Wednesday, July 11, 2007

Slumgullion #41

A link list to five blog posts you should see:

At Writhe Safely, "Damn, feminists" discusses the tendency of feminist activists to overlook mental health issues and specifically the case of Simone D., which, as flawed plan points out should have all feminists up in arms, writing letters, making phone calls:

Crickets chirp at what’s happening in your own back yard; not a single post in the feminist blogosphere about Simone D., New York Hispanic woman with an impressive story of injustice and a rather pressing need for acts which activists can and are being urged to do on her behalf in the activist way they pride themselves on. Given the right conditions. Which are what again?
At The Trouble with Spikol, Liz looks at PETA head Ingrid Newkirk's attack on Michael Moore's weight. Here's an excerpt, but read the whole, excellent piece:
“Congratulations from PETA on the reviews for Sicko,” Newkirk wrote. “Although we think that your film could actually help reform America’s sorely inadequate healthcare system, there’s an elephant in the room, and it is you.” This was followed by Newkirk’s advice that Moore convert to vegetarianism. She wrote: “As they say at Nike (sorry!): ‘Just do it.’”

I was horrified—as were many others who read the letter. PETA later claimed that where Newkirk was using the “elephant in the room” metaphor, she was merely invoking a commonplace idiomatic expression rather than commenting on Moore’s girth. But that’s bullshit.

She could’ve just as easily put it in other words, but PETA has always prioritized cleverness over compassion. I’m sure she and her staff were thrilled when they thought of that one. What a zinger!

Newkirk’s decision to co-opt the debate about Moore’s film is preposterous. Sicko creates an essential opportunity to galvanize activism on the subject of healthcare, and given the reality that Moore histrionically illustrates in his film, we can’t afford to waste this moment.
At The Joy of Autism, "Are We Listening?":
It is rare to sit in a room with so many other autistic people, some walking back and forth in the lunch room humming to themselves in a heightened perhaps even ecstatic state, where I can only imagine in other less accepting settings, would be frowned upon. When I came to squeeze into the small space where this young man hummed to deposit my lunch tray, he politely moved away to make room for me, extremely aware despite the fact that others would believe otherwise.

When I saw him next time in the leisure area, he was asking others to play a board game with him. Other autistic kids were hanging out together, and sprawled themselves out on couches in front of the TV, not unlike other teenagers. Around the grounds, people wore badges that indicated if they wanted to talk, if they would only talk to people they knew, or if they did not wish to talk at all. There were many times I wanted to flip my own badge that indicated the latter – as I am a person who likes to absorb and observe, yet have been taught to socialize and be diplomatic and suffer from a compulsion to keep that impression going. Although it’s a skill I’ve acquired, I still find it exhausting. I wished that those badges existed at the many functions I have attended, where most people pretend to be something that their not, or interested in things that others say that they actually have no interest in at all. I consider all the wasted time I’ve had to spend doing "small talk." and all the time I spend in explaining life as we know it to people who don’t have the time to understand.
At ChronicBabe, "How asking for help has brought me closer to friends":
My friends sometimes forget that I am in pain, and for the most part, I'm glad my friends forget about it. The last thing I want is for my pals to walk around, worrying about me, thinking every time they see me that I'm a mess.

But because I've learned to live with pain, I don't always say anything about it. I might take a day off because I don't feel well, but I don't announce it to the world. I might need somewhere to sit when we go out, but I find it myself most times. There are days when I can't walk very far, or I'll go out with girlfriends and I can only dance to a couple songs. But I don't whine about it.

Because I'm relatively quiet about the pain I live with, people forget I have it, especially my friends.
At Bums & Bellybuttons, "The Day I Became Different":
....When I was about 5, I learned that I was different. When I entered the restaurant with my parents, a young boy (about my age, I guess) stood up and repeatedly announced to the entire population, "She's in a wheelchair!" Needless to say, staring commenced. Pairs and pairs of eyes swiveling toward me, a little girl, cute in her party dress, suddenly not the girl she was five seconds before she came through the door. Even thinking about it 20 years later makes me want to claw my skin.

It had never occurred to me to realize that sitting down made me fundamentally different than just about everyone I encountered. No one else seemed to notice, so why should I? My parents didn't make a big deal out of it, unless it was for my own physical safety. It just was as it was.

Monday, July 09, 2007

What would that look like?

In the recent discussion of Aimee Mullins in Sports Illustrated, Sara, Trin and I have been debating Mullins' portrayal in that mag, and the portrayal of amputees and disabled people, generally, by the media. In the sidebar at right I've got a category for analysis of media coverage of disability, Wheelchair Dancer frequently looks at NYT coverage (examples of that here, here, and here), and there's a thoughtful discussion at Medical Humanities Blog, also about a woman amputee excelling in her career.

So, what would positive media coverage of Aimee Mullins, specifically, look like? How would someone laud her successes without putting her on the supercrip pedestal or fetishizing her amputated limbs either textually or with photos? Here are a couple alternatives to the SI story's sexualized supercrip slant:

And here is Petra Kuppers on "Addenda? Contemporary Cyborgs and the Mediation of Embodiment" where she specifically analyzes a fashion photo of Mullins wearing those old-fashioned wooden prosthetics she briefly mentions in the SI article. It's a complex look at disability, feminism, Mullins' agency or complicity with the image, "false consciousness" and media portrayal both of disability and femininity. I'm too short on time and energy just now to write about it, but it's right on topic here.

Visual description: There are three photos here. The first is one of Lynn Johnson's collection on Mullins and is in black and white. Mullins stands in her athletic uniform and high tech racing prosthetics on a race track facing a woman holding a microphone and two men with tv cameras on their shoulders. This is a media interview at the 1996 Paralympics in Atlanta.

The second photo is the fashion art pic Kuppers analyzes and this is her thorough description: "The large colour photo presents Mullins sittting on the floor, her head in her hand in a defeated or melancholic position. She appears squeezed into the frame, contained by the photo’s borders. The colours of the image are brown and beige, earthy, taking up the blond of Mullins’ wild hair and echoed in the make-up. Mullins is wearing various stiff items of clothing, all of which extend out of the photo frame. The clothes are referenced in the accompanying text, in accordance with the generic conventions of fashion photography. The comprise of: a calico-coloured skirt skeleton reminiscent of whalebone crinoline underskirts (crinolin [sic] frame, for hire from Angels and Bermans) and a textured close-fitting top (suede T-Shirt by Alexander McQueen) to which shoulder ornaments are attached that look like wooden filigree Japanese or Spanish fans (wooden fan jacket, by Givenchy Haute Couture). She is also wearing artificial ‘mannequin’ lower legs (not referenced as ‘model’s own’ in the picture blurb, but extensively discussed in the Press). The legs look old and stained, and while one foot with coloured toenails is visible in the frame, the other reaches out to frame-left."

The final photo is Mullins running full-out on a beach with the ocean and blue sky behind her. She's heading down the beach away from the camera and appears to be wearing the exact black bra top and string bikini bottom she wears in the posed studio photo topping the SI article -- that much-discussed other photo.

Sunday, July 08, 2007

Overdue bill threatens life support

From The Flint Journal in Flint, Michigan:

Bedridden with a chronic lung disease, Patricia Alsteen depends on machines to help her breathe.

But the mother of four said she's worried that her electricity will be shut off because she can't pay a sizable power bill that accrued, in part, because of her life-support equipment.

For weeks, Consumers Energy Co. has been threatening to shut off her services, she said.

"I understand I owe them money," said Alsteen, 43. "I would pay it if I had it."

A spokesman said Consumers is holding the account open while she works with agencies that might be able to help with her energy bills.

