides arrives. So we called it a victory and chanted some more, yeah you know what it was..."The people united will never be defeated!"
The best thing about this action is the AP covered us with a photographer too, so the story is going out across the nation...and I just got word CNN included our action in a story. The other best thing about the action was the people who turned out and worked to get this organized. The energy was fantastic! Amazing! The best thing to happen to feminist/disability rights in a long, freakin' time!
Local Chicago TV news coverage, complete with video of the protestors.

Bush won't renominate anti-disability rights judge for appeals court

The Associated Press reports that:

In a concession to the Senate's new Democratic majority, President Bush won't rename four controversial federal appeals court nominees whose confirmations were blocked last year, Republican officials said last week.

William Haynes, William G. Myers III and Michael Wallace all asked to have their appointments withdrawn, these officials said. Judge Terrence Boyle was informed of the White House's decision, according to an ally.

In 2005, Boyle, a federal judge in North Carolina, was noted by the People for the American Way as being unfit for promotion to the federal Court of Appeals for several reasons. From the PFAW website:
Judge Boyle’s record is troubling in at least two distinct ways. First, he has been reversed frequently by the Fourth Circuit, one of the most conservative appeals courts in the entire country. In fact, he has been reversed considerably more frequently than has the average district court judge in the Fourth Circuit and around the country. He has also been reversed an average of more than twice as often per year as any other federal district court judge President Bush has nominated to the appellate bench. Such a high record of reversals, especially considering that Judge Boyle has frequently been reversed for making the same or similar errors, calls into question his ability as a jurist. And his apparent effort to obscure his record of reversals in his answers under oath to questions from the Senate Judiciary Committee, as detailed below, raises extremely serious concerns.

Second, Judge Boyle’s record reveals a troubling history of espousing a damaging neo-federalist philosophy from the bench that is particularly harmful to civil rights. He has been very aggressive in supporting “states’ rights” views in cases that criticize Congress’s authority to protect individuals from discrimination committed by state agencies. Moreover, a number of his decisions have been specifically hostile to civil rights, including with respect to cases brought by people with disabilities as well as in redistricting and race and sex discrimination cases, many of which have been reversed. And he has been reversed several times in important cases concerning campaign finance.
Boyle's troubling record includes the case of the United States v. North Carolina, an employment discrimination case about the state's gender bias in hiring correctional officers at men's prisons. Among the many conclusions Boyle made that basically rejected the federal right to apply Title VII to a state, he declared that North Carolina's "culture" was a valid reason for disparate employment practices.

And Boyle's hostility toward the ADA has been well documented by rulings hostile to both the federal law and disabled persons' civil rights. In Pierce v. King, Boyle denied the ADA applies to state prisons because they do not have a "substantial effect" on interstate commerce. The plaintiff in the case filed an ADA employment discrimination case against NC because the state prison did not offer him accommodations for prison work that could lead to time off for good behavior. Boyle went further, saying that Congress had no authority at all to apply the ADA to states because, unlike other civil rights laws, the ADA seeks "special" and not "equal" treatment.

While the Fourth Circuit upheld Boyle's decision in the Pierce case, it was vacated when the Supreme Court unanimously ruled on a similar Pennsylvania case, Pennsylvania Department of Corrections v. Yeskey. That case addressed the discrimination of a disabled prisoner's ineligibility for an inaccessible "Motivational Boot Camp" for first-time offenders that significantly shortens a prisoner's time behind bars. Even Justice Scalia, who wrote the opinion, asserted that “the plain text of Title II of the ADA unambiguously extends to state prison inmates.” The broader issue of Congress' power to apply the ADA to the states was not addressed.

In Brown v. North Carolina Division of Motor Vehicles, disabled North Carolinans sued against what was basically a tax on disability, where disabled parking permits required payment of a fee not imposed on nondisabled citizens. Again, Boyle used the opportunity to declare the ADA special rather than equal treatment under the law, and even declared disabled people to not be a legitimate group insofar as protection from discrimination is concerned.

The PFAW report on Boyle continues:
The Supreme Court has repudiated Boyle’s theories even in a decision limiting individuals’ rights under the ADA. In Board of Trustees of the Univ. of Ala. v. Garrett, 531 U.S. 356 (2001), the Court ruled 5-4 that individuals could not sue states for damages under Title I of the ADA because of insufficient evidence of state discrimination against the disabled and because the remedy was not congruent and proportional to the violation. But nowhere did the majority suggest that legislation pursuant to the Fourteenth Amendment must be limited to discrimination based on race, alienage, national origin or gender, and nowhere did the Court suggest that states cannot be required to comply with the ADA as Boyle had ruled. To the contrary, even the court majority specifically recognized that while damages were not available, Title I of the ADA “still prescribes standards applicable to the states” which can be enforced in lawsuits “for injunctive relief,” directly contrary to Boyle’s view. Id. at 374, n. 9. And in Tennessee v. Lane, 124 S.Ct. 1978 (2004), the Court ruled that even money damages may be available for some violations of Title II of the ADA. Boyle’s radical “states’ rights” view goes far beyond even the most conservative justices on the Supreme Court and would effectively dismantle the ADA as applied to state government agencies.
Note that last sentence above to understand exactly who Bush has been nominating to federal positions: Boyle’s radical “states’ rights” view goes far beyond even the most conservative justices on the Supreme Court and would effectively dismantle the ADA as applied to state government agencies.

In Williams v. Avent, Inc., Boyle gave summary judgment against a plaintiff claiming she was fired instead of being given reasonable accommodation for a back injury that minimized her ability to lift much weight. The Fourth Circuit spanked Boyle in its discussion of "reasonable accommodation" under appeal. The description of that judgment's criticism of Boyle is worthy of reading as presented on page 20 of the PFAW .pdf file -- you'll need to scroll down to the 20th page to see it.

But there's more. On environmental racism and religious discrimination Boyle also denied the state was culpable for discrimination. The Fourth Circuit has also reversed several decisions by Boyle on redistricting cases where he consistently favored white plaintiff voters. On one occasion, Boyle issued an opinion on a case he was not even assigned to -- before the assigned judge ever heard arguments.

Finally, on federal campaign finance laws, Boyle has sided with local anti-abortion organizations against the FEC. The Fourth Circuit did reverse.

