Monday, April 23, 2007

Poetry Monday: Kenny Fries

To The Poet Whose Lover Has Died Of AIDS
by Kenny Fries

. . . then the wasting begins and the disappearance a day at a time. -- Mark Doty

The night of your reading I notice he has carved
a place for his wheelchair. But after the first
poem, through the applause, the noise of moving
out of his way. Then, only the space remains
and nobody, not even those standing, eyeing
what was his position, will take his place.
The next day, when you tell me he wet himself
and could not stay, I think how leaving causes so much
commotion, how in school during rollcall the teacher
never knew how long to wait for the voice, present,
before moving on to the next name in the order.
The tittering, the shifting in chairs, when it went on
too long. When you first told me he was sick,
I could not ask if you, too, were infected --
I searched your poems for clues. Now he has died
and I have gone back to read your poems, needing
your words to prove love does not disappear
a day at a time. All those years together,
over a decade of loss, and I don't know
what's left to say. If we are given love
only to have it taken away, what solace
can anyone offer but your voice be present
among the shifting chairs, the embarrassed noises
of absence. The wait is always too long.

---------------------------------------------------

Here's another poem by Fries.

Here's some news about Fries' Fulbright studies in Japan last year. And here's his brand spanking new book, called The History of My Shoes and the Evolution of Darwin's Theory.

And lastly, a poem by Mark Doty, the poet Fries writes to in the poem above.

Sunday, April 22, 2007

Slumgullion #36 -- The deranged killer edition

The Republic of T -- How to Create a School Shooter:

Am I blaming the victims of the VA Tech shooting? No. I’m blaming the guy who picked up the gun and shot them. He did what he did; what he chose to do, but after, hearing about his experience in high school, seeing his videos and reading among his words “You made me do this,” I almost think he was shooting at everyone who’d ever mistreated him, or that he perceived as mistreating him; as well as those who laughed at the bullying, saw it but did nothing about it, or even approved of it.

I’m also saying that we as a people, as a society, have to stop our part in supporting the social systems and conventions that end up creating people like Cho and the others. Or, as Amy Traub said, “our attempt to understand doesn’t end with the casting of moral blame,” but with recognizing that there are things we can do, things we can change about our culture and our society if we choose too, that i help prevent more tragedies like this one. If that’s what we want.

Autism Vox -- On Some Comments about Cho Seung-Hui (lengthy comments on this post too):
Mention of Cho Seung-Hui possibly being autistic has been circulating on the internet throughout this week. Some charged exchanges have arisen on some blogs in regard to this; fears have been expressed about what such a connection—-of autism to what happened at Virginia Tech on Monday—might mean for the public perception of autism, and of autistic people in particular.

Respectful Insolence -- Vaccines caused the Virginia Tech rampage? (Via Autism Vox):
Never mind that blaming autism for the rampage is bad enough, but Moses has to compound the vileness by implying that vaccines can turn children into killers. Never mind that there is no good evidence that the mercury in thimerosal in vaccines in any way contributes to the development of autism or autism spectrum disorders. Never mind that the latest statistics from, for example, California show no decrease and, indeed, a continued increase, in its autism caseload in 3-5 year olds in the first quarter of 2007, now four years since thimerosal was removed from all childhood vaccines other than the flu vaccine, when by now, if mercury causes autism, we should have seen a huge decrease in the caseload. Never mind that there's lots of other evidence that shows no link between vaccines and autism.

MindFreedom -- I was a college student "mental patient":
As with any overwhelming tragedy, I'm also worried about what is waiting in the wings. We here at MindFreedom are pro-choice about people's choice to take psychiatric drugs, and when I was in college at one point i begged for antidepressants. However, after any major catastrophe, people experiencing prolonged despair and trauma and overwhelm and extreme differences and passion within this highly-conformist society... can end up on drugs, drugs, drugs, drugs, drugs, drugs, drugs, and more drugs, for years, decades and even life, all without adequate advocacy, information and alternatives.

The immensity, intensity and volume of the tsunami of psychiatric drugs hitting our young people -- both in and out of school -- is so outrageous, so potentially devastating, that it amounts to the Greenhouse effect of the mental health system. Currently the mental health system and our society are in denial. No "Al Gore" has emerged to go campus to campus, showing a slide show about how brain structures can be harmed from long-term high-dosage psychiatric drugging... and how there are better and more sustainable ways to help young people with mental and emotional distress and differences.

Writhe Safely -- Here It Comes:
People believe evil and psychosis are synonymous because we live in a system where evil acts can be pardoned by reason of insanity. Sometimes they come together in the same person, insanity and evil, check.

But to conflate the two is a logical fallacy, psychosis is not evil, and it doesn’t cause evil. Correlation does not imply causation, I assume most people understand this fundamental scientific principle. A person can suffer (and I do mean suffer) from psychosis without doing evil, and a person can do evil without exhibiting psychosis. But when evil and psychopathology co-exist in the same person we’re in for a shitstorm. A coercive, lock-em-up and throw away the key toldyaso shitstorm.


The Trouble with Spikol -- Tech Trouble:
Now that the photos and videos and writings have been released, it's reasonable to assume that Cho Seung-Hui suffered from serious mental health problems. But it's not that simple. It would be unfair to state, without elaboration, that Seung-Hui was mentally ill. That tars all mentally ill with the ol' violence brush--a damaging and innacurate perception that contributes mightily to the problem of stigma. It's too absolutist to say that.

Would it help, then, to identify the kind of mental illness he suffered? I don't think so. Whether he was chronically depressed or had OCD or anything else, the diagnosis cannot explain what he did. Yet I suspect that people will want a diagnosis because they're desperate for answers: Why did he do what he did? What makes a person do this?

Yet Another Never Updated Blog -- Don't draw the wrong lessons from Virginia Tech's misfortune:
The point is, we don't need to abandon recent efforts at inclusion and de-stigmatizing of people with mental illness. What we need is to take violent crime seriously, and understand that violent crime does indeed include intimidation, stalking, and arson. They aren't youthful errors. They aren't jokes. They aren't just little things that should be ignored. They are steps on a ladder of violent escalation.

I hope that all colleges will learn from this, not that mentally ill people are dangerous, but that crime is dangerous.
The Blogenberry -- Fallen records... fallen students:
I think the events at Virginia Tech are no more understandable than the events at the University of Texas in 1966. The eerie randomness of shootings and mental illness in a society awash with weapons and violent mythology. A giant state school campus that is a training factory with aggressive recruiting of students from all races and backgrounds is going to come with its share of alienation. In global terms what is the context of this event? 32 dead can hardly match the nearly 200 dead in a single bombing in Baghdad (including 17 U.S. soldiers) this week. Yet there were no network anchors in Baghdad, no ribbons and candles and live broadcast vigils from Baghdad. No scrapbook for Baghdad even though its carnage is not unrelated to the random horrors at Virginia Tech.

Despite tantalizing talk of warning signs and disturbing behavior there is no real way to stop a Seung-hui Cho bent on slaughter just as there is no way to stop an Islamic terrorist, self-proclaimed martyr (recorded on videotape) on his way to heaven via the suicide bomb express. Suicide attackers in Austin, Oklahoma City, Baghdad or Blacksburg leave no real insights into their motives or lessons for preventing the repeat of their crimes. What they do leave are grisly, vivid mementos for the scrapbook. The attackers themselves have joined the ritual of their own deadly aftermath.

Friday, April 20, 2007

504 Sit-in Anniversary

Ed Roberts: Congressional Hearings in the Federal Building, Friday April 15, 1977, conducted by Congresspersons Phil Burton and George Miller

I had prepared testimony which I will give you, but I think I'd like to wing it.

First of all, I would like to begin by saying to the two of you who came and saw and helped us over these years in major battles, thank you. Now we're down to the bottom line. The basic issue here is are we going to perpetuate segregation in our society. We are one of the largest minorities in this country. I looked at the 18 points H.E.W. put out this morning. I have never seen a better blue print for segregation. These kinds of issues, the issue of Civil Rights and Human Rights are not issues that people with disabilities can compromise with any further.