"We are waiting to hear back from the customer about contact she made with some other agencies, and we're continuing to work with her on a payment plan," said spokesman Terry DeDoes.

Alsteen said she is on Social Security and hasn't been able to work for several years. She has a caregiver and lives with her four children, ages 7-18, and a grandchild, 2.

She's been hospitalized several times over the past year, including once for a bout with pneumonia that nearly killed her, she said.

"Every time I go in the hospital, I have to pay somebody to come and take care of my children," she said.

During the day, she receives oxygen from a machine through a trachea tube. At night, she is on a ventilator.

Over the winter, Alsteen paid about $230 a month to Consumers under a seasonal billing protection plan, she said. But because she used about twice that amount of energy, a bill of more than $2,000 came due when the plan ended in May, she said.

A recent television news report on her situation drew a couple of donations, including $450 from an Owosso woman who took up her cause and started a fund at Charter One Bank in Owosso.

The benefactor, Jenny Roberts, said the overdue power bill is literally a life-and-death situation for Alsteen.

"When she was crying, I was crying," Roberts said. "She said, 'If they shut off my life support, I'll die.'"

DeDoes said Alsteen didn't need to pay the entire balance.

Consumers granted a 14-day extension for her to pay an agreed-upon sum, then cut the payment to $321, DeDoes said. A church stepped in and covered that bill, he and Alsteen said.

The utility also sent forms on a discounted rate for life-support equipment, along with a list of agencies she might call for help, he said.

Alsteen said she already receives the discounted rate and hasn't been able to find much assistance.

"I called agencies, I called churches - everywhere I could think of or where people told me to call," she said. "None of the agencies had money.

"I feel kind of like a bum asking people for help. I'm not that kind of person."

Consumers planned to speak with Alsteen on Monday to discuss her situation, DeDoes said.

"We encourage customers to call us as soon as they believe they are going to have a problem paying a bill, and not when they receive a shutoff notice," he said.

"That way, we have more time to set up payment plans and work with a customer."

Donations can be sent to The Patricia Alsteen Fund, c/o Jenny Roberts, c/o Charter One, 200 E. Main St., Owosso.

Friday, July 06, 2007

Friday music: Mr. Larkin by State Radio



Direct link to the YouTube live version of this song. A softer version is available at eMusic.


Lyrics:
Mr. Larkin

I work in the kitchen
At an old folk's home
I do my best but I too am getting on
I do the dishes but lately I been dropping plates
See as I get older my hands are starting to shake

So Mr. Larkin
See I got to hold this job
Did you misspeak when you told me
She was all but gone
Mr. Larkin
Dock me my one week's pay
But don't ask me to leave
I can't afford that today

Ten years ago my wife took sick
So I brought her here
My job I quit
I started working for the home
So I could be by her everyday
We couldn't afford the cost in any other way
So

So Mr. Larkin see I
I know she know who I am
Every now and then she'll squeeze my hand
It's what I live for it's why she don't die
So Mr. Larkin won't you won't you give me this try

I walk to work on route 27
I see the same cars pass everyday
And through all this New England weather
You know never once have I been late

So Mr. Larkin see I
I know she know who I am
Every now and then she'll squeeze my hand
It's what I live for it's why she don't die
So Mr. Larkin won't you won't you give me this try

I see the argument you're makin'
And I understand you got to do your job
And believe me I know she's turning angel
But you see this woman is all I got

So Mr. Larkin see I
I know she know who I am
Every now and then she'll squeeze my hand
It's what I live for it's why she don't die
So Mr. Larkin won't you won't you give me this try
Won't you give me this try
Won't you give me this try


Okay, so the song "Mr. Larkin" is about nursing homes and staying near your loved one.

This is the State Radio song that I cannot get out of my head:

"Camilo" about the Iraq war. The live video version explains the song's origin.



Lyrics:

Woke him up with a barrel to his head
His eyes shut tight bracing for the blow
Resigning his life to the metal held
In another man's hand

Twenty days in a concrete fallout
What life have I to take your own
Oh my country won't you call out
Doorbells are ringing with boxes of bones
And from another land's war torn corners
To a prison cell in my own
Punish me for not taking your orders
But don't lock me up for not leavin' my home

Your words just a bloody fallacy
A house of cards you painted white
You tried to recreate Normandy
But you made up the reason to fight
And now red oil is spillin' down on the street
And your eyes too big for the belly is weak
Will you not refuse this currency
Or is blood money just money to you
Is blood money just money to you

Twenty days in a concrete fallout
What life have to take your own
Oh my country won't you call out
Doorbells are ringing with boxes of bones
From another land's war torn corners
To a prison cell in my own
Punish me for not taking your orders
But don't lock me up for not leavin' my home

Camilo
Camilo
Leavin' my home
Camilo

Frida Kahlo -- Celebrating the 100th anniversary of her birth

Artist Frida Kahlo was born on July 6, 1907, in Mexico City, Mexico, to a Mexican Indian and Spanish mother and Hungarian Jewish father. She died at age 47, on July 13, 1954, but she is, quite possibly, the most world-famous disabled woman living or dead. Her art is her fame, as well as her relationship with fellow Mexican artist Diego Rivera and her communist politics. Deeply personal, her art is filled with imagery of impairment and physical pain.

There are indications that in addition to childhood polio, a devastatingly injurious tram accident at age 18, and the loss of a limb in her later years, Kahlo was born with some spinal condition such as spina bifida.

Along with the paintings shown here, I've got a collection of links more interesting than anything I can write about Kahlo:

Her paintings are catalogued and described fairly well (in both English and Spanish) here, as part of an excellent site all about Kahlo, her life and her work.

This article, "The Trouble with Frida Kahlo" by Stephanie Mencimer, published in 2002 in Washington Monthly explores how Kahlo -- and all female artists -- needed to have a tragic or sensational personal story to enter the male canon. Mencimer's analysis begs for a disability studies rebuttal, particularly comments like this:

Some feminist art historians have struggled against such reworkings of women artists, but Kahlo's pop-culture mania revives it with a vengeance. Kahlo certainly facilitated this process by painting herself as the quietly suffering female. In every possible sense, the mass-culture Kahlo embodies that now-poisonous term: victimhood. She was the victim of patriarchal culture, victim of an unfaithful husband, and simply the victim of a horrific accident. But that's probably one reason why she's so popular. "People like to see women as victims," says Mary Garrard, a professor of art history at American University.
And this:
Many of her surgeries may have been unnecessary. Even Herrera notes, "If Frida's physical problems had been as grave as she made out, she would never have been able to translate them into art." Kahlo's close friend, the famous doctor Leo Eloesser, believed that she used her many surgeries to get attention from people, particularly from Rivera. There's no doubt that she was obsessed with him in a way that should make feminists cringe. She also made several suicide attempts and spent much of her adult life addicted to drugs and alcohol.
Though the article is well worth a read for it's look at how Kahlo's inability to bear children is widely interpreted as a tragedy when she may well not have seen it as such. And for when Mencimer notes this:
One wonders what the postal service was thinking when it put Kahlo on a stamp. "Visas are denied to [foreign] artists with Frida Kahlo's politics," notes Chadwick.
Here is, I think, a more developed and disability-studies-friendly analysis of Kahlo's self-portraiture. (That's a link to the main page of a Frida site. Check out the sidebar feature labeled "Frida and her obsession of self-portraits.")