Boyle was the only one of the four judges who Bush will apparently not be renominating that did not withdraw himself from consideration. And Bush's decision is only prompted by the clear opposition he will face from a Democratic Congress. This is a direct effect of our vote, though only time will tell if Bush's next nominations are any better on civil rights for disabled folks.

Disability bloggers quoted on CNN

Earlier this week, David at Growing up with a Disability, Penny of Disability Studies, Temple U., and Nufsaid at Ramblings were noted by CNN for their blogging against the Ashley Treatment from their perspectives of personal experience. I believe I've linked to my friends' writings on this before, but it's so good to see them as part of the national debate. The CNN article here.

Fun has now been penciled into the schedule -- Pass it on

Therefore, be it resolved that January 19th, befittingly a Friday shall be Radical Fun Day.

On occupation

I've been putting off writing about this for many weeks now because I wanted to express the connections between disability and war and oppression and civil unrest in some intellectual and compelling fashion, but really, what's more compelling or obvious than the fact that war always and inevitably causes death and disability? And oppressed people who fight for their humanity become more disabled in greater numbers when their oppressors try to maintain control.

I wanted to talk about the connections between my pet topic here of disability rights and Brownfemipower's writing on indigenous rights and how they intersect, but really, they are one and the same. Sometimes disability arises in specific interesting ways through the topics BFP covers, but it's really present in every image and word.

Here's an example in a four-minute video intro to a movie.

Wednesday, January 10, 2007

Screen all pregnancies

An article in The New York Times reports that the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists now recommends that all pregnant women, regardless of age, be offered screening for Down Syndrome. This is a change from offering screening primarily to pregnant women age 35 and older, and while the new guidelines are prompted partly by technology that makes early screening less dangerous to the fetus, the change also reflects what can only be described as a more comfortable relationship with the eugenic tendencies of prenatal screening to "screen out" flawed fetuses.

From the article:

In explaining the new recommendation, several physicians said the cutoff age of 35 had always been somewhat arbitrary. “Many women are unhappy with it, because it doesn’t mean anything to them; it’s kind of being put upon them,” said Dr. James Goldberg, a former chairman of the obstetrics college’s committee on genetics, who helped develop the new guidelines.

For example, Dr. Goldberg said, a 29-year-old woman and her partner might now choose amniocentesis instead of a blood test. In the past, the more invasive procedure was seldom recommended for younger women because it could sometimes result in miscarriage. Now the risk is considered to be quite low, and in any event, Dr. Goldberg said, for some couples “losing a normal pregnancy secondary to the procedure is not as problematic as the birth of a Down syndrome child, so they’re willing to take that risk.”

As I understand it, the old age-35 policy was based on balancing the concern of miscarriage of any fetus to the statistical probability of a woman giving birth to a child with Down Syndrome. As stated explicitly above by Dr. Goldberg, that balance is perceived to be shifting significantly enough to encourage wider screening practices. Implicit in his statement is the notion that a positive test result for Down Syndrome is alleviated with abortion, otherwise the risk would not be worth it.

Significantly, the NYT article does not associate this medical policy with societal perceptions of or supports (or lack of) for people with Down Syndrome. It does not recognize through further interview or research that women receiving a positive screening get significant pressure by both the medical community and society at large to abort fetuses with this largely nonfatal and highly variable condition. While the changing policy may provide more women with more information about their pregnancies, it will not provide that information in full cultural context and will not, apparently, include guidelines for how to best decide what to do with that information.



__________________________________________

On a separate note: The website for the medical organization issuing these guidelines reveals that uterine transplants are just around the corner.

FRIDA protests Ashley Treatment at AMA tomorrow

From the press release:

At 1 p.m. on Thursday, January 11, Feminist Response in Disability Activism (FRIDA), with the support of other disability groups, will stage an “Ashley Treatment” demonstration at the national headquarters of the American Medical Association (AMA) in Chicago at 515 N. State Street.

FRIDA will demand that the AMA start practicing real ethical accountability and dialogue with the disability community. The action is in response to the AMA’s sanction of the“Ashley Treatment” through its publication of the original case article in the Archives of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine case.This AMA-owned journal went so far as to call for further “study” of the issue by subjecting more children to the same drastic surgeries and follow them over time.

People with disabilities and families nationwide have reacted with outrage to the drastic medical “solution” to what is actually a complex social problem of finding real supports for people with disabilities and their families. FRIDA is also not surprised that the initial recipient of the “Ashley Treatment” was a little girl, given that girls, and girls with disabilities in particular, are perceived as easier subjects for mutilation and desexualization.

Ana Mercado of FRIDA notes, “Our bodies really are the battlegrounds on which ethics debates are fought.” FRIDA seeks to protect our bodies from having to become battlegrounds in the first place. The issue at hand is not our bodies, but the choices that other people make for our bodies.

FRIDA is a group of radicalized women with disabilities representing ourselves and fighting for freedom for our bodies. FRIDA is supported in this action by Chicago ADAPT, the national ADAPT community, Not Dead Yet and Advance Youth Leadership Power (AYLP).

Once more for 2006

Inclusion Daily Express lists the top disability rights news stories in the U.S. for 2006.

Less obvious stories about disability rights that carry into 2007 are the Medicare Part D drug plan and the war in Iraq.

Like a sieve, only not so much

I had that ABG draw this morning, as scheduled, to determine if recent dizziness is caused by my ventilator settings or something else. That went well. An RT I'm acquainted with did it cautiously but easily and with very minimal pain. It had to be done by her in the local hospital rather than the adjoining clinic because, well, I don't know. Fear of arteries, I guess. But it was good to see her (except for the "aww, look at poor you on the vent" part) and tell her I've felt very healthy and appropriately-oxygenated or whatever since I got the hole in my neck and all.

For reasons possibly due to Gimp Compound breakdowns in communication, I also had an appointment for a regular blood draw to examine my levels of potassium, magnesium, and other yummy -esiums that were dangerously low a year ago. They were checked six weeks ago and I've been choking down lots of bananas and potatoes and other starchy colorless joys since then because those levels were only borderline acceptable. If French fries qualified as hot and greasy little mediums for the -esiums, this dietary addendum would be more fun. If I ever did get a thrill from a banana, that joy was killed last year when I was eating two each day for months to get the potassium up.