My ability to move around and my ability to regain a pride in myself as a person with a disability is one of the most important things that has happened here today. To see hundreds of people with disabilities roll, sign, using canes, the more severely retarded people for the first time joining us in an incredible struggle, is one that leads me to believe that we're going to win this. Because we are not going to stop until 504 is a reality. 504, I believe, is a basic Civil Rights platform, a platform that guarantees to each person with a disability in this country that they are equal in the eyes of the law and that they will have equal access to educational institutions, hospitals, to the institutions in our society which serve us all?.

This Hearing is symbolic and we want you involved. And we are going to make a change then, and by making these changes we're going to begin to acknowledge in this society that people with disabilities are people first and we are not going to concentrate on the fact that they happen to be different. In fact, I am proud enough now to believe that people in our society are missing a tremendous feeling by not knowing me, by not knowing Judy Heumann, by not knowing the people here and the millions of other people with disabilities in our society. I think this country would be a much freer and fuller place if equal access and equal rights were guaranteed.
Judy Heumann:
It's very difficult for us to sit here allowing discussions to go on which, in our opinion, really violate the intent of the law. Whether here was a Section 504, whether there was a Public Law 94-142, whether there was a Brown vs. Board of Education, the harassment, the lack of equities that has been provided for disabled individuals, that now is even being discussed by the administration, is so intolerable that I cannot put into words. I can tell you that every time you raise issues of separate-but-equal the outrage of disabled individuals across the country is going to continue, is going to be ignited. There will be more takeovers of buildings until finally, maybe, you'll begin to understand our position. We will no longer allow the government to oppress disabled individuals. We want the law enforced. We want no more segregation. We will accept no more discussions of segregation and I would appreciate it if you would stop shaking your head in agreement when I do not think you know what we are talking about.

Jeannine Whitmer, Demonstrator

I know the issues around 504. I know how it will affect educational facilities. I went to school at Wayne State because it was accessible, and it was assumed I would go there. It had nothing I wanted- it was the only option open. Michigan State and U. of Michigan were and are inaccessible. Now I go to SF State and it is relatively accessible. It's taken four years, chopping down their barriers. The building which has the liberal studies in it is inaccessible. Basic Science building is inaccessible. That means the disabled cannot go into the technical science fields there. If I were just starting in my education now I would go into medicine. As an undergraduate they said to me, "You want to be a doctor?" I was laughed at, so out of frustration I went into education, because it was easy and I wanted an education.
Source

Note: I've got lots going on this weekend (and this past week), but didn't want to pass this anniversary by without reminding those that might not know it that at age 38, I belong to the first generation of disabled Americans who were allowed to attend grade school and high school with our nondisabled peers. There were exceptions, but physically disabled children (and definitely developmentally disabled children) were routinely excluded from all public school interaction with their nondisabled peers, sometimes entirely because they rode on wheels. It is because of the heroes of the 1977 504 sit-ins who demanded that the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 be fully implemented. They said they would wait no longer and they demanded equal access to public buildings. The ADA was possible because of this. My education and ability to sit here and type today was profoundly effected by the actions of these disability rights heroes of the past. Just thirty years ago.

More linkage as I get the time.

Update: Here's some background info on the Rehab Act and the 504 Sit-In, written for the Independent Living site by Chava Willig Levy:
The Rehabilitation Act of 1973

In October 1972, Congress passed a rehabilitation bill that sparked jubilation among disability rights activists. That jubilation was short-lived, however, because President Nixon promptly vetoed the bill.

Ten years earlier, the disabled community might have swallowed this bitter pill of defeat stoically. But revolution was in the air. Protests were staged across the country. In New York City, Heumann and eighty comrades held a sit-in on Madison Avenue, bringing traffic to a standstill (Ingram, 1981). Angry letters and demonstrators flooded Washington. Finally, Congress overrode Nixon's veto. On September 23, 1973, the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 became law.

Once again, jubilation was tempered with certainty that the battle had just begun. The new law was a meaningless piece of paper without federal regulations through which it -- and particularly Section 504 of the law -- would be enforced. Section 504 states:

No otherwise qualified handicapped individual in the United States shall, solely by reason of his handicap, be excluded from the participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any program or activity receiving federal financial assistance.

Eunice Fiorito, former director of New York City's Mayor's Office for the Handicapped, first president of the American Coalition of Citizens With Disabilities, and currently Special Assistant to the Commissioner of the Rehabilitation Services Administration, recalls:

It was 1975 and there were no regulations. We proceeded then to come into 1976 and there were still no regulations, and therefore the law was not being implemented. (In 1977) within two days after the Carter Administration was put into place, about 15 of us came to see Secretary (of Health, Education and Welfare) Califano, expressing our desire to work with him and his staff to get (the regulations) out in a reasonable period of time. We went back and forth to meeting after meeting in good faith. And we finally said to them, "Look, we have had enough. If you cannot come up with a decision, then we must take action."

We gave them until the fourth of April. And on the fourth of April, they did not have the regulations ready for issuance. So we developed an alternate plan: to bring our plight to the attention of the [American] people. (Ingram, 1981)


Taking a Stand by Sitting in

On the fifth of April, disabled activists took action in 10 cities across the country. With reason to fear that the 504 regulations were to be rescinded, they staged sit-ins in federal office buildings. Their demand: that the 504 regulations be signed into law. In most cities, the demonstrations were over by day's end. In the nation's capital, officials would not allow food and drink into the building, starving the demonstrators out. "But in San Francisco, [over 150] demonstrators stayed and stayed. They were not going to go away" (Ingram, 1981).

Mary Jane Owen was there.

After sleeping the first night on the hard floors, mattresses were delivered from the supplies of the State Health department. Food arrived from McDonald's, Delancy House's drug programs, the Black Panthers and Safeway. The Mayor himself scolded the federal officials for ignoring the needs of the uninvited guests and brought in shower attachments to be used in the tiled restrooms.

Some of us decided to call a hunger strike to confirm to ourselves and others our commitment to stay at any cost There were so many [heroes] -- Steve, who lay day after day and night upon night, [recording] events because -- he knew what was happening was important enough to risk his health; Jeff, who... wrote new words for old civil rights songs with which we loudly greeted federal employees [each] morning; the deaf woman who entered the building to teach a class in sign language and stayed; the mentally retarded woman who always injected a note of realism into our too abstract deliberations. (Owens, 1987, p.9)

On April 28, the demonstrators learned that Secretary Califano had signed the 504 regulations. They continued to occupy the building, however, until they had reviewed the final regulations and were satisfied with their content. On May 1st, the motley crew representing virtually every disability-disbanded, knowing that this experience would unite them forever.

BTW, Chava Levy hasn't updated her blog in a long time, but her "Yellow Sign" story, parts 1, 2, and 3 are good crip reading.




Wednesday, April 18, 2007

On Virginia Tech

My thoughts go out to the families and friends of those killed at Virginia Tech. It's hard to know what to say about such devastating violence and tragedy, or if to say anything at all. I've left some meandering thoughts over at Avast! Feminist Conspiracy!, and while there will be much speculation in the days and weeks to come about Cho Seung-Hui's mental health, I've nothing to say about that here at this time.

Monday, April 16, 2007

Double discrimination for ethnic minority children with autism

Source: BBC News

Excerpt:

A National Autistic Society report on "the reality for families" suggests 62% of parents had no choice over the school their children would attend.

Children with autism who are from ethnic minorities face a double discrimination in education, campaigners say.

Parents were much less satisfied with their child's academic and social progress than White British parents.

The government said meeting the needs of autistic children was "a priority".

Parental perceptions are that their children lost out because of the sort of unwitting racism identified in a recent Department for Education and Skills report.

Joan Nelson, whose son is black and has autism, told the society she believed ethnicity had a significant impact on the level and type of education he was given.

"There appeared to be more of a belief that my child was bad as opposed to having special needs," she said.

Black boys were penalised because their special needs meant they had difficulty accessing appropriate education, because they were Black, and because they were boys, she said.

"This hinders them in achieving what they should in today's system."