For true disability studies analyses of the 2002 film Frida, starring Salma Hayek, read Marta Russell's CounterPunch review and a wonderful discussion between Harilyn Rousso and Simi Linton at DisabilityWorld. Both movie reviews note the obliteration of any depiction of Kahlo's childhood polio and it's early effects, with the tram accident framed instead as the life-altering tragedy to her physical health. Also, her recovery from that accident is made complete in the film so that a tango between Kahlo and another woman is not complicated by what would have been an interesting limp. The Rousso-Linton discussion ranges beyond the movie itself to look at use of the word "cripple," sexuality, and class and disability.

Rousso says:
Remember the scene in the garden where she's sitting in her wheelchair a few months after the accident? To me, this is the quintessential stereotype about the person who is in an accident or illness--that their main desire, preoccupation is to be able to walk again. She is sitting in the garden, her parents arrive and she gets up out of the wheelchair, takes her first steps and suddenly becomes almost nondisabled.... I found it shocking when we finally do see her using a wheelchair in an ongoing way, which is about an hour and a half into the film. We are given no sense of the progression of her disability. Until then, her disability was not shown as affecting her daily life. It was shown as affecting her painting - both her decision to paint and at least some of the content of her paintings, but not the details of her life. She was by and large portrayed as a "non-disabled disabled women." Then suddenly well into the film she is shown as quite significantly disabled.
Here's a link about Liz Crow's short experimental drama Frida Kahlo's Corset. "Corset" refers to the orthopedic back braces Kahlo wore because of her impairments.

From a 2005 exhibition, here's the Kahlo site for the Tate Modern Art Museum in London.

Finally, this PBS site on the film The Life and Times of Frida Kahlo includes five of Kahlo's works of art made into image maps with additional info available to mouse rollover.

Links lead to visual descriptions in English and Spanish: The four paintings in this post are The Broken Column (1944), Tree of Hope, Remain Strong (1946), Henry Ford Hospital (1942) and Self-Portrait with the Portrait of Doctor Farill (1951).

Thanks to Penny for the heads-up on Frida's birthday.

Thursday, July 05, 2007

Not "legless": Ten pairs of legs!

There's been a discussion making the rounds on feminist blogs about a recent Sports Illustrated story on Aimee Mullins, double-amputee athlete, actor, model, most current President of the Women's Sports Foundation and apparently also one of the 50 Most Beautiful People in the World. The SI story uses the "supercrip" stereotype to hype Mullins considerable accomplishments with a lede that first lists her successes and then sets her up on that unreachable pedestal:

Her accomplishments are each impressive enough on their own, but when you take into account that she's done it all on silicone and titanium legs, she's just making the rest of us look bad.
Accompanying the text are several photos -- one, thankfully, showing her actually competing athletically -- with the most prominent pic being the topic of bloggy discussion. Here it is, at left. It's a full body black-and-white shot of Mullins in profile, positioned on all fours as if at the starting blocks for a foot race. She's wearing high-tech, below-the-knee prosthetics, a black bra and string bikini bottoms, with a wind machine swirling her hair in the air. She's not on a race track. This is a posed publicity shot.

Now, I do hesitate to just post this photo, but as it happens, Mullins is already the number one Google image search leading to my site, for a magazine cover photo she modeled years ago and which I never did actually post here -- only linked to prior to now. But, what the hell, this is that photo too:

Photo description: It's a magazine cover with the bold capitalized words "DAZED" across the top and a background of all white. Mullins wears form-fitting athletic pants and studio lighting accentuates the curve of her buttocks. She's got the high-tech prosthetics that look much like wide flat metal hooks, and she's not wearing anything else. She's turned away from the camera enough that her upraised left arm allows her to peek over her bicep at the camera and her left breast is in provocative profile. At knee height, down by her prosthetics, runs the capitalized text "Fashionable?" though the word is split on either side of her body so it could also read "Fashion Able?"

This is the photo The Gimp Parade routinely gets 100 hits/day for. Well, it competes for most hits with this photo of Marine Lance Corporal James Blake Miller, taken about a year ago in Fallujah (make of that what you will):

Visual description: Taken by Luis Sinco for The LA Times, it's a head shot of Miller, wearing a desert camouflage-colored helmet, face smudged with camouflage war paint, eyes staring tiredly, and a cigarette hanging from his lips. Smoke swirls around his face. The news story, linked just above, explains why this photo has been dubbed "Marlboro Man."

I posted a link to it for Memorial Day, 2006, when I was noting that the war continues to disable people and leave them, both here and in Iraq, with less than they had before. This pic is a sort of porn too really, you know.

Anyway, here are links to discussion at IBTP, Bastante Already, Fetch Me My Axe, and Trinity at The Strangest Alchemy, here and again here. To skip the PhD version, just read Trin's first link, and maybe the one at FMMA. The feminist tension throughout these posts seems to be basically one of radical feminist privileging of a strictly feminist media analysis over one that would be more of a disability-feminist analysis.

Sara of Moving Right Along comments at IBTP:
It is my fond wish that amputees be seen as just another flavor of ordinary, not extraordinary or freakish just because we don’t have all our original body parts, so ordinary that people don’t even blink when they see us coming. If we could achieve this, it would make our lives easier and richer because we could spend less of our precious, irreplaceable lives fending off other people’s projections and could instead just get on with it all. And getting images of us out there in mainstream publications showing various among us doing ordinary or extraordinary mainstream things that would be just as ordinary or extraordinary for anyone else, things like competing in sporting events like ordinary folk, even being extremely successful at it as some people are, is definitely one very good way to go about this. It is!

However, pornification does not equal normalization.
Even more to the point, in a later comment, Sara adds:
... I have to say that I pay as little attention to acrotomophiliacs (the fetishists you mention) as I possibly can. My introduction to them was via a year-2000 article on apotemnophilia (no longer available online without a subscription) which I found at the Atlantic Monthly website in 2003. This article was the first thing listed in response to an AltaVista search I’d run as my first step doing research to determine whether I’d rather have my leg off or die of cancer that year, which doctors had concluded by then were my only two immediate choices.

Fortunately, my second result sent me to a prosthetics site showing a young woman who’d just climbed a mountain in her prosthetic leg. The blurb about her didn’t focus on her ass and say whether she’d ever modeled.

Living as a woman, sexual objectification and obligatory attempted submission to fuckability/worth standards are implied, no matter what. The objectification I experience as an amputee is distinct from the objectification I experience as a woman in that it is not always sexual. For clarification of what I’m talking about, please see these posts:
Talking Points: An Object Lesson at my site

and these posts and their comments from the last Disability Carnival:
Disabled Performing Pioneers by Marcy at Dirty Laundry
and
Disability and Media by Daniel at Medical Humanities Blog

Whether we are talking objectifying amputees and other putatively or definitely disabled folks, women or men or children, sexually or otherwise, the problem is the same: people not seeing other people as people first but as objects and symbols they then have to be re-taught are human. I expect Twisty would say it all happens because of the dominance engine that fuels the patriarchy, though I also expect she’d put it better.

You might think it’s only bad when you’re being sexually pornographied. However, there are lots of ways to demean people by objectifying them. Consider this: Yesterday, in walking from my car to the post office, maybe half a block, I had two perfect strangers come up to me and basically tell me I was a brave woman for leaving my house. One came up from behind asking “How’s the leg working out for you?” (And I was wearing really cute shoes!) The other one told me right to my face, with tears in her eyes — you know, instead of “Hi, how are you?” — “You’re a brave woman!”

This kind of thing happens to me everywhere I walk. I would find it inhibiting if I weren’t already so shopworn.

When I was young, I couldn’t leave the house without being pestered by some man about my tits and my ass. Now I can’t leave my house without being congratulated for my [projected] courage by complete strangers.