The ABG was what I really thought I needed, but I went along with this extra blood draw because, well, when six people are involved with arranging your clinic visit and you wish to live in harmony amongst them, what's a little poke with a needle. And maybe I could ease off on the bananas if all went especially well, right?

Things looked worrisome when the clinic receptionist said, "Hmm, this appointment was for yesterday. Have a seat in the central waiting room and we'll see what we can do." See what I mean about harmony at the Gimp Compound? Which of us screwed that up? Shhh, never mind.

I didn't wait long to see the Woman-Masquerading-as-a-Phlebotomist. I spent that time listening to the sick dull ache of my right inside wrist. Those nerves around arteries know how to discourage activity in their territory. I knew it wouldn't last too long, but it's a uniquely-flavored pain. I once had an RT take an ABG without me feeling the stick at all, which shouldn't be physically possible, but I enjoy contemplating the perversity and competence of that moment from time to time.

When called upon in the clinic waiting room, I did everything I could for the WMAAP. I told her past successes in springing healthy leaks in me usually involved the "butterfly needle," tiny enough to match my little veins. I sent her confidence vibes. I sat calmly while she dug around in the crook of my left elbow, the edge of my left wrist, and had a friend dig around the top of my right hand.

Then she pronounced me too dehydrated to bleed and told me to go away and come again another day.

No, really.

In the many hundreds of blood draws I've had in 38 years -- including some very unpleasant situations when I was actually sick and dehydrated -- individuals have sweated, apologized and passed the needle off to colleagues, but no one has ever told me it was not possible to make me bleed.

"You have no available blood today. Sorry. Go home."

Actually, since I had gotten the ABG I believed was important, and we had reached the limits of my commitment to family harmony, I was prepared to tell them to back away with their needles anyway. But still.

The pain from the ABG has abated almost entirely now and there's just the most minute sensation in the nerves to remind me that anything happened there at all. The other needle holes in my hands and arms hurt and are bruised blue. I did get results of my ABG and though I haven't yet talked to my primary, apparently the numbers look good.

I wish I'd had the chance to see my doctor's face when all this occurred with the WMAAP. She sometimes surprises me with hilarious breaks from her stoic, thoughtful professionalism, and I'd like to have seen which way it would go today. And who she would have found to get the job done, because she would have found someone or elected herself.

In the meantime, more bananas.

More linkage on Ashley

Time magazine: "Pillow Angel Ethics, Part 2," Part 1 here.

DREDF statement (Disability Rights Education & Defense Fund)

Commentary at The Independent: "The moral line in medicine shifts once again."

Nufsaid at Ramblings: Mom of disabled son weighs in.

DreamMom: Parts 1 and 2 on the Ashley Treatment -- Another Mom of disabled child responds.

Brownfemipower at Women of Color -- Lengthy comments.

Women's Space/The Margins -- Again, long comment thread.

And with huge comment threads, Alas, A Blog: Here and here.

Did I miss someone? Add the link in comments.

Updated:

Sharon at The Voyage writes here and here.

Elmindreda of Random Reminiscing Ramblings writes "Dear Ableist."

Tuesday, January 09, 2007

Pants-wetting 12-year-old arrested for disorderly conduct

Incredibly, here's how the story ends:

After the arrest, police told her parents they could probably avoid paying a fine if they agreed to make the girl do community service.

HIV-gay bigotry, wrongful death and the ADA

Appalling and legally interesting. From GayCityNews:

Claude Green was driving his truck in Welch on June 21, 2005, with Billy Snead as a passenger, when he suddenly suffered heart failure. Snead was able to guide the truck to a stop and administer CPR, reviving Green who gasped for breath. While Snead continued to minister to Green, Chief Bowman arrived at the scene and physically pulled Snead away from Green, exclaiming that Green was HIV-positive.

Bowman called 911 for an ambulance and blocked Snead from attempting to resume attending to Green. When the ambulance arrived, Bowman told the emergency workers that Green was HIV-positive, which they recorded, but it appears that they attempted CPR while driving him to the hospital. Bowman also went to the hospital and informed the emergency staff there that Green was HIV-positive. Green died shortly after reaching the hospital from heart disease.

Green was not HIV-positive.
Note, first, that Green died in June of 2005. This case has been waiting judgment for a long time now.

What the federal judge ruled:
Judge Faber's analysis was lengthy, complicated by the fact that the U.S. Supreme Court has not definitely resolved all the relevant issues. He concluded that due process and equal protection claims resulting from the death of somebody because of civil rights violations committed by a government actor could be brought under federal civil rights statute, and furthermore that the Americans With Disabilities Act claim also survived to the extent it arose from denial of services to a person with a disability.

Green alleged that her son qualified as a person with a disability because Bowman wrongly perceived him to be HIV-positive.

Faber's opinion noted that there was no indication anywhere in the court record that administering CPR to an HIV-positive person would present any special risk of transmission, casting doubt on what would undoubtedly be the defendants' main theory of justification for Bowman's actions in blocking care for Green.

Significant issues remain to be sorted out in this litigation, but at this initial stage, Faber's ruling permits the case to go forward on the basis that the estate may have a valid federal civil rights claim against the city and Bowman for the way in which Green was treated on the day of his fatal heart attack.

Well, crap

The good news is the possibility of a collaborative book with son Jamie. I look forward to that.

Monday, January 08, 2007

Death of 14-year-old only tip of the iceberg of abuse

From the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, "A Hidden Shame: Death and Danger in Georgia's Mental Hospitals":

Alone in the darkness of a state mental hospital, Sarah Crider, 14, lay slowly dying.

She complained of stomach pain at 4:30 p.m. She vomited about 8:30. When the only physician on call at Georgia Regional Hospital/Atlanta came at 9:20, Sarah had vomited again, but the doctor did not examine her, medical records suggest. She threw up around midnight and once more about 2 a.m., this time a bloody substance that resembled coffee grounds. But hospital workers did not enter Sarah's room again until 6:15 a.m. By then, it was too late.

A few hours later, two hospital employees drove to Cobb County to tell Joyce Dobson, Sarah's grandmother. Dobson adored Sarah for all her complexities: artistic but troubled, challenging but comic. Now she could think only of two nights earlier, when she had last visited Sarah and heard another patient's haunting scream.

I hope nobody killed her, Dobson blurted out.

In fact, what happened to Sarah was beyond anything Dobson could have imagined.

Read the rest.