Transgenderism and disability rights

Found via Trinity at The Strangest Alchemy, this post by Eli Clare, which is a transcript of Eli's keynote speech at the FORGE Forward Conference. Read it for the gorgeous poetry. Or the connections Eli's made between transgenderism and the disability rights movement.

Eli begins:

All my life as a genderqueer crip, I have puzzled my way through bodily difference, struggling with my own shame and love, other people’s pity and hatred. Yesterday I helped facilitate the Disability Gathering here at the conference. We spent the day, disabled people and our allies telling stories, laughing, crying, and sitting quiet. It reminded me of the incredible importance of community, how bodily difference means one thing in isolation and quite another when we come together, finding ourselves reflected in each other’s stories.

My first experience of queerness—of bodily difference—centered, not upon sexuality or gender, but upon disability. Early on I understood that my body was irrevocably different from my neighbors, classmates, playmates, siblings: shaky, off balance, speech hard to understand, a body that moved slow, wrists cocked at odd angles, muscles knotted with tremors. But really, I am telling a kind of lie, a half truth. Irrevocably different would have meant one thing. Bad, wrong, broken, in need of repair meant quite another. I heard these every day as my classmates called retard, monkey, defect, as nearly everyone I met gawked at me, as my parents grew impatient with my clumsiness. Irrevocably different would have been easy compared to this. I stored the taunting, gawking, isolation in my bones; they became the marrow, my first experience of bodily difference.

.... But really I want to delve beyond the rhetoric we often don’t pay attention to. Delve into the myriad of lived bodily differences here in this room tonight and think hard about three lessons I’ve learned from the disability rights movement. The first is about naming, the second, about coming out and disclosure, the third, about living in our familiar, ordinary bodies.
I could try and summarize what he talks about, or explain how brilliantly he manages to explain what has been a vague unarticulated barrier to my own fuller understanding of transgenderism, but I really need to think on it for awhile. I will say this much: the connections Eli makes between the lived bodily experiences of disability and transgenderism show implicitly why anti-trans hate is hating on us all.

Poetry Monday: Every Man's Burden

The Magic Wand
by Lynn Manning

Quick-change artist extraordinaire,
I whip out my folded cane
and change from black man to blind man
with a flick of my wrist.

It is a profound metamorphosis—
From God gifted wizard of roundball
dominating backboards across America,
To God-gifted idiot savant composer
pounding out chart-busters on a cockeyed whim;
From sociopathic gangbanger with death for eyes
to all-seeing soul with saintly spirit;
From rape deranged misogynist
to poor motherless child;
From welfare-rich pimp
to disability-rich gimp;
And from ‘white man’s burden’
to every man’s burden.

It is always a profound metamorphosis.
Whether from cursed by man to cursed by God;
or from scriptures condemned to God ordained,
My final form is never of my choosing;
I only wield the wand;
You are the magicians.

Sunday, April 15, 2007

A musical interlude with Joni Mitchell

When Mitchell was 9 she got polio, and while the effects of the disease have not been readily apparent to most of her fans, her music has been creatively shaped by a weakened left arm:

From the beginning, Mitchell played guitar in different tunings to compensate for the fact her left hand had been left weakened by a childhood bout with polio. As a result, her chord shapes, combined with the meandering meters of her more fanciful compositions, tend to resemble jazz more than standard folk or rock.
In a conversation with Joni Mitchell by Jody Denberg, September 9, 1998, Mitchell said:
...the 80s were a rough decade for me and on top of it I was diagnosed as having post-polio syndrome which they said was inevitable for I'm a polio survivor, that forty years after you had the disease, which is a disease of the nervous system, the wires that animate certain muscles are taken out by the disease, and the body in its ingenious way, the filaments of the adjacent muscles send out branches and try to animate that muscle. It's kind of like the EverReady bunny, the muscles all around the muscles that are gone begin to go also because they've been trying to drive this muscle for so long. That's the nature of what was happening so I had it mostly in my back, so you don't see it as much as you would in a withered leg or an arm. But the weight of the guitar became unbearable. Also, acoustic guitar requires that you extend your shoulder out in an abnormal way and coincidentally some of the damage to my back in combination with that position was very painful. So, there was a merchant in Los Angeles who knew of my difficulties and knew that this machine was coming along that would solve my tuning problems and he made on spec a Stratocaster for me out of yellow cedar that was very light and thin as a wafer, so an electric guitar is a more comfortable design for my handicap. Then, a genius lothier built me this two and a half pound guitar which is not only beautiful to look at but it kind of contours to my body. It fits my hip and even kind of cups up like a bra! It's just beautifully designed and then also I abandoned regular medicine and fell into the hands first of a Kahuna and then a Chinese mystic acupuncturist who put down his pins and just points at you. I know this sounds real quacky but they did some mysterious good to the problem and I feel fine.




Direct link to video at YouTube here. It's a live performance of "Both Sides Now" from 1970.

Friday, April 13, 2007

Things that crack me up, #24


















From Flickr by gmack24

Visual description: It's a photo of a brown sign posted to a cement wall. There's a walking pedestrian with a red circle and slash across her and these words below: "Do Not Walk on Ramp"

Daphne Wright found guilty of murder; death penalty decision yet to come

I recently wrote about Daphne Wright, the Deaf black lesbian charged with a brutal murder in South Dakota. This week the jury found her guilty after eight hours of deliberation. Story here.

On the penalty phase of the trial, coming this next week:

"The door is wide open for the defense putting on any kind of evidence that the defense believes might sway a juror to opt for life in prison rather than the death penalty," [South Dakota Attourney General Larry Long] said.

One possibility for the defense is to show how her deafness may have been an issue in the case.

At a pretrial hearing, a defense witness who is an expert on the deaf testified that it's borderline whether Wright could understand what's going on in the courtroom.

McCay Vernon of Florida said Wright reads at the third-grade level but either was deaf at birth or at 10 months of age, when she came down with rubella.

The rubella also may have caused some brain damage, though Wright has above-average intelligence, Vernon said.

She understands sign language well but may miss some things because it takes two to four times longer to say something through signing as normal speech, he said.

And Wright doesn't easily grasp the definition of some legal terms, such as Miranda rights, Vernon said.

"When you use the term 'rights,' they mean right like to the right hand or right like correct," he said at the time.
Commentary by Chuck Baldwin, the Argus Leader South Dakota journalist who live-blogged the event, includes further discussion about the possibility of fair trials for people not remotely demographically represented by the jury, specifically D/deaf individuals:
Deaf people feel out of place and discriminated against in the hearing world. American Sign Language, after all, is their first language. English is, at best, a second language. And they are Americans.

But how many of us try to learn their language? Who even thinks that communication might be our responsibility, too?

Add to that - Wright is black and a lesbian in mostly white, Bible-thumping South Dakota - and there was a real concern. Could she get a fair trial here?

Could she get a fair trial with no blacks, no lesbians, no deaf people on the jury?

Could she get a fair trial when Judge Brad Zell rejected a defense motion for consecutive translation, which is more accurate than the simultaneous translation used?

Could she get a fair trial when Zell rejected a defense motion to allow a certified deaf interpreter in the courtroom with her?

This isn't about guilt or innocence. It's about a fair trial. And many deaf people around the country have been absolutely certain South Dakota was trampling on Daphne's rights - guilty or not.

Headlines like this one illustrate why that is an important question.

Deaf blogger Ricky Taylor at RidorLIVE.com offers a racist, misogynist link (you can go to his site for it, I'm not linking here) further showing the kind of prejudices that exist out there and talks about the Wright case and verdict himself:
I do not care if it was Daphne or Jane Doe as long as she is Deaf. Why? Because it sets the precedence for others to follow in the future trials. What we see in Sioux Falls may set a tone for others to follow by saying, “Well, they did not use deaf peers on the jury, why should we?” in the future trials.

It is all about the right to be JUDGED by HER/HIS peers. It has nothing to do with accomodations (It is good that they are doing a good job on it!).

More on fair trial concerns here.