The objectification escalates. And it’s all the same dynamic, even when it’s not strictly sexual.
Mainly, I wanted to put Sara's remarks in gimp context, so they wouldn't surrender to the archival oblivion at Twisty's. Trin takes issue with other IBTP commenters who suggest photos of Mullins in SI would be better if she were au naturel, that is sans prosthetics:
Heaven forbid your assistive technology make you hot. It's supposed to look all klunky and weird and alien so we can pity you. Didn't you get the rulebook?
Personally, I'd love to see Sara and Trin hash this out as two disabled women (though I know Sara cringes a bit with that identification) who seem to disagree. My guess is that they don't so much disagree as they see different aspects of the radical feminist analysis that need to be emphasized from a disability perspective.

My perspective: Mullins appears to be the amputee soft-porn that causes most people to show up at this blog, and I suspect they're not hanging around to read the latest on Kevorkian or the anniversary of the Olmstead decision. And blogging ego aside, I do have a problem with that.

On the content of the SI article itself, this is what really caught my eye:
[Mullins] owns 10 different sets of prosthetic legs, from her titanium sprinting legs ("my brother calls them my 'robo-cop legs,'" she laughs) to the intricately carved ashwood museum pieces she once modeled in a fashion show for designer Alexander McQueen.
Share the irony with me: I recently commented on something written by a woman temporarily using crutches and wheelchair who repeatedly referred to her "life without legs." And here's Mullins, a double-amputee who talks about her ten different pair.

I also want to know how she accumulated her legs. Do they all work? Are some spares or gifts because of her relative fame? How many, on any given day, might be useful enough that she decide between them? At one point I owned as many as four wheelchairs and scooters. I think there are three around here just now, but I'm sitting in the only one that is suitable for anything but an emergency. The one in the garage (bought around 1990) may not work at all, and the one in the basement (Quickie manual, circa 1985) would cause me great pain and discomfort if an emergency arose and I found I needed to use it, though it would get me from here to the can.

Are Mullin's ten pair extravagance or simply spare parts, like mine? And is there anyone in the world who can claim more pairs of legs than her? I mean, there are lifetime amputees who've never had a single prosthesis or wheeled chair. Does Mullins have crutches and chairs, as well? That would be the story here for me. Well, unless we can just talk about an impressive woman with many accomplishments, without the supercrip theme.

Tuesday, July 03, 2007

Wiki frenzy

There are several new wikis focusing on disability information that have popped up recently. Like with all wikis, they're a work in progress open to anyone who wishes to contribute. Here are the links:

Disapedia
Wikibility Rights
Civil Rights WikiSpace, with dis info here and here

Slumgullion #40 -- Let's Hear it for the Boys edition

Most disability bloggers seem to be women, but the mens got good things to say too:

"My guide dog is about to retire" by Damon at Do Your Worst:

My guide dog Liam, who I've had for seven and a half years, will be retiring at the end of this week. He's now nine years old. Liam is a bit of a stressy sensitive dog so this seems the best time to retire him.

So, what does this mean. It means that Damon has to go back to using a white cane - something he hasn't done since leaving school in 1991.
"The Pitfalls of Pity" by Gordon Cardona at Gordon's D-Zone:
It was when on the local newspapers and media I get to know that my best friend had received a prize for ‘helping his poor crippled friend’ (me that is). I was speechless and betrayed. At first I blamed my friend for it and said I wouldn’t trust him any more. But then I knew that it was all about the way society viewed people ‘like me’ that was the cause of it all.

I suddenly felt inferior and felt betrayed by my teachers, my schools and all the institutions that supported this prize. Sadly, this prize goes on every year and guess what? Non-disabled boys and girls still receive this prize for ‘being friends’ to their disabled ‘less fortunate’ friends.
Was it only last September that Mark Boatman at NodakWheeler escaped from a nursing home? The vent-using quadriplegic had to leave his home state to do it, but since he moved to neighboring Montana he's got a pet dog, seen The Rolling Stones in concert, and now he's heading off to college. Check out his adventures in the many photos he posts.

"On Being Married to Big Foot" by Stephen Kuusisto at Planet of the Blind:
She can clean dog hair off the kitchen floor in less than two minutes with her feet. This is a kind of domestic dancing that even the ancient and labyrinthine Gods and Goddesses of Knossos would take their hats off to, but of course they didn't have hats, which is probably why they died out if you stop and think about it.
"Livin’ la vida corta" by Michael Bérubé at Pandagon:
And I hope I haven’t given people the sense that everything is just wonderful with Jamie all the time, and that Down Syndrome isn’t such a big deal if you just take the Right Attitude. (There’s a little story in the DS community about how having a child with DS is like winding up in Holland when you’d planned to go to Italy, and while this story serves the crucial function of reassuring new parents that their lives are not ruined or blasted or just plain over, it’s really not a very good analogy, in the end.) There’s a reason why so many Jamie Stories involve me taking him on trips or playing golf with him or going to aquariums and zoos with him: it’s not like he has friends. Oh, people are mostly very nice to him, and kids greet him cheerily in school and in town, and his teachers and aides like working with him, because he’s a great kid. But he doesn’t have the kind of social network other fifteen-year-olds do; he doesn’t do sleepovers and play dates and just hanging out. (When Nick’s friends were here last month — and Nick’s friends are absolutely wonderful to Jamie — I told Jamie he could stay up until midnight and hang out with them. After a few minutes he came into my study, sat down, and said dejectedly, “I don’t know how to hang out.” I explained that he didn’t really have to do anything at all; he could just sit in Nick’s room and listen to what everyone was saying. But, of course, he was quite right. You have to know how to hang out before the invitation to hang out makes any sense.)

Friday, June 29, 2007

Friday music: random wheelchair reference

Black Gold
by Soul Asylum

Two boys on a playground
Tryin' to push each other down
See the crowd gather 'round
Nothing attracts a crowd like a crowd

Black gold in a white plight
Won't you fill up the tank, let's go for a ride
I don't care 'bout no wheelchair
I've got so much left to do with my life

Moving backwards through time
Never learn, never mind
That side's yours, this side's mine
Brother you ain't my kind

You're a black soldier, white fight
Won't you fill up the tank, let's go for a ride
Sure like to feel some pride
But this place just makes me feel sad inside

Mother, do you know where your kids are tonight?

Keeps the kids off the streets
Gives 'em something to do, something to eat
This spot was a playground
This flat land used to be a town

Black gold in a white plight
Won't you fill up the tank, let's go for a ride
Sure like to feel some pride
But this place just makes me feel sad inside

Black gold in a white plight
Won't you fill up the tank, let's go for a ride
I don't care 'bout no wheelchair
I've got so much left to do with my life



Music video here.

Thursday, June 28, 2007

Things that crack me up, #32

For Steve and Connie:

Visual description: It's a color photo evidently taken somewhere on graduation day as many of the people in the background are wearing gowns and academic regalia. A tarred walkway cuts over a grassy area. In the foreground a red sawhorse blocks the entire walkway for no obvious reason. These words are printed boldly in white on one of the red horizontal crossboards: "Providing a safer environment for the visually impaired."

Disability Blog Carnival #17 at Planet of the Blind

The topic is humor: "Laughter, The Best Medicine." Go, already.

The next carnival will be at Retired Waif on Thursday, July 12, with deadline the Monday before. The carnival submission form is here.

Visual description of the photo at left: It's the first icon created for the Disability Blog Carnival and it's a photo of a blue parking lot sign with the white lettering "Somewhat Disabled." In white text across the photo, the words "Disability Blog Carnival (come share the uncertainty)"

Monday, June 25, 2007

Poetry Monday: Wordgathering, Issue 2

The second issue of the online disability poetry journal Wordgathering is up with plenty to read.