Still thinking on Ashley

I'm crossposting this comment of mine from a discussion I'm participating in elsewhere:

One thing I find so frustrating about the widespread discussion of the "Ashley Treatment" is the complete unwillingness by so many people to assess the parental decisions. Understandably, people are sympathetic to their situation and are rightly giving them some benefit of the doubt. But the decision-making process between medical professionals and parents of disabled kids is always really complex, always done on a steep learning curve, and always involves pressure from those medical experts that parents do not always have the experience to rationally assess. It's relevant that the parents' website expressly states that they did not have any doubts about this decision and want very much to offer and push this treatment for other children. That's an incredibly worrisome degree of certainty and salesmanship about a complex and murky ethical decision, if you ask me.

I could name a few less extreme but questionable ethical medical practices I was subject to as a child with a physical condition that intrigued the medical community my parents consulted beginning at the time of my birth. At the age of nine (same physical age as Ashley) I was examined in a medical boardroom by about 20 medical professionals who saw nothing problematic with me wearing only panties and walking around the boardroom table so that individuals could touch my muscles and discuss what they all saw in my body. There was technical debate and also discussions I completely understood about this or that failure of my muscles when I was asked to perform. A joke or two was made, probably as attempts to lighten the atmosphere, but the laughter is a distinct part of the unhappy memory that has stuck with me these past 30 years. A photographer took pictures that I was sure ended up on the newsmagazine show 20/20 a couple years later as falsely-labeled examples of anorexia. I doubt that was true, but it's always haunted me. I was a bright nine-year-old, but I didn't consent to those pictures of me in only my panties and I don't know who has seen them or where they ended up.

My parents can easily see now -- and even did in the confusion of that day -- that it was an inappropriate and harmful venue in which to give a child medical care, but they were desperate and hopeful and didn't know if the consequences of this ordeal would lead to some cure or treatment that, on balance, would make it worthwhile. They gritted their teeth and stuck it out, hoping for something useful to come of it. Lots of medical decisions are like that. It does not mean the parents should not be judged or culpable for what is decided. The ends do not jusitfy the means, especially when the ends are so completely unknown. And it seems telling and worrisome that Ashley's parents lack any self-reflective doubt about a clearly uncertain situation. It's dishonest about the dynamics, at the very least.

Sunday, January 07, 2007

Mini-Slumgullion

An all non-Ashley version:

Connie at Planet of the Blind writes about trading up to get her husband Steve.

Amy Tenderich at Diabetes Mine writes on bravery and chicken-shittedness.

Go wish Bint Alshama at My Private Casbah a belated Happy 30th Birthday! She's also outlived her initial cancer diagnosis four years now and so there's two reasons to celebrate.

Because sometimes I miss him: Cutter John and The Starship Enterpoop.

Saturday, January 06, 2007

Hmmm -- Updated

Oops. I was trying to update my template so that the labels function of the new Blogger would be available on the sidebar. It is now. In the process, I've lost my entire blogroll and other assortive stuff. Yes, there is supposedly a way to update your template without doing this, but it certainly wasn't clear to me until it was too late.

The blogroll has badly needed updating anyway, but I wasn't prepared to do it tonight. So, hopefully a new improved sidebar list will be back shortly.

If there's a link you think I should consider adding -- I am mainly interested in links to disability sites that discuss disability rights, disabled women, and the social aspects of living with a disability -- leave a comment here. Thanks.

Update: I've added part of my gimp blogroll back. If you used to be linked or know someone that was (or wasn't but should have been), remind me because I didn't have the list saved anywhere. As for the auxiliary blogroll of feminist blogs and other sites I kept my eye on, not all of it will return but I haven't decided exactly what that part of the reworked list will look like yet.

Ashley Treatment discussion at Pandagon

I regularly enjoy reading the feminist posts and discussions at Pandagon, but the recent coverage there of the story of Ashley X and the medical procedures to alter her body for the convenience of her caregiving parents begs for further discussion away from what seems to be a rather strident point of view that beleaguered parents of disabled children really can do no wrong. You know, because it's their unimaginable burden and, luckily, not ours.

Amanda begins by stating:

To make it very clear, she will never improve. She’s never going to develop the capacity to make decisions or think or move much on her own.
So, okay. This may be completely true. Or it may be partially true and she will show some minor improvement but never be able to make important decisions independently. Or, like quite a few underestimated disabled people chatting about this on the nets, the medical experts may have done what so very frequently happens to disabled people and discounted them far too early. This discounting and underestimating the medical community does before disabled people are then limited in their life options through the decisions of others is a key aspect of the institutional and societal discrimination disabled people face every day.

Is Ashley's situation one where the medical experts' pronouncements of her permanently childlike mental status is absolutely accurate? Wheelchair Dancer and Cory Silverberg argue persuasively that it doesn't matter and I'd warn that the slippery slope argument too often only really applies on the far side of the disability divide rather than within the widely divergent ranks of disabled people, whose abilities vary at least as widely as abilities among those considered nondisabled.

The disabled folks who are talking about this case are not worried about sliding into that crevice the Ashley Treatment opens the way for -- we have been in it, we've been included in discussions as the equivalent of Ashley, public policies and conventional wisdom dealing with the moral fuzziness of this case too often already puts us right there with Ashley. We too are seen as the "objects" of this problem, with the "subjects" duking it out over what constitutes appropriate care. The differences between our mental capacities and those of people like Ashley are used to separate us, invalidate all those times we are treated as if our disabled bodies complemented a disabled mind. We too are infantilized and patted on the head as parents and other experts on our conditions testify to our needs.

Amanda also says:
In terms of disability rights activism, the compelling case for it is the idea that having a disability doesn’t mean that your life isn’t worth living and therefore you should be accomodated and given as many opportunities as anyone else for the joys of life that other people who are considered more able-bodied have. With that in mind, I think it’s quite possible the parents of this girl are living up to that standard, if in a way that’s startlingly out of the norm. They’ve identified their daughter’s needs and pleasures—basically, those of an infant—and are looking for ways to fight social structures and even biology that would erode their daughter’s ability to have those things. It’s weird, but it makes sense. From that perspective, they are taking activism into a new dimension, seeking not a cure, but a radical rethinking of how far we’re willing to go to accomodate the disabled as they are. I might be wrong, but it’s worth considering it from that angle.
What an ugly twisting of disability rights activism to use it to justify behavior "startlingly out of the norm." How is removing the child's breast buds to prevent future sexual abuse "fighting social structures" and public ambivalence to the fate of the thousands of disabled people sexually abused every year. Why is fighting normal biology acceptable for "abnormal" bodies or abnormal minds? How is being treated differently from nondisabled human beings part of the disability rights cause? How does "radically rethinking how far we are willing to go to accommodate the disabled as they are" relate to a case where a child's body undergoes radical surgery? Why does including disabled people among those you treat with basic human respect require radical rethinking at all?