Thursday, April 12, 2007

Disability Carnival #12 at From Where I'm Sitting

It's on crip culture of all kinds. Go. Enjoy. Tokah has done a remarkable job!

The next carnival is scheduled to be at Ballastexistenz on Thursday, April 26. Deadline, I expect, is the Monday before, as usual. Amanda has set the theme as "What Box?"

Also, I've just volunteered to host a carnival in May but I'm not sure of the exact date yet. The theme will be "Firsts" in whatever way you'd like to interpret that. I'd especially like to see our nondisabled allies contribute, as well as disability bloggers who haven't been heard from yet or feel they might not be qualified to post. More details later.

Wednesday, April 11, 2007

New to the blogroll

Although some of these used to inhabit my blogroll before the great sidebar catastrophe of January, I've just added the following under "More Gimp Parades":

40 Million, Blind Bookworm, Chewing The Fat, Croneway, Diabetes Mine, Disability Culture Watch, Eschara, Funky Mango's Musings, Lisa Bufano, Modus Vivendi, Screw Bronze!, Selectively Bossy, The Adventures of a Paperback Princess, Peter Tan's Digital Awakening, The Future Doc Wilson, The Opposite of Tragic, The Rettdevil's Rants, and Wordgathering.

I learned recently from Skippy's posting about the technical side of blogrolling that my vast list of disability bloggers will rank lower on Google the more I add to it. That's unfortunate if it makes it harder for people to find each other, but it doesn't change my plan to add any gimp blogger to my roll who writes on the social aspects of living with impairments. Actually, I judiciously add sites that are not blogs too, and there are several new examples of that above.

Tuesday, April 10, 2007

Mini-Slumgullion #35

Lots of people think politics don't really matter,
but if you're one of the poor and disabled people
who have to rely on the government,
politics can kill you.



Nick Dupree -- "I Feel messed Up":
This country has been slashing programs for the poor and disabled for over a decade like it has no consequences, or worse, as I detailed in Fighting Cuts, Demanding Universal Health Care, they think that cutting off services benefits them--that it is a great thing. It isn't. It doesn't benefit you. It is evil. I believe this is the fifth 21 cut-off death in the city of Mobile alone, that I know of. The disability community in the South feels under siege. Know that there's still a developing, worsening situation with home care policy in America as more and more people turn 21 and find the supports they need just aren't there.

Politics is not a game. The disregard (or outright cruelty) of politicians can kill.
The latest news on Baby Emilio Gonzales:
A judge granted a family's request to keep their critically ill baby alive, ruling Tuesday that the boy should not yet be removed from life support as the hospital planned.

Children's Hospital of Austin has been caring for 17-month-old Emilio Gonzales since December, but it says its medical efforts are futile and the child is suffering. It invoked a state law that allows hospitals to end life-sustaining treatment in such cases with 10 days notice to the family.

Emilio's mother, Catarina Gonzales, 23, challenged the decision, and the judge agreed to block the hospital's move for at least nine more days.

"He may not live that long, but that's nobody's choice. That's my choice. And that's God's choice. Nobody can say, 'No we're going to take him off, that's it,'" she said. She says her only son isn't unresponsive, and that he smiles and turns his head toward voices.

Probate Judge Guy Herman set another hearing for April 19 to consider Emilio's case.

The boy has health coverage through Medicaid, and the hospital contends money is not part of its decision. Its concern, hospital officials said, is the boy.
Michael Bérubé at Pandagon on "Testing, testing":
There are people who oppose abortion except when the fetus has a significant disability; there are people who support a woman’s right to abortion but oppose prenatal screening on the grounds that it will lead to a revival of eugenics. And, as I point out in the essay (by way of the work of Rayna Rapp, who’s written a terrific book on the subject):
the ultra-orthodox Hasidim in New York are strenuous promoters of prenatal genetic screening because Tay-Sachs disease — a genetic disability so excruciatingly debilitating that it sometimes seems as if it were invented by bioethicists as an extreme limit case — occurs disproportionately often in Ashkenazi Jews.
You can learn more about Tay-Sachs here, if you like — and then you can think about whether you would seek to bar prospective parents from screening for it. Interestingly, Rapp points out that while otherwise politically and culturally conservative Jewish groups (one of which advocates prenatal screening and conducts arranged marriages) have embraced screening for Tay-Sachs, the Catholic Church (OK, folks, here it comes) in New York City owned the airspace rights to a new hospital building under construction and demanded that “genetic counselors be barred from working in the new maternity service to be located there.” So while some religious traditions can be downright extremist, it’s not as if all religious conservatives agree about this kind of thing. Nor is it the case that all opponents of screening are conservative; some of them are disability-rights activists whose politics are generally feminist and socialist.
It's a weird choice of quote just above since Bérubé's post has lots of thoughtful aspects to it, but I just felt compelled to highlight that last sentence: "Nor is it the case that all opponents of screening are conservative; some of them are disability-rights activists whose politics are generally feminist and socialist." Those of us who are feminist disability-rights activists possessing impairments/disabilities are often disbelieved or dismissed when our political opinions appear to align with conservative beliefs. I say "appear" because I think that's a failing of those liberals who can't see the politics of choice in all its incarnations, particularly the ones that don't directly concern them. But anyway.

Another interesting aspect of the discussion Bérubé starts with this post at Pandagon is that the comments are overwhelmingly about gayness being something one is born with. As a topic, that's intriguing, I suppose. As a topic shift, it's tiresome and irritating. I haven't added to the conversation over there yet (so I've little excuse to complain, perhaps), but I invite everyone to do so.


Monday, April 09, 2007

A musical interlude


"Girl Anachronism" by The Dresden Dolls

the lyrics by Amanda Palmer:

you can tell
from the scars on my arms
and cracks in my hips
and the dents in my car
and the blisters on my lips
that i'm not the carefullest of girls

you can tell
from the glass on the floor
and the strings that're breaking
and i keep on breaking more
and it looks like i am shaking
but it's just the temperature
and then again
if it were any colder i could disengage
if i were any older i could act my age
but i dont think that youd believe me
it's
not
the
way
i'm
meant
to
be
it's just the way the operation made me

and you can tell
from the state of my room
that they let me out too soon
and the pills that i ate
came a couple years too late
and ive got some issues to work through
there i go again
pretending to be you
make-believing
that i have a soul beneath the surface
trying to convince you
it was accidentally on purpose

i am not so serious
this passion is a plagiarism
i might join your century
but only on a rare occasion
i was taken out
before the labor pains set in and now
behold the world's worst accident
i am the girl anachronism

and you can tell
by the red in my eyes
and the bruises on my thighs
and the knots in my hair
and the bathtub full of flies
that i'm not right now at all
there i go again
pretending that i'll fall
don't call the doctors
cause they've seen it all before
they'll say just
let
her
crash
and
burn
she'll learn
the attention just encourages her

and you can tell
from the full-body cast
that i'm sorry that i asked
though you did everything you could
(like any decent person would)
but i might be catching so don't touch
you'll start believeing youre immune to gravity and stuff
don't get me wet
because the bandages will all come off

and you can tell
from the smoke at the stake
that the current state is critical
well it is the little things, for instance:
in the time it takes to break it she can make up ten excuses:
please excuse her for the day, its just the way the medication makes her...

i dont necessarily believe there is a cure for this
so i might join your century but only as a doubtful guest
i was too precarious removed as a caesarian
behold the worlds worst accident
I AM THE GIRL ANACHRONISM

Poetry Monday: The Knife of Language

Helen Takes the Stage
by Kathi Wolfe

(Helen Keller starred in a vaudeville show The Bluebird of Happiness in 1924.)
Here I am,
playing,
like a well-trained
seal, for you,
between the clowns
and singing dogs.
Your surprise
at seeing me in the flesh
in a room smelling like cigars,
makes my skin prickle with heat
more than the stage lights.
Did you know
that Mark Twain taught
me to play pool and spit tobacco?
Annie, my teacher, hates
my being here.
"It's so undignified
to tell jokes to drunks
and traveling salesmen," she says.
I crave applause
more than scotch, cigarettes
or hot dogs swimming in mustard.
With the knife of language,
I've carved out the best life
an icon can.
But, being a saint
is as difficult
as getting a drink during Prohibition.
Yet, until the curtain falls,
I am tethered, like you,
to the laughing
muck and mire of the earth.