Here's the start of an amazing poem by Onyinyechukwu Udegbe:

IT'S A LIE

It's a lie, I am not afraid to be seen.
Your gaze does not see me.
Your gaze cannot see me,
Your gaze has not seen me.
It is not I, that your gaze sees.

Your gaze is not welcome in this, my own, kitchen.

They too loved the hottentot, everyone loves the circus.


Go read the rest of the poem, and the other good stuff over there.

Digital revolution excludes closed captioning

Article here. Excerpt:

In the rush to create new products and make television programming available anytime, anywhere, the need for closed captioning is being overlooked.

The major broadcast networks have launched state-of-the-art online video players -- that do not include captions.

Apple has revolutionized TV viewing by making shows available for download on iTunes -- without captions.

The television industry is spending billions to deliver spectacular high-definition signals -- but viewing captions on HD programming is a Byzantine process that has frustrated many viewers.

"With the move toward hi-def, and the explosive growth in video on the Internet, it's like we're starting all over again," said Mike Kaplan, who serves on the steering committee of the Hearing Loss Association of Los Angeles. "Since 1993, closed captions have been built into every TV set larger than 13 inches. So why in 2007, with the latest and greatest technology at our fingers, is it getting harder and harder to view captions?"

The lack of closed captioning on new media doesn't only close out deaf and hard-of-hearing viewers. According to a BBC study, 80 percent of households that use captions are watching the subtitles to learn the language or to follow a program in a noisy place.

With network ratings hitting record lows, the failure to extend closed captioning to the digital world ironically makes TV shows less accessible for some at a time when programming is more widely available than ever.

Although the Federal Communications Commission requires captions for broadcast and cable content, the rules do not cover Internet streaming or digital downloads. That makes extending closed captioning to those media more a matter of corporate responsibility than regulation.

The FCC rules do cover high-definition and video-on-demand delivery, but experts complain that, between companies not complying with regulations and a lack of consumer awareness, many viewers still feel chained to their traditional analog sets.
On the issue of cost:
The sluggish network response might suggest adding captions is technologically difficult or expensive. But experts on both sides of the issue agree that's not the case.

Broadcasters have spent millions developing elaborate online games and interactive elements to engage fans, while the price of converting televised caption text for the Web is only about $200 per episode. Once a software system is in place, that cost tends to decrease further.

Perpetually cash-strapped PBS has managed to add captions to many of its shows online.

"All the tools exist to do it. It's just a matter of time and money to make it happen," said Tom Apone, who works with Mr. Goldberg at the Media Access Group and helped develop caption software for PBS. "It's pretty straightforward and not terribly expensive."
The whole article is well-worth a read.

With a family member who has increasingly poor hearing, this is an issue that effects my family life. The best chance for sharing some video entertainment is dvds, but caption availability is spotty at best, and does not appear to effect new dvd releases of classic films.

With cost not the apparent reason for lack of accessibility, and public need not enough on its own, this seems another situation only massive litigation can cure.

Poor Magazine

Leroy Moore on "Race, Disability and Justice in the Media" at Poor Magazine:

Although mainstream and, yes even some of our progressive media outlets still have a laissez-faire approach when it comes to disability, it doesn’t mean that people with disabilities are not creating newsworthy headlines. From the political arena to music studios and even in Hollywood people with disabilities are starting to play a major role in politics, music, art and much more; however the mainstream and a lot of progressive media have chosen to not cover our groundbreaking stories. And, if they do cover a story about the disabled community, they almost always use out-of-date terminology or worst talk to experts in the field about disability not to the people living with the disability. How many media outlets reported on the record amount of disabled candidates who ran for political office in last year's election or the recent police shooting of a disabled elderly woman in Atlanta?

Life without legs

A commentary in the recent Minnesota Women's Press by Ka Vang on being temporarily disabled is entitled "Life without legs" and refers to said "leglessness" within the brief text at least three times. Vang's temporary disability is not actual leglessness (not that there's anything wrong with that, eh?) but the inability to walk unaided:

For the last month I have been walking with the help of crutches, a wheelchair and cast. Being temporarily disabled gave me the opportunity to experience life from the perspective of a woman without legs.
It's not that I don't understand the radical rethinking sudden physical impairment can have on a person's sense of self and body. I understand how the sudden inability to walk around easily like you did, say, last week, can be psychologically experienced as "losing your legs." It can even be a humorous over-dramatization that helps a person to cope. Black humor and all that. But, really, the temporary need to use crutches and a wheelchair does not merit a headline and many references to "life without legs."

Is that how Vang sees people who have less temporary needs for crutches and wheelchairs -- as missing body parts simply because those parts don't work at optimum levels? It feels like an erasure of reality on several levels.

Vang does have some valuable insights, the sort of "Oh! Duh!" realizations impairment offers most people if they experience it and reflect on it in a larger context. And that's nice to see:
I work as a diversity director for a higher education system. Diversity is my life and passion, so I thought I understood everything that there was about diversity groups. I was wrong. About three weeks into my life without legs I had an epiphany. People who are enabled have accommodations every day. For example, when we have a meeting, everyone is seated around a table. We are seated on chairs because standing for an hour-long meeting is just too much for a person who has legs. The legs get tired, so enabled people are accommodated by having chairs to sit on. Another example: When people with good vision enter a dark room we can't see because there is no light. So we turn on the lights. We are making an accommodation with the lights so we can see in dark places. A person in a wheelchair would not need a chair. A person who could not see would not need lights. We, enabled people, give ourselves accommodations every day. Why can't we give accommodations to those who have a disability?

Just another five weeks to go before I can walk without a cast. Although life without legs was extremely difficult, I feel it made me a better person.
I just wish she didn't feel the need to amputate her limbs (and by extension, the limbs of the rest of us who don't walk on our own) to have this epiphany.

h/t Mark at Norwegianity

Sunday, June 24, 2007

Things that CRACK me up, #31

Online Dating

Why? Well, for one thing, the frequent use of the word "crack." Also for repeated discussion of dicey, dangerous things like "suicide," "death," and "dead." And the one-time use of the word "queer."

Meh.

h/t Echidne

Friday, June 22, 2007

Pedro Guzman -- Disability claim disputed

I've been checking daily for news on U.S. citizen Pedro Guzman's disappearance after police deported him in early May. There hasn't been much. Just Monday's news that government officials dispute claims that Guzman is mentally disabled:

LOS ANGELES—Government court documents released Monday question whether a man who allegedly was wrongly deported to Mexico is mentally disabled.

The documents also assert that that man, missing since being sent to Tijuana, had visited Mexico several times.

Pedro Guzman, 29, was jailed on a misdemeanor trespassing violation and then deported to Mexico on May 11 after telling immigration and sheriff's officials that he was an illegal immigrant, according to the agencies.

Guzman's relatives sued the Department of Homeland Security and the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department last week in federal court, claiming Guzman was a U.S. citizen and had been wrongfully deported and demanding that U.S. authorities help find him. The family also claimed Guzman had told sheriff's officials he was born in California.

In the lawsuit, filed June 11, the family said Guzman was mentally disabled, and was unable to read or write. But in documents filed Monday, a U.S. State Department official claimed Guzman's mother said he had no mental impediments.

"During the conversation on June 12, Mr. Guzman's mother told a Consular Assistant that Mr. Guzman is not mentally impaired in any way," Mark Leoni, chief of American Citizen Services in Tijuana, said in court filings Monday.

Guzman's brother, Michael Guzman, said he couldn't confirm or comment on the conversation his mother had with the consular officer because he had no knowledge of it. The mother was not immediately available because she was searching for her son in Tijuana.

