Saturday, February 17, 2007

Saturday Slumgullion #28

The Argus-Leader of Sioux Falls, South Dakota, reports that plans to build the sign-language/Deaf community of Laurent have been scrapped.

The "Road to Freedom" bus travels the United States to raise awareness about the ADA.

From The Boston Globe: "The Rebirth of Braille"

CBSNews' 60 Minutes on the death of Timothy Souders:

Six months ago, Tim Souders was in solitary at the Southern Michigan Correctional Center. He was 21, serving three to five years. Though an investigation would show he needed urgent psychiatric care, Souders was chained down, hands, feet and waist, up to 17 hours at a time. By prison rules, all of it was recorded on a 24-hour surveillance camera and by the guards themselves.

The tape records a rapid descent: he started apparently healthy, but in four days Souders could barely walk. In the shower, he fell over. The guards brought him back in a wheelchair, but then chained him down again. On Aug. 6th, he was released from restraints and fell for the last time. Souders had died of dehydration and only the surveillance camera took notice.
The right to grow up: Gordon of Gordon's D-Zone weighs in on the Ashley X case.

At the Medical Humanities Blog, a fascinating map illustrating private health care spending globally (shown at right) and a corresponding map of infant mortality. Brief visual description provided.

A federal appellate court rules that "morbid obesity" alone does not qualify for workplace accommodation under the ADA.

A 2004 ADA case filed by the EEOC against Wal-Mart for discriminating against a workplace applicant with cerebral palsy gains news life as a federal appeals court reinstates the case.

The ongoing drama of the case between the New York Nassau County school district and a deaf boy who wants to bring his service dog with him to school continues. Previously, the police were called when the boy brought the dog with him.

From the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, another story on lack of architectural access. This one interests me, in part, for how it contrasts with reports on disabled people who sue for changes rather than patiently attending meeting after meeting :
"The way you do everything changes," she says. "It's harder, but it's still worth living. A lot of times, it's the artificial barriers that get in our way."

Barriers, like when Latta's condo complex renovated the clubhouse in 1998 and forgot to install a wheelchair ramp.

The decision meant Latta had to miss bridge tournaments, homeowners association meetings and even dips in the pool.

The board finally purchased a portable ramp, after Latta's complaints, but they control its installation.

"So now, they own the key to my accessibility," Latta said.

But Latta's life hasn't suffered.

Though this Washington Post article is just over a year old, it's a well-written description of the journalistic tendency to make disability into inspiration for the nondisabled masses.

A variation on journalistic treatment of disabled folks, The Village Voice's Valentine's Day report on a disabled man's search for love includes this visual description:

He walks the streets stiffly. His feet, like a duck's, point inward with each step. His shoulders hunch up toward his hairy lobes, and pockmarks and pimples stretch from the tip of his short brown hair all along his jawline. If he looks slightly down—past his rounded belly, past the hand lying robotically rigid by his side—to the ground, his chin doubles. He checks out the girls that pass, one hazel eye following a tad faster than the other.

A well-written opinion piece by Penny Reeder on United States currency, the Bush administration, and their commitment to equality for blind folks:

And, the final third of you who have decided that “The Blind” really don’t deserve to be treated like everyone else in the country and the equivalent treatment provisions of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 really don’t apply to “The Blind,” well, I’m going to introduce you to the Nation’s Capital-area’s ParaTransit system. I want to know what will happen when you try to give a MetroAccess driver your envelope full of currency. There’s no way he will accept a credit card even if you cheat and dig that out. And, if you don’t have the right change, your driver may – as mine did recently when I handed her a twenty instead of a one – threaten to “just put you off,” because you should know the rules, after all!

From the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, a report on how bus service cuts affect the visually-impaired who rely on public transportation.

Thursday, February 15, 2007

Volkswagen pulls "jumper" ad from TV

From AdWeek:

Volkswagen today said it would pull a 30-second TV spot called "Jumper," which had drawn criticism from suicide prevention groups.

The ad, by MDC Partners' Crispin Porter + Bogusky in Miami, shows a man who stands on a building ledge, contemplating suicide. He abandons the notion after being informed that there are three VW models for under $17,000....

The commercial was decried by several groups, including the Suicide Prevention Action Network, National Alliance on Mental Illness, American Psychiatric Association, Mental Health America and the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention. Those organizations claimed the spot is insensitive to depressed and suicidal people.

"We commend [VW] for their actions" in pulling the ad, said Robert Gebbia, executive director of the AFSP. "We need to speak out when we're not happy, but we also need to say thank you when companies do the right thing."

The move follows General Motors' decision last Friday to edit a spot by IPG's Deutsch/LA that showed a despairing assembly line robot that dreams of flinging itself off a bridge. Following an outcry by advocacy groups, the spot, which aired on the Super Bowl, was pulled from GM Web sites and the company agreed to recast the commercial's finale. A retooled "Robot" spot will air by month's end.

The video of the VW ad is available at the first link above, for now. It's been posted and removed from YouTube a couple of times, so it may not be available to view and judge for yourself for very long.

Visual and aural description:

Somber music. An unshaven man of perhaps 35 stands at the edge of an urban rooftop, the grey city all around in the distance, and hollers to a crowd in the street below: "There's no affordable housing! You think I wanted high taxes or global warming? Reality tv? I don't even know my neighbors." As he speaks a policeman raises a bullhorn to respond, but lowers it as he listens to the man.

Then a shiny silver VW zips up and honks. The driver leans out the window of the car and shouts up: "Three V-dubs for under $17,000!"

The man barely hesitates, then says, with a little stutter, "I'm comin'-- I'm coming down. I'm coming down." He turns to hop off the ledge to the safer space of the roof as the ad ends with swelling music and a separate picture of the three VW models, tires screeching, lining up in a row.

Update: Well, it's February 22 today and I've seen this ad twice late in the evening on the cable channel Spike in the last few days.

Parents sadistically abuse disabled toddler

From Book Girl at Falling Off My Pedestal, I hear about this UK couple and their unbelievable campaign of violence against a child:

She was forced to eat her own faeces and will be "scarred for life" after boiling water was poured on her hands, causing third degree burns.

The sick couple also yanked clumps of hair from her head, leaving bald patches and open wounds, and kicked her repeatedly in the groin, causing "horrendous bruises" plus liver damage.

The girl, who has cerebral palsy, was also forced to sleep naked in a dark toilet and eat her own faeces in Duncan's twisted idea of potty training.

She was also malnourished as Duncan refused to let her eat unless she could feed herself with her severely weakened hand, meaning she ate mainly porridge.
They've received a total of 22 years in prison, according to the news report.

Locally, I keep hearing the ABC news affiliate advertise a story of a woman who sold her developmentally disabled sister to someone, and received just 8 months in jail, but I cannot find any evidence of the case yet on the internets.

In the media

Today, Thursday: On The Largest Minority, a disability radio show on WBAI, a panel of people with varied and interesting experiences of disability discuss the Ashley X case. From the press release:

On this month's Largest Minority radio show we'll present a provocative discussion of the controversial "growth attenuation" procedure for a young girl in Seattle, known as the "Ashley Treatment" -- what does this mean for people with disabilities? What does it say about the public perception of PWD's?

Panelists will include:

-- Hank Bersani, President of American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities
-- Arthur Caplan Ph.D., Chair of Department of Medical Ethics at the University of Pennsylvania
-- Lawrence Carter-Long, Director of Advocacy, Disabilities Network of NYC
-- Lunetha Lancaster, formerly of CIDNY (Center for the Independence of the Disabled in NY)
-- Edward R. Matthews, the Executive Director of United Cerebral Palsy

Also on the show, we'll talk to Simi Linton, writer, public speaker and advocate who is currently co-director of Columbia University's seminar on disability studies. Her latest book, a memoir entitled My Body Politic, has just been released in paperback. More information at: www.SimiLinton.com

You can listen the show streaming live online at 11am eastern by going to www.wbai.org Following the broadcast the show will be archived both on WBAI's website and at our homepage, www.LargestMinority.org

Friday: ABC's Nightline features the documentary film Darius Goes West, winner of four awards at three different film festivals:
-- Audience Choice Award, Santa Barbara Film Festival

-- Best Documentary and the Audience Choice Award, Oxford Film Festival

-- Honorable Mention Award, Documentary over 30 Minutes, Picture This:
Canada's first International Disability Film Festival

Additional info for Darius Goes West:
Web site

Movie Trailer

Blog

Wednesday, February 14, 2007

Poetry: Lucia Perillo

by Lucia Perillo from The Body Mutinies

Thinking about illness after reading about Tennessee fainting goats

Maybe they're brethren, these beasts bred clumsy,
hobbling stiff-legged over cheatgrass tufts.
Prized for how they'll freeze unpredictably
then fall, rehearsing their overwrought deaths.
Sometimes it's the woman who brings the meal
who sets them off by wearing yellow slacks,
or sometimes the drumming a certain wheel
makes on the road's washboard. Stopped in their tracks
they go down like drunks: Daisy and Willow
drop always in tandem, while Boot will lean
his fat side first against the hug-hut door.
How cruel, gripes a friend. But maybe they show
us what the body's darker fortunes means-
we break, we rise. We do what we're here for.