And from The Washington Post in July of 2001, an article by the above poet on heroes and inspiration: "He's Your Inspiration, Not Mine":
Don't get me wrong -- I like to readnews reports on disabled people, at least when they're about issues -- health insurance, discrimination, education -- that concern me and my peers.

Just keep us in some kind of real context. Occasionally, show us not as main characters but as background characters -- like a story about a Metro delay or the Smithsonian Folklife Festival that includes, but doesn't necessarily feature, the folks with white canes and wheelchairs stuck on the subway or sitting in the audience. And on TV and in movies, give us some roles as regular characters -- like Marlee Matlin's deaf political consultant on "The West Wing." There's been progress on this front in the last few years; I'd like to see more.

And I'd like to see stories about some of the peoplewho really are heroes to those of us with disabilities. Like those who found a sudden demand for their previously unwanted services during World War II, and rose to the challenge. While able-bodied men were away fighting, disabled people worked in factories and offices and served as volunteers. Reporting for a 1995 article, I talked to Norma Krajczar of Morehead City, N.C. As a visually impaired teenager in Massachusetts, Norma was a volunteer aircraft warden; the thought was that her sensitive hearing would give her an advantage over sighted wardens in listening for enemy planes. And I learned that Akron, Ohio, became known as the "crossroads of the deaf" because of all the deaf people who came to work in tire factories converted to defense plants -- making more money than they had ever been able to before. Yet, even with all the reporting that's been done recently about the Greatest Generation, you don't hear much about those folks.

Friday, April 06, 2007

If Skippy or Sarahlynn sent you: Welcome!

Thanks for coming, and thanks to Skippy and Sarahlynn.

If you want to read a couple things I've written recently (as opposed to Things That Crack Me Up and Slumgullions) go here here or here.

Thursday, April 05, 2007

As it should be, of course

The Gimp Parade is the number one result of a Google search for:

"she is a very sexy vent dependent quadriplegic"

How I love that someone typed in this particular search, regardless of who they were hoping to find.

Wednesday, April 04, 2007

"Autism Speaks" creator on Oprah

Kristina Chew at Autism Vox reports that Oprah will feature "The Faces of Autism" on April 5 (tomorrow), except those faces will be filtered through the lens of guest Suzanne Wright, co-founder of Autism Speaks. For those unfamiliar, Wright's organization is responsible for the video "Autism Every Day," which will also be featured on The Oprah Winfrey Show. The video was released in May 2006 and features a mother saying in the presence of her autistic child that she thinks about killing that child.

You can read about the reactions of autistic folks to this video here, here, and here.

Oh, Oprah.

Things that crack me up, #23


















From Flickr contributor giginger

Visual description: A window display with five different wheelchairs among green and warm reddish-orange curtains. A big sign reads "Don't you wish your wheelchair was HOT like me?" and three smaller signs by different wheelchairs reading "Don't cha?" "Don't cha?" "Don't cha?"

Tuesday, April 03, 2007

Medical professionals who are excellent, asses and part of a failing system

My posse and I trekked into the Twin Cities this morning (despite threats of dangerous weather that have come true all around Minnesota over the day) because of a malfunctioning G/J feeding tube that needed immediate replacement. The balloon part that inflates in my stomach to hold it all in place had deflated itself and the damn thing was trying to come out, which it cannot really do without also pulling away from where it enters my upper intestine (jejunum).

This deflation and migration caused me some discomfort but not any intense pain, the hospital that installed it worked me into the schedule this morning and it was easily replaced. I returned home before people started sliding off the icy roads and all is mostly well with my world.

But there's this little drama that plays out each time I get the tube replaced and I've only just today discerned the pattern among the cast of medical professionals I spend about a half hour with -- usually every three months. The nurse who comes to get me in the radiology recovery room (for outpatient procedures I am unfamiliar with) is always male, which is fine, but curious since nursing is a predominantly female profession. He's also always incredibly personable and relaxing to be around, which I appreciate since he is my host to Events That Thus Far Have Gone Smoothly But Do Involve Medical Risk. This host has been several different specific guys in the past year, all kind and competent.

The x-ray techs are also mostly male in this high tech procedure, though today there was one woman present other than myself and the nurse I brought with me from home. These x-ray techs do non x-ray-ish things like sterilize my stomach with Betadine and arrange the surgical drapes. I expect the specialization of the nursing and x-ray tech requirements somehow explains the male predominance I've observed, but I don't know exactly how or why.

The nurses and x-ray techs have all always been reassuring, professional, caring, kind, responsive -- everything you want in medical people. The doctor shows up for five minutes to yank the old tube out and thread the new one in. The guy I usually get calls me "sweetheart" and comes and goes rather politely but quickly. He seems skilled, and I appreciate that.

But here's the thing: He's a total ass to the other people and, in subtle ways, to my nurse. It's not one isolated incident. He's displayed asshattery on several occasions now, belittling the employees under him at the hospital and treating my nurse like she and others like her are either negligent or incompetent. Today's deflated balloon and faulty tube, he asserted to my nurse, was the fault of her and others in my employ who just won't leave it alone and must have manually deflated the balloon.

The doctor discussed this with my private nurse out of my hearing, basically giving her professional chiding and advice without ever once consulting me about my care. It didn't dawn on me until today that not only am I just a body on the table that he does a quick procedure to and then leaves, but he doesn't even consider me a partner in my own care of the equipment he installs in my body. Perhaps because I have a nurse, I don't know. Maybe it's part of his abrupt pragmatism and crowded schedule, but I doubt it's as simple as that.

Meanwhile, the other employees of the hospital that he seems to consistently belittle and treat like dirt continue to shower me with thoughtful care. It's unlikely he's like that just when I'm around once every few months, right? This is a working condition for these other professionals that serve me well and might someday decide that they don't deserve this crap and move on to another job.

There's gender, ableism and a kind of professional classism at work in these dynamics I observe, and it's taken me a year of quarterly encounters and some quizzing of my nurse to get a fuller picture of it, since I'm not privy to all of it that occurs even in my specific interests. And this is an example of medical competence, really. In all ways medical, it's basically a successful encounter. And yet that successful-ness seems precarious to me because of all the power dynamics involved with this one doctor, and that's been on my mind all day.

Genni McMahon, who blogs at Ilyka Damen's, has had much more dramatic, critical problems with medical care on her mind today. Read it all, but here's a taste:

My mother became very ill the night before last with a high fever, extreme body aches, and weakness. She’s 62, swims three times a week and uses her Nordic Track everyday. She’s a partner in an accounting firm, takes no prescription medicine, and is a health nut. She couldn’t get out of bed, so my sister and I went to her house and called her doctor; he’s a skilled physician, but like most of the system, he’s a doc for profit. His office told us to take her to the ER. There, we had a really bad experience and they managed to nearly kill her, which I’ll share in a moment.

First, though, let me say that in spending the entire day in an ER, with momentary breaks to go get things from my mom’s house and take a kid from one caretaker to another, I noticed what I think is the absolute cornerstone of What’s Wrong With Healthcare In America. I’m sure you’re curious as to my discovery, so I’ll let you experience it as I did.

Sunday, April 01, 2007

Mini-Slumgullion # 34

Joshua Kors at The Nation -- "How Specialist Town Lost His Benefits":

Jon Town has spent the last few years fighting two battles, one against his body, the other against the US Army. Both began in October 2004 in Ramadi, Iraq. He was standing in the doorway of his battalion's headquarters when a 107-millimeter rocket struck two feet above his head. The impact punched a piano-sized hole in the concrete facade, sparked a huge fireball and tossed the 25-year-old Army specialist to the floor, where he lay blacked out among the rubble.

