Sunday, May 08, 2005

Love of imperfection

A couple old posts from Real Live Preacher don't quite find a tone of disability acceptance and pride, but are nonetheless lovely to me even if the author doesn't realize he's ruminating on issues of bodily normality, self-image and disability. In the first essay, RLP writes about his young daughter's vision impairment and how the unique gestures of accommodation she makes for her bifocals are simply part of the child he loves.

Her glasses make her eyes look bigger than they really are, giving her a “Hummel” kind of cuteness. If you stand close to her, there is a little magic zone where she isn’t sure which lens will best render your face. She will cock her head back to try the bottom lens, then drop her face down and try the top.

I’ve been known to find this zone and stay there until someone drags me away.

In a second, later entry, RLP expresses poignantly his regret (mixed with understandable happiness) that her vision improves until his little girl no longer needs her bifocals. He's wistful about her better eyesight and how it changes things for himself and for her, and he expresses guilt about this wistfullness even as he recognizes his love for his daughter's imperfections is something precious and important.
A very good part of me loved her bifocals. It’s one of the best parts of me, in fact. I loved the way she tilted her head with bifocals, like an old woman. So cute in a six-year-old. She would tilt back to read and forward when looking at me across the table.

I’m stunned to find the seed of Munchausen in me. I’d like to keep the bifocals for my own sake. I would. This kind of evil is always lurking very close to the best in us. It’s okay. I see it. I’ve named it. It has no power over me.

The ambiguity of his feelings is not evil to me, but it is very powerful. It's part of disability pride and the lack of interest in a cure that so many disabled folks hold and which nondisabled folks find unbelievable. It's because impairments are a natural part of life. It's the sheer (perhaps even divine?) ordinariness of human imperfection and how it paradoxically renders each person memorable and unique, creating individual perception, creativity, gesture, and connection to the ones we love.

As his daughter experiences vision without the bifocal magnification she was used to, RLP does not name her new vision as superior to her previous way of seeing. He recognizes it is only different.
My little girl lost her worldview, her way of seeing things, and that always hurts. This is good pain, leading to new ways of seeing, so I put my hand on her leg and kept driving. I let her cry. And I was proud of her. Proud that she is so little and bravely shedding her old way of looking at the world. Bravely she takes up this new way of seeing.

Both essays in their entirety are worth reading for their thoughtfulness and sensitivity.

Saturday, May 07, 2005

The art of Riva Lehrer

These portraits of disabled people by an artist with a disability aren't new, but I enjoy them.

Friday, May 06, 2005

The Chunky Bastard Monster Step and other good times

One of the difficulties with having a mobility impairment is that even inquiring about accessibility from nondisabled people who truly wish to be helpful often fails to provide any useful information. Or it results in misleading information that further complicates a journey, short or long. A direct inquiry as to whether there are steps, for example, proves to be a meaningless exercise if an unobservant nondisabled person is never bothered enough by their existence to note they are there. I've called ahead to businesses where the person on the phone swears the place is completely wheelchair-friendly, only to arrive and find three steps leading into the ballroom or restaurant and no alternate way inside.

The helpful phone person, when informed, will say something promising like, "Oh. Hmmm."

Or possibly, "Well, we don't get many handicapped people in here."

Agent Fang's excellent blog, Fangworld, describes some recent travel adventures armed only with her wheelchair and wit. It all begins promisingly enough, as it often does:

I started looking at the really big hotels. Got one with a car park attached. Good start. Rang up, had a little chat about access. This is the time to judge whether you are really welcome, or will terrify the staff, who have likely never seen human/wheel combinations before (or will at least act like it). Staff were nice. Asked for suite with handrails and wheelchair access. There was a pause before she explained they only have one suite with access... the mini suite. Didn't sound bad, so I booked it at the standard double price -- she did explain it was a little more usually but for disabled people who couldn't choose the standard room they would put me and Mr F (who's had a two day week this week, v. smug) in the mini suite.

Their arrival, of course, proves to be something of a disappointment:

As we rolled up to the hotel, the first thing immediately apparent was the Small Harmless Step in the website photograph was actually a Chunky Bastard Monster Step. Deep breath. Second was their prestigious 30 space car park was actually a tarmacked area rented from the hotel next door. We looked on in innocent surprise at the tiny narrow spaces, and a faint warning bell sounded in my head as we realised they'd forgotton to reserve us the two I'd been allocated for wide door access. In the end Mr F dropped me off outside the hotel and went to park, whilst I sat in full view of the reception desk, glaring at the monster step and a little sticker on the door saying "We Are Access Friendly".