Monday, February 12, 2007

A little labor history



What the poster says:

The hatmakers of Danbury, Connecticut -- the United States' leading center for felt hat manufacture -- led one of the major battles for workplace health and safety of the industrial age. As artisan workshops gave way to factories, uncontrolled exposure to nitrate of mercury took an increasing toll on the health and lives of the workers. Hatters worked in a steam of toxic fumes often with their hands in the poisonous chemicals which were used to turn rabbit fur into felt. Up to 20 - 40% of the workers suffered from the "hatters' shakes," nerve damage, rashes, headaches, emotional instability, and impaired ability to walk, talk, and eat. Their condition gave rise to the phrase "mad as a hatter." Workers who complained were fired and "blacklisted". United Hat Makers of North American Local 10, in coalition with progressive reformers in the Workers' Health Bureau, led a protracted campaign in the 1920s and 30s to clean up the workplace. Despite intense resistance from the manufacturers they finally forced a government ban on non-military workplace mercury in May of 1941.

Sunday, February 11, 2007

Poetry: Lois Keith

Another poem on disability, written by Lois Keith:

Tomorrow I Am Going To
Re-write The English Language


Tomorrow I am going to rewrite the English language
I will discard all those striving ambulist metaphors
Of power and success
And construct new images to describe my strength.
My new, different strength.

Then I won't have to feel dependent
Because I can't Stand On My Own Two Feet.
And I will refuse to feel a failure
Because I didn't Stay One Step Ahead.
I won't feel inadequate
When I don't Stand Up For Myself.
Or Illogical because I cannot
Just Take It One Step At A Time.

I will make them understand that it is a very male way
To describe the world
All this Walking Tall
And Making Great Strides.

Yes tomorrow I am going to rewrite the English language
Creating the world in my own image.
Mine will be a gentler more womanly way
To desrcibe my progress
I will wheel, cover, and encircle.

Somehow I will learn to say it all.

Losing my religion, part 3

In August of 2005, before my medical crisis that November, and prior to the long hospital stay and the thoughts and prayers offered by so many good people, I wrote Losing my religion, part 1 and part 2. I've thought on writing the promised part 3 many times since, but haven't been able to clarify my complex feelings enough to write more.

But last week, Chris Clarke of Creek Running North (and, recently, Pandagon) lost his beloved dog Zeke and was compelled to respond to the many blog comments and emails he's received that insisted on reassuring him about an afterlife for his lost friend when he has made clear he is atheist. He felt the need to specifically ask the people of the internets to stop pushing their beliefs upon him while he grieves. He said this:

But when people persist, in what they know is one of the worst weeks of a person’s life, in telling that person his belief system is wrong and misguided as a way of ostensibly showing sympathy and compassion, that, my friends, is an example of religious intolerance. When people respond to a politely worded request to can the heaven stuff by ramping up the heaven stuff, that is an example of religious intolerance. When a person has to take time out from grieving to forgive people who’ve made him feel a lot worse, telling himself that he has to give them slack because they’re upset over the death of his family member, that he has to remember they’re just trying to make him feel better with promises of meeting again despite his express request, that is a symptom of religious intolerance.
And I find myself thinking: This is why I quit going to church and why I cannot reconcile the community I experienced as a less visibly disabled child with any sort of meaningful participation in organized religion as a visibly disabled adult.

From the perspective of so many people, being disabled is like living the worst week of your life all the time, and therefore justifies the imposition of their religious beliefs on you all the time. You know, to be helpful. Combined with the persistent beliefs in many religions -- reinforced by religious texts -- that disabled folks are afflicted because of past sins or will only have worthwhile lives when healed, the weight of other people's religious convictions can drive away even true or possible believers who are disabled. It's been the case for me and some commenters here.

To clarify, I'm agnostic, and also so distracted by the disability attitudes of others in a religious environment that I cannot separate the good aspects of religious community from the overbearing ableist ones. Even in non-religious settings, the "God bless yous" from strangers can be impressive in quantity and fervor. It's clear that an enormous portion of the population believes disability equals a greater need for prayer. And I'll say it now: that just is not true. By and large, this determination that disabled people need special spiritual consideration has a lot to do with visual disability and the perception of who is and is not suffering. For example, when I was a pre-wheelchair teen struggling to walk and not trip over clumsy feet, I did not get the "God bless yous" that I did when I began traveling by chair. From a practical perspective, my life became easier and less exhausting when I started living on wheels, but the public perception seemed to be that I needed more input from God.

Disability is not equivalent to suffering. It's reasonable to say that impairments and the challenges that surround them can and frequently do involve a variety of human suffering, but the relationship is not certain or necessarily acute and it's insulting when people assume that it is. Pain, hardship and fear are qualities of human suffering, and during my medical crisis that has ended with my continuing use of a ventilator to breathe it is sometimes hard to separate my social experience of disability, the essential bodily experiences of my neuromuscular disease and the impairments it has caused, and the slightly different quality of having an illness or deteriorating condition that does definitely cause suffering. Exploring this has led me to write much more personally here in the last year.

One can be severely impaired, conscious of it all and not feel in need of special kindness from other people, though, of course, general kindness is appreciated. That was the position I typically felt myself in when I began this blog and it is how I feel most often now on a daily basis, though it would be true to say I experience more pain, hardship and fear than I have before in my life. My health and upkeep are much more complicated than they've ever been before and won't ever improve significantly.

My parents and most of my extended family are church-going Christians who probably cannot separate their lifelong relationships with their rural communities from their membership in a church congregation. Through them, I've been offered spiritual support from their communities, to which I don't really belong. While I was in hospital, I cherished visits from my parents' pastor and the rehab institution's chaplain, mainly for the focused attention to my spirit and emotions without familial baggage. But I also specifically appreciated prayers, though try as I might, I cannot fully connect with the religious purpose of them. Because I needed the emotional support so desperately for a time, I found myself able to translate other's prayers into what I could use -- loving thoughts and positive energy.

So I don't participate religiously anywhere and feel unable to explore my spirituality in public religious settings because of the "special needs" status so often afforded disability. If there were a Unitarian congregation anywhere remotely near my home, there's a chance I could work something out, but I live in a conservative rural area and there is no thoroughly liberal church available to lessen the overall dissonance and make me feel welcome enough to belong. Maybe that's optimistic or wishful thinking about Unitarians. I had mostly good experiences with a congregation in Arizona when I visited it, though it seemed less challenging mainly because I was able to attend with openly lesbian friends. Acceptance of all kinds of difference is spiritually connected -- this I know.

Hugo Schwyzer, blogging about his friend Chris' post and his own religious beliefs writes:
Do I pray for non-Christians? Sure I do. Do I tell them about it, as if I’ve done them a special favor and tucked the spiritual equivalent of a $20 bill in their purse when they weren’t looking? No, I don’t.
He describes how he sometimes carefully parses his words to convey his loving thoughts to people in ways that don't distract by imposing his religious beliefs. I'm much more uncertain about my relationship to prayer, yet less careful of what I say to others going through difficult times. Ironically, that's a reflection of my ambivalence rather than any form of religious certainty. I certainly don't push any particular religious doctrine (since I don't have one) but to me it feels more like using a French phrase in a sentence -- if infrequent and unpretentious, only a little cultural conversion is required. Then again, I also don't offer these good wishes unless I've been told of actual suffering and hardship, as opposed to something I assume.

Saturday, February 10, 2007

Disability Carnival #8 at Medical Humanities

Yep, I'm late to post this, but all the links are over there, waiting to be clicked.

And my fellow Minnesotan Mark Siegel of The 19th Floor is hosting the next one on February 22 (deadline the Monday before) and the theme is Employment.

BTW, the widget available for putting a permanent link to the Disability Carnival on blog sidebars is utter crap. Witness it here.

I'd like to propose that anyone with even marginal talent and an idea that seems inclusive of the broad term "disability" try to make one we can all use. Or make several. I'll give it a go too.