There are lots of viable ways to approach this complex topic of the "Ashley Treatment," but justifying it as a form of disability rights activism is not one of them.

Update: Well, Sally said much of this, much better, in my own blog's comments here.

Friday, January 05, 2007

The Ashley Treatment

Not a good time to write in detail about what I think, here are some other folks who have expressed what's on my mind better than I could have. The first three especially address the Ashley Treatment from both disabled and feminist perspectives:

Wheelchair Dancer

Penny Richards at Disability Studies, Temple U.

Mary Johnson of Ragged Edge

Cory Silverberg

Arthur Caplan, Ph.D., director of the Center for Bioethics at the University of Pennsylvania

Thirza Cuthand at Fit of Pique

I'm Funny Too at Did I Miss Something?

I posted briefly here and here.

The "Ashley Treatment." Do you suppose I could syndicate my medical plan too?

On mental capacity

I felt on top of the discussion yesterday afternoon, but it's shot way ahead of me by midnight last night. I'll get into it more, but for now, this infant:











and this nine-year-old child:














are not mentally equivalent just because the medical determination is that the latter has the mental capacity of a three-month old baby. One has experienced nine years in the world, which may include nine years of memories and clearly does include nine years of consciousness, however different or limited from the consciousness which most of us know.

Friday at the Gimp Compound or Dizzying up the Girl

So, about ten days ago, my trach's cuff burst. In my throat, in the middle of the night. And just for fun, this happened when I was just coming down with a virus of some sort and happened to be sitting on the toilet. I was with a new nurse -- new to me and new to the profession, so she'd never seen a trach switch before. And my Mom had never done one, but we woke her up for the opportunity. Dad was there too -- it was an exciting event for us all.

But it went very well. When I'd last had a scheduled Parts Replacement Event, I'd asked the doctor to show both my mother and the nurse present how to do it. We were mostly prepared. We only lacked sterile lubrication to make it easy to slide the new one in. But in the excitement, we didn't pay the usual attention to the exact amount of water to fill my cuff comfortably with.* And we didn't adjust the strap around my neck just right -- because I have a scrawny neck, the trach can be shoved in too far so that it curves against the back wall of my windpipe and the opening is curved up against the front of my windpipe, which both hurts and impedes delivery of air.

What with the virus and this trach switch requiring fine-tuning for optimum breathing and comfort, I've been pretty dizzy the last ten days. Oh, and I've just finished weaning off the Effexor Dr. Perky placed me on in rehab, so that might be contributing to my dizziness too.

I've got an appointment for a blood gas** next week and I've spent part of today with the cuff filled beyond speaking-capability in order to better approximate the exact settings I used in the hospital, which is when I was last monitored by RTs and a pulmonologist. I've been the vent expert in my life since I came home with the machine last March.*** Ironically, state-paid home health care for a vent user requires hired nurses, but nurses are not trained in the specialty of vent management unless they get special training to be ICU nurses or the like. Nurses also are not typically allowed to do trach change procedures, though obviously it is necessary that they be prepared to step up in a setting like mine if I need one in an emergency.

Respiratory therapists get training on ventilators, what the settings all mean, how they effect a patient, and they learn to do trach changes and take blood gases (and do the lab work) as part of their routine in a rehab hospital like I was at. I very much enjoy the individual women who are employed as nurses for me, but geez. The rules don't quite fit the purpose and I need an expert just now.

Oh, and there's a new nurse coming to work here tonight. I don't know if she's ever done suction, worked with a vent, or what. So finding that out is my job tonight. I'm dizzy and tired and fed up with these regulations that don't really give me the full expertise they claim they do.

______________________________________________

* The cuff is the inflatable part of a trach that puffs up in the windpipe to ensure that the air going in the tube gets to my lungs and doesn't go upward and out my mouth and nose instead. The trach I currently use, a Bivona TTS, inflates the cuff with sterile water instead of air, which other kinds of trachs use. So when it burst, I immediately got about 7 or 8 ccs of water in my lungs in addition to not getting the vent air where I needed it. And we added about 5 ccs more before being certain the cuff was blown.

The photo above is the Bivona TightToShaft trach kit, which includes the trach itself (top left), the obdurator (shaped in a gentle curve like the trach, it's hard plastic that fits inside the trach tube to help with insertion), and the wedge or "tooth" (top right, used to unhook the installed trach from the vent tubes for suction or getting on clothing). The red cap to seal off neck breathing while leaving the trach installed and cheapo trach tie I do not use but both are also in the picture above. You can't really see the cuff, but it looks just like a little condom on the end of the naked trach. The tiny photo inset shows the cuff inflated.

** A blood gas (or arterial blood gas, ABG) is a blood draw taken from an artery in order to measure oxygen, carbon dioxide and other stuff. In this case, it helps determine if my ventilator settings are giving me too little or too much air.

*** When I say that I am the vent expert in my life, I mean that I know more than any person who comes in contact with me -- including the dude from the medical supply company who is supposed to come monthly and do a maintenance check on my machines. I know what the codes are for the various alarms when they go off, I know what the settings of frequency, sensitivity, tidal volume, expired tidal volume, PIP, PEEP, MAP, etc. all mean generally and in terms of what I suposedly need. I know how to cancel the alarm and change settings depending on if I am getting sufficient air, which varies according to how full the trach cuff is. I know that a high pressure alarm usually means there is condensation in the sensor tubes and I know the ways to fix that. I'm happy and proud I have learned all this in the past year, and it was my responsibility to do so, but given that I am required to have nurses in my presence constantly in order to receive state aid for home care, I am not thrilled that I know more than every single professional around me and that their nursing training does not mean they bring the actual vent machine expertise to the job.