I am never sure if such proud claims are cluelessness or some sort of legal ass-covering bluff. Maybe just wishful thinking. Anyway, Agent Fang is on yet another little journey, so stay tuned to her blog to hear how that goes.

Thursday, May 05, 2005

Happy Birthday Nellie Bly!

Elizabeth Jane Cochrane, born on this day in 1864, was a feminist before the word existed. She was a disability rights advocate too. Her journalism career began at age 23 after her sharp reply to a Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, newspaper article that criticized working women. Under the name "Nellie Bly" she became known as the "best reporter in America" at the end of the 19th century. She is known for her journalistic courage in committing herself to a mental asylum for ten days to uncover the practices there. Her reports -- available online in full text as Ten Days in a Mad-House -- led to a state investigation of New York City's Blackwell Island asylum and eventually to better funding and reforms in patient care.

She was a researcher, an investigative reporter, an industrialist and a reformer. In 1873, she set out to best French author Jules Verne's fictional character who traveled Around the World in 80 Days. She did it in less than 73. Later, she was the first female to cover the front lines in World War I.

(Via Penny Richards at Disability Studies, Temple U.)

Wednesday, May 04, 2005

Daughter denied Colorado driver's permit because of blind mother

This story via Sam at Disability Law. Here's an excerpt:

Julie Barber is 15, with a learner's permit and a burning desire to get behind the wheel of a car. But due to a combination of a recent change in state law and her mother's severe vision problems, she won't be driving anytime soon.

In a lawsuit filed Monday in U.S. District Court in Denver, Barber and her mother contend they are victims of discrimination. That's because the state requires a parent or guardian with a Colorado driver's license to be in the car with Julie. But her mother doesn't have a license, and state authorities are refusing to allow the Barbers to substitute another adult.

Marcia Barber, 50, contends Colorado Attorney General John Suthers suggested she assign legal guardianship of her daughter to someone else so the girl could drive, according to the lawsuit.

Tuesday, May 03, 2005

Buffalo firefighter suddenly improves after ten years without memories

Donald Herbert, a firefighter from Buffalo, New York, has lived in a nursing home for the past seven years, mostly silent, nearly blind and with severe memory impairment since injuries leading to oxygen deprivation occured at an apartment fire in 1995. Over this past weekend, he suddenly became animated and asked for his family, believing he had lost only about three months time and not the ten years that have changed his youngest son -- a toddler -- into a 13-year-old boy who answered the phone when Herbert had a nurse call home.

By all accounts, this change seems miraculous and how permanent or complete Herbert's recovery will be is unknown yet, but there are some salient points to his story with regard to disability. From the NYT:

In 1999, a year after he was moved to the nursing home, Linda Herbert [his wife] prevailed in a brief legal fight with Mr. Herbert's parents, Geraldine and Donald P. Herbert, over who should have control over decisions in a medical emergency, like pneumonia or a serious infection. All agreed that extraordinary resuscitative measures should not be taken in the event of a stroke or a heart attack.

No one has asked any of the Herberts if they would have signed a DNR ("Do Not Resuscitate" order) had they known the firefighter would wake up in a decade and recognize family and friends (and to be fair, it's not the sort of thing to be routinely expected), but it's quite possible the verdict wouldn't have been unanimous. And so little is really understood about the human brain that experts cannot predict or explain when a "miraculous" recovery of this sort might happen. From Newsday.com:
Dr. Rose Lynn Sherr of New York University Medical Center said when patients recover from brain injuries, they usually do so within two or three years.

"It's almost unheard of after 10 years," she said, "but sometimes things do happen and people suddenly improve and we don't understand why."
And while nondisabled observers might ponder what life "trapped inside" a nonresponsive body or brain might be like, even imagining it to be hellish and a living death, as many said about Terri Schiavo, Herbert's experience of the past decade doesn't seem to be a hell of any kind. He thought he'd been recovering for about three months. And, of course, as people are wont to do, he seems happy to be alive and visit with family and friends. Good thing that DNR didn't get put to use. Good thing he didn't have a feeding tube.

Monday, May 02, 2005

Autism is a World on CNN May 22

The Academy Award nominated documentary Autism is a World makes its television premiere Sunday, May 22, at 8 p.m. (ET) on CNN. Narrated by actress Julianna Margulies but written in her own words, the film tells the story of 26-year-old Sue Rubin of Los Angeles. From the press release:

Rubin has been on an extraordinary journey for 26 years. When she was four, her unusual behavior led to a diagnosis of autism and contributed to the belief that she was mentally retarded. But at age 13, a new communication technique gave Rubin the ability to connect with the world and exhibit her considerable intelligence. Now, she is a junior in college, a tireless disabilities-rights activist and an articulate guide into autism.