Update: Here's my best effort for today:



Visual description: A photo shows a simple, nonstandard parking lot sign that reads, "Somewhat Disabled." The words I've superimposed on the photo below the sign are "Disability Blog Carnival (come share the uncertainty)"

Saturday Slumgullion #27

Lots of news articles to share:

From the AARP Bulletin, June 2004, "Suing to get out in the world: San Franciscans break out of nursing homes to live on their own" -- Yep, the story is over 2 years old, but it's worth a read.

This is current. The Associated Press reports this news from LA police: Hospital van spotted dumping paraplegic man on Skid Row. Homeless, without any wheelchair, dragging a "malfunctioning colostomy bag."

An assisted-suicide bill meeting stiff opposition in Hawaii legislature. Variations on this bill have been presented in Hawaii since 1999.

From The Oregonian, the story of the Portland death of a schizophrenic man and the civil rights lawsuit against the police procedures surrounding his death.

A CBS News video from New York Fashion Week featuring a show of disabled, wheelchair-using models. Par for fashion in general, the main woman in the feature seems to live quite a bit more poshly than most of us (she owns her own restaurant and has a huge, beautiful home), but this is a good example of the longing and perceived longing of disabled women to fit into our culture by being seen as more stereotypically girly and feminine. And yet, this is a stereotype-challenging piece with regard to disability.

Poynter Online, a site discussing the profession of journalism, has an article about coverage of the case of Ashley X which includes an interview with bioethicist Arthur Caplan. But read it for the feedback which follows and includes thoughts of actual disabled folk.

From Astoria, Oregon, disabled students and the obstacles faced at a local community college that may have to move to meet long-overdue ADA standards:

The nursing department was relocated and supplied with a lift. A lift was added at the library for wheelchair-access to the second floor. But Hoagland-McGee still can't reach the basement without going outside and down a hill, on a slope that exceeds the ADA-required limits.

She can enter Towler Hall, but mainly just one hallway. To move elsewhere, she has to go outside, even in the snow.

Remodeled restrooms and wider hallways allow wheelchair access at Fertig Hall, but to get there from Towler, where many courses are offered, Hoagland-McGee must go outdoors and wind her way up a steep hill, in the street - the sidewalk there has no wheelchair access - continue up a driveway and essentially double back toward the building on higher ground.

"It's just not practical," she said.
The state-operated Rosewood Center of Maryland may be closed following a report of abuse and inadequate care:
[Rachel London, Maryland Disability Law Center attourney and author of a recent report] cited the example of a deaf patient named Jason who had been without an interpreter for much of his time at Rosewood and had been restrained for bad behavior with a "safety coat," which is similar to a straitjacket.

"These restraints incapacitate Jason's hands, his only means of communication," London wrote.
From Lancaster Online, a Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, apartment complex is being sued over ban on seeing-eye dogs.

Why can't we be like the Brits? Desperados is yet another TV show across the pond that features disabled folks.

Darius Goes West -- From the site: "Darius Weems, a 15-year-old with Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy, had never left his hometown of Athens, Georgia. In the summer of 2005, he and a group of young college students traveled across the country in a wheelchair-accessible RV to test accessibility in America. Their ultimate goal was to reach Los Angeles and convince MTV's hit show, Pimp My Ride, to customize Darius's wheelchair. Along the way, they found joy, brotherhood, and the knowledge that life, even when imperfect, is always worth the ride."

From The Herald, UK: "I'm blind, but there's no need to talk to my dog"

From NPR: "Examining the inner life of the 'lonely patient' " -- On a doctor's nonfiction exploration of chronic pain and illness.

From the NYT: Emmanuelle Laborit and deaf theater in France.

From the St. Paul Pioneer Press: Health problems linger for 9/11 workers.

And some excellent recent blogging:

David at Growing Up with a Disability writes about his experience with jury duty.

Gerilyn at G in Sri Lanka writes on the her observances of the lives of disabled folks in Kandy, Sri Lanka.

At Soli Libri, a brief review of Pearl S. Buck's The Child Who Never Grew. Apparently, Buck's daughter had a severe disability.

And last, Chronic Babe -- "The question of the day remains: May I touch you?" It should be obvious right? If you have to ask. . . .

Thursday, February 08, 2007

Doctors involved with Ashley Treatment not as unified in support as previously indicated

From today's Salon.com, Rebecca Clarren reports in "Behind the Pillow Angel" that:

Doctors at the Seattle hospital that operated on a disabled girl to keep her from reaching sexual maturity -- the controversial "Ashley Treatment" -- were more troubled by the procedure than has been reported previously.
While it's not paticularly surprising that some of those on the ethics panel did have and do continue to have misgivings both about the specific case and the broader ramifications of the Ashley Treatment, the details of those misgivings are an important addition to the debate, which has frequently included declarations that the situation must be acceptable because a panel of experts signed off on it.

From the Salon article:
The committee members met Ashley and watched her interact with her parents. They saw her in a wheelchair and how she responded to her father's voice. "We got to see this little girl and see a little slice of what her life was like," Diekema told Salon. "It's very clear that Ashley's life is pretty small, that it's about her family. It's not about running around on the playground or dating. Her life is what a 3-month-old's life is like."

After Ashley and her parents left the room, the committee spent two hours in debate. At the end, no one voted with a show of hands. But in the ensuing discussion, the air was fraught with tension. The committee grappled with the following questions. How does keeping Ashley smaller help her? Does the treatment take away anything important to Ashley's own life?
Dr. Douglas Diekema has been the public face of the Seattle hospital, charged with explaining and defending the medical institution's actions, but statements made by Ashley X's parents on their public blog have apparently characterized the situation -- and the treatment's future for other children -- in ways problematic for hospital and those who were on the ethics panel. Again from the Salon article:
The public omission of the debate within the hospital and at the ethics committee results in part from federal medical laws to protect patient privacy. But because the public has been left unaware of the nuance and complexity of the ethical debate within the hospital, doctors worry that other disabled children could be more easily subjected to the Ashley Treatment. (On their blog, Ashley's parents write: "It is our hope that this treatment becomes well accepted and available to such families.") It was in part this fear of the case setting a precedent that initially spurred doctors at the Seattle hospital to question the surgical procedures.

"There were a number of people who were not very comfortable with the idea, and other people who weren't comfortable with it at all," said John McLaughlin, director of the neurodevelopmental program at the hospital. "In the end, the parents' articulate and assertive approach to wanting this done is what carried the day for that one child. However, most of us have major reservations about it for anyone else. My bottom line is that this is one more example of well-intended, but poorly thought-through treatment of kids with disabilities."

Put more succinctly, as her guardians, the hospital gave the final authority to Ashley's parents because they didn't have better medical solutions than the growth attenuation that was proposed and didn't necessarily believe it was a good idea at all.

Most troubling (and though I've seen it discussed on disability listservs, this article is the first I've seen to note this) has been the lack of candor about the whole procedure, from the actual medical treatments included in the endeavor to improve the child's (parents'?) life to the full process of the ethics committee:
What also has Merkens and other doctors and bioethicists worried is that key details of the case have been kept hidden. The article on the Ashley Treatment in the Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine left out several critical details. The authors wrote that Ashley had begun her growth spurt but omitted what percentage of her final height she had already achieved. If she had already reached 85 percent of her final height, the hormones may only have saved her an inch or two, said Dr. Robert Nickel, a developmental pediatrician at the Oregon Health and Science University in Portland. "The real question is: Is there any benefit to this treatment?" said Nickel. "I would have counseled them to wait, to sit back and see what happens over a year because this child might accomplish most of this on her own."

The article also never mentions the breast-bud removal, ostensibly the most contentious element of the Ashley Treatment. (The parents' blog provided that piece of the story.) Taken as a whole, the Ashley Treatment may appear more beneficial than it really is, said Dr. Christopher Feudtner, a pediatrician and bioethicist at the University of Pennsylvania. That's troubling because the treatment, he said, "is prone to abuse."

"We're manipulating her body so that she can fit in better to society, while neglecting the inner manifestations of pain, and that's a radical extension [of current medical philosophy]," Feudtner added. "Some child, somewhere, with much less severe mental disability than Ashley, will get this treatment. It will happen and there needs to be more people standing up and saying this will have side effects we didn't anticipate."

On the ethics panel (italics mine):
Again, the lack of detail about the discussion inside the Seattle hospital has medical observers concerned. "If we don't know exactly the reasoning and the debate that took place formulating that position, there's no way to understand how [the ethics committee and doctors] thought it through," said Feudtner. "It would be analogous to a judge rendering a verdict with no published ruling. This lack of an auditable record leaves any internal dissension or debate squelched from view, leaving the sense this was an easy decision for the committee to make, when that may not have been the case."

