Monday, May 21, 2007

Admin notes

Welcome to the hundreds of visitors following the AOL links here through the news story of Emilio Gonzales. There's not really much original content from me specifically regarding that story, but feel free to browse these related categories: Ashley Treatment, children, choice, health care, and Medicare. My indexing doesn't cover most of my older posts yet, but the past six months or so are included.

Feel free to comment, though I have disallowed anonymous comments. Also, since I'm away from the computer for most of the next day, I've enabled comment moderation. That will delay appearance of comments until at least Tuesday evening.

Finally, I've added a few links to my sidebar under "More Gimp Parades":

Fate is Chance
L'Azile
Fey Stranger
Disabled Christianity
Screw Holland
The Adventues of Leelo and His Potty-Mouthed Mom
ADHD & Me
Life Sat Down

Enjoy.

Poetry Monday: Jhamak Kumari Ghimire

What is the Interpretation of the New Millenium?
by Jhamak Kumari Ghimire

A soft light glimmers
on the eve of people’s deaths
The fern unfurls out of season
without its stem
having matured

No mourning will be observed now
on the eves of people’s deaths
What is the interpretation of this age?
A separate live identity
thrives inside a scream

After a hollow ending
the raped
accused
abducted
orphaned skeletons
won’t exorcise their agitation
at the crossroads of expression
as one exorcises
witches and ghosts
by sacrificing chicks

The sari and blouse torn in
the poverty of a rag to wear
in the freezing winters
dam the snow rivers of the season
and yet there is no hint of bitterness
The yearned-for attacks
not just of one winter
but of thunder and lightning
spread no mutinous luminescence
A peaceful flame burns forever
at evening time in the homes of the dead
It is likely that
the cultured people who affect devotion
do not wish to offer to the fire
a single tear
for this millennium
Now, what is the interpretation of this age?
Each hurting moment
Each hurting tremor
kisses the arrival of the new millennium
without the slightest cry of pain

Not a stir of the new millennium came
to the frostbitten heels of the old grandmother
to the ragged tunic of the old grandfather
The water jugs filled by a young girl
near this courtyard of poverty
taunt the new millennium
the flowers she has plucked and arranged
unearth countless realities
and search in the grandmother’s torn sari and blouse
in the grandfather’s patched tunic
for the interpretation of the new millennium

------------------

Photo description: Ghimire is a Nepalese woman in her early twenties. It's a black-and-white photo showing her with a short haircut and her bare right foot resting atop her left knee. She reportedly types her work with her toes. She's wearing a printed button-down blouse and dark-colored pants. She's laughing, with such a large happy grin on her face, straight pretty teeth showing and eyes squinted shut with laughter.

Emilio Gonzales dies

Baby Emilio died on Saturday. From the AP story:

AUSTIN, Texas (AP) - A 19-month-old boy whose terminal illness started a contentious legal and ethical debate over who decides when life-sustaining treatment should cease has died.

Emilio Gonzales died in his mother's arms Saturday night at Children's Hospital of Austin, family attorney Jerri Ward said....

Emilio, who had been on a respirator since December, was believed to have Leigh's disease, a progressive illness which destroys brain functions. His mother had fought in court to continue his medical care while doctors, saying there was no hope of recovery, sought to remove him from the machines keeping him alive.

Doctors wanted to invoke a state law allowing the hospital to stop life support after a 10-day notice for patients deemed medically futile.

Emilio's mother, Catarina Gonzales, said she knew her son would die but wanted doctors to continue care, pointing out that he smiled and turned his head when he heard voices. Her lawyer argued the state law was unconstitutional. In April, a judge agreed to temporarily block the hospital's move to end life support....

The state Senate approved legislation this month to change the law and give patients' families more time before ending life-sustaining treatment.
via FRIDA:
We of FRIDA offer our sincere condolences to Emilio's family and are thankful that he was able to pass without being under denial of treatment. We hope that his mother finds comfort in thinking of the many disability rights allies, including many readers of this blog, who sought to aid in whatever ways they could.

We encourage you to leave your comments and thoughts on this website, or post on other websites, and most especially we encourage you to write your thoughts to your local papers to make sure that the nation thinks long and hard about why this family had to fight this fight with the State of Texas and the medical establishment.

Thursday, May 17, 2007

Need something to read because you came here to see what's up, only to find that I am currently a slacker?

Go here and read Retired Waif's lovely rant. A tiny taste:

Yes, I have a terrible attitude. I catch reproachful looks all the time. After all, I’m supposed to be the saintly Buddhist theology major, the non-traditional student who’s just so happy to be here, the poor kid on scholarship, and a thousand other things that make the constant chip on my shoulder lately seem so out-of-place to school-people, not to mention that girl who just got married and with her whole life ahead of her got that horrible disease, and I swear to God if I do anything other than smile bravely people downright glare at me for not giving them their little feel-good “there but for the grace of God,” “isn’t she inspiring” moment.

There are a number of people who need to disabuse themselves of the notion that I exist to show them the dignity of the human spirit in the face of adversity.

Eleventh Circuit: Mental Retardation is Not a Disability Under the ADA

I stole the headline from Sam Bagenstos at Disability Law. He has the relevant excerpt from the unpublished Eleventh Circuit District Court decision which asserts that:

It is unclear whether thinking, communicating and social interaction are “major life activities” under the ADA.