Rubin wrote the documentary, and is the viewer’s guide into autism. By typing into a handheld communication device, Rubin explains her feelings and her actions, such as her need to clutch spoons or why she finds comfort in falling water; her relationships with other people; and how she copes with the tasks of daily living and the challenges of college.

Rubin also describes some of her unusual behavior. She does not make eye contact when greeting strangers and instead may fixate on their shirt buttons. She cannot verbalize a person’s name but may frequently repeat the same word or phrase. By discussing some of her behaviors, Rubin provides insight into this complex part of autism.

Rubin guides the audience through all that is special and usual about her life. From the racetrack where she goes to unwind to the classroom where her intellect shines and from a presentation at an autism conference to the challenges of paying bills or shopping, Rubin takes an unflinching look at the world of autism and the challenges she must face daily.

Sunday, May 01, 2005

Disability bloggers everywhere

I haven't been able to write here for a while, but lots of traffic here at the moment from Ragged Edge. Do yourself a favor and check out these other bloggers who write about disability that the Edge didn't have a chance to mention:

Disability in the Brazilian Context

Iron Jawed Angel

Nightengale of Samarkand

Nodakwheeler

The 19th Floor

Also -- Yeah, But Houdini Didn't Have These Hips -- an online friend of mine, Sarahlynn, is one of many parents who blog about life with a child who has Down Syndrome. Her perspective often teaches me to think harder about the whole realm of disability experience, and her thoughtful blog includes links to many other parents like herself. Plus, behold adorable pictures!

Thursday, March 24, 2005

On Terri Schiavo

As Harriet McBryde Johnson says, "The Terri Schiavo case is hard to write about, hard to think about." I've had an emotional deer-in-the-headlights response about it for quite some time now. Months. And while the legal options for saving Terri Schiavo from starvation may have been exhausted, I'll offer here some writings by others that provide the disability perspective so lacking in the mainstream debate.

Harriet McBryde Johnson on Slate, via Disability Law:

In addition to the rights all people enjoy, Ms. Schiavo has a statutory right under the Americans With Disabilities Act not to be treated differently because of her disability. Obviously, Florida law would not allow a husband to kill a nondisabled wife by starvation and dehydration; killing is not ordinarily considered a private family concern or a matter of choice. It is Ms. Schiavo's disability that makes her killing different in the eyes of the Florida courts. Because the state is overtly drawing lines based on disability, it has the burden under the ADA of justifying those lines.

Steven Drake, research analyst for Not Dead Yet:

Given the current research regarding brain activity and misdiagnosis, it's a virtual certainty that countless people have been helpless to prevent their own deaths through starvation and dehydration. There's an analogy to DNA evidence and the death penalty. Here in Illinois, the staggering numbers of innocent and wrongly convicted people on Death Row resulted in a moratorium on the death penalty. Whether you agreed with the death penalty or not, everyone was forced to find ways to make sure no innocent person ended up on Death Row again. The same amount of concern should apply to medically induced deaths, in which the numbers far exceed the number of convicted people executed each year.
More by Stephen Drake:
People on the right are killing us slowly with cuts to the budget and Medicaid while the people on the left kill us quickly and call it "compassion" -- either way we end up dead -- AND WE OBJECT.

Ragged Edge Editor Mary Johnson's outstanding comments at Common Dreams:
There isn't a single disability rights activist I've heard from who is happy that things ended up at such a sorry pass, and who isn't afraid that this will make liberals hate them even more than they now do. Yet it cannot help being noticed that it generally depends on whose ox is being gored as to what side of the states' rights debate one comes down on. We're all for federal laws when it comes to things like civil rights -- and gay marriage. We're not, though, when it comes to things we've labeled as "right to die" -- which we say are "privacy issues."

We might want to take another look at the cost of such privacy.

Further links to follow here.

Monday, March 21, 2005

Pioneer plans town for sign language users

Marvin T. Miller plans to start a town in South Dakota for users of American Sign Language. Deaf since birth and the co-founder of the first national deaf newspaper, he has dreamed of a community based on sign language communication since his youth. Laurent, named after Laurent Clerc, a French educator from the 1800's who founded the first school for the deaf in the United States, would be the first town started in the region in well over 100 years.