Thursday, January 04, 2007

Resolutions for the new U.S. Congress

Pelosi was signed in as House Speaker today -- exciting and historic, that. I don't have much faith in her "100 hours" plan because the most important topics for this new Congress to address are too complicated to solve so quickly, but I do have hope for the year. Disability issues top the list of concerns Pelosi and the Democrats need to address:

1) Ending war and increasing peace in Iraq and Afghanistan -- From a purely economic perspective, responsible health care for injured American military personnel already endangers all of us:

More than 1.4 million U.S. soldiers have been deployed to Iraq and Afghanistan since late 2001, and about 26 percent have filed disability claims, according to raw data provided by the Department of Veterans Affairs. That percentage could grow as soldiers leave the armed forces.

''I see the whole thing as a mini-Medicare, another huge entitlement program, which is going to be sprawling out over the course of our lifetimes and our children's lifetimes,'' said Linda Bilmes, a Harvard University public finance professor and co-author of the Stiglitz study. "The big costs come when they get back . . . they stand a good chance of being really underfunded and not taken care of properly.''

Veterans groups worry that they'll be forced to compete with other government programs for funds. Not enough attention is being given to the future mental health and medical needs of Iraq and Afghanistan war vets, they say, especially given how those wars differ from previous ones.

This doesn't even count the much higher costs to Iraqis, with civilians dying from non-war-related, preventable health conditions now due to an almost total lack of access to medical care:

Zainab may be one of the 655,000 Iraqis who would be alive today if the Bush administration hadn't launched its criminally conceived and executed war. Violence caused most of the excess deaths. But 54,000 people died from non-violent causes, such as heart disease, cancer and chronic illness. They were victims of a health care system eviscerated by mismanagement, ill-placed priorities, corruption and civil war.
PetitPoussin comments on another tragic example here.

Congress' number one priority needs to be working honestly to end this conflict. Our job is to make them keep at it until it's done.

2) Universal healthcare and Medicare policy reform -- From the corrupt Republican Part D drug plan to federal requirements for proof of citizenship, recent reforms have complicated health care for thousands of Medicare recipients and shut others out altogether. Not to mention the over 46 million Americans who remain completely uninsured.

3) ADA Restoration Act -- Okay, this doesn't sound nearly as urgent as the two problems above -- and it isn't. Except that the war and increasing lack of health care contribute to the number of Americans with disabilities who must rely on the anti-discrimination law to remain a productive part of society. With Mark Foley and his vendetta against the ADA gone, Democrats have a chance to truly support disabled people by bolstering the ADA against further beatings from the Supreme Court.

House Democrat Steny Hoyer in 2004 speaking at the Tony Coelho Lecture in Disability Employment Law and Policy at the New York Law School:
When we wrote the ADA, we intentionally used a definition of disability that was broad -- borrowing an existing definition from the Rehabilitation Act of 1973.

We did this because the courts had generously interpreted this definition in the Rehabilitation Act. And, we thought using established language would help us avoid a potentially divisive political debate over the definition of "disabled."

Therefore, we could not have fathomed that people with diabetes, epilepsy, heart conditions, cancer and mental illnesses would have their ADA claims kicked out of court because, with medication, they would be considered too functional to meet the definition of "disabled." Nor could we have fathomed a situation where an individual may be considered too disabled by an employer to get a job, but not disabled enough by the courts to be protected by the ADA from discrimination.
The .pdf file of Hoyer's speech is locked from copying and pasting here, but I encourage you to follow the link and read the four principles he gives for the restoration of the ADA that Congressional action can provide. Briefly, these are 1) restate Congressional intent, 2) focus the law on discrimination and not details of an individual's disability, 3) disallow the courts' argument that disabled people must be saved from harming themselves, and 4) reassert that accommodation means finding solutions together rather than creating an adversarial relationship between employers and employees.

That's my short list of work for the new Congress to tackle. Not too much to ask.

Minimum wage for everybody -- yes, even the disabled

Arizona voters passed a new minimum wage that goes into effect this week and for the first time it will not exempt disabled workers from economic parity. As you might imagine, this disturbs many people who run business using sheltered workshops where pay is adjusted according to perceived differences in worker productivity.

According to the New Standard News:

Some 5,600 employers pay sub-minimum wages to about 424,000 workers across the country, according to a 2001 report from the US Government Accountability Office. More than half make less than $2.50 an hour.
Marta Russell, disability rights activist and author of Beyond Ramps (an excellent analysis of the economic ghetto created for disabled persons in a capitalist society), comments:
"‘Commensurate wage’ is an Orwellian tag for a law that legalizes inequality," said disability-rights activist and author Marta Russell. "It degrades the disabled laborer to equate his [or] her productive capacity as less than [that of] a non-disabled laborer and to not give them equal pay. Who is to say that the disabled worker’s labor is not equal to or more productive or profitable for their employers than the average couch potato’s?"
And:
"All laborers should be paid at least a minimum wage, and preferably a living wage," Russell, who uses a wheelchair, told TNS. "That is the only way to raise the disabled workers in question here to an equal economic level with non-disabled workers and lift some of them up out of a below-poverty-level existence. To be paid anything less is to further enslave the disabled worker more than workers in general are already enslaved."

"Frozen girl" discussed on TV tonight

If my sources are right, there should be a discussion tonight on CNN's Nancy Grace show of the "frozen girl" and the ethics of her parents' choices that are recently making news. From the BBC News:

Ashley X was born with severe and permanent brain damage, called static encephalopathy.

The nine-year-old has the mental ability of a three-month-old baby and cannot walk or talk.

Her parents argue that keeping her "frozen" as a girl rather than letting her go through puberty and growing into a woman will give her a better life.

They authorised doctors to remove her uterus to prevent menstruation, to limit her breast growth through the removal of breast buds so that she would not experience discomfort when lying down, and give her doses of hormones to stop her growing taller.

Opponents have accused Ashley's parents of "Frankenstein-esque" behaviour - of maiming the child for the sake of convenience.

From the website of Ashley's parents:

The “Ashley Treatment” is the name we have given to a collection of medical procedures for the improvement of Ashley’s quality of life. The treatment includes growth attenuation through high-dose estrogen therapy, hysterectomy to eliminate the menstrual cycle and associated discomfort to Ashley, and breast bud removal to avoid the development of large breasts and the associated discomfort to Ashley. We pursued this treatment after much thought, research, and discussions with doctors.