Wednesday, May 16, 2007

Some Fred Small lyrics for Ruth

Talking Wheelchair Blues
by Fred Small

I went for a jog in the city air
I met a woman in a wheelchair
I said "I'm sorry to see you're handicapped."
She says "What makes you think a thing like that?"

And she looks at me real steady
And she says, "You want to drag?"

So she starts to roll and I start to run
And she beat the pants off my aching buns
You know going uphill I'd hit my stride
But coming down she'd sail on by!

When I finally caught up with her
She says "Not bad for somebody ablebodied.
You know, with adequate care and supervision
You could be taught simple tasks.
So how about something to eat?"

I said that'd suit me fine
"We're near a favorite place of mine."
So we mosied on over there
But the only way in was up a flight of stairs.

"Gee, I never noticed that," says I.
"No problem," the maitre d' replies.
"There's a service elevator around the back."

So we made it upstairs on the elevator
With the garbage, flies, and last week's potatoes
I said "I'd like a table for my friend and me."
He says "I'll try to find one out of the way."

Then he whispers, "Uh, is she gonna be sick,
I mean, pee on the floor or throw some kind of fit?"
I said "No, I don't think so,
I think she once had polio.

But that was twenty years ago.
You see, the fact of the matter is,
If the truth be told,
She can't walk.

So he points to a table, she wheels her chair
Some people look down and others stare
And a mother grabs her little girl
Says "Keep away, honey, that woman's ill."

We felt right welcome.

Then a fella walks up and starts to babble
About the devil and the holy bible
Says "Woman, though marked with flesh's sin,
Pray to Jesus, you'll walk again!"

Then the waiter says "What can I get for you?"
I said "I'll have your best imported brew."
And he says "What about her?"
I say "Who?" He says "Her."

"Oh, you mean my friend here."
He says "Yeah." I say "What about her?"
"Well, what does she want?"
"Well, why don't you ask her?"

Then he apologizes.
Says he never waited on a cripple before.
We immediately nominated him for Secretary of the Interior.

Well, she talked to the manager when we were through

She says "There're some things you could do
To make it easier for folks in wheelchairs."
He says "Oh, it's not necessary.

Handicapped never come here anyway."

Well, I said goodnight to my newfound friend
I said, "I'm beginning to understand
A little bit of how it feels
To roll through life on a set of wheels."

She says "Don't feel sorry, don't feel sad,
I take the good along with the bad
I was arrested once at a protest demo
And the police had to let me go.

See, we were protesting the fact
That public buildings weren't wheelchair accessible.
Turned out the jail was the same way.
Anyway, I look at it this way--
In fifty years you'll be in worse shape than I am now.
See, we're all the same, this human race.
Some of us are called disabled. And the rest--
Well, the rest of you are just temporarily able-bodied."

-- posted for Ruth at A Different Light

Tuesday, May 15, 2007

Things that crack me up, #27

Sitemeter Google query o' the day:

"how do rodents adapt to dessert"? [sic]

How about it? Answers for inquiring minds?

As an aside: It is astonishing how many topics I post on fit extremely well into my catch-all category of "windmills and squirrels and etc."

Friday, May 11, 2007

Friday music: Random wheelchair reference

The Ramones: "I Wanna Be Sedated"



Lyrics:

Twenty-twenty-twenty four hours to go I wanna be sedated
Nothin' to do no where to go-o-oh I wanna be sedated
Just get me to the airport put me on a plane
Hurry hurry hurry before I go insane
I can't control my fingers I can't control my brain
Oh no oh oh oh oh

Twenty-twenty-twenty four hours to go I wanna be sedated
Nothin' to do no where to go-o-oh I wanna be sedated
Just put me in a wheelchair get me on a plane
Hurry hurry hurry before I go insane
I can't control my fingers I can't control my brain
oh oh oh oh

Twenty-twenty-twenty four hours to go I wanna be sedated
Nothin' to do no where to go-o-oh I wanna be sedated
Just put me in a wheelchair get me to the show
Hurry hurry hurry before I go loco
I can't control my fingers I can't control my toes
Oh no oh oh oh oh

Twenty-twenty-twenty four hours to go I wanna be sedated
Nothin' to do no where to go-o-oh I wanna be sedated
Just put me in a wheelchair get me to the show
Hurry hurry hurry before I go loco
I can't control my fingers I can't control my toes
Oh no oh oh oh oh

Ba-ba-bam-ba ba-ba-ba-bam-ba I wanna be sedated
Ba-ba-bam-ba ba-ba-ba-bam-ba I wanna be sedated
Ba-ba-bam-ba ba-ba-ba-bam-ba I wanna be sedated
Ba-ba-bam-ba ba-ba-ba-bam-ba I wanna be sedated

***

Wednesday, May 09, 2007

Please sit by

Or stand by, if that's your thing. There are a couple dozen emails from readers that I'm not ignoring -- if they seem to be a topic of mutual interest to me and the sender, that is -- but have put on the back burner for a couple days. I'm putting together the next carnival, which should go up as scheduled tomorrow. And I'm trying to follow the recent discussions of the Ashley Treatment. There's a lively discussion on that in the post just below.