As I've noted before, Martha's Vineyard was a deaf community in the 1800s. The Minneapolis Star Tribune mentions this from a slightly different perspective:

Laurent would not be the nation's first deaf community. More than 200 years ago off the Massachusetts coast, a group of European settlers on the island of Martha's Vineyard carried a gene for deafness and produced generations of children who could not hear.

By the 19th century, one village on Martha's Vineyard had so many deaf residents that even those who could hear had to learn sign language to succeed there.

What I've read previously indicated that sign language usage was so well-integrated that residents were not so much obligated to learn (read: burdened with the chore of communicating with the Other) but enjoyed all the benefits of bilingualism that anyone in a foreign country would.

While the culture on Martha's Vineyard resulted from heredity and geographical isolation of the time, there have been concentrations of deaf residents in many regions since then. But nothing quite so deliberately planned has been achieved before. From the NYT:

The difference in Laurent, say some among the 92 families who have reserved spaces in the town from as far as London and Australia, is that every element of it would be designed with them in mind. The homes and businesses, they said, would incorporate glass and open space for easy visibility across wide distances. Fire and police services would be designed with more lights and fewer sirens. High-speed Internet connections would be available all over town, since the Internet and Video Relay Service have become vital modes of communication for deaf people. And any shops, businesses or restaurants would be required to be sign-language friendly.

Not everyone interested in living in Laurent is deaf, though Miller, his wife and four children all are. Most deaf children are born to hearing adults, and education of deaf children -- with the frustrating tension between public school language barriers and special school seclusion -- is a primary motivation for Miller. Not surprisingly, fierce debate centers around whether deaf people should integrate more fully into society or exclude themselves with enclaves like Laurent hopes to be. Often, this argument depends on whether deafness is seen as a medical condition of the individual ("curable" for some through cochlear implants) or as a culture to be celebrated. Laurent is obviously a cultural project and as planning continues, progress can be followed on Marvin's Laurent, SD, blog, added to my sidebar at right.

Wednesday, March 16, 2005

NPR features artist Sunny Taylor

A wonderful interview on NPR introduces Sunny Taylor and discusses her realistic oil paintings and disability rights philosophy. View her portfolio on her personal site and read what she says about disability, work and power in a capitalist society, as well.

Tuesday, March 15, 2005

French ad offers fresh perspective

A French energy company has produced a video advertisement about access for the disabled that is quite interesting. The link leads to a page in French (naturally) where you can choose high (haut) speed or low (bas) speed video. Here's a quick description of the ad:

"One is the Loneliest Number" is sung by Aimee Mann in the background. On a noisy city sidewalk a nondisabled woman is jostled slightly by the busy activity of numerous people in manual wheelchairs hurrying about their business. She appears to be wanting help with something but no one stops to talk to her. A different woman in a bank informs a teller she would like to open an account, but he responds in sign language she clearly cannot understand. On a street in
the heavy rain, a nondisabled man slips and slides to keep his footing while people in wheelchairs easily roll by. At a public phone, a nondisabled man stoops over awkwardly because the phone is adjusted for a seated person's height. Across the street, a person in a wheelchair points at him because he looks so strange. A "pedestrian" traffic signal that would usually show a symbol of a person walking has a symbol of a person wheeling instead. It turns green and a happy young man and woman in wheelchairs cross together. In a library, a nondisabled man steps around a woman using a white cane, but when he looks at a book he sees that it is all in braille and he cannot read it or any of the books around him in the library. At the bottom of the screen: Le monde est plus dur quand il n'est past conçu pour vous. Translation, is, I believe: The world is harder when it is
not conceived for you. Then a voice says: Desormais, les espaces EDF sont accessibles à tous. From now on, the spaces of EDF are accessible to all.
I'd be curious to know how nondisabled viewers of this ad interpret it. Would their description include everything mine does above or would they not have noticed some things that were obvious to me? For example, would they notice that the first nondisabled woman is not only the lone person without a chair but seems to need some help and no one stops? Would they notice that the disabled person pointing to the man at the phone is staring because he is not "normal?" These observations of the content of the advertisement involve inversions of everyday encounters to me, but does a nondisabled person viewing the ad even register that this is what is happening? I'd be interested to know.

The ad isn't a perfect translation of the disability experience, of course, but it is much more sophisticated than most cultural statements about accessibility. It reaches beyond the idea of ramps and physical adjustments of the environment to include social relations and the conceptual privilege nondisabled people enjoy by sustaining an environment that is not "conceived" as being for everyone.