"The next thing I remember is waking up on the ground." Men from his unit had gathered around his body and were screaming his name. "They started shaking me. But I was numb all over," he says. "And it's weird because... because for a few minutes you feel like you're not really there. I could see them, but I couldn't hear them. I couldn't hear anything. I started shaking because I thought I was dead."

Eventually the rocket shrapnel was removed from Town's neck and his ears stopped leaking blood. But his hearing never really recovered, and in many ways, neither has his life. A soldier honored twelve times during his seven years in uniform, Town has spent the last three struggling with deafness, memory failure and depression. By September 2006 he and the Army agreed he was no longer combat-ready.

But instead of sending Town to a medical board and discharging him because of his injuries, doctors at Fort Carson, Colorado, did something strange: They claimed Town's wounds were actually caused by a "personality disorder." Town was then booted from the Army and told that under a personality disorder discharge, he would never receive disability or medical benefits.

Town is not alone. A six-month investigation has uncovered multiple cases in which soldiers wounded in Iraq are suspiciously diagnosed as having a personality disorder, then prevented from collecting benefits. The conditions of their discharge have infuriated many in the military community, including the injured soldiers and their families, veterans' rights groups, even military officials required to process these dismissals.

They say the military is purposely misdiagnosing soldiers like Town and that it's doing so for one reason: to cheat them out of a lifetime of disability and medical benefits, thereby saving billions in expenses.

Journalist Stuart Hughes, who blogs at Beyond Northern Iraq, writes for the BBC News on Heather Mills -- "Heather: Amputee Inspiration or Irritation":
Even when I had two legs I was no dancer, so the idea of fox-trotting, tangoing or cha-cha-cha-ing in front of an audience of millions is unthinkable to me.

And aside from the issue of whether she is merely trying to rebuild her tarnished image after her bruising separation from Sir Paul McCartney, I admire her determination to take on the bipeds at their own game.

One gambling website is taking bets on whether Mills' leg will fall off during the series, pointing out her prosthesis "must fall off, not be purposely taken off, during a dance routine for all Yes wagers to be graded a win". If you want a betting tip from me, put a tenner on her prosthesis staying firmly attached.

The current generation of prostheses are secured with tightly-fitting silicone liners fitted with pins or suction seals, which roll onto the skin like a sock. The chances of Heather's flying into the audience during a high kick are precisely zero.
Jean Chambers at Philosophy Now reviews Martha Nussbaum's Frontiers of Justice: Disability, Nationality, Species Membership:
The ‘frontiers’ of Frontiers of Justice are three social frontiers at the edge of the political community as it has been defined by social contract theorists such as Rawls. The early social contract theorists Thomas Hobbes,John Locke and Jean-Jacques Rousseau posited free and independent men, roughly equal in power, living at first in a pre-social ‘state of nature’. Such men would have had little reason to form a society and submit to the authority of laws unless they could individually benefit from giving up their absolute liberty. Therefore the only social contract they could rationally agree to would be a mutually advantageous one. But this familiar scenario has tended to exclude from the resulting polity anyone who it might not be mutually advantageous for such men to cooperate with – anyone who is not free, not equal, or not independent. Nussbaum claims that people with disabilities, citizens of other nations, and non-human animals have thereby been banished by contract theorists to the frontiers of social justice.

People with disabilities may not be free or independent; and those with severe mental disabilities may be unequal. Nussbaum argues that such people should nevertheless be considered full citizens entitled to dignified lives, even if no one could gain from cooperating with them. She notes that the social contract tradition has always denied the reality of dependency, despite the obvious fact that everyone is dependent on others during infancy, old age, injury, and illness. Historically women have done most of the largely unpaid work of caring for dependents, so by ignoring women, the social contract theorists conveniently evaded the thorny issue of justice for dependents and caregivers. Nussbaum argues that justice for people with disabilities should include whatever special arrangements are required for them to lead a dignified life, and the work of caring for them should be socially recognized, fairly distributed, and fairly compensated.

Friday, March 30, 2007

Things that crack me up, #22

I know this is a serious search engine query (Yahoo this time instead of Google), and it's such a general question that I have no advice, but the specific wording of it cracks me up:

"What steps can I take if I'm Disabled in a WheelChair in 2007"?

Accessibility here, just somewhere else




















































Flickr credits: Lee Bennett, ekai, and Isgphoto, respectively.

Visual descriptions of the three photos above: 1) A simple sign that reads "Wheelchair Ramp Available, Inquire Within," 2) A simple sign reading "Accessible Restrooms On The Second Level," and 3) A door with a sign at door handle level reading "Disabled WC" and a piece of paper posted about a foot above reading "POLITE NOTICE: This toilet is out of order. Please use the facilities upstairs. Sorry for any inconvenience caused."

Thursday, March 29, 2007

More writing on Ashley X

As people incorporate the Ashley Treatment into their thinking about disability or just spend a little time with the ethics of it all, more continues to be written about the case and the precedent it creates:

Patricia Williams for The Nation, posted at AlterNet:

This was also very wrong as a matter of ethics and public policy. There seems to be, in the national debate about this case, a popular consensus that the parents were well motivated, so who are the rest of us to judge? That sentiment is expressed loftily, as in Peter Singer's New York Times op-ed ("she is precious not so much for what she is, but because her parents and siblings love her and care about her"), and crudely, as in an anonymous online posting to the disability rights organization FRIDA ("I think your group is a pain in the neck ... if and when something happens to the caregiver, who will take care of the disabled person ... your group or the state who really does not give a hoot.")
Dave Reynolds at Inclusion Daily Express asks the question "Should 'Ashley X' be at the Center of Community Living Debate?":
Frankly, however, I haven't been able to make that link between community supports and Ashley's parents. I don't think one has much to do with the other.

For one thing, I found nothing in statements by Ashley's parents to suggest that an increase in community supports would have kept them from surgically changing their daughter to fit what they wanted her to be, an eternal "Pillow Angel". To the contrary, they said that they had tried in-home services but were not happy with them. Not that their satisfaction with the services would have mattered; even if they had the best in-home supports for Ashley, they still would have chosen their radical procedure.

"We would never turn the care of Ashley over to strangers even if she had grown tall and heavy," they wrote.

And because we knew this would never be just about Ashley X, Today's Zaman, a Turkish news site reports:
Two families with children suffering from cerebral palsy voiced support on Friday for another family’s plea to stunt the growth of their son, 13-year-old Umut Mert, who suffers from the same disorder. Füsun Evren, Umut Mert’s mother, earlier this week announced she was looking for a doctor who would stunt her son’s growth, in an operation now referred to as “Ashley’s treatment,” so named after a 9-year-old Seattle girl whose parents opted to stunt her growth with high-dose estrogen.

.... Professor Saim Yeprem from the Religious Affairs Directorate said that Ashley’s treatment was unacceptable. Yeprem said: “Umut Mert would be castrated if he received Ashley’s treatment. Castration is opposed by all religions, not only Islam.”

Dr. Güler Saygun from the Turkish Disabled Persons Administration said that applying such a treatment would require approval from the Ministry of Health’s Ethics Council. The head of the Turkish Association for the Disabled, Zülfikar Akar, said: “We don’t think it’s the right choice, but the mother’s situation is indeed difficult. These situations happen because care centers don’t offer long-term care for people with disabilities.”

Wednesday, March 28, 2007

Big badass slumgullion #33

Blog posts and news reports all mixed together... slumgullion-like:

The Gray Panthers of San Fransisco blogs about managed care and assisted-suicide:

...The California Association of Physicians Groups, an organization that represents Northern and Southern California Permanente Groups and lobbies for “groups practicing in the managed care model” (http://www.CAPG.org), have recently come out with letters to the Legislature and press statements strongly advocating for assisted suicide in California.

Will assisted suicide proponents finally admit that a quick hundred dollar lethal prescription is vastly cheaper than offering extended care over the long haul?
Diebold sues Massachusetts for selecting a competitors voting machines over theirs. Judge denies Diebold's request to block bid. --Via Sara

Merge of schools for blind and deaf students opposed in Oregon. Also in Ohio. I've been following the controversy about this on a listserv, but Stephen Kuusisto of Planet of the Blind weighs in here.