In other news, the weather is unbelievably beautiful today, and probably for the next few days. I intend to enjoy all the pre-mosquito outdoorsiness I can, and I expect that to impact the rhythm of posting here. All summer long, if I'm lucky. In the meantime, feel free to comment on old posts or keep the Ashley X discussion going. Or visit these fine folks:

As The Tumor Turns

Diary of a Goldfish

The Perorations of Lady Bracknell


PilgrimGirl

The 19th Floor

Wheelie Catholic

Tuesday, May 08, 2007

Hospital violated state law performing "Ashley Treatment"

I will do more than simply post the links on this soon, but the news for now from the Washington Protection and Advocacy System (soon to be Disability Rights Washington - DRW):

Many people with disabilities have expressed great concern over the use of invasive medical procedures used to keep a young child with disabilities small. As reported at great length, parents of a six-year old girl named Ashley asked doctors at Seattle Children’s Hospital to give Ashley high doses of hormones, and remove her breast buds and uterus.

Pursuant to its PADD federal mandate, the Washington Protection and Advocacy System (WPAS) used its federally granted access authority to initiate an investigation into the use of the “Ashley Treatment.”

The investigation revealed that legal the rights of the child were violated when the hospital involved proceeded with the hysterctomy portion of the treatment without a court order first being obtained.

The hospital acknowledges its mistake and has agreed to implement many procedures to prevent similar legal violations from happening in the future.

Please read the WPAS Investigative Report Regarding the “Ashley Treatment” for more information about what happened to Ashley and how to prevent it from happening to other children with disabilities.

Update: Ashley X's parents respond to today's report:
Parents of Ashley X's Position on the Legal Findings on Hysterectomy

As the loving parents of Ashley X we support the vigilance of WPAS in their effort to protect the vulnerable members of our society.

In 2004 Ashley X was indeed given a hysterectomy without a court order. Prior to the surgery, we had consulted with a disability lawyer and learned that the state law, which is intended to protect the rights of the disabled to procreate, did not apply to Ashley's case since:

1- Given Ashley's developmental state and prognosis, which is well-documented by her doctors and was reported to the Ethics committee, voluntary procreation is not meaningful or applicable to her case and will never be.

2- Sterilization is not the intent of the Ashley Treatment but a byproduct of it

While we support laws protecting vulnerable people against involuntary sterilization, the law appears to be too broadly based to distinguish between people who are or can become capable of decision making and those who have a grave and unchanging medical condition such as Ashley, who will never become remotely capable of decision making. . Requiring a court order for all hysterectomies performed on all disabled persons regardless of medical condition, complexity, severity, or prognosis puts an onerous burden on already over-burdened families of children with medical conditions as serious as Ashley's.

As responsible and loving parents, deeply concerned for the wellbeing of our child, we provided a better quality of life to our Ashley, who is doing very well under our love and care. We hope that other families of the many children like Ashley will likewise be able to care for and benefit their children without undue obstacles.

We appreciate your continued support, prayers, well wishes, and respect of our privacy.

Monday, May 07, 2007

Why the disabled do Taliban's deadly work

Globe and Mail article here.

Excerpt:

His disability didn't come as a surprise. As the insurgency in Afghanistan gathers urgency, the Taliban and other forces are recruiting marginalized and vulnerable groups to carry out suicide attacks while men from their own ranks keep up the ground offensive.

The pool of the disenchanted and hopeless is large in Afghanistan -- people left on the fringes by their economic, physical or mental circumstances -- and there are few services to rehabilitate them after three decades of war.

"Almost 90 per cent of [suicide bombers] are people with some form of disability," forensic expert Yusuf Yadgari said.

Every bomber's body in Kabul-based attacks passes through Dr. Yadgari's morgue. He has so far detected such disabilities as muscular dystrophy, amputated toes, blindness, skin diseases and signs of mental illness in the bodies of suicide bombers.

Although no statistics are available, anecdotal evidence increasingly backs up Dr. Yadgari's observations. Security experts argue that the Taliban seek out the disaffected, the poor and the marginalized, a group that certainly would include a majority of the disabled. And non-governmental organizations say reports of disabled people being trained as suicide bombers, although unproven, are common.

"One reason why people entertain the idea is there is complete loss of hope in being able to live a normal life," said Firoz Ali Alizada, who lost his legs to a land mine and now uses artificial legs and crutches.

"In a culture like ours, disability and the possibility of being out on the street are equated with great shame. A man who is married and has children is suddenly incapable of supporting and feeding his family. ... He might find it easier to die."

Ron Kovic on war

This is a video of activist Ron Kovic by MoveOn.Org speaking about war, the disability it causes and the cost to Americans. Thanks to Trinity for the link.



Description: Visually, it is a close-up of Kovic speaking. He's a genial-looking, balding white man with a trim white beard and mustache, wearing wire-rimmed glasses. He's wearing a button-down white dress shirt, unbuttoned at the collar, and a black vest. Preceding his speaking is a black screen with the words "Video Vets interview with Ron Kovic" and then a cover of his autobiographical book Born on the Fourth of July. And following his speech is another black screen and the web address MoveOn.org

Audio: "My name is Ron Kovic. And I joined the United States Marine Corps out of high school in 1964 inspired by President Kennedy's "Ask not what your country can do for you, but ask what you can do for your country." I asked what I could do for my country. I volunteered for two tours of duty in Vietnam. I was ready to- I was willing to risk my life and I was willing to die for my country. I so- I trusted- I trusted my leaders, I trusted this government. And all of that was shattered after Vietnam.

"On January 20th, 1968, while leading my scout team across an open area. Leading an attack on a village, I was shot in the right foot, the first bullet went through my foot and blew out the back of my heel. The second bullet- I continued to return fire in a prone position. The second bullet hit my right shoulder, went through my lung and severed my spine from my mid-chest down. I became paralyzed for the rest of my life. Vietnam changed my life and that wound changed me forever.

"I'd seen the cost of war, the human cost of war at the intensive care ward in Danang. I'd seen it at the Bronx VA. I'd lived amongst the rats and the overcrowded conditions. Patients pushing call buttons, aides never coming to their- men lying in their own excretement. And a government- a government that could pay for the most- the most technologically-advanced weaponry, the most lethal weapons you could imagine. Millions of dollars, billions of dollars, and yet could not care for their own wounded when they came home.

"Over the last month and a half, I found myself amongst the wounded once again at the Long Beach Veterans Hospital. I was told that there were two young men in the room next to mine. They were in their early twenties. They were Iraq veterans who'd just been paralyzed in the Iraq war. And it just touched me very deeply.

"I spent that month and a half in the Bronx VA. I met some of the most wonderful people, very dedicated people, very caring human beings. But there were the same overcrowded conditions. There was- there was the equipment that broke down, the equipment that did not work, the need for more funding, the need for more caregivers, more aides. And there were patients who continued to have to wait for assistance, same as the Bronx in 1968. There was a shortage of nurses.

"How can you send young men like myself and those of this generation to Vietnam and to Iraq? How can you send them and spend billions of dollars on a war that is lost, a war that cannot be won? A senseless war. A wasteful war. How can you do that? How can you put their lives at risk? How can you put them through that emotional trauma and not care for them when they come home? This is- this is unacceptable. I love this country. I was willing to risk my life. I gave three-quarters of my body to this country in Vietnam. And I'm watching this same thing happen all over again.

"What is it gonna take? How many more have to die? How many more have to come home wounded and maimed like myself?"

Poetry Monday: Mark Doty

An excerpt from "Atlantis" by Mark Doty:

4. ATLANTIS

I thought your illness a kind of solvent
dissolving the future a little at a time;

I didn’t understand what’s to come
was always just a glimmer

up ahead, veiled like the marsh
gone under its tidal sheet

of mildly rippling aluminum.
What these salt distances were

is also where they’re going:
from blankly silvered span

toward specificity: the curve
of certain brave islands of grass,

temporary shoulder-wide rivers
where herons ply their twin trades

of study and desire. I’ve seen
two white emissaries unfold

like heaven’s linen, untouched,
enormous, a fluid exhalation. Early spring,

too cold yet for green, too early
for the tumble and wrack of last season

to be anything but promise,
but there in the air was white tulip,

marvel, triumph of all flowering, the soul
lifted up, if we could still believe

in the soul, after so much diminishment ...
Breath, from the unpromising waters,

up, across the pond and the two-lane highway,
pure purpose, over the dune,

gone. Tomorrow’s unreadable
as this shining acreage;

the future’s nothing
but this moment’s gleaming rim.

Now the tide’s begun
its clockwork turn, pouring,

in the day’s hourglass,
toward the other side of the world,

and our dependable marsh reappears
—emptied of that starched and angular grace

that spirited the ether, lessened,
but here. And our ongoingness,

what there’ll be of us? Look,
love, the lost world

rising from the waters again:
our continent, where it always was,

emerging from the half-light, unforgettable,
drenched, unchanged.

Sunday, May 06, 2007

Is it teh funny? Discuss



Above is a YouTube video clip (link to it on YouTube here) from the cable comedy show Campus Ladies, an episode where the women research and then report to a class on the benefits of being "handicapped." Guest stars Janeane Garofalo.

This needs greater visual description, which I will add very soon. Here's the description from the Oxygen channel website:

When Joan and Barri's Sociology Professor asks his class to "live the life of someone struggling outside mainstream society," the Campus Ladies choose to be handicapped. But after Cassie Dipetrio (guest star Janeane Garofalo) befriends a wheelchair-bound Joan, the "perks" give her second thoughts.


Update: Okay, a visual/audio description. The clip is over four minutes long. It begins with the two women characters, Joan and Barri, getting out of an SUV where they've just parked at a curbside disabled access parking space. "We got the sweeeet spot Joannie!... And look where we are, right in front of the student store! The perks of being handicapped!" As they are chatting and getting an old Everest & Jennings manual out of the back of the vehicle, two young women come along and one of them says, "Excuse me. This spot is for handicapped people." Barri laughs a little and says, "Wellll, I don't know if you can tell, but my friend here is confined to a wheelchair." As she says this, Joan and she open the folded chair and Joan sits in it. Barri continues as she unfolds a white cane and puts away her dark sunglasses: "And I am legally blind." (Barri got out of the driver's seat of the SUV as the clip began.) The young women look at each other in amazement and shrug.

The scene switches to the inside of the student store where the women shop and chat:

"Do we get a discount? A handicapped discount?"

"We do, we get a huge quantity off just because we're (whispers) handicapped."

Joan is looking at tops hanging on a wall and gets out of the wheelchair to stand on the seat and reach for a shirt way up high. A woman (actor Janeane Garofalo) comes up to them in a manual chair, sees Joan, apparently surprised that she is out of the chair and can stand. She says, "Joan?"

When Joan and Barrie see her, they apparently know her and one of them says about Joan standing, "Hi Cassie, look it's-- Ohhh, it's a miracle! Oh, wait! Cassie!" Cassie wheels away quickly, upset. "Cassie! Cassie! Cassie!" they call after her. Barri: "Oh boy, I think she knows."

Joan sits back in the chair, shakes her head and says "Damn."

The scene switches again, this time to a college classroom where Barri and Joan are speaking to the other students while a male professor stands by and the listening students sit looking sceptical or frowning. The women finish each other's sentences in their enthusiasm: "There are so many perks to being handicapped, here are just some of them: Number one, they have whole special rooms and walkways devoted to handicapped people. Number two, you always get to park in a handicapped parking spot, even if you're blind and if you had a car, that's where you would park. Number three, you get super-duper discounts all over campus! I don't know if you guys know that. In the cafeteria, you always can get to the front of the line, and people always help you. Oh my gosh! Everyone's willing to carry your stuff, whether you're blind or in a wheelchair. You kind of have it made. So what we learned from being handicapped for a week, other than it was tremendous! Oh. My. Gosh! Did you guys have as much fun as we did? If you didn't have to lie to people and be dishonest, which we did with all the disabled kids on campus, and take advantage of a lot of stuff you wouldn't normally take advantage of... other than that it. was. out of sight! And what we learned overall is that handicapped people don't face nearly as many obstacles as you and I do in our daily life. They just cruise! It's excellent!"

Again the scene changes to what I believe is supposed to be a lounge area on campus for disabled students. Pictures on the wall show an empty wheelchair on a beach and another has crutches. There's a Foosball Table in the background and a half dozen students in the room. Janeane Garofalo's in her wheelchair in the center telling a young woman who uses a walker something about "I prefer you wear the helmet..." as Barri and Joan enter.

This is taking much more time than I expected, so a summary of the remaining dialogue: Barri and Joan apologize to the disabled students if they were offended, but assert that everyone is the same except that they (J & B) can run and see and escape buildings in earthquakes, etc. Joan's wheelchair is there, apparently having undergone some repairs and an heated discussion ensues where Joan says she's not sure she should take it back and Janeane's character repeatedly insists she can't have it back, they're not giving it to her. Joan doesn't appear to hear and keeps saying she can't accept it. Then the two mention donating money to make the campus "Snack Shack" wheelchair accessible and Janeane's frown becomes a smile.

One last scene occurs in the auditorium of some theater where the women use disabilities to get into the venue.

Coming Tuesday -- Info pulled upon request

The full info on Tuesday.

Update: Info here.

Friday, May 04, 2007

Friday Poetry

Goodbye to Tolerance
by Denise Levertov

Genial poets, pink-faced
earnest wits—
you have given the world
some choice morsels,
gobbets of language presented
as one presents T-bone steak
and Cherries Jubilee.
Goodbye, goodbye,
I don’t care
if I never taste your fine food again,
neutral fellows, seers of every side.
Tolerance, what crimes
are committed in your name.

And you, good women, bakers of nicest bread,
blood donors. Your crumbs
choke me, I would not want
a drop of your blood in me, it is pumped
by weak hearts, perfect pulses that never
falter: irresponsive
to nightmare reality.

It is my brothers, my sisters,
whose blood spurts out and stops
forever
because you choose to believe it is not your business.

Goodbye, goodbye,
your poems
shut their little mouths,
your loaves grow moldy,
a gulf has split
the ground between us,
and you won’t wave, you’re looking
another way.
We shan’t meet again—
unless you leap it, leaving
behind you the cherished
worms of your dispassion,
your pallid ironies,
your jovial, murderous,
wry-humored balanced judgment,
leap over, un-
balanced? ... then
how our fanatic tears
would flow and mingle
for joy ...

----------------------------------

Who Said It Was Simple
by Audre Lorde

There are so many roots to the tree of anger
that sometimes the branches shatter
before they bear.

Sitting in Nedicks
the women rally before they march
discussing the problematic girls
they hire to make them free.
An almost white counterman passes
a waiting brother to serve them first
and the ladies neither notice nor reject
the slighter pleasures of their slavery.
But I who am bound by my mirror
as well as my bed
see causes in colour
as well as sex

and sit here wondering
which me will survive
all these liberations.

Thursday, May 03, 2007

Gimp Etiquette

In comments to my BADD post below, Attila the Mom links to Sunny Dreamer's list of Wheelchair Etiquette and Mr. Soul says:

Wheelchair/gimp etiquette is different in different places. New Yorkers will promptly pick you up if you fall on your face, and then walk on without even saying "hello"--which to me is weird! OTOH, southerners say hello--or "hey!"--to EVERYBODY, therefore if they don't say hello to you, it is evidence of disability-phobia and avoidance.

I am curious about gimp-etiquette elsewhere.
Speaking not just about wheelchairs but more generally, here's a roundup of what I recall some folks have said:

Bint at My Private Casbah has written about this:
During the periods of time that I've lived outside of the south, I came to see that people in those areas are just a lot less friendly--at least in the way that southerners would probably describe friendliness. It's not that they are necessarily rude but they just don't seem to seek out social interactions as much as we do down here. For instance, if someone saw me eating alone at the local coffeeshop one morning and they started asking me questions about my disability, I wouldn't consider it rude at all. It's just something we do down here. We will hold a conversation about almost anything with a stranger. On the other hand, striking up a conversation with the barista or customer at a northern coffeeshop, just isn't going get the same reaction.

I think it would be a bit interesting to find out if being questioned (about your disabilities) by strangers bothers other southern PWD as much as it does those who are from the north. I wonder if others feel like I do when it comes to these sort of questions from others who have disabilities. When I encounter other disabled people and they ask me questions, it feels less like talking to a stranger. Even if they ask me questions that go beyond what I'd probably be comfortable telling a stranger, it doesn't really seem rude to me because I don't have to feel any pressure to give them the super-cheerful answers that I sometimes feel obligated to give non-disabled people. Does that make sense? I dunno.
And so has Sara at Moving Right Along. Here on the reticence of New Englanders and trying to bridge that gap:
So sometimes I would have a female customer with no hair, far, far less common than a male customer with no hair, and maybe she had that grey transparency to her skin people in chemo have, and maybe she didn't. Maybe she wore a kerchief, because she was okay with the baldness, or a wig, because she felt she had to hide it. And I would never know the truth of this person's life unless she chose to volunteer it. But I had all this -- yes -- love, and this newly sprung hole in the wall of reticence through which it all just wanted to leak over everyone. Yet there was nothing I could do except smile.

Sometimes I would think I knew the truth, and I would smile extra big. And sometimes I would ask people how they were in a voice that I tried to make thick with extra meaning, like some kind of metaphorical secret handshake. And sometimes they would beam back at me or smile sadly back at me in ways that hinted "handshake received and returned." And sometimes they wouldn't.
And Steve at Planet of the Blind has said quite a bit about helpful strangers generally. I forget if he has expounded on regional differences, or global, since I know he's traveled, though he hints at it a bit here:
And all you wanted was coffee. Maybe a cholesterol busting eggs and bacon dish. Yes and you wanted silence. You wanted a moment's worth of freedom from American sincerity. You had wanted to sit, unclouded, contemplating your earthly duties with nothing more than a bite of scrambled eggs and a swig of coffee.

O the vastness of disability. O the lonely geography of America and all its respective, shattered childhoods...
I have to think about this a little before I generalize between my experiences in Minnesota, Illinois and Arizona, the places I've lived. But I will say that there are distinct differences between a rural Midwestern town and a urban university environment in the American Southwest.

Anyone else?

Ode to Sitemeter

Okay, not so much an ode as a list of things it has led me to today:

1) This little ad from the Official Sponsor of the Brazilian Paralympic Committee. The link to it reads "This ad shows the real limitation of paralympic athletes." That's pathetic as an introduction, for a number of reasons, but the little ad is clever in a web-tech-ish way. Steering a manual chair isn't nearly that hard though, even for the wimpy-armed, like me.

2) Under the category of Things That Totally Flippin' Freak Me The Hell Out.

3) Someone's Google search for "prosthetic legs for formal situations" led here, which I am certain proved unhelpful. But some other hits for the search are truly fascinating.

Vivian Sobchack writes about "Real Phantoms/Phantom Realities: On the Phenomenology of Bodily Imagination." It's incredibly dense prose, but interesting:

In the summer of 1993, as the result of a recurrent soft-tissue cancer in my thigh, my left leg—after three operations, literally as well as metaphorically, "a drag"—was amputated high above the knee. Here, taking a phenomenological approach, I want to attend to the extraordinary and radical expansion (not merely the presumed reduction) of my lived body's articulations of itself during the post-operative period when I was supposedly "missing" a leg and the subsequent period in which I learned to use and then "incorporate" my prosthetic leg. Indeed, during this time (as well as in the retrospective period in which I prepared this presentation), my body became for me an intimate "laboratory" in which I could examine, test, and reflect upon the experience and dynamics not only of so-called "phantom" sensations, but also of the relations between my body image and my bodily imagination, my body and language, and between the visible and invisible aspects of an irreducibly subjective and objective experience.
And an article on amputees and prostethic limbs written in 1999 for the New Statesman:
The September issue of Dazed and Confused magazine, guest-edited by the fashion designer Alexander McQueen, featured the model Aimee Mullins, whose legs were amputated below the knee in infancy because she was born without fibulas. She had not one pair of prosthetic legs, but several. On cervine carbon-fibre pins, she is a paralympic runner. She has pairs for swimming, windsurfing and parachuting, the last with shock absorbers. Although the designs of Mullins's various prostheses are striking, their paradoxical effect is to ensure that her disability is not the first thing people notice about her. Making further mockery of her disability, her "social" legs are a couple of inches longer than her real ones would have been. "Differently abled" is not a happy euphemism even by the low standards of the politically correct phrase book, but in innovations like these the term gains real meaning.
4) Unspeakable: The Story of Junius Wilson by Susan Burch and Hannah Joyner is finally available for pre-order. The book isn't out until this fall, but I'm looking forward to it since I wrote about Wilson last October. Eventually, I plan to review it.

Tuesday, May 01, 2007

BADD all over

Instead of responding to that last thread tonight, I want to wander around and read what other contributors to the Blogging Against Disablism Day extravaganza have said. The gateway to everybody's posts is at Goldfish's place. I count 119 participants over there so far.

Also, there's exciting stuff happening in Washington, DC, this week. ADAPT has been fundraising, protesting, getting arrested, working for support for hearings on the Community Choice Act (CCA, S 799 and H.R. 1621). The purpose of the bill is to break the control of the powerful nursing home lobby on Medicaid funding for long-term care. As the law currently stands, many people are forced into institutions to receive funding assistance for nursing care that they could receive at home. I'll write more on this soon, but follow the ongoing ADAPT Action here.

Visual description: The image above belongs to ADAPT, an acronym that used to stand for American Disabled for Accessible Public Transit before the passage of the ADA. The acronym now stands for American Disabled For Attendant Programs Today. The image shows a wheelchair stick person reminiscent of the universal access symbol except her arms are upraised and breaking the chain binding them together. The acronym looms large in the background in bright blue.

May 1 -- BADD -- Fear, avoidance, and the people we never get to know

Blogging Against Disablism DayFear of disability. Fear of disabled people. For the most part it never shows up on this blog except when myself or a commenter becomes the subject of it or it's in the content of news stories, probably because the people who choose to comment here self select with at least the desire to be disability positive. And I think that's true in most situations on most disability blogs -- someone uncomfortable with the topic and the people whom the topic is about might click into the site but not stay to read. In three years blogging at The Gimp Parade, I do not believe there is a single comment here where someone admits to a personal fear of disabled folks or disability.

This comment is the closest expression (that I can recall, feel free to roam the archives and prove me wrong) of the fear we all know is out there acting upon so many of our daily interactions with people. It's from my post last year about meeting a mom and child in a grocery store:

Anonymous said...

I think it is cool that the mother stopped you and explained to her daughter in basic terms why you had your scooter, instead of schooshing her quietly away. In a way i think it may be a hard thing for allot of people to explain disability(s) to their kids because they do not know enough information and/or are uncorfortable adressing the subject. in some ways it is allot like parents adressing the sex issue at home. some hate to discuss the issue at home.
I was guest posting then at Alas, A Blog, and that same entry over there did get comments openly expressing the fear of disabled people, which is the post's topic, after all.* It's a whole level of discussion that apparently-nondisabled people felt comfortable sharing at Alas in response to that post (and many other posts there), but never once here where battling disability prejudice and discrimination is a main and relentless topic.

At Alas, commenter Raznor says:
It seems that people just don’t know how to handle disabled people. I think most able people, and I include myself in this, feel uncomfortable when they see disabled people - at least those who don’t see them often in their everyday life.
Little Light responds:
I’ve suspected for a while, Raznor, that it comes down to a very basic thing, one that I’ve picked up more from working around death than anything: seeing the realness of disability and acknowledging that it’s something real people have to deal with is, to most able-bodied people, a terrifying reminder that it could be them, too. It’s the same fear as the fear of the elderly or obviously ill, a sort of contagion of mortality, and in our culture, the able-bodied will generally do just about anything not to think about those things. I may be a newcomer to ability-issues stuff, but I took a shine right away to the use of the phrase ‘temporarily able-bodied’ to describe people like you and me.

Some degree of needing to worry about ability and disability on a personal level is inevitable for even the halest-and-healthiest, and I’d argue that it’s fear and arrogance, most of all, that keeps us from acknowledging it and maybe looking into helping society better serve those of us not currently in the able-bodied column.

Dealing with issues of privilege requires real empathy. And it’s one thing to empathize with people belonging to a category you never will or never can. It’s another to empathize with people in situations you could very well be in tomorrow and still acknowledge your privilege. If you’re pushing to make your office building more universally accessible, how far do you have to go from thinking, ‘Boy, this isn’t fair, imagine how much of a pain in the ass this would be if I were using wheels’ to ‘I could be using wheels’? Right away, because of the necessary empathy, you’re dealing with thoughts the average able-bodied person doesn’t like dealing with. The only way to insulate themselves from those thoughts is to shut off the empathy. And right there, we’ve got a problem.

(Well, probably the problem. But that’s another argument.)
For all the progress that's been made publicizing disability issues and having disability be considered an issue of social justice on some mainstream liberal blogs -- or liberal feminist blogs -- there seems to be very little self-reflective discussion of ableism and the fears that drive it by nondisabled folks. It's easy to find some men blogging about their gender privilege and doing quite a bit of self-analysis as they support or struggle with feminist ideals. And there's lots of liberal white guilt blogging going on about race issues. Also, straight, nonqueer folks, including me, blog now and then about heteroprivilege or genderqueer issues, trying to work it out in our own heads. People are openly wrestling with those issues and their relationship to them.

So where are the self-reflective posts by nondisabled folks about ability, bodily privilege, fear of people with cognitive disabilities, or even angst about becoming impaired? Where is the recognition of participating in and privileging from an ableist culture? If that awareness of personal ableism exists, why doesn't any of it bleed into the comments on my blog or those of my disabled blogger friends except during explosive debates like the Ashley Treatment?

Yesterday, Hugo Schwyzer, whose blog I deeply enjoy, wrote a post called "A note on virtue, exercise, and disability: a response to Mr. Soul" in response to an email where Mr. Soul offered this challenge:
I see that you have blogged extensively about what you call “mental illness”–but you never use the word “disability”–and have zero entries (in how many years of blogging?) about disability or disability rights politics. Do you think your dislike of using the term disability, or the subject of disability itself (as evidenced by the way you have consistently ignored the topic) has to do with your fitness obsession, and the way you conflate a healthy, fit body with godliness?
Mr. Soul occasionally comments here and I know him to be a self-identified lifelong disabled person from the American South. He sends me intriguing emails too, and while I can't speak for him, I found Hugo's post extremely frustrating in the way it "responded" to Mr. Soul's email, but didn't actually address it.

Hugo is the very definition of a self-reflective politically liberal blogger, and although he writes:
It’s true I don’t blog about disability issues. To be fair, I never intended this blog to be about all possible social justice issues. At its core, this blog reflects my own passions and interests, which tend to revolve around sexuality, gender, faith, and animal rights. I hardly ever blog about the Iraq war, for example, because I don’t think I have anything original to say on the topic. (My views are generally in line with those of, say, Dennis Kucinich, but he knows more about the topic than I.) The same is true of disability; it’s not something with which I am wholly unconcerned, but it is a topic about which I am sure I know less than many other fine bloggers.
Mr. Soul's question seems a fair one-- for Hugo and for all the people who regularly muse about other social justice issues from a very personal perspective. Hugo could have answered that he implicitly discusses disability from a social justice perspective in many of his posts on mental illness, but instead he focuses mainly on his belief that fitness is a virtue. It's disappointing that he doesn't address the actual point I see in Mr. Soul's question, and I don't mean for this post for Blogging Against Disablism Day to be an attack on Hugo Schwyzer or any one person, but here's what fascinates me:

At some point in the last few months of thoroughly enjoying Hugo's thoughtful writing, independent of any conversation about him with Mr. Soul or anyone else, I'd mentally categorized Hugo as one of those generally open-minded men who would have no personal interest in knowing a disabled woman like me. Now, it's very possible I'm absolutely wrong about that, but there are legions of people in the world who would not easily choose to know and befriend someone with obvious visible bodily differences. Or mental differences either. The mental category of "those who would not choose to befriend me because of my disability" exists in my head because of personal experiences that caused me to create it.

Our identities too often rely upon social categories -- and affirmations of the ideals that go along with those categories -- which alienate us from the categorical Other. Hugo's concept of fitness as a spiritual and social virtue cannot easily embrace the reality of the involuntary "unfitness" of those of us disabled folks who cannot ever expect to physically meet those fitness ideals without some seriously creative re-imagining of what "fitness" might be. (I wouldn't advocate that re-imagining, by the way, though that's not what I want to talk about here today.)

On the visits to medical specialists throughout my childhood, my parents were inevitably asked how I was doing intellectually in school. While I have never personally met a person with muscular dystrophy who seemed cognitively impaired, medical literature does link the physical impairments with possible developmental problems, so the doctors' questions were meant to slot me into the diagnosis. Literally at the very top of my class throughout grade school when these questions were being asked, I learned to value my intellectual capabilities as a sign of my own normalcy and inherent worth. Being able to report to the docs that I got the highest scores in my class on math and language tests meant I was not as flawed as they thought I might be. And there's really no way for me to say that honestly without admitting that my fear of abnormalcy and my desperate need to be seen as excelling intellectually required I see people unable to do so as different from me, less relatable, less valuable, less virtuous even.

I'm not cured of that thinking. In the same way, I won't ever be "cured" (ironic word to use, eh?) of the racism or heteronormative thinking society has imbedded into me. I do try to work on it, and despite my hierarchical disability thinking from the earliest ages, I have always been aware of the isolationist, exclusionary results of ableism. Before ableism even had a name.

My twin sister had epilepsy as a child, and while there's been no sign of it for a couple decades now, she spent our entire childhood on anti-seizure meds -- barbituates -- that created learning difficulties for her in school. Imagine learning your multiplication tables while experiencing the daily highs, withdrawals, and chemical brain changes of barbituates. My closest human bond is with my twin, and yet I didn't know she was brilliantly witty until our college years, when she was able to give the meds up and remain seizure-free. I'm proud and lucky to know her as an adult, but I was there in her life every day when we were kids and did not know that other person she was. And not just because of the drugs.

This is incredibly tender territory for my sister and me. As invested as I was in creating normalcy through academic achievements, I would not have chosen to befriend my sister when we were children and she struggled to learn and create social relationships. My own place in the adolescent social structure was too shaky because of my physical impairments. Like every self-conscious kid subject to the cruelty of my peers, I spent my time trying to fit in and be like everyone else, and my being the "smart kid" was my ticket in. In fact, there were occasions that I was important to many of my peers only as a source of test answers or a measure of their own academic competence. Memory of my tenuous place in the social scene is not as painful as the tension it created between my sister and me. Happily, we've worked through much of that.

Fast forward from my childhood to the last decade and the half dozen online feminist bulletin boards I've participated on over the years: I've left two of those communities because I was the sole woman identifying as disabled and didn't feel my perspective on ableism was welcome enough to post my thoughts and experiences safely. On a private board I still belong to there was once a discussion (I forget the exact topic) that evolved into several women noting that they would never date or marry someone with a serious disability. They were categorical about it. It was an automatic "no, thank you."

It's not that I don't have my own subjective mental list of what I'd want in a mate, but my first reaction (which I posted) was "Hey! There's life on this side of the divide!" I also noted that this prejudice against even considering a disabled partner is the reason the odds are greatly against my ever having a life partner. "Never, no thank you" is a pretty strong bias to get beyond, even if I'm as charming as I think I am.

All these threads of disability fear and avoidance have been in my head because of this second annual Blogging Against Disablism Day. Who participates and who reads what is written will be self-selected according to who wants to confront their fears about disability, and who lives within the social consequences of disablism -- or ableism, choose your preferred term. There's enough variation in bodies and minds that most everyone lives on both sides of the divide according to someone else's subjective mental list. I can't help thinking about those who've missed out on knowing me, and those I chose to never get to know.


* It's not very important, but as long as I'm directing people to those comments from my guest post at Alas, I want to note that comment #13 is a trackback from someone else even though it appears to have been made by me. My comments at Alas show up under my old internet nickname Blue or Blue Lily. I think that comment was posted from a nice little blog called The Belonging Initiative.)