Often, the argument against compliance to the ADA is that disabled people are demanding something "extra" and their quest for equality oppresses business owners or employers who must suddenly provide something additional to the disabled person that no one else is asking for. The implied belief is that the nondisabled person never asks for anything "extra," though this is not really true. Rather, the built world is "conceived" to include the extras they might need. Lights, for example, which none of us who can see consider an extra at all, but a blind person surely doesn't need. Another "extra," as seen from a traditional male perspective is on-site daycare at work. Of course, that view involves both the conception of a world where women take care of all the children AND stay at home to do it. "Extra" is in the eye of the beholder in many instances of disability access too.

Yet the idea that accommodating disability is an extra is so firmly implanted in our culture's conception of the world that we don't even see our nondiscrimination policies toward the disabled for the proof of and continuation of marginalization that they are. Look at the simple example of "disabled person access" signage. We have designated signs for where disabled people can find inclusion in our society. Can I get in this building? Look for the sign. Can I ride this bus? Look for the sign that allows for my existence on board. (Of course, even the universal symbol for disability is marginalizing in that a stick figure in a wheelchair hardly illustrates access for someone who is deaf.)

The signs ARE useful when used to designate actual wheelchair accessibility (which often has no relationship to compliance with the legal standard), but this is because the rest of the world continues to be conceived of without a thought for inclusion of everyone. And the ways the signs tend to separate us out is a form of segregation, however benign the intention. Having a place to put disabled folks in is as dangerous to us and our ability to be a part of society as having no place for us at all. We want to be everywhere. We want signs to be redundant. We want all of society conceived to include us.

There's a short story that further illustrates this need for a paradigm shift. In a fictional utopia of disability inclusion in the year 2050, a historian tells the awakened Crip Van Winkle how things have changed:

All conveyances, public or private, for transportation by land, air, sea and cyberspace, for individual or collective travel are naturally covered by the Universal Design principle. You don't seem to understand, van Winkle, the United States of Europe officially abolished Apartheid in the year 2024 -- 30 years after South Africa but better late than never. Since then, Universal Design has been the law of the land and the international sign of access that you guys were so proud of, is forbidden. It singles out and stigmatizes a particular group of citizens. Besides, it is not necessary anymore -- I guess it never really was necessary. Already in your day and age it would have been better to mark the places that were inaccessible in order to point out the full extent of the injustice. By using the symbol of access you did yourself a disservice, because the symbol served as an alibi for the accepted norm of inaccessibility emphasizing the exception rather than the rule.
Like the short story, the French ad attempts to reveal the ableist paradigm we all live under by inverting it. While a clever advertisement doesn't indicate how well the company achieves inclusion in the real world, the awareness it shows is refreshing. It suggests that lack of inclusiveness is a failure of creativity that should not be explained with any alibi.

(Ad via Aleja.)

Friday, March 11, 2005

Jarek Molski and me

Sam at the Disability Law blog (the first one listed on my sidebar) reports on several important new stories, including a new NEJM essay by doctors in the Netherlands on killing disabled newborns and a judicial opinion issued on the Molski case in California. It's the Molski case I want to focus on here now.

Jarek Molski, a 34-year-old resident of Woodland Hills, California, has filed more than 400 lawsuits against businesses all over California charging noncompliance of Title III of the ADA as well as state laws preventing disability discrimination. While Molski sued for damages (and personal injury in many instances) under the California statutes, the ADA has received the brunt of the complaints from business owners and media reports. Often, publicity over Molski's actions fails to make the distinction that Title III of the ADA does not allow suit for damages. (Clint Eastwood failed to make this distinction as well, when he testified before Congress supporting weakening of the ADA.) Ironically, this limit to the federal law contributes to the problem of continued noncompliance of businesses nationwide -- and encourages serial plaintiffs like Molski. Sam explains:

The public accommodations title of the ADA does not authorize an award of money damages. Without that financial incentive, it's hard to find plaintiffs or lawyers who believe it worth their time to file ADA public accommodations suits. Even people who really were excluded from stores or restaurants that were really in violation of the ADA often will not want to go through the stress and hassle of an ADA suit if the best they can do at the end of the day is get a court to tell the defendant to go and sin no more. So the plaintiffs in ADA public accommodations suits are likely to be disproportionately ideological plaintiffs -- people who see it as in some ways their mission to make their communities accessible. Ditto for the lawyers. Such people are likely to file lots and lots of suits. There's nothing inherently suspect about that.