In the NYT: Trafficker of Healer? And Who's the Victim? -- On pain treatment

From NPR, artist Lisa Bufano finds creative inspiration for dance in being a double amputee. Video of some dance segments also available at the NPR link. Visual description of photo at left by Gehard Aba: Caption from NPR "This 2005 piece, Fancy, was commissioned by the University of Linz. In it, Bufano wears stilts fashioned from red, Queen Anne-style table legs."

Also from NPR, the Healing Waters Project, which provides fishing as a therapy for wounded war vets.

At Garrison Keillor's The Writer's Almanac (I know, but the poem he presents is somebody else's, not by his bigoted self) -- "How to Tell If You're a Participant or a Staff (A Handy Guide for Day Programs)" by David Moreau

Diary of a Goldfish on "As no questions, hear no lies" -- Goldfish weighs in on strangers' questions about impairments.

Bioethicist Arthur Caplan and Michael A. Devita (whom I don't know anything about) write about a transplant surgeon being investigated for "hasten[ing] the death of a 26-year-old patient in order to harvest his organs more quickly to ensure they would be transplantable."

On how the relay phone service for the deaf is used by con artists and the people hired to do the relay cannot legally interfere:
Operators vary in their estimates of scamming prevalence, but most agree that con artists chew up roughly a third to half of their workload, at times even more. Because of confidentiality rules set down by the FCC, relay companies say they can't monitor or estimate the number of abuse calls.

"If we did just legit calls, our office would be closed. The managers tell me, 'if it weren't for those calls, you wouldn't have a paycheck,' " says one operator in New Castle, Pa., who wished to remain anonymous for fear of losing her job. She has worked at an AT&T relay center for more than a decade and is putting her children through college on her wages.
At TomPaine.com, "Cutting Native People's Health Care":
American Indians have access to federally-paid health care based on hundreds of treaties the United States signed with Indian nations, under the accepted federal practice of more than 100 years and as a requirement of the trust responsibility the U.S. owes the Indian nations to care for their welfare. Indians have not, however, received their fair share of federal health care, especially in light of this heightened duty. In fact, a July 18, 2003 study by the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights entitled “A Quiet Crisis” found that
... the federal government’s rate of spending on health care for Native Americans is 50 percent less than for prisoners or Medicaid recipients, and 60 percent less than is spent annually on health care for the average American.
Clearly, the United States is not fulfilling its treaty and trustee responsibility to provide health care to American Indian people.
From the NYT: "Can You Live With the Voices in Your Head?" -- On auditory hallucinations

From The New York Review of Books: "A Track All His Own" -- On "outsider" artist Martín Ramírez. The image just above, created in 1954, is a drawing by the artist of a horse and rider in profile, with both the horse and some lines drawn around them in box-like progression to create an illusion of depth in shades of purple. The rider seems to be wearing chainmail and I find the drawing reminiscent of ancient Greek drawings on pottery and murals. The horse has one front leg kicked up high. More on the artist and his history as a schizophrenic and immigrant from Mexico here and here.

Simi Linton at Disability Culture Watch offers a heads-up that next week's Law & Order: Criminal Intent on NBC Tuesday evening will feature some Deaf actors:
I know that they hired many Deaf actors and that their process (of development, casting and production) was extraordinary.
From The Stranger, an anonymous column on the Iraq war and disability fetishism:
And thanks to George W. Bush—and Donald Rumsfeld and Dick Cheney and Condoleezza Rice and corrupt Republicans and ineffectual Democrats—there are going to be a lot more amputees around for me to see as sexual beings. During the Vietnam War, two American soldiers were wounded for every fatality. Now, thanks to advances in body armor and battlefield medicine, 16 U.S. soldiers are wounded for every fatality. That means fewer depressing military funerals and more sexy disabled vets, more Bryan Andersons and Marissa Strocks.
From the Minneapolis-St. Paul Star Tribune, and article about local Muslims trying to balance culture and faith. Among several other conflicts, some devout Muslim taxi drivers refuse to transport people with service dogs:
Airport commissioners have expressed concern about cabbies refusing to pick up fares because of Islamic prohibitions against carrying alcohol. They also worry that Islamic rules about dogs might prompt drivers to decline rides when 300 visitors with guide dogs attend the American Council of the Blind convention in Minneapolis this summer.

Abdinoor Ahmed Dolal, a Muslim cab driver from Kenya, was stunned by the commissioners' concerns. The Qur'an places high value on assisting the disabled, he said. So Dolal says Muslim cabbies have offered to give blind conventioneers free rides to Minneapolis, forgoing the $30 fares as a sign of good will.

"The issues we have are so simple and have nothing to do with extremism or fanaticism," Dolal said. "We are Muslims and we are Minnesotans and if we sit down and listen to each other, we can work things out."
The cover story of the latest Weekly Standard: "Identity Politics Gone Wild: The Deaf Culture Wars at Gallaudet University" -- The tone of this conservative piece seems partly to be that taxpayers don't need to pay for this school, but it's also very critical of Deaf culture as an identity.

Tuesday, March 27, 2007

Texas guidelines for interpreters for the deaf

This 59-step guide on how to provide interpretaton for deaf defendants in the Texas court system came across on a listserv I observe.

The full diagram viewable at this .pdf file. Visual description of the full chart at the link is difficult without spending an hour or two writing out the complexity of this huge flow chart. The image below shows only about a dozen steps, from a green circle that reads "1. Contact between person and court." with arrow to a yellow shape that reads "2. Is person arrested and taken to judge acting as a magistrate?" If the answer is yes, an arrow leads to number three, if no, an arrow leads to number 12. In several places along the process, the question is whether or not the judge learns the person is deaf, hard of hearing, or doesn't speak English. An answer of "no" at these points presumes the person can hear or understand English.

Molski and the Ninth Circuit

I've written about Jarek Molski before. He's the paraplegic Californian who has sued hundreds of businesses for Title III ADA violations (public accommodations access). Under the California Unruh Act, which is a state civil rights law, he has also sued for damages -- something the ADA won't allow but that defendants like Clint Eastwood have in the past claimed of the ADA.

Molski is known as a serial litigant, and last week the Ninth Circuit reversed Molski v. M.J. Cable, Inc. in his favor. Sam Bagenstos of Disability Law blog was cited in the opinion and describes the case and outcome:

The case the court decided today, Molski v. M.J. Cable, Inc., involved Molski's suit under the ADA and California's Unruh Civil Rights Act against a restaurant in Woodland Hills. The evidence at trial made clear that the restaurant was inaccessible in violation of Title III of the ADA, but the jury found no violation. Rejecting a motion for a new trial, the district judge concluded that the jury could have properly found that Molski was not an "individual" entitled to protection under the ADA but instead was a business (who makes money bringing accessibility suits).

In today's opinion by Judge Ferguson, the Ninth Circuit reversed. The court concluded that the evidence compelled a finding that the restaurant violated the ADA. As for the notion that Molski wasn't an "individual," the court found no basis in the statute for that reading.
The opinion, available as .pdf file here, is interesting reading for a number of reasons.

First, it rejects the defendant's claim that Molski is a "business" and not an "individual" with standing under the ADA because of his history of ADA litigation and the money he has been awarded through the damages provided by the Unruh Act. Not only that, the opinion interprets the ADA as not requiring a disabled individual to be an actual client or customer to have standing under the ADA's Title III since choice among businesses, whether a person uses a business or not, is part of the law's intent.

This is an important point because it means, for one thing, that an individual with future hopes of using a business has legal recourse to work toward that day. Imagine, for example, not physically being able to enter and become a customer, but being denied standing because of that lack of access. Or imagine some large event like a family wedding or political convention with an upcoming date when disabled people want to be present. The Ninth Circuit's opinion seems to account for those sort of situations.