Michael Guzman said his brother appeared normal, had a driver's license and worked in construction, but had severe processing problems.

"To the point that he's retarded? No, he's not like that," said Guzman. "But he doesn't remember things, he can't record things well in his mind."

A spokesman for American Civil Liberties Union of Southern California, which filed the case on behalf of the family, said the government assertion didn't make sense.

"Why would someone in the process of being released on house arrest agree to voluntary deportation unless he was confused about what he was signing?" said ACLU spokesman Michael Soller.

In a court filing dated June 13 but released Monday, a U.S. Immigration and Customs officer asserts the family said Pedro Guzman had been to Ensenada, Mexico, for several weekend trips and had no problems. Michael Guzman said the family had visited Mexico, but not since Pedro Guzman was 10 or 11 years old.

"But again, he doesn't remember anything, so he wouldn't know what to do," said Guzman.
Often, disability seems to be considered an all or nothing condition: Either the man is competent or he's not. Either he could communicate with perfect clarity or he was completely incapable of advocating for himself.

My own experiences mirror this perception of Guzman, though from a physically disabled perspective. The legal definition of disability under the ADA declares that a person qualifies as disabled if she has a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more major life activities; has a record of such an impairment; or is regarded as having such an impairment. But the practical aspects of applying for disability financial assistance, noting you might have special needs as a juror when you receive a summons, or applying for a driver's license can require a disabled person to basically swear they are incompetent. Incapable.

It's a paradox created, in part, by the social realities of disability. Give a guy in a wheelchair the appropriate environment -- ramps, elevators, lowered countertop for cooking dinner -- and he may not behave as if impaired in any way. He may in fact not be hindered, in the same way that a higher countertop would allow a very tall person to make dinner without getting a backache. Yet the tall person would simply be considered tall and the guy in the wheelchair is thought of as disabled.

To qualify for financial aid as a disabled person, you pretty much have to say you're unable to work, when the reality for so many of us is that we are unable to get hired. Or unable to work the increasingly demanding American work hours that strain so many people's health and stamina. Or perhaps, employers are unable to afford hiring us so long as health care is inextricably linked to employment.

It's not clear exactly what happened with Pedro Guzman and the police or what his cognitive impairments might be. But it's understandable to me that he might truly be unable to have advocated for himself and avoid being deported, and still be employed and have a driver's license. He may have visited Mexico in the past and still be capable of getting very lost when dropped resourceless into that country. He may be unable to read and write and not have any "mental impediments". He may appear normal and have "severe processing problems".

If Guzman were to turn up and prove he does not have any cognitive difficulties whatsoever, it would still be a bit of a red herring as far as wrongdoing by government officials. They deported a U.S. citizen. And his mother did not help clear up confusion with her reported statement that he does not have any mental impairments of any kind. But disability is like that, not black-and-white, not either-or.

Olmstead Anniversary and the "right to die"

Today, June 22, 2007, is the eighth anniversary of the Supreme Court decision in Olmstead v. LC and EW. LC and EW are Lois Curtis and Elaine Wilson, two women in Georgia who had spent most of their lives in institutions because of disabilities, despite it having been determined that they were each capable of living in a much freer environment. For disabled people, the Olmstead decision is comparable to Brown v. Board of Education in the way it has legally declared that segregation is an unacceptable public policy. And Olmstead was only possible because of the ADA.

Elaine Wilson died in 2004. Here, from The Atlanta Journal-Constitution article published at the time of her death:

In 2000, [U.S. District Court] Judge Shoob accepted a settlement that the state would guarantee the women community-based housing, training programs and employment.

At that hearing, Ms. Wilson testified to Judge Shoob: "When I was in the institution, I felt like I was in a little box and there was no way out."

Of the plaintiffs' testimonies, Judge Shoob said: "I was amazed. They were both so articulate. At a party after the hearing, they gave a talk about how it felt to take care of themselves and what a wonderful life they were leading. I went up on the podium and hugged each one of them. I'd never done that before."

Ms. Wilson had been shunted among institutions and shelters from age 15 and subjected to shock treatment and psychotropic drugs "that knocked her out and ruined her kidneys," said her mother, Jackie Edelstein of Atlanta.

"When I first met Elaine in 1999, it was very hard to see someone with a valuable talent," said Harriet Harris of Lithonia, executive director of Circle of Support Inc., which provided Ms. Wilson with caretakers. "She was very angry and defensive, having spent so many years fighting for survival. Like someone who had been wounded over and over, it was very hard to trust anyone."

Once Ms. Wilson was placed with a caretaker and given independence, her life changed dramatically.

"She blossomed," said Legal Aid attorney Sue Jamieson of Atlanta, who took on the case in 1995. "She took an interest in cooking and church and her personal appearance. She wanted to do advocacy for other people so [she] acquired training in presenting workshops and giving speeches.

"She developed a PowerPoint presentation that described her life. When I heard it, I was extremely moved. I had no idea that Elaine had acquired that level of sophistication. She had exploited her natural skills and abilities to a degree I would never have believed possible. It makes you wonder how many other people like Elaine are out there."
In 2004, on the fifth anniversary of Olmstead, activist Zen Garcia noted:
Olmstead v. LC & EW began as a civil rights case for two women who desired life in the community, but it ended up being a case representing the rights of all people, symbolizing to many of us the decades of legal government segregation and civil rights abuse.

We learned that, at the same time states were fining nursing homes for abuse and neglect, they were giving them bonus for keeping the cost per resident down. This caused an outcry from advocates across the nation.

Since incurring my own disability I had noticed a cycle of misrepresentation that condemned people like myself to nursing home placement. At the time, I was involved with the Georgia Department of Medical Assistance's Long Term Care Advisory Board, and I gave speeches at most of the DMA's Public Outreach Forums, declaring on several occasions that "It is not a lack of money that is the central issue when it comes to long term care, but whether states and corporations have the right to profit at the expense of the people."

Michael Gottesman, a Georgetown University Law Center professor, says it costs less money to provide for mentally disabled people in the community than in an institution. "The evidence is overwhelming in that regard," he insists. "It's politics that explains the states' resistance. It's a combination of the employees in these institutions don't want to lose their jobs, the administrators don't want to lose their kingdoms, and there are still lots of folks out in the community who are happy with continuing to lock these people up and keep them out of sight."
And, of course, Georgia is also where, in 1989, quadriplegic Larry McAfee languished in nursing homes and a hospital ICU for so long that he petitioned the courts for the right to die. Mainstream media mostly leapt on the story of a crip who felt he'd be better off dead, but as history professor and disability activist Paul Longmore writes:
He told Joe Shapiro of U.S. News and World Report that the worst thing about his disabillity was that people treated him as though he was "invisible." He told ABC's Nightline: "If you're a citizen or resident of Georgia and you become ventilator-dependent, you'd better be prepared to become an outcast unwanted by the state." His mother said that he was "thrown around like a bag of rotten potatoes that nobody even wants." "You're looked upon as a second-rate citizen," McAfee told Shapiro. "People say, 'You're using my taxes. You don't deserve to be here. You should hurry up and leave.'" "It gets to the point," he said, "where you realize that this is your life, . . . and in my case, it's not worth pursuing."
Yet, while McAfee petition to die was granted, he lives on. Significantly, the granting of his petition stated that permission for McAfee's ventilator to be turned off so that he would die would not be ruled a suicide, but the natural consequences of his paralyzing injuries many years earlier. This is just how deep the "better dead than disabled" idea runs: Allowing McAfee's wish to die through assistance in flipping a switch would've been legally ruled a natural consequence of a car accident.