The presence of bioethics panels or consultants at other hospitals offers Feudtner little comfort. Medical bioethics is a relatively new field. While nearly all hospitals now have some kind of ethics board or consultant, 72 percent have no process to evaluate themselves, according to a report to be released later this month by the American Journal of Bioethics. There are no national standards or guidelines for ethics committees to follow. There are no standard ethics committee guidelines that aim to address the prejudices and preconceptions, even very subtle biases, of its members. Less than half of all people who conduct ethics consultation have had any formal training.

Also, the article reports that the Seattle hospital alone has had inquiries from three other families asking this "treatment" since the story went public.This puts the hospital and it's ethics panel in rather a quandry, I'd think, since the original news Dr. Diekema gave was that the procedure made perfect sense and was agreed to be beneficial by all involved.

Flannery O'Connor: The "crippled hillbilly Emily Dickinson"

It's nice to know I have people who read my blog, but even better is to know they are smart folks thinking through complex ideas even when not commenting here. One reader alerts me to the recent New York Times travel piece where reporter Lawrence Downes visits Flannery O'Connor's Georgia and compares it to the gothic and captivating South or her short stories and novels. Here's the link to the NYT article, which itself links to both a brief slide show of O'Connor's farm near Milledgeville, GA, and an excerpt from her short story "A Good Man is Hard to Find." And because NYT links sometimes frustrate or fail as they age, here's another source for the same article.

From the article:

Her output was slender: two novels, a couple dozen short stories, a pile of letters, essays and criticism. But her reputation has grown steadily since she died. Her “Complete Stories” won the National Book Award for Fiction in 1971. Her collected letters, “The Habit of Being,” banished the misperception that she was some sort of crippled hillbilly Emily Dickinson. They revealed instead a gregarious, engaged thinker who corresponded widely and eagerly, and who might have ranged far had illness not forced her to stay home and write.
From my reader, in an e-mail:
She WAS a crippled hillbilly Emily Dickinson, and there ain't a damn thing wrong with that. It's as if [Downes] has to assure himself she is "more" than that, or he can't deal with his own admiration. The idea that a crippled hillbilly knows more than he does about sin and redemption, the meaning of life, the horrors of deception, etc. ... well, that just can't happen. So, he elevates her, supercrip style, yet even ultimately denies her that full status.
In fact, though he fails to make the connection between O'Connor's lupus, her use of crutches to get around and the frequent disability of her fictional characters, Downes does list several memorable ones:
O'Connor's characters shimmer between heaven and hell, acting out allegorical dramas of sin and redemption. There's Hazel Motes, the sunken-eyed Army veteran who tries to reject God by preaching "the Church of Christ Without Christ, where the blind don't see, the lame don't walk and what's dead stays that way." Hulga Hopewell, the deluded intellectual who loses her wooden leg to a thieving Bible salesman she had assumed was as dumb as a stump. The pious Mrs. Turpin, whose heart pours out thank-yous to Jesus for not having made her black or white trash or ugly. Mrs. Freeman, the universal busybody: "Besides the neutral expression that she wore when she was alone, Mrs. Freeman had two others, forward and reverse, that she used for all her human dealings."
Then he says, emphatically: "These people can't be real." Much like O'Connor herself, who -- thank God -- is not the "crippled hillbilly Emily Dickinson" he was afraid she might be.

Tuesday, February 06, 2007

HIV discrimination in health care

From columnist Deb Price at detnews.com:

Posing as discharge planners from hospitals or as HIV-positive patients, they contacted skilled nursing facilities, plastic surgeons and obstetricians in Los Angeles County.

What they found is shocking: 55 percent of surveyed obstetricians, 46 percent of nursing facilities, and 26 percent of plastic surgeons told Sears' student sleuths that they had a blanket policy of rejecting anyone with HIV.

Excuses offered for discriminating: inexperience with HIV and inadequately trained staff, and the claim that HIV patients always need "specialists."

Monday, February 05, 2007

Undergraduate memory

In my freshman year at Arizona State, I took a semester of art courses that assured me that I was not destined to live the life of a professional or struggling artist. After class, my dorm was in the same direction as the parking lot for a classmate who was, without doubt, an artist. She was into neon sculpture at the time.

Our chats as we ambled across campus in the morning heat consisted of her sharing the current unnatural hairstyle of her vagina (sometimes pink, sometimes green) and my trying to convince her that I "went out" like normal people do.

"Do you ever go out?"

It was a question I got often from classmates and it always baffled me. Have you not found me here in public attending the same events as you? What about me cries hermit and recluse?

The question was always intended to probe the life of a disabled college classmate, though significantly, it rarely led to the questioner's wanting to "go out" somewhere with me. Maybe it was really a larger, more practical question that they never quite asked: Did you know you're the first cripple my age that I've ever chatted with? How would you get into the clubs I go to? What's your life like?

My college roommate, Marian, was pretty much the first cripple my age I ever really talked to. I didn't go to most of those clubs. I usually settled for the accessible portion of small local bars. Occasionally nondisabled friends carried me into the dance clubs, but it meant leaving my scooter behind and dancing with my manual chair for the night. Fun, but an extraordinary physical effort for me. And I could rarely pee in those places. My evening ended whenever my bladder cried "Uncle." This was the late '80s, pre-ADA.

I went to the movies almost every weekend, sometimes more than once. Often it was the cheaper midnight showing of the latest film. Sometimes it was the double-header at the local dollar theater. Man, that place was gross for traveling on wheels. When I went to the show with my nondisabled friend, Sandi, she would stand on the back of my scooter or I'd turn the seat 45 degrees sideways and we'd share it, giving the Queen Wave to everyone who honked at our two-person sidewalk parade.

Most of my nondisabled friends hopped on for a ride now and then. One guy, Pat, used to take wild screaming scooter rides by himself through the parking lots after I'd transferred into his car, and while other friends stood by to help hoist it into his giant dilapidated trunk. Brian and I usually played a little game where when we saw each other on the quad, I would fly straight at him as if I couldn't control my machine and he stand faithfully still as my chair raced toward his shins, but stopped just in time to gently touch them. It freaked other people out.

There was this guy in a big black power-tilt chair who used to zigzag through the campus crowds and seemed to be steering randomly. He freaked the hell out of me, but perhaps he was playing the exact same game.

Yeah, I "went out," but there was a different pattern to it. Sometimes it involved the public buses, and then, rarely would nondisabled friends come along. Those were gimp outings, or shared with poorer nondisabled friends who had never yet owned a car. House parties, dorm parties, movies, shopping, eating out, and the local Improv when it moved in. I didn't do many of the Spring Break trips -- usually just around Arizona instead of beaches in Mexico.

Did I "go out" like normal people do? Yes. And, I guess, no.

Random Parts Replacement Fun

Ventilator traded in for one which does not randomly turn itself off:

Check.

New ventilator's obscure nonprescription default settings changed (by an adventurous nurse!) to match the other one I have here at the house so that I can use it without getting an immediate headache:

Check.

Trach changed by my mother while the local doctor watches so that she can stop having nightmares about what might have gone wrong during the emergency switch last month:

Check.

Appointment to get my scooter fixed so that it will stop drifting backwards randomly and risking sudden trach/vent tube crisis:

Check.

Plans with a local welder to fix the rack that holds my vent to my scooter so that it will stop threatening to fall off randomly:

Check.

Appointment for routine feeding tube Parts Replacement Event:

Call tomorrow.

Whew.

Attention

Go tell Amanda of Ballastexistenz that she rocks. Her site is a Yahoo pick of the week!

Sunday, February 04, 2007

disTHIS! film series

This coming Wednesday, February 8, 2007, the disTHIS! film series in NYC will screen two short films on love, sexuality and disability.

Disabled & Looking for Love

and

The Crippendales

Info on the films and the location of this monthly screening of disability films available here.

At PostSecret

Saturday, February 03, 2007

Euthanasia for the mentally ill

Article here.

Slippery slope? Nah.

Thursday, February 01, 2007

As long as we're on poetry

One I keep in an obscure email file to find and read now and again. By Linda Bierds:

Osteogenesis Imperfecta
--Michel Petrucciani (1962-1998)

Picture a horse on a shallow path,

the thwick, thwick of its hooves in the grass.
This is the sound of the spine collapsing.