To go even further, I could see a serial plaintiff using damages from the state statute rulings to "fund" further noncompliance complaints. After all, 15 years on the books hasn't been enough to encourage thousands upon thousands of businesses nationwide to install even simple ramps. Like any law, the ADA and other disability nondiscrimination statutes can surely be abused, but I have a difficult time finding sympathy for inaccessible businesses I could never patronize that gripe about complying with a law passed in 1990.

In my hometown, both the local post office and the renovated screening rooms of the movie theater are inaccessible to me. To be clear, the only post office for miles around has no way for me to enter and no current plans to change because of the age and historic nature of the building. Dozens of other local businesses are inaccessible too, and this is not unique to this current residence of mine. Like other mobility-impaired individuals, when I consider going somewhere new -- when friends or family discuss a social outing with me -- the first consideration we must have is whether or not the place we wish to go is accessible. If it complies with the law. As often as not, we must alter our plans. If I decided to sue every business I came across that was truly violating the law just by failing to give me entrance into their front door (never mind restroom accessibility, which is equally important, really), I would not have to exert myself to become a serial plaintiff too. Noncompliance is everywhere.

Update, March, 2007: Last time I checked, the local post office says they will lay down an extremely steep (not-up-to-code) ramp at the back entrance if you call ahead for it. I've never tried this and don't know if it actually provides useability of any kind.

And the local multi-screen movie theater has installed stadium seating that requires wheelchair users to sit very close to the screen. I haven't been there since starting to use the ventilator, but before that I could not use the designated spaces without causing some serious neck pain from craning my neck. Installed seating close to the screen compensates for this problem by letting the customer recline a bit, but wheelchair users don't have that choice and cannot sit farther from the screen because of the stadium-seating stairs. This is an example of innovation for nondisabled people that makes the venue inaccessible for those in wheelchairs.

Tuesday, March 08, 2005

Rapists target disabled women in Zimbabwe

This brief news report states that disabled women in Zimbabwe are being raped because of a widespread myth that -- like virgins -- sex with them will cure a man of HIV/AIDS.

Monday, March 07, 2005

Cure 'em or kill 'em on ABC soaps

This past week two different ABC soap operas had storylines culminating in the typical cure 'em or kill 'em scenario mainstream entertainment uses to illustrate it's angst about disability. Both situations involved long-time male characters whose lives have been intricately woven into the shows over more than a dozen years. Both characters have held typical male hero status in the past for their actions, physical attractiveness and morality, and both have been very popular with fans of each show.

On All My Children, Edmund Grey had been a paraplegic for many months now following some sort of tragic accident, and though the show's seemingly positive commitment to not miraculously curing him was a chance to explore the reality of life with a wheelchair, they did not take that opportunity. Instead, Edmund grew bitter, bemoaned the loss of his sexuality and distanced himself from his beautiful wife.

Edmund did return to his job post-injury, though how he managed to get there isn't clear, especially because of the ornamental nature of the ramp in the family mansion's sunken living room. The ramp -- long, lovely and not too steep -- was blocked by a door swinging inward into the living room. No wheelchair would have been able to get around that door. If the ramp had been moved over six inches or built wider, it would have been functional and a true example of making an awkward inaccessible room user-friendly. But actually living with a disability was never the point of Edmund's injury and living disabled was never meant to be Edmund's fate. Bitter disappointment and death apparently were.

Edmund was murdered last week -- some typical whodunit mystery -- and his tortured soul and twisted body are finally at peace. Oh, there had been risky surgeries to try and heal him, talk of marriage counseling and giving post-injury life a chance. Everyone but Edmund saw hope and alternatives to his angry impotence. But since a cure was impossible (as it should be, at this point in time, if spinal cord injury is the impairment), so it was death -- the other option for disability, once again. And yes, Edmund's dead body lay on a hosptial gurney, assuring the viewer he would not reappear years later without some supernatural intervention. He is well and truly dead.

And on General Hospital, Lucky Spencer was shot and lapsed into a "persistant vegetative state." On a ventilator, the doctors all believed him a hopeless case. In a clear adaptation of the Terri Schiavo legal battle, his father wasted no time and rushed to court in a fight against his son's aunt, brother and many friends who wished to keep Lucky alive. Perhaps three days had elapsed since his injury, but Lucky's father believed he must "pull the plug." His theory, tearfully pleaded in court, was that his son understood danger and needed the threat to his life. When the ventilator is turned off, if Lucky is "still in there somewhere" he will react on instinct and wake up, his father said. If not, it was useless all along. But Lucky's father felt this was the cure.