But it turns out that being freed from the nursing home made McAfee's life worth living again. (Joseph Shapiro's report of McAfee's adventures is well-covered in his book, No Pity, an excellent, concise and readable account of the history of disabled people in the United States.) As for institutionalization and assisted suicide, the general consensus among disabled folks who speak on this is that being treated like a human being does that -- it makes life livable and worthwhile.


Photo description: The picture is by photographer Tom Olin from a recent ADAPT action in Washington, D.C. A black woman wearing a pink t-shirt solemnly holds a bright orange placard that reads "Real People, Real Choice" while dozens of demonstrators are visible behind her.

Wednesday, June 20, 2007

Like peanut butter and chocolate

Two great tastes -- together. Summer is the season of guest blogging and Bint of My Private Casbah is at Feministe this week. How delicious is that?

Tuesday, June 19, 2007

Kevorkian's Big Lie

This is written by Diane Coleman, president of disability rights organization Not Dead Yet, from an op-ed in the North Country Gazette:

Every time the courtroom doors opened during Jack Kevorkian’s weeklong trial in 1999, security guards allowed two wheelchair users to enter and sit in designated spaces, as well as three disabled but walking advocates, all representatives of the group Not Dead Yet. We rotated the opportunity to be in the courtroom among about 40 disability activists who came from several states to represent the majority of Kevorkian’s body count, people with non-terminal disabilities.

Kevorkian had been quoted in Time Magazine to say he would love to debate the critics who charge that he is too hasty in deciding who may die. “I will argue with them if they will allow themselves to be strapped to a wheelchair for 72 hours so they can’t move, and they are catheterized and they are placed on the toilet and fed and bathed. Then they can sit in a chair and debate with me.”

In response, our leaflets simply stated, “We’re here, and we demand the equal protection of the law: Jail Jack.”

Kevorkian claims involvement in over 130 deaths, and it’s been irrefutably documented in such respected publications as the New England Journal of Medicine that over 70% were not terminally ill, and 70% were women. Many disability rights advocates view him as a serial killer of people with disabilities.
Read the rest here.

Why is this important now? Because Kevorkian was recently released from jail and the misinformation about his actions and motives continues.

I do believe reasonable people can disagree about the issue of assisted suicide, provided they understand fully the inequality of providing the "freedom to die" for a class of people routinely denied basic freedoms to live. But Kevorkian has no place being named a hero for his actions.

Cross-posted at Echidne of the Snakes

Monday, June 18, 2007

Poetry Monday: Eli Clare

Eli Clare has a book of poetry coming out through Homofactus Press. The Marrow's Telling: Words in Motion. Here's testimonials on the new book from some other talented people, plus info on ordering and an excerpt from a poem in the collection.

Back in April, I linked to a speech Clare gave about disability rights and transgender issues. This is one of the amazing poems included in that speech to illustrate the points made:

HOW TO TALK TO A NEW LOVER ABOUT CEREBRAL PALSY
by Eli Clare

Tell her: Complete strangers
have patted my head, kissed
my cheek, called me courageous.

Tell this story more than once, ask
her to hold you, rock you
against her body, breast to back,

her arms curving round, only
you flinch unchosen, right arm trembles.
Don’t use the word spastic.

In Europe after centuries
of death by exposure
and drowning,
they banished us
to the streets.

Let her feel the tension burn down your arms,
tremors jump. Take it slow: when she asks
about the difference between CP and MS,

refrain from handing her an encyclopedia.
If you leave, know that you will ache.
Resist the urge to ignore your body. Tell her:

They taunted me retard, monkey,
defect
. The words sank into my body.
The rocks and fists left bruises.

Gimps and crips, caps
in hand, we still
wander the streets but now
the options abound: telethons,
nursing homes, welfare lines.

Saturday, June 16, 2007

Slumgullion #39 -- The Jack's Back Edition

Yes, some coverage of Kevorkian's release and the assisted suicide debate:

Colleen Carol Campbell at the Ethics and Public Policy Center -- "Disturbing Lessons from the Case of Dr. Death":

In America, the "futile care theory" that says resources should not be wasted on patients with poor prognoses is gaining traction; the theory's applications can be deadly. In 2005, 11-year-old Haleigh Poutre had been hospitalized for only eight days when her Massachusetts state custodians began fighting to remove her ventilator and feeding tube. Doctors had diagnosed her condition as a persistent vegetative state, but Poutre recovered before they could euthanize her.

Most Americans believe that the terminally ill should be free to reject excessively burdensome treatments with dubious benefits or unreasonable costs relative to benefits. But laws that propose suicide as a solution to human suffering reinforce the message that the disabled, depressed and severely ill are burdens who can find dignity only in death.
David Kessler at The Huffington Post -- "Paging Dr. Kevorkian":
So I do understand the argument of why not regulate it and make it safe; but, I also remember whenever we haven't been able to achieve something such as when we couldn't go to the moon, we didn't say -- well, we can't do it so let's just blow it up. Or, before we could successfully do heart or kidney transplants we never said not let's keep trying; let's just let them slip away quietly. Our answer should never be, if we can't improve care -- let's find a way to help them die quicker.
At F.R.I.D.A. (Feminist Response In Disability Activism)-- "FRIDA members on Jack Kevorkian":
I've just seen a list of Jack Kevorkian's assisted suicides, and the vast majority of them are women - at least 70% of them. Many of them were not terminally ill. One of the women that he helped to die is Judith Curren - she was 42 and suffered from chronic fatigue syndrome. During the weeks before her suicide, she was assaulted by her husband. Perhaps this experience and her despair may help to explain why she wanted to end her life.

I am surprised that the gender element is missing from analyses and commentaries in the press.... Why is it that more disabled and ill women want to die than men? Gender doesn't seem to part of the analysis in the press at all.

Apparently, the National Organization of Women, amongst other feminist organizations, support the availability of assisted suicide. But there are also feminist arguments against it.
Mitch Albom in the Detroit Free Press -- "A face-to-face with a defiant Dr. Death":
He likened what he had done to a doctor who had to cut off a patient's leg to get rid of cancer. "Unfortunately, the patient must lose a life to end the suffering."

As we spoke, I heard intelligence, self-assurance, even arrogance. What I didn't hear was humanity. He didn't seem to think much of the human race. He likened life to "a tragedy." He quoted famous people saying they wouldn't bring babies into this world. When I said that would wipe out mankind, he said, "What's wrong with that?"

I began to sense a man who was more interested in death than life. Death was his academic passion, and sick patients were part of that academic pursuit, like lab rats.

Australian academics suspended over criticism of thesis on laughing at the disabled

A short summary of the story from The Courier Mail:

TWO academics have been suspended without pay for six months for criticising a thesis which they said poked fun at disabled people.

John Hookham and Gary MacLennan, both senior lecturers in creative industries at Queensland University of Technology (QUT), criticised the PhD work in an April article in The Australian newspaper.

The thesis is a film starring two intellectually impaired men and is entitled Laughing at the Disabled.

The academics said the men were put in cruel situations they did not understand - one in which they were sent to a rural pub to tell locals they were looking for romance, provoking advances from a drunk woman.

They said the scenes provoked raucous laughter at a university screening.

"The purpose of humour is not just cruelty ... we don't think it's funny to mock and ridicule two intellectually disabled boys," the pair wrote in the article.

An excellent detailed report from The Australian:
The project had been developed in conjunction with the disability group Spectrum and the two men depicted in it as well as their parents were comfortable with the idea, having had experience with Noonan in the making of Unlikely Travellers [a film about a group of disabled people who had gone to the Sahara Desert, which has been purchased by the ABC and will be screened later this year].

In addition, the university's ethics committee had cleared the project.