Not a pop, but a rasp, he would tell you,
Petrucciani. Evening, perhaps, a gloss
on piano keys, flute, the metronome's

serrated tip. And perhaps he would speak
of a sudden freeze, an orchard shadowed
by a dozen men, long aprons black-waxed
and flapping. Another place, another

century. Reaching deep in their leather sacks
they are casting water to the vivid limes,
their arms alive with the bow-strokes of cellists.
Then over the fruit an ice begins, dries
into glassy arcs. And over the ice,

the dark harp of thrush's song, and over
them all, the weather. And how perfect
the brindles of ice, he might say, curved like ribs
to those greening hearts. Perhaps he would shift
in his soft chair, weight too great on his glossy bones,

his slowly eroding frame, and ask you
to picture the orchard at dawn. One horse
at rest near the frozen path. Now the thwick, thwick
of apron flaps. Far off to the east,

the slow, equatorial rim of the season
widens. Imagine how fiercely they dip the cups,
the life of their arms, the falling,

how the horse's throat-deep, rhythmic sighs,
and the vapory mist of each dipper's breath

step forth, take their shapes, and are gone.

I shall lift my arms

There's a meme going around: What's your favorite poem by Pablo Neruda?

"If You Forget Me" is my all-time favorite (not an easy thing to decide). Why my favorite? Because I once had a long lazy sexy discussion with someone about which emotion ruled here -- anger, sadness, resignation, longing. And aren't long lazy sexy discussions exactly what poetry is for?

If You Forget Me

I want you to know
one thing.

You know how this is:
if I look
at the crystal moon, at the red branch
of the slow autumn at my window,
if I touch
near the fire
the impalpable ash
or the wrinkled body of the log,
everything carries me to you,
as if everything that exists,
aromas, light, metals,
were little boats
that sail
toward those isles of yours that wait for me.

Well, now,
if little by little you stop loving me
I shall stop loving you little by little.

If suddenly
you forget me
do not look for me,
for I shall already have forgotten you.

If you think it long and mad,
the wind of banners
that passes through my life,
and you decide
to leave me at the shore
of the heart where I have roots,
remember
that on that day,
at that hour,
I shall lift my arms
and my roots will set off
to seek another land.

But
if each day,
each hour,
you feel that you are destined for me
with implacable sweetness,
if each day a flower
climbs up to your lips to seek me,
ah my love, ah my own,
in me all that fire is repeated,
in me nothing is extinguished or forgotten,
my love feeds on your love, beloved,
and as long as you live it will be in your arms
without leaving mine.



And in original Spanish, for those that can fully appreciate it:

Si Tu Me Olvidas

Quiero que sepas
una cosa.

Tú sabes cómo es esto:
si miro
la luna de cristal, la rama roja
del lento otoño en mi ventana,
si toco
junto al fuego
la impalpable ceniza
o el arrugado cuerpo de la leña,
todo me lleva a ti,
como si todo lo que existe:
aromas, luz, metales,
fueran pequeños barcos que navegan
hacia las islas tuyas que me aguardan.

Ahora bien,
si poco a poco dejas de quererme
dejaré de quererte poco a poco.

Si de pronto
me olvidas
no me busques,
que ya te habré olvidado.

Si consideras largo y loco
el viento de banderas
que pasa por mi vida
y te decides
a dejarme a la orilla
del corazón en que tengo raíces,
piensa
que en esa día,
a esa hora
levantaré los brazos
y saldrán mis raíces
a buscar otra tierra.

Pero
si cada día,
cada hora,
sientes que a mí estás destinada
con dulzura implacable,
si cada día sube
una flor a tus labios a buscarme,
ay amor mío, ay mía,
en mí todo ese fuego se repite,
en mí nada se apaga ni se olvida,
mi amor se nutre de tu amor, amada,
y mientras vivas estará en tus brazos
sin salir de los míos.

Wednesday, January 31, 2007

Molly Ivins, RIP

A smart outspoken woman, she will be sorely missed. A reminder of what she gave us:

"What you need is sustained outrage...there's far too much unthinking respect given to authority."

"I believe that ignorance is the root of all evil. And that no one knows the truth."

"It is possible to read the history of this country as one long struggle to extend the liberties established in our Constitution to everyone in America."

"The United States of America is still run by its citizens. The government works for us. Rank imperialism and warmongering are not American traditions or values. We do not need to dominate the world. We want and need to work with other nations. We want to find solutions other than killing people. Not in our name, not with our money, not with our children's blood."

"There is one area in which I think Paglia and I would agree that politically correct feminism has produced a noticeable inequity. Nowadays, when a woman behaves in a hysterical and disagreeable fashion, we say, 'Poor dear, it's probably PMS.' Whereas, if a man behaves in a hysterical and disagreeable fashion, we say, 'What an asshole.' Let me leap to correct this unfairness by saying of Paglia, Sheesh, what an asshole." [Molly Ivins about Camille Paglia]

from her last column, January 11, 2007: "We are the people who run this country. We are the deciders. And every single day, every single one of us needs to step outside and take some action to help stop this war. Raise hell. Think of something to make the ridiculous look ridiculous. Make our troops know we're for them and trying to get them out of there."

Tuesday, January 30, 2007

Midweek slumgullion #26

Thought-provoking reads from across the pond, courtesy of Ouch!:

From the New Statesman: "Funny peculiar" -- Mat Fraser on disability and what is funny.

The Guardian: "I won't be happy until I lose my legs"
-- A woman tellls of her lifelong desire to be a double-amputee.

The disabled and Wii: An open letter to Nintendo
-- I've wondered if the new gaming system would or would not be an opportunity for exercise for the involuntarily sedentary, or anyone whose athletic options are limited. The comments are interesting.

Eyes on whose prize, part 2

It was during the transphobia/delink Twisty debates across feminist bloglandia last December that Kactus at Superbabymama happened to note that she'd added this blog and several others to her blogroll. In the comment discussion that followed, an anonymous commenter noted with some resignation that The Gimp Parade links to Heart at Women's Space/Margins, the radical feminist blogging community (if there is one) for several of the women who expressed such hateful transphobia on that ugly I Blame the Patriarchy thread.

My blogroll has since erased itself and I've been slowly adding back what I can remember, but at that time I tried to express whatever strategy it is I've employed for organizing my blogroll. This wouldn't be so important, except that I consider my blogroll the best, most exciting part of this blog because when I began this site in 2004 there weren't so many disability rights bloggers around. Check it out now -- the gimp blog section is joyfully unwieldy.

Here's that commentary on my blogrolling strategy:

I currently have links to both IBTP and Heart's blog, though I've thought many times in the past few months about deleting the link to Twisty. The fact that I just haven't taken the time to tweeze through my blogroll in a long time, despite adding new links I'm excited about, is one reason Twisty is still there.

Another reason she remains linked at my blog sidebar is because my blogrolling policy in so fuzzy and arbitrary in many ways already: it's divided into the crips and the nondisabled, national magazines about disability are mixed in with very small-audience disabled bloggers, Go Fug Yourself is right there in the list with Women's Space.

A few disability bloggers I seriously disagree with are listed simply because disability rights discussions of any kind and disabled bloggers are, frankly, hard to find, not sexy enough to be popular and we need to network and learn from our diverse experiences as disabled folks, if we can.

The final reason Twisty is still blogrolled is because of her recurring use of "fucktard" and some periodic objections to it in comments when she does use it. It's not news to me that all feminists are not my friends, with regard to disability politics, and I don't want to be oblivious of discussions that concern my interests. I have a hard time separating the outright offensive from the clueless, when both may be a part of the feminist movement that I, too, consider myself connected too. Ignorance on disability as it relates to feminism (or even generally) is just too heartbreakingly common. I confess I don't know where to draw the blogrolling line.

Heart's blog stays on my blogroll. I don't find her to be particularly knowledgeable about disability rights and politics, but in many other ways I believe her to be a great resource and committed to a level of diversity found on few white, nondisabled feminist blogs.

I don't mean any of the above to excuse the hate spewed on trans folk in the comments at IBTP. I would like to point out though, that despite Twisty's smart-ass comment in her own out-of-control thread, it's entirely possible that her recent health issues kept her offline for a few days and she didn't want to invoke another round of tiresome sympathy by mentioning it. Instead of being the sad cancer patient, she was "controversial" and mean-spirited instead. I believe that's within the realm of behavior she might display. Just sayin'.

Regarding trans hate and radical feminism specifically, I've been trying to connect the dots to ableism and write about it for quite a while now, but haven't been able to put what I know is part of the same issue of feminism, essentialism, bodily truths, and social constructionism together from a disability perspective just yet. I'm so glad Brownfemipower mentioned disabled women in her discussion if this. It is connected.
Aside from the obnoxious use of "tweeze" and the clearly inaccurate characterization of Women's Space being "committed to a level of diversity found on few white, nondisabled feminist blogs" I stand by my rationale. It'd be more accurate to say that Women's Space touches on diverse issues of difference concerning women more regularly than many other feminist spaces, but that's not the same as full commitment, particularly if you include the atmosphere created by regular participants over there.