And further details on the procedures:

In early 2004 when Ashley was six and a half years old, we observed signs of early puberty. In a related conversation with Ashley’s doctor, Ashley’s Mom came upon the idea of accelerating her already precocious puberty to minimize her adult height and weight. We scheduled time with Dr. Daniel F. Gunther, Associate Professor of Pediatrics in Endocrinology at Seattle’s Children’s Hospital, and discussed our options. We learned that attenuating growth is feasible through high-dose estrogen therapy. This treatment was performed on teenage girls starting in the 60’s and 70’s, when it wasn’t desirable for girls to be tall, with no negative or long-term side effects.

The fact that there is experience with administering high-dose estrogen to limit height in teen-age girls gave us the peace of mind that it was safe—no surprise side effects. Furthermore, people found justification in applying this treatment for cosmetic reasons while we were seeking a much more important purpose, as will be detailed below.

In addition to height and weight issues, we had concerns about Ashley’s menstrual cycle and its associated cramps and discomfort. We also had concerns about Ashley’s breasts developing and becoming a source of discomfort in her lying down position and while strapped across the chest area in her wheelchair, particularly since there is a family history of large breasts and other related issues that we discuss below. The estrogen treatment would hasten both the onset of the menstrual cycle and breast growth. Bleeding during the treatment would likely be very difficult to control.

It was obvious to us that we could significantly elevate Ashley’s adult quality of life by pursuing the following three goals:

1) Limiting final height using high-dose estrogen therapy.

2) Avoiding menstruation and cramps by removing the uterus (hysterectomy).

3) Limiting growth of the breasts by removing the early breast buds.

The surgeon also performed an appendectomy during the surgery, since there is a chance of 5% of developing appendicitis in the general population, and this additional procedure presented no additional risk.If Ashley’s appendix acts up, she would not be able to communicate the resulting pain. An inflamed appendix could rupture before we would know what was going on, causing significant complication.

I plan to watch the show tonight and then discuss this further.

Wednesday, January 03, 2007

Choosing a college

Sitemeter tells me that someone wandered here with the Google phrase "I'm a disabled teen looking for the right college" despite the fact that I've never said anything that would be specifically helpful in that regard. But since I did find the right college for myself back in 1987 when I was a disabled teen, I'll give it a shot and invite anyone else with suggestions to add them as well.

My entire reason for being compelled to check out Arizona State University as a school to attend came from when I was a shy freshman high school girl and overheard the only other wheelchair user at my school (a senior guy) mention ASU while we were riding the short bus to school one morning. Or maybe he was talking about UofA, but I got it in my head that Arizona would be hospitable in ways that Illinois was not.

I had the grades to get in most places, but never considered anything Ivy League-ish because the ADA didn't exist then and I was well-aware that the older the building, and the more historical the building, the less it would be useful to me. I don't recall how many schools I visited my senior year-- not so many since I was fixated on ASU -- but, inexplicably, I visited Wisconsin's Whitewater campus too. No contest because of one issue -- snow.

My Dad, my twin sister and I scouted out ASU on Halloween day of my senior year in high school. I recall this because Bert and Ernie were the first two individuals I met on campus and this no doubt effected my decision. Giant costumes of Sesame Street characters somehow epitomized the joys of college for me, I guess.

We met with Disabled Student Services and they arranged a tour of campus (hosted by a disabled man) and an accessible dorm room. I stared at palm trees, which I had never been in the presence of before. I ate actual Mexican food made by people who are not bland Scandinavians afraid of cooking with spice. It was really an obvious choice, though made with lots of naivete. And it was the right one for me. Any doubts my Mom and Dad had about me zipping off to live halfway across the country when I did not even have a motorized chair until the week before college began, they mostly kept to themselves and waited to see how far my youthful enthusiasm would carry me.

Presumably wiser now, this is what I'd look for in choosing a college for a disabled teen:

  • Accessibility, both architectural and attitudinal. You don't want to spend too much time fighting to get in the building or to be able to take the test, so institutional commitment to access is not enough -- it should already be substantially in place.

  • Actual disabled students visible on campus going about their lives like everyone else. This includes temporarily disabled students successfully getting around because the school has a means to help them. Golf carts with student chauffeurs were part of disability transportation services at ASU. A university capable of dealing with sudden impairments of its students is more likely to be flexible enough in its accessibility services to accommodate a wider variety of needs. As a scooter user, the repair department was absolutely crucial to me.

  • Diversity programs that include disability as a category of diversity along with race, sexual orientation, etc. Better yet, classes or programs in disability studies would show that someone at the school has a clue.

  • Bathrooms in several places around campus that are not only accessible, but comfortably accessible. Don't enroll somewhere you'll be miserable peeing at for the next four years, it just isn't worth the stress.

  • Ditto for general living accommodations. And the grocery store that you'll need to buy ramen noodles at needs to be handy too.

  • Public transportation that is relatively reliable.
That's my list, for now. Anything else I didn't think of?

Tuesday, January 02, 2007

Miss Ability: Judging disabled women's beauty

Miss Ability has been called the surprise hit of Dutch television in 2006, but the Times Online reported last week that the rights to the program in Britain, France, Germany and the U.S. have now been snapped up. Soon we, too, can look forward to a live beauty contest where disabled women compete in nightgowns and bathing suits, then present short video films on how they've "overcome" their physical conditions -- whatever impairments contestants have must be "visible to the eye" in order for them to compete. Viewers get to vote.

Absolutely Independent, the Dutch company selling the rights to this idea asks in its prospectus:

Ever whistled at a woman in a wheelchair? Checked out the boobs of a blind babe? If the answer’s ‘no’, this barrier-breaking show will put an end to that.
According to Times Online, the company insists that "the show does not patronise disabled people." The article also adds:
British broadcasters will bid for the show in the new year. But there are fears that the trend for extreme reality shows could produce tasteless television.
It would be a shame if this led to television becoming tasteless, wouldn't it? I hope we never live to see the day. But as you might expect, the excitement precipitated by mentioning the ogling of the boobs of blind babes has gotten some attention, and the discussions has been interesting.