But after seeing the rushes, MacLennan, a lecturer at the university, said: "I have a handicapped child and I pray to God that my child never comes into contact with someone like you." Also present was Hookham, who questioned the use of disabled people.

That night, Noonan emailed MacLennan and Hookham, asking them to expand on their responses.

MacLennan emailed back, saying: "It's quite simple, Michael, I was brought up by my mother - one of the uneducated Irish peasantry. She was the best human being I have ever met. She taught me not to mock the afflicted. I had to go to a university to see the mocking of the afflicted being celebrated under the spurious rubric of 'post-structuralism'."

A few weeks later, Noonan gave a lecture that involved scenes from Unlikely Travellers, and at the end of his lecture he explained that the two disabled men involved in the film were present. Indeed they were, and they answered questions from the class. What happened next depends on who you listen to.

According to various blog entries written by students, some of them found the experience positively challenged their view of the disabled, as here were two men quite open about their disabilities and prepared to speak openly and honestly.

But others claimed the experience shocked and embarrassed them.
Here's a round-up of some bloggers on the events.

Here's a link to some videos on the academics' position, an excerpt from Noonan's previous work Unlikely Travellers, and some disability advocates on the controversy.

Thoughts?

Friday, June 15, 2007

Things that crack me up, #30



Versus. . . .










Squirrel goes on rampage, injures 3

Thu Jun 14, 10:42 AM ET

BERLIN (Reuters) - An aggressive squirrel attacked and injured three people in a German town before a 72-year-old pensioner dispatched the rampaging animal with his crutch.

The squirrel first ran into a house in the southern town of Passau, leapt from behind on a 70-year-old woman, and sank its teeth into her hand, a local police spokesman said Thursday.

With the squirrel still hanging from her hand, the woman ran onto the street in panic, where she managed to shake it off.

The animal then entered a building site and jumped on a construction worker, injuring him on the hand and arm, before he managed to fight it off with a measuring pole.

"After that, the squirrel went into the 72-year-old man's garden and massively attacked him on the arms, hand and thigh," the spokesman said. "Then he killed it with his crutch."

The spokesman said experts thought the attack may have been linked to the mating season or because the squirrel was ill.

h/t Pandagon

Photo description: These two pictures did not come with the story and are not actual photos of man or squirrel in question. The first is of a thin old man with a white beard using two wooden sticks as canes as he walks across a broad city square. The second is a picture of an actual squirrel photo-shopped with a zipper down his chest so that he appears to be wearing a squirrel suit. He's got a skull t-shirt on underneath his fur.

Wheelie hockey

Picture credit to omni1 at Flickr

Visual description: This is a colorful drawing of wheelchair street or floor hockey. A central court has four players in wheelchairs with hockey sticks and a ball being batted around. The goalie is a nondisabled girl. Players are smiling and a half dozen people around the perimeter of the court have banners and are cheering with arms in the air. Lots of drawn textures: a gray stone wall, the goal net in mesh blue, a stripey carpet to one side of the court and a green stone floor on the other side. At bottom, the caption written on the drawing "Going for Gold. Gold Medal".

Things that crack me up, #29

"This is a job for Blindness Girl!"

And, her resume explained by Steve Kuusisto at (where else?) Planet of the Blind.

Pedro Guzman

This is a story that's been floating around for the past week. Penny covered it, and Belledame at Fetch Me My Axe has too. From the ACLU press release:

U.S. Citizen Illegally Deported From Jail Is Missing in Mexico

ACLU and Law Firm Seek Federal Help to Find Developmentally Disabled Man


Monday, June 11, 2007

LOS ANGELES — Federal immigration officers and the L.A. County Sheriff's Department illegally deported a U.S. citizen last month, the ACLU/SC has learned. He is missing in Mexico, and today the ACLU/SC and the law firm of Van Der Hout, Brigagliano & Nightingale file a lawsuit in U.S. District Court seeking his safe return.

Pedro Guzman, 29, was born in Los Angeles and raised in Lancaster, California. He was serving time at Men’s Central Jail for trespassing, a misdemeanor offense, when he was deported to Tijuana May 10 or 11. Mr. Guzman is developmentally disabled, does not read or write English well, and knows no one in Tijuana. He declared at his booking that he was born in California.

He spoke to his sister-in-law by telephone from a shelter in Tijuana within a day of his deportation, but the call was interrupted. Family members traveled to the city in an attempt to find him and have remained there, searching shelters, jails, churches, hospitals, and morgues.

There are no circumstances under which government officials may deport a U.S. citizen. Federal officials have refused requests by family members and a private lawyer to assist in the search for Mr. Guzman.

"This is a recurring nightmare for every person of color of immigrant roots," said ACLU/SC legal director Mark Rosenbaum. "Local jail officials and federal immigration officers deported the undeportable, a United States citizen, based on appearance, prejudice, and reckless failure to apply fair legal procedures."

"What has happened to Pedro Guzman is a tragedy," said Stacy Tolchin of Van Der Hout, Brigagliano & Nightingale. "His life may be in danger, and the government must act immediately to locate him and return him to the United States."

Jail and Department of Homeland Security officials failed to identify Mr. Guzman’s disability and improperly obtained his signature for deportation from the United States. "The procedures for determination of legal status implemented by Los Angeles County deputy sheriffs … fail even minimal criteria for constitutional due process," the lawsuit states.

Sheriff's deputies trained by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement conduct immigration checks at L.A. County jails. The ACLU and immigrant-rights groups warned that involving local law enforcement in immigration policing would lead to mistaken deportations and violate the due-process rights of inmates.

Anyone with information about Mr. Guzman can call the ACLU/SC at (213) 977-9500.
As noted at And We Shall March:
Guzman, a Southern California native, was abandoned in a place where he knows absolutely no one, with no money and without cognitive ability to get himself back to his home. As of right now our government won't even formally ask Mexican officials to search the morgues. That's how little care is extended for someone who is not a missing white girl.

There are no circumstances in which government officials may deport a U.S. citizen.

Thursday, June 14, 2007

One in Seven

One in Seven

I just added to my sidebar the above icon and link to Lady Bracknell's most excellent "One in Seven" post from the 2006 BADD (Blogging Against Disablism Day). I hear that Trinity made the icon, which is lovely. For all the easy info to add it to your own site, go here.

Visual description of the icon: It's about an inch-and-a-half square. A sans-serif number seven fills the square in a forest green shade over a much deeper blackish-green background that flares to bright kelly green closest to the number. In white text over the number are the words "one in seven".

Disability Blog Carnival #16 at PilgrimGirl

I'm really, really excited about Jana's presentation of the carnival, up today at PilgrimGirl. The theme is "Borders" and there is so much rich material linked to there, as well as an excerpt from a piece of Jana's writing on Gloria Anzaldua's Borderlands. Check it out.

The next carnival was scheduled for David's, but since he's off on an exciting, unexpected trip to Costa Rica (!), the Kuusisto's are hosting #17 at Planet of the Blind on Thursday, June 28. I hear that the theme will be "Laughter, The Best Medicine." Deadline is Monday, June 25, and further info on submitting is available at the carnival site here.

Visual description of the carnival icon above: Penny made this several carnivals ago and being a thorough historian she describes it herself: "The image is from an 1803 etching by Robert Dighton, depicting Brook Watson (1735-1807), an English merchant and politician who lost his lower right leg to a shark attack in his youth (while swimming off the coast of Havana, Cuba, in 1749)." It's a color drawing of an old man in profile, wearing a brown coat and knicker pants. His right leg is amputated below the knee, and replaced with a wooden peg. The other leg has a bandage on it and he is using a cane. The words "Disability Blog Carnival" are superimposed over his middle section.