Anonymous' response to me:
I used to read your blog every post. It hurt me so much though when I finally got around to exploring your site more. For me it's like, I don't know why you've linked to so-and-so. Is it because that's what you truly feel? Are you just trying to provide a wide variety of viewpoints? I don't know.

I do know it scares the hell out of me when I see Margins or Questioning Transgender or Genderville or some other hate site. Even if it's not a direct link.

I'm sure you can somewhat sympathize because ableist sites are just a dime a dozen because so few people even realize it exists. Otherwise good sites, too. Nice folk. Just not aware.

I just want you to know that I know you're doing good work. You've helped me out more than once. But I just can't visit your site anymore because I'm afraid. That's my issue. I'm oversensitive.
Well, Anonymous ain't oversensitive, and blogroll strategy aside, this has really made me think hard since then about my reactions to hate speech, generally, and my disposition against the ableism I encounter.

At the time I responded with this:
The hatred and fear people have about disability and disabled folks is most often expressed through silence or invisibility. In public policy it has historically been through institutionalizing disabled people and making us invisible, but the average person/blogger/commenter simply ignores us instead of raging out loud as is done with hate speech and transphobia.

As a blogroll owner, how do I delink to protest hatred or fear of people like myself if it's expressed by ignoring disabled issues and people? If the common factor of ignorance and cluelessness represents itself as silence too, who do I decide to give up on, in terms of disability issues? And since I do believe transphobia is related to fear and hatred of disabled folks, I don't imagine that where one is expressed the other doesn't also exist. The more I learn, the more I'm sure this is true.
If I made the practice of discounting disabled people's opinions a criteria for who is delinked from my site, I'd have had to remove several of my favorite mainstream feminist spaces in these weeks since Ashley X's story has hit international news. Even if I limited my delisting to blogs where parents of disabled children who disagree with the Ashley Treatment were dismissed out-of-hand, there'd be significant changes.

But back to what's been weighing on me about my own reactions to transphobia, ableism, racism, and other obvious signs of hatred of difference.

What I'd call my formative years as a person with a disability and the need for a wheelchair began in 1983 when I was 15. The Americans with Disabilities Act wasn't passed until 1990, so as I learned about disability in America, I learned that I could not ever count on physical access to public places. The Rehab Act of 1973 was meant to create access in government buildings, but as a high schooler I learned that I could never take it for granted that the pizza joint, movie theater, concert hall, museum, or restaurant my family or friends and I headed to on any given day would actually be a place I could enter. If I could enter, there was still the real likelihood that the outing would end abruptly when I needed to pee and could not access the public restrooms.

Spontaneity increased the likelihood that right there at the front door of the inaccessible building we'd anticipated entering, I and whomever I was with would have to turn away and find someplace else we could go. Calling ahead to ask about accessibility rarely changed the outcome, since nondisabled workers frequently failed to remember some stairs or that the restroom door was just 19 inches wide and in the basement anyway. Sometimes I could be carried inside. Sometimes we could use the kitchen entrance. In some movie theaters lacking dedicated places for wheelchair users to park, I could wedge in next to the smelly garbage can. Once at a Georgetown bar, my friends and I walked the dark and gummy back alley to a delivery ramp that led directly into the cozy back room but the ramp was at a 45-degree slant requiring several of my friends to push my scooter while I accelerated, so I arrived amongst the dinner tables like a bullet shot out of a gun. I'd been in the front of the bar -- an entryway with tables and too-high stools -- and basically been told to leave and try the back door.

When I wasn't alone, there was often some way to make it all work, but only rarely did I ever go anywhere that the building just allowed me in. And there's no immediate recourse to structural inaccessibility. No amount of argument with the manager widens the bathroom stall door or eliminates the need for an elevator. No phonecall or letter made the next day alleviates the problem, either. Pre-ADA, no one was compelled to fix access anyway. They could legally shrug and turn away -- and some did.

There were occasions when the event we'd hoped to attend was prepaid, important, or too exciting for everyone with me to miss, and so I went home or waited somewhere alone while others climbed the stairs without me. I did and do have dedicated friends. My best friend in high school once held me piggy-back through an entire concert so that I could see the band instead of sitting in my chair looking at other people's butts. My brother and father carried me more than once into the melee of the Indianapolis 500, blocks away from our car and up into the bleachers without my wheelchair. Schoolmates carried me on and off the commuter train for the history class fieldtrip into Chicago to see Brian Dennehy perform the play Galileo.

I had a happy and remarkably integrated adolescence because of the love and loyalty of the people around me, but that level of daily exclusion, that impenetrable kind of exclusion that is only fixed with sledgehammers and new elevators IF someone who owned the building decided someday to bother (not on my account, and not when I was waiting at the door) did its part to shape who I am and how I react to discrimination and disregard. I learned emotional ambivalence, the skill of being water off the duck's back, so that I could meet this isolating uncertainty every day.

It's been my defense mechanism, to shrug and say, "oh well." It's sometimes been accompanied by activism and calls demanding access, but mostly only after returning home in defeat. I don't know how other people with disabilities have coped. I don't know how people of color during Jim Crow handled their rage about the back of the bus and the separate drinking fountains, though there is something to be said for being able to get on the bus. I do know something of how women handle the rampant sexism in our culture. These are all relatively quiet violences to the soul.

When the hatred is clearly spoken or made physical, those are different more urgent situations to address. And I'm unfamiliar with them. I spent my youth anesthetizing myself just enough to stand the daily less-violent silent injustices, and I think it means I tend to underact when the hatred is more open. Open hatred is rarely directed at me, because I'm straight, white, upper-middle-class background, educated, and because ableism usually looks different than the racism or transphobia that leads to sudden violence and death. Which isn't to say that the nondisabled person who states, "I'd rather be dead than live like you do," isn't speaking hate -- but almost nobody calls it that and we've all been taught that such a statement is personal preference rather than code for "your life isn't worth as much as mine."

I think my reactions to hatred have sometimes puzzled my friends, the radical feminists ready for a fight, the women of color, lesbian, gay and transgender folk who live with their families under threat of much quicker physical violence than I ever have. I see that and know I need to change and join the greater fight for them and myself a bit differently. How much has the ADA actually changed and how much of my defenses can I afford to dismantle? Does there really need to be a balance between helping myself stay sane and reacting appropriately? It shouldn't be that way.

Monday, January 29, 2007

One of the perks. . .

of having a disability -- some specific impairment (take your pick) -- is that you get to say original, thought-provoking things like this:

I love my feet. I have always loved my feet, no matter how many or which ones I had at any given moment. . .
Read the whole thing, by Sara at Moving Right Along.

Eyes on whose prize

I want to speak my own truth, and honor the words of others when they speak theirs. I want to be an ally, but I don't want to get in the way. I want to make the connections between my experiences and other people's in ways that broaden my understanding and avoid the narrowing of concerns into little camps of people struggling for recognition. I want to interject disability issues into conversations where they seem unspoken or invisible, and I don't want to feel selfish for doing it. And I want other people to do the same, so I can see where I've centered my own concerns and marginalized someone else's. I want to see how the whole big mess fits together.

Wanting so much usually keeps me rather quiet, outside of the small community of disability blogs that have become a comfort zone for me. And the comfort has been needed lately when the Ashley Treatment -- a story so fundamentally about attitudes on bodily and mental difference and disability -- continues to be debated everywhere. Only on sites dedicated to bodily and mental difference specifically, have I seen any real re-centering of that debate away from ableist tendencies to make allowances for behavior or words that dehumanize the less than normal body. I've felt myself turning in protectively to my dis or dis-cool friends: Penny, Connie and Steve, WCD, Amanda, I'mFunnyToo, David. . . .

It's no coincidence I feel safest among those who also have an obvious stake in whether or not physical or mental ability is used to determine how we treat people. It's no coincidence that our widely disparate experiences of disability arrive at the same political sympathies. And I suppose it's no coincidence that when we're discounted as irrelevant or fanatical about the topic at hand, we're all discounted together.

And today, Kevin at Slant Truth reminds me that this is how the system of oppressions works, and that it's happening elsewhere and isolation isn't the right response:

I will come out proud and say that I am supportive of the Trans community and will work from here on out for their full personhood. The hate I have seen lately is beyond my comprehension. I reject it all. Fuck you if you aren’t down.
Oh, I've more to say on this, now that I've resolved to begin. But I wanted to get this much out there now.