And of course it was the classic "cure." One way or another, the problem would be solved. The judge ruled for the father unplugging life support and miraculously Lucky began to breathe on his own. In a clear example of cure 'em or kill 'em dramatics, the cure was to either wake up instantly or die. Either way disability and the real issues of injury and impairment -- along with the social judgments making a story like this acceptable -- were disappeared. Lucky was almost immediately restored to perfect health and the ethical decisions made in court reinforced that dead is better than disabled.

Tuesday, March 01, 2005

Spector v. Norwegian Cruise Line

On Monday, the U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments as to whether or not the ADA should be enforced on foreign-flagged cruise ships which dock at U.S. ports. Emerging Horizons offers a summary of the oral arguments and NPR provides some good overall coverage of the legal conflict involved. Spector v. Norwegian Cruise Line stands to be the next test for the ADA, which the court has repeatedly weakened, mostly in decisions over what constitutes a disability and who then qualifies for protection under the act.

This case will likely hinge more on the value the court places on U.S. civil rights, generally, versus the interests of the international community, as the oral arguments suggested. As the ADA is applicable -- or not -- so will be any other U.S. anti-discrimination laws, it was pointed out. This seemed to add a new light to the cause, as discrimination on the basis of race was mentioned as a practice that could not reasonably be barred using the Civil Rights Act of 1964 if the anti-discrimination law for Americans with disabilities is found inapplicable to a foreign-flag ship. If this civil rights law does not apply to these ships, no other one will.

Ah, let me help you with a way to get around that pesky problem, Justice Scalia indicated to the lawyers for the cruise line. "Why don't you draw that line?" he said, suggesting that because the ADA requires physical changes to the structure of vessels for compliance, there might be some neat way to not discriminate for everything but that which requires actual change. Sell everyone a ticket, and let them sort out who can get up the stairs to where the lifeboats are on their own.

A decision is expected from the court by July.

Monday, February 28, 2005

Access to the stories of our lives

Four Academy Awards went to Clint Eastwood's Million Dollar Baby last night. It's worth noting that Hillary Swank joins dozens of others as a nondisabled actor taking home the highest accolades of her profession for portraying a disabled person. The stage from which she accepted her reward isn't accessible to many disabled people, though it was carefully designed with steps not too steep to accommodate the long evening gowns of nondisabled women who might wish to ascend them in glamour. Every consideration was given with regard to fashion, of course, and $90 million in public funds smoothed the way.

Disabled people had to sue for basic access to seating at the famed Kodak Theater. Despite often being more focused on a cure than on access issues, even Christopher Reeve had strong opinions about this exclusion when the first Academy Awards were held there in 2002:

"It's not acceptable. Absolutely not acceptable.... I was on the Oscars in 1996 which was about a year after my injury and I was talking about films that made a difference... films that illuminated social issues like race relations and disabilities, and to have an Oscar ceremony in a building that doesn't have accessibility is a real disgrace."

At least three Oscar ceremonies (and numerous other performances) were held while the lawsuit was ongoing, though it has been settled now. Still, renovations to meet the 1990 accessibility requirements of the ADA will not change the basic presumption at the Kodak Theater (and most everywhere else) that access to the stage is unnecessary. After all, nondisabled people will be happy to tell the stories of disabled people's lives -- accurately or not. There's considerable money and fame in it for them, you know.

Meanwhile in the UK, Crippled Monkey at Ouch! reports that Million Dollar Baby will be one of the very few films not made available to the hearing impaired and blind through subtitles and audio description. A coincidence, oversight, or part of a larger disregard for disabled access that Eastwood clearly feels? It's hard to tell, but it is very interesting.

And for myself, the local theater has been showing Million Dollar Baby this past week, but chose to run it in one of their newly-renovated stadium seating screening rooms that does not allow wheelchair seating anywhere but up close to the front. And since the screen is positioned for the nondisabled patron in her reclining theater seat -- most reclining from a much more comfortable distance than I have the option of choosing -- the neck-wrenching angle required to enjoy a movie makes it effectively inaccessible to me. Oh, how I love Netflix.

Wednesday, February 23, 2005

Proof of life

I read a lot of disability studies literature. And I buy more than I have time to read. When I was in high school in the late '80s there was no such thing as disability studies literature. There was the tabloid newspaper version of the Ragged Edge -- called The Disability Rag back then -- and that was about it. The Rag was all I had as proof that the societal experience of disability wasn't in my head. When I tried to apply what I was learning in a Minority Politics class to disability, my social studies teacher was polite but not encouraging. He didn't see the connection at all.