Second, there's some gratifying crip awareness to the opinion illustrated particularly in the eighth footnote, which notes the ableism of the defendant's argument:
The defendant’s analogy that “[Molski] was no more a customer at [Cable’s] on that day than he would be had he been sitting at the counter waiting for the restaurant’s cashier to turn his or her back so [Molski] could steal the money from the cash register” is simply wrong, not to mention puzzlingly insensitive in its imagery, given that Molski is confined to a wheelchair.
I can forgive the "confined to a wheelchair" perspective given there's recognition that the defendant in court refused to really assess or give credibility to what the plaintiff's accessibility needs might actually be.

The third thing that interests me is the opinion's description of the inaccessibility Molski experienced at the defendant's restaurant. Remember, Molski has been vilified for being a "vexatious litigant" and the ADA attacked routinely in the media because of serial litigants like him. Here's the description:
Upon entering the restroom, Molski noticed numerous architectural barriers to his accessing the facilities. The door pressure on the bathroom door was too heavy, and the door lacked a handicap accessible sign. Inside, the stall doors could not close with Molski’s wheelchair in the stall. The stall lacked grab bars on both the rear wall and side wall, which prevented Molski from maneuvering from his wheelchair to the toilet. The toilet seat cover dispenser was unreachable. The pipes underneath the sink were not insulated, and therefore, according to Molski, posed a special risk to those without feeling in their legs, as hot pipes could burn them without their realization. The sink also lacked levered hardware, a type of fixture that is easily moveable without strong grip strength. Molski was unable to reach at least one of the paper towel dispensers. Molski testified that the hygienic violations were especially important in his case because, due to his chest-down paralysis, he uses a catheter and a urine bag that must be emptied frequently. He explained that failure to empty the urine bag can cause autonomic dysreflexia, a condition that can result in whole body spasms and even cardiac arrest. Handling the bag with unwashed hands can also lead to bladder infections.
With the exceptions that I don't have any urine bag to empty and rarely even see a toilet cover dispenser anywhere, this description describes just about every inaccessible restroom I have ever been in -- and found I literally could not use. I want to go through it line-by-line.

The heavy door. Most restroom doors push inward, which means that a heavy door that requires one to pull toward them to open and exit the room is almost impossible for someone on wheels or on crutches, particularly given the cramped architecture of most restroom entrances. Yes. I have been trapped in public restrooms with heavy doors, unable to exit and unsure if anybody would find me there for hours.

The stall door would not close with Molski and his chair inside it. For many women I know, this is a security issue as well as a matter of equal access. Besides, usually leaving the door open while transferring and peeing means that you face the public mirror and everyone who enters and leaves the restroom (and sometimes those in the hall just outside) cannot help but look at you while you use the toilet.

The stall lacked grab bars. This is the main problem that would make this restroom completely unusable for me. This is the reason why, hundreds of times, I have left a business I have already spent money at to go look desperately for somewhere else to pee.

The exposed pipes under the sink. Insulation of exposed pipes prevents legs from being burned by hot water. Since I haven't used a manual much in the past decade and my scooter pulls alongside rather than up and underneath the sink, this isn't a special problem for me now, but it used to be an issue of serious safety when I did.

The sink lacked lever hardware. This makes a sink completely unusable for many of us.

No towel dispenser was reachable. This is especially a problem where sinks are part of vanity-type counters because those counters are almost always covered with water from previous sloppy users. If I can't reach the towels, I can't use the sink from my seated position without soaking my arms and the front of my top with someone else's used water. This is gross and unsanitary and requires me to choose between washing my own hands or keeping my top clean and dry.

The defendant didn't dispute any of these violations Molski listed. In fact, Anthony Dalkas, the vice president of the company owning the restaurant, testified that they hadn't addressed these access issues because they hadn't been required to (italics mine):
In his testimony, Dalkas acknowledged that the company had not attempted to identify barriers to the disabled. He admitted that Cable’s had not made the renovations because “[w]e weren’t compelled to do it.” Dalkas testified that Cable’s could afford each of the repairs but stated, “once you start down that path[,] you’re opening a can of worms that will cost a lot of money.”
I stand by what I said two years ago about ADA compliance and serial litigants like Molski:
...15 years on the books hasn't been enough to encourage thousands upon thousands of businesses nationwide to install even simple ramps. Like any law, the ADA and other disability nondiscrimination statutes can surely be abused, but I have a difficult time finding sympathy for inaccessible businesses I could never patronize that gripe about complying with a law passed in 1990.... Like other mobility-impaired individuals, when I consider going somewhere new -- when friends or family discuss a social outing with me -- the first consideration we must have is whether or not the place we wish to go is accessible. If it complies with the law. As often as not, we must alter our plans. If I decided to sue every business I came across that was truly violating the law just by failing to give me entrance into their front door (never mind restroom accessibility, which is equally important, really), I would not have to exert myself to become a serial plaintiff too. Noncompliance is everywhere.

Monday, March 26, 2007

Things that crack me up, #21

It's just so mysterious.

Restroom signage somewhere in Orleans, France.















From Flickr by bananeman

Visual description: It's a simple drawing of a woman in a manual wheelchair at right and a washroom sink at left. There's a giant green arrow leading from the sink and pointing to the woman. I suppose this is somehow meant to indicate the sink is accessible, but there are no accompanying words, and really, it looks like you're supposed to douse the woman with water or pry the fixture loose and whack her with it. Or something.

Poetry Monday: Their Sudden Tongues

Tulips
by Sylvia Plath

The tulips are too excitable, it is winter here.
Look how white everything is, how quiet, how snowed-in
I am learning peacefulness, lying by myself quietly
As the light lies on these white walls, this bed, these hands.
I am nobody; I have nothing to do with explosions.
I have given my name and my day-clothes up to the nurses
And my history to the anaesthetist and my body to surgeons.

They have propped my head between the pillow and the sheet-cuff
Like an eye between two white lids that will not shut.
Stupid pupil, it has to take everything in.
The nurses pass and pass, they are no trouble,
They pass the way gulls pass inland in their white caps,
Doing things with their hands, one just the same as another,
So it is impossible to tell how many there are.

My body is a pebble to them, they tend it as water
Tends to the pebbles it must run over, smoothing them gently.
They bring me numbness in their bright needles, they bring me sleep.
Now I have lost myself I am sick of baggage ——
My patent leather overnight case like a black pillbox,
My husband and child smiling out of the family photo;
Their smiles catch onto my skin, little smiling hooks.

I have let things slip, a thirty-year-old cargo boat
Stubbornly hanging on to my name and address.
They have swabbed me clear of my loving associations.
Scared and bare on the green plastic-pillowed trolley
I watched my teaset, my bureaus of linen, my books
Sink out of sight, and the water went over my head.
I am a nun now, I have never been so pure.

I didn't want any flowers, I only wanted
To lie with my hands turned up and be utterly empty.
How free it is, you have no idea how free ——
The peacefulness is so big it dazes you,
And it asks nothing, a name tag, a few trinkets.
It is what the dead close on, finally; I imagine them
Shutting their mouths on it, like a Communion tablet.

The tulips are too red in the first place, they hurt me.
Even through the gift paper I could hear them breathe
Lightly, through their white swaddlings, like an awful baby.
Their redness talks to my wound, it corresponds.
They are subtle: they seem to float, though they weigh me down,
Upsetting me with their sudden tongues and their colour,
A dozen red lead sinkers round my neck.

Nobody watched me before, now I am watched.
The tulips turn to me, and the window behind me
Where once a day the light slowly widens and slowly thins,
And I see myself, flat, ridiculous, a cut-paper shadow
Between the eye of the sun and the eyes of the tulips,
And I have no face, I have wanted to efface myself.
The vivid tulips eat my oxygen.

Before they came the air was calm enough,
Coming and going, breath by breath, without any fuss.
Then the tulips filled it up like a loud noise.
Now the air snags and eddies round them the way a river
Snags and eddies round a sunken rust-red engine.
They concentrate my attention, that was happy
Playing and resting without committing itself.

The walls, also, seem to be warming themselves.
The tulips should be behind bars like dangerous animals;
They are opening like the mouth of some great African cat,
And I am aware of my heart: it opens and closes
Its bowl of red blooms out of sheer love of me.
The water I taste is warm and salty, like the sea,
And comes from a country far away as health.