Report of this at MensNewsDaily shows exactly how problematic a viewer-determined pageant for disabled women could be. Well, or pageants generally:
“Who are you voting for Bubba?” “Gee, that blond chick is in a wheelchair, but she got hellava big hooters.” “Me, I’m gonna vote for the redhead, her eyepatch is so kinky” “You wankers are nuts, I’m going to vote for the broad with no arms. She’s the perfect woman, you can hit her and she can’t hit back.”
It's all there in just a few sentences, isn't it? Ableism, sexism, objectification, male privilege, fetishism, and the connection between objectification and violence, though it's all said in good fun, of course. What a relief the program is not patronizing too.

On the Snopes bulletin boards, these comments on Miss Ability:
I think that many disabled people would take any sort of recognition as a meaningful human being, rather than the state of inconsequence that is so often relegated to them, even if that recognition is based on something so limiting and empty as appearence.

Challenging? Yes. Progressive? Nope.
***

I feel like it's a little sad that we need a separate ceremony for disabled people. I mean, I know why...I know that people are weirded out. But I feel like ultimately, it would be better if disabled people could participate alongside their nondisabled counterparts.

***

I have this vague uncomfortable feeling that this is something like a modern day side show. "Look! She's crippled, but she looks hot in a bikini! And she talks, too! Amazing!"

***

While I can understand and agree with many of the concerns presented here, I do think this is a small step in the right direction. Too often, even in modern times, disabilities of any kind lead to ostracism and being outcast, whether from prejudice or people just "feeling weird". It's good that the media is finally acknowledging that the disabled can be attractive as well. I have been attracted to disabled women before.
My guess is that the above represent some fairly common opinions about disabled people and sexual attractiveness of women. Disabled people are all needy of attention and approval. It makes sense to separate out disabled women from "normal" women when the topic is beauty. Being seen a legitimate sexual subject for the male gaze is progress for disabled women. The comparison to a circus sideshow is apt, though.

Jessica at Feministing isn't sure exactly what position to take, noting that it "seems kind of cool -- at least in terms of redefining beauty standards." (Emphasis is hers.) Commenters are also divided, though I admittedly don't read comments over there often enough to know the regular trolls.

A sampling of those comments:
Now disabled people can be treated like meat too?
It was interesting that only certain disabilities were allowed. None of those "yucky" (might get in the way of guys finding them hot?) disabilities like cerebral palsy or those that can't be seen?
***
How much money went into this show that could've been better spent, say, on research or helping poor, unattractive wheelchairers build a ramp in their home?
***

I think it's even more disgusting than the usual beauty pageant. What a favor to disabled women (who are in desperate need of enforcement of laws designed to protect their rights, products they can use, and gynecologists who will examine them)--let them be part of the great American sexism show of all time.
***

Why not just include women with disabilities in the typical crap beauty pageants? Doesn't this seem at odds with the "least restrictive environment" idea?

***

In terms of the zeitgeist, this is actually possibly a step in the right direction. It's not so far to go from recognising disabled people as sexual objects to recognising them as sexual beings.
***

The emphasis on contestants having "overcome" a disability ... is completely patronizing and misleading. My disability is a part of me. I cannot "overcome" it any more than I can "overcome" being female, though both of those traits are things that often put me at a disadvantage in the world. It is something you work with and work around, potentially forever. The vital difference is that "overcoming" something means you put it behind you forever. Non-disabled people just love to hear about disabled folks who "overcame" their disabilities because, phew, that means they're fine now and we can go back to not giving a shit about them or their ongoing difficulties or their need for tougher access laws! It is the disability equivalent of the "post-feminist" label and I say it sucks.
The last two comments come from women who identify as disabled and highlight the ways in which this competition differs from your standard beauty pageant for the women contestants and the women those contestants are meant to represent. In addition to the cultural beauty standards that will inevitably be used in judging the winner, the narrative of "overcoming" also determines who is the best disabled woman.

This overcoming narrative -- particularly as part of a contest where the subjects must be "visibly disabled" -- is a paradoxical fiction. Each woman must look stereotypically physically disabled but prove she doesn't suffer the consquences her impairments or society create for that very visibility. Or that she doesn't mind. It goes without saying that the best woman in this contest will not discuss any mental illness or incontinence or lack of civil rights. She won't drool but she won't hide her limp either, because the audience needs to see that. Odds are she'll present as straight and white. She'll sing well and dream of world peace. Men find her pretty despite everything, and all is right with the world.

Monday, January 01, 2007

Books for the new year

Happy New Year everyone!

Like every book lover I know, I've got a towering (and growing) pile of books waiting to be read. I thought I'd share a brief list of some books from that pile that I plan to read in 2007. All of these are disability-related and currently wedged between my full bookshelf and dresser. If you've already read them, are interested in discussing them, or happen to be the author, this is your heads-up to what I hope will be interesting future discussions here on wherever these books take us.

The Speed of Dark by Elizabeth Moon -- Moon won the Nebula Award in 2003 for this novel told from the perspective of a young autistic man. Normally a writer of military sci-fi, this story apparently differs from the author's usual genre and was prompted because she has a child with autism.

Geek Love by Katherine Dunn -- This will be a reread for me, but I haven't been back to it since I first found it at the fabulous feminist bookstore Women and Children First in Chicago when it was originally published in 1983. An amazing novel about carnival freaks and disability told in first-person by Olympia Binewski, a bald, humpbacked albino dwarf.

Crip Theory: Cultural Signs of Queerness and Disability by Robert McRuer
-- From the Amazon description: "McRuer examines how dominant and marginal bodily and sexual identities are composed, and considers the vibrant ways that disability and queerness unsettle and re-write those identities in order to insist that another world is possible."

Planet of the Blind by Stephen Kuusisto -- Fellow disability blogger Stephen's first memoir.

My Body Politic by Simi Linton -- Author of the excellent Claiming Disability: Knowledge and Identity tells her personal story.

Blackbird Fly Away by Hugh Gallagher -- A personal memoir.

By Trust Betrayed: Patients, Physicians, and the License to Kill in the Third Reich by Hugh Gallagher -- A definitive book detailing the eugenics movement against disabled people in Nazi Germany. Gallagher also wrote FDR's Splendid Deception.

Wicked by Gregory Maguire -- I read this while in the hospital and unable to blog about it. An alternative telling of The Wizard of Oz from the Wicked Witch Elphaba's point-of-view. Disability and physical difference everywhere.

I also hope to read Jen Burke's A Life Less Convenient and Stephen's newest book, Eavesdropping, but I haven't bought them yet.