Holocaust memorial day

Today is the 62nd anniversary of the liberation of the Auschwitz death camp of WWII and an international day of remembrance of the Holocaust. At a ceremony in Newcastle, UK, where the six million Jews who were murdered were remembered:

Chief Rabbi Sir Jonathan Sacks called on people to remember the other victims of the Holocaust, including gay people, gypsies, the mentally handicapped and the physically disabled.

He emphasised this year's theme of The Dignity of Difference, saying: "At the heart of evil is dislike of the unlike, the fear of difference, the belief that because you are not like me you are a threat to me. Fear becomes hate and hate begets violence and violence turns to murder and murder becomes the attempted annihilation of a whole group.

"The great human challenge is to honour what we have in common while respecting what makes us different because if we had nothing in common we would be unable to communicate, and if we had everything in common we would have nothing to say. If we do not learn the lessons of the past then I fear for our future."



Sunday, January 28, 2007

On being a good girl

Posted to the latest Disability Carnival at DisStudies, Temple U, Dave Hingsburger of Chewing the Fat writes about "The Good Girl" and the perils of being trained to be polite and follow the rules. He begins:

Several times a year I'm asked to do an abuse prevention workshop for people with disabilities. As part of that workshop we do a role play wherein Joe (who assists me in doing this workshop) plays a staff and in that role asks someone with a disability, "How was your day." The person with a disability responds, "I don't want to talk about it." Then the question is asked of the group, "What would a good staff do next?" The answer we are looking for is some version of, "The staff would say, 'That's OK you don't have to talk about it now. We can talk about it later if you want."

This role play is informative to me - it lets me know what kind of world that people with disabilities live in, how they see 'good' staff. I've had all sorts of responses to this question, "Put her in the side room," "Take supper away from him," "Lock him outside," "Don't let her use the phone," "Put her on the floor." Shocking, but a glimpse into how some staff use power in their relationship to those in care.
But the teenage woman with Down Syndrome that he gets to assist in the roleplay has clearly been taught that "politeness" and her need to be "a good girl" trumps any situation where she might be unhappy, dissatisfied or abused. She confides that she herself would never complain about someone treating her badly because that would be impolite. And she becomes afraid that she's been displeasing when Hingsburger points out she is working at cross-purposes with the basic message of the workshop and roleplay:
During the rest of the workshop she never again volunteered for a role play, to assist in any way. She just sat with her hands in her lap and she smiled at me. That pasted on Down Syndrome smile that I understood for the first time (really) had nothing to do with Down Syndrome it had to do with being down trodden. She was entirely 'nice' for the rest of the time we were together.

She left the workshop by coming up to me and apologizing again. "I'm a good girl," she said as she walked away from me.
This young woman had been taught the primary importance of not being troublesome, not needing, not complaining, being "happy" at all times, and not breaking the rules that cast her as the recipient of other people's good will. The pressure to please is relevant to feminist politics as well as the lessons of safety and autonomy that parents, teachers and guardians should consider for children, disabled or not. But this true example of the societal pressures brought to bear on developmentally disabled individuals -- and likely girls and women, in particular -- illustrates the complexities of the meaning of consent for those whom society implicitly denies the right to dissent.

When those of us without developmental, intellectual or cognitive disabilities take it upon ourselves to judge if others have the capacity to make decisions for themselves, what criteria are used? Do we foster their decision-making skills in the same way we might for nondisabled-but-developing minds of children that we plan to give full autonomy to eventually? Do we allow them to make mistakes and grow from them? Do we offer them a sense of self that is worthy of personal preferences, convictions and enough bodily autonomy to be safe from abuse they can recognize, or do we limit their available responses? Do we let the idea of their mental impairments limit our own sense of their personhood and the entitlements to all which that means?

How many people who have been trained, taught and brainwashed to believe that being considered "good" is more important than their own safety have subsequently been determined incapable of making their own decisions and incapable of consent?

Saturday, January 27, 2007

Saturday Slumgullion #25

Peter Singer's op-ed on Ashley X: A Convenient Truth.

One story of ADA compliance failures and a school district in Charlottesville, NC.

Autistic students will be forced to testify, or at least take the witness stand, against their alleged abuser -- Kathleen Garrett, a special ed teacher, is charged with abuse that knocked out one child's teeth. Attila the Mom comments here.

A detailed article on the trials of getting employed -- Lawyers With Disabilities Say Obstacles, Stereotypes Persist.

Feministing interviews disability activist Laura Hershey.

Amanda of Ballastexistenz has a really great 8 minute vide
o called In My Language, dedicated to Ashley X. I think it is fairly accessible to those with either sight or hearing impairments, she shows us through singing and rhythym how she communicates with her environment, and when she speaks using an electronic voice machine, she also provides subtitles. Update: Partial written transcript here. Discussion at Metafilter here.

The investigative reporting on conditions in Georgia state mental hospitals continues. An excerpt from part 3:

He was choked until his last breath. Blood pooled beneath his skin from two wounds to the back of his head. His body lay in an ignominious sprawl: facedown on the floor of a state psychiatric hospital.

Georgia's chief medical examiner ruled his death a homicide. So did a coroner's jury.

Yet no one ever faced criminal charges for killing Rickey Dean Wingo. No one was even disciplined.

In Georgia's state mental hospitals, even the most egregious cases involving employees — patient deaths, assaults, beatings — usually result in penalties no harsher than firing, and sometimes no punishment at all, an investigation by The Atlanta Journal-Constitution shows.

Mike Ervin writes on "15 years of ADA filled with setbacks, victories" for the Progressive Media Project.

Tiny Cat Pants comments on what I'm Funny Too has to say about liberals and disability issues.


Thursday, January 25, 2007

Disability Carnival #7 is up at Penny's!

The theme is Disability History and Disability in the Arts, so rock on over and enjoy!

Flying rodents of unusual size

Last week, I described the pre-dinner events of my 20th birthday. And the banana balloon capture caper.

Dinner itself was fun too. Marian, Anne, Deb and I walked to the restaurant -- two scooters, a power wheelchair and one bi-ped skipping along to keep up. Traveling in a pack of wheelchairs over familiar sidewalk terrain is something of an art. The unspoken rule is that everyone paces themselves to the slowest chair (or the walker) but allows for speed changes and swerves around uneven pieces of pavement. In neighborhoods around campus where we were all familiar with the potholes and seizmic cracks in the sidewalks, a simple trip together somewhere sometimes felt like an intricate dance -- slowing, speeding, weaving sideways to avoid a crumbled edge of cement, zipping closer so we could keep up converation. We'd anticipate the sudden stop and lurch of each other's chairs to navigate smoothly. Well, mostly. There were collisions now and then.

I still didn't know where we were going for my surprise dinner, though briefly I expected it might be McDonald's because of the perverse humor of my friends. We ended up at Monty's in downtown Tempe. The main strip has changed a lot since those days, with many new restaurants beyond the means of the local students, but Monty's was one of the few fine-dining experiences within walking distance of the dorms back then, and I'd never been inside.

Possibly, the highlight of the evening was when Deb stepped up to the hostess and announced our arrival, then added "we'll just need one chair." Our little parade through the many rooms of the restaurant was fun, too. Oh, the expressions as we rolled by -- one, two chairs, three. The public spectacle of disability is always more fun when shared. To often it's experienced alone and feels alienating instead.

I had the famous barbeque ribs for dinner -- a splurge. And a bottle of wine, then Irish coffee with dessert. Yes, alcohol at a restaurant on my 20th birthday. I was the only one underage but sometimes gimpiness freaks servers out so much you don't get carded. There are perks now and then.

Anyway, dinner was delicious and I drove out of the place with a good buzz. We all did, which I suppose explains our detour under city hall on the way home. Tempe's city hall building is an impressive bit of architecture -- it's an inverted pyramid with large slabs of window covering the slanted sides. The "point" of the pyramid is underground and is reached by long fabulous ramps that go "WHEEEEEEE!" When drunk.

It was dark down there after-hours, which accentuated the sense of speed. Anne's scooter lacked the stiff automatic braking on slopes, and she shrieked with laughter. The buzz of our power chairs and voices echoed off locked office doors and through the leafy atrium under the building"s bulk. And there was another whirring screeching noise we couldn't identify as we raced up the ramp and plunged down it again. Deb leapt onto benches. More shrieking laughter. And that other whirring and shrieking.

'What is that?"

Marian gasped. "BATS!"

We'd disturbed their nighttime playground and they were swooping around us in the darkness. The echoing noise of our chairs frightened them, perhaps. Now we all shrieked in earnest, ducking instinctually, as we sped up the ramp and back into the sultry October night. As it turns out, scary bats are hilarious when you're drunk.