As an undergrad in political science when the ADA (Americans with Disabilities Act) passed in 1990, I repeatedly attempted to cover disability issues in my elective topic assignments. Other than the deluge of panicky articles on compliance written for business owners and employers, little was available at the library for research. I did have a professor in African American Politics who accepted my assertion that disabled people are a political and social identity group. And he was generous with my wandering analyses and tangential questions, but his class was on black folks. No such class existed at that time about people like me.

Years passed and in the late '90s while wandering a Borders bookstore I found several books about disability politics and activism in the education section under "special needs." (Yeah, that's a little like finding a collection of speeches by Martin Luther King, Jr. in the music section with the books on jazz. Or feminist theory under "parenting.") I bought all three books that I found because I feared I'd never see them again. The university library lagged behind, but it too showed improvement. I learned of several academic journals specifically about disability as a social experience -- instead of addressing disabled people as medical/rehabilitative subjects, these journals turned the lens around and examined how everyone else treated disability and the persons affected by it. I joined the Society for Disability Studies, an organization for academics, professionals and activists interested in disability.

Whenever I could afford it, I snapped up the new books appearing under "special needs." The Body and Physical Difference : Discourses of Disability. The Disability Studies Reader. Claiming Disability: Knowledge and Identity. I also talked to the bookstore about their Dewey-Stupid system and suggested they move the books to respective sections on cultural studies or history or whatever, but they were incapable of that sort of initiative. At home, I lined up my purchased books and counted them frequently. Gleefully. I counted them like an eight-year-old counts her candy bars at Halloween.

And when I read these books I wasn't looking to learn anything new at first, though over the years I have learned a great deal. Did you know that people who carry the recessive traits for sickle-cell anemia and cystic fibrosis are resistant to malaria and cholera, respectively? (Thank you, Lennard Davis.) Those are hidden benefits to two dreaded disabling conditions. It's possible that the genetic differences these people carry could help humanity someday.

Did you know that in the 19th century, Martha's Vineyard was an isolated whaling community with a high incidence of hereditary deafness and communication on the island was routinely in sign language, whether participants were deaf or not? It was a solid part of the culture there and a naturally evolving accommodation that benefited all. Whalers could sign from ship to ship easier than using voice.

Anyway, I didn't originally buy all these books to learn. I bought them as proof of the events I experience everyday when I roll out my door -- I needed to see my life in print. I bought them to see if anyone else had been able to articulate something I had never satisfactorily put in words about my social identity. And I bought them because I had searched for them for so very long. Now I no longer keep count of how many books I have or how many exist yet to buy, and instead I enjoy the still growing complexity of the theory and political importance of what they have to say. I use them to help explain my life to others when I can. Best of all, disability studies helps me grasp the spirit and challenges of feminism in a way that seems to work for me, though the book that articulates that fully hasn't been written yet. Or maybe it's shelved somewhere strange and I haven't wandered past it yet.

Tuesday, January 25, 2005

Oscar season deadly for disabled

This is more important than anything I could write for this long-neglected blog right now:

Most of "what makes life unbearable" when you're disabled is related to things other than not being able to move one's body. But before we can understand this, we must be able to talk about what these other things are. We must be able to have very public conversations about them -- in a way, and with a focus, that is scarcely imaginable today.

The entire article, by Mary Johnson, editor of the e-zine Ragged Edge, eloquently explains how Oscar-nominated Million Dollar Baby and The Sea Inside present the lives of disabled people as unbearable while ignoring -- and refusing to portray -- the real and desperate social needs of actual disabled people. Like in-home personal care instead of institutionalization, reliable transportation, affordable accessible housing, and employment. Instead we get a celebrity actor-director-restaurant-owner who goes to court to fight disability rights legislation and avoid making the world accessible and thus a place where we too can participate in our communities. Then, Eastwood makes a movie about the unbearableness of disability that ends with a "mercy death." Anyway, the article is important. Read it, okay?

Friday, July 16, 2004

Quote

Lily had promised herself, her little leg, that -- number one -- she will never let it be cut off. And -- number two -- she will never let it be obliterated by a miracle. The idea of betraying so valiant a limb, which has carried and marched beyond the call of duty. To say, here is your reward: to cease to be -- to become, instead, a false twin for the good leg. Her bad leg is special because it is so strong. Lily has learned, however, that to others it is special because it is weak. No one, not even Our Lady, will get their holy waters on her little leg.

-- p.351, Fall On Your Knees by Ann-Marie MacDonald