Back at the dorm, the room I shared with Marian had been toilet-papered extensively. I felt special. And that banana-shaped balloon was there for the upcoming adventure.

Wednesday, January 24, 2007

Things that crack me up, #17

Behind some Google searches, there is mystery. This search led here:

"maybe i needed 70 years of life to get ready for a woman like helen"

Tuesday, January 23, 2007

Various NPR disability stories

Label falls short for those with mental retardation by Joseph Shapiro. Excerpt:

The term mental retardation was supposed to be an improvement. But the fight over language keeps going on. That becomes clear if you ask those with mental retardation what they think about that description.

"I hate that word — mental retardation," says Thelma Greene of Washington, D.C. "I wish they would change that one, because it sounds so institutional, like you can't do nothing for yourself and you're depending on somebody else to do everything, from putting on all your clothes down to your shoes. And that's not right."

"Retardation is not the good word," Anthony Vessels, also of Washington, says in agreement.

"I never did like that word 'retardation' or 'mental retardation,' adds Victor Robinson. "Because everyone has called people names about that. And no, none of my friends did like that name or any other name, being called 'stupid, dumb.' And it hurts a person very much."
"Poster Child" Emily Rapp about her life and her book, Poster Child: A Memoir

A look at an autistic savant's brilliant mind from Talk of the Nation, about Daniel Tammet's memoir Born on a Blue Day.

Things that crack me up, #16

Well, not so much cracked up this time, as surprised by something I did not know:

Not only was John (Cougar) Mellencamp born with a mild form of spina bifida, but he was birthed in a windmill.

I know.

Jury duty update

My post from last September about being summoned for jury duty always gets a few Google hits per day, so I thought I'd provide an update.

I was required to call in to the courthouse once in October on a designated morning to see if I needed to come in that afternoon. The recorded message told me that my jury pool wasn't needed, but that I'd get another letter in the mail during my three-month on-call period if they needed me to check in again. That never happened, so presumably my brush with legal excitement has passed me by. That is all.

Friday, January 19, 2007

Radical Day of Fun

In preparation for my 20th birthday, my roommate and friend Marian warned me I was being taken out to dinner, so I should reserve that Saturday for mystery fun. Neither of us had any idea then that Marian would never get to wish me a happy 21st, so I'm doubly greatful my 20th was filled with such wacky fun.

Here's the conversation I had with Marian a couple days prior to the event:

Me: We're going out to dinner?

Marian: Mmm hmm.

Me: Where?

Marian: You don't get to know yet.

Me: Who's coming?

Marian: You, me, Anne and Deb.

Me: Is it a fancy place?

Marian: Ummm. Yup.

Me: Should I dress up?

Marian: I would.

Me: Should I wear hose?

Marian: God no! . . . Maybe when you get married.

***

When Saturday came, so had a package from my parents, and other friends came to hang out in the dorm room Marian and I shared while I opened that. This was the pre-party, and it was mellow but fun. It included the cake my parents arranged to be sent from a local bakery. Several people gave me toy or stuffed dinosaurs because of a misunderstanding that I was collecting them. The cutest ones remain with me as memories of those early years in college. Anne gave me a giant helium-filled banana-shaped balloon that said something about "bunches of fun."

Some days later the big banana's ribbon leash came loose and the balloon edged its way over to our oscillating fan. Afraid it would get sucked into the fan, Marian and I executed a rescue mission that sounds more like some bizarre drinking game, particularly since we decided on it while not entirely clothed. I forget what that part was all about.

Marian had a homemade "reacher" consisting of a dowel stick with an L-screw attached to one end. She skillfully used it to dress, run a washcloth over her face and dozens of other small tasks her juvenile rheumatoid arthritis made more difficult. Her stick was key to our banana-balloon rescue caper.

Here was the plan: If we turned the fan off, the balloon rose to the ceiling, completely out of our reach from our chairs. Turn the fan on and the big foil banana edged down behind the fan as though it might hurl itself into the whirling blades. One of us would drive up in front of the wind from the fan and bat the balloon downward and in front of the fan using Marian's stick. The challenge was then for that person to speedily reverse out of the way so the other could swoop in and reach for the balloon in the brief moment it dipped low enough to catch.

We were working with two electric wheelchairs (well, mine a scooter) and a dormroom floorspace of maybe ten-feet square, so half-naked, dowel-batting, chair-swooping and arm-lunging required teamwork and coordination not improved by giggling. I forget if we were sober or not, but in retrospect, probably not.

***

More on the birthday dinner itself tomorrow. I'm extending my radical fun through the weekend.

For other people's radical or drunken fun, check out the links at Sly Civilian.

Thursday, January 18, 2007

Slumgullionish miscellanea (#24)

William Peace's "Protest from a bad cripple: The Ashley Treatment and the making of a pillow angel" in CounterPunch:

Doctors have established a precedent with Ashley—it is ethically and socially acceptable to mutilate the bodies of disabled people. What Ashley and her doctors have failed to grasp is that all disabled people share a common bond. In my opinion there is no difference between myself and Ashley despite the great disparity in our intellectual abilities. If you doubt this let me relay one story from my childhood. In 1972 I was a 7th grade student at a Catholic school in New York. The school was not unusual but I was. I had a rare neurological condition that was beginning to take its toll on my ability to walk. Shortly after school started I vividly recall homework being handed out and the nun came over to me and said, “You no longer need to do homework because you are one of God’s special children”.
A thorough collection of the disability community's responses to The Ashley Treatment.

From NewsDay, Sen. Charles Schumer (D), of New York talks about the special difficulties faced by injured National Guardsmen and Reservists:
Disability claims filed by National Guardsmen and Reservists are denied at twice the rate of active duty troops, he said. Guardsmen and reservists in college sent for full-time training earn just $297 per month, while active duty soldiers earn more than $1,000, he said.

In addition, wounded guardsmen and reservists often must recuperate at medical facilities far from home, he said. They are tied to units scattered throughout the country.

The Guard and Reserves have been used more in the Iraq War than in any prior conflict. At one point, half of the deployed troops in Iraq were with the Guard or Reserves.

"They are risking the same amount of danger," said Schumer (D-N.Y.) at a news conference at Hofstra University Monday, surrounded by cadets with the school's ROTC program. "They should be given the same benefits."
The South Dakota Argus Leader reports on the unusual motions filed in the murder trial of deaf defendant Daphne Wright:
The lawyers requested the victim's friends and family be prohibited by the court from acting out or displaying emotion during the trial. They also requested the court not allow "gruesome or inflammatory photographs" from the crime.

Wright, 43, is accused of kidnapping, killing and dismembering Darlene VanderGiesen, 42, in February 2006. Wright and VanderGiesen were both deaf, which has become an issue in the court proceedings.

Prosecutors have indicated they will seek the death penalty if Wright is convicted on the charges she faces: murder and kidnapping.

But Wright's lawyers say that because she is deaf, it would be cruel to execute her.

And to my Malaysian friend who sent me a link about disability news there, I have lost that email. Please resend the info and other news in the future.

AHA!

I've just found this. It's a program that provides a virtual keyboard that I can type on with my mouse. Yay! Seems to work and it's freeware!

Wednesday, January 17, 2007

Transgender story on All My Children

From the Texarkana Gazette:

The story that AMC has weaved with the telling of Zoe’s tale has been wonderful. Amazing. And it surprises me.

I had no idea Zarf or Zoe would command this much presence and story.

The scenes where Zoe made her first appearance on Bianca’s doorstep and the subsequent reveal to a stunned Bianca were outstanding scenes. Better than I thought AMC could ever pull off.

. . . However, and here’s a spoiler, so stop reading if you don’t want to know: Zarf is going to become a prime suspect in the show’s Satin Slayer killings.

The residents of Pine Valley should be prepared to be knocked off their feet next week as Zarf is set to explain his story to those who suspect him of murder.

Those following the recent Delink Twisty/transphobia debates all over feminist blogland will see the relevance of this: Zarf/Zoe spent today's episode in jail, and as evidence that she is the serial killer everyone believes her to be, another character even mentioned the psychokiller in The Silence of the Lambs. I wouldn't call that coincidence. More like hateful stereotype.

Incidently, the character seems to be entirely innocent.



Tuesday, January 16, 2007

Neglect

Yesterday's list of glorious gimpiness failed to mention my fabulous elbows, one of which I lean on to type. Today it registers jealousy with a painful infection probably caused by a disintegrating armrest on my scooter harassing it for some weeks now. I'll not be typing much until it heals, since my gloriousness does not currently include patience for typing with just one pinky to avoid my usual position. The new armrest is